Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think £200 a week is not excessive shopping bill wise for a family of 6?

143 replies

sweetkitty · 19/09/2022 23:18

This is part of a wider issue of me being fed up of DH and his penny pinching can’t afford it attitude.

DH and I and four teenage DC who eat well like teenage DC. DH has for a while been in charge of doing a weekly Tesco online shop as in his words “I go far too much over budget” so this week he spent £96 on the online shop then I went to Asda with him - the total was another £94 which he wasn’t happy about as it was apparently far too much as he is usually £60. The reason he’s been going to Asda is Tesco keep missing things/don’t have the range. Now I said to him I think we should start buying in bulk to try and reduce costs a bit instead of for example buying the smallest box of Ariel pods he always buys as he think they are cheaper let’s buy a huge box of Persil powder instead. I also stocked up the good cupboards. Bit as the DC are always saying there’s not a lot in for quick snacks etc.

That was no alcohol or pet items as I buy all the pet items out of my money and usually go to Home Bargains and stock up on cleaning products and the like once a month. I don’t think £200 is a lot for 6 essentially adults, it used to be about £140 but that was before everything went up plus the DC are eating us out of house and home.

To put it into context our annual household income is 115-140K we have no household debts and a smallish mortgage so we are not scrimping by thankfully. At one point I picked up some new chocolate bars just to have a look and he said to me “put them back you are not getting them” exactly like I was a child. I was so angry I said I am a grown woman with a job if I want them I will bloody well buy them.

OP posts:
LindseyHoyleSpeaks · 20/09/2022 08:51

Sounds normal to me. Our budget is similar and our income is less than yours. I imagine your mortgage is smaller than mine too. The real issue here is that he is financially controlling - plus he’s right! Not attractive at all!

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 20/09/2022 08:50

Sounds a reasonable amount to me. We still end £130 for a family of 4, and we don’t waste, so multiplying it up that’d be about right for 6 adults.

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 20/09/2022 08:48

I spend on average £70 a week for 3 of us,

Your dh does the shopping and spends 40 to 50 less when he does it by himself you added that much extra into the trolly

I also hate when my dh comes shopping as he just throws crap in and the cost gets doubled,

However if you paid I don't see the issue and your dh was being a prick

Oh and tell he to move from tesco plenty of cheaper supermarkets around

Quincythequince · 20/09/2022 08:45

GhostFromTheOtherSide · 20/09/2022 08:39

You can obviously afford it but tbh I think that it’s all to easy to be complacent about spending when you can afford to just spend.

Just because you can afford to spend £200 a week on groceries doesn’t mean that you have to.

The reality is that a lot of spending is based on branding and advertising. You can buy Heinz tomato ketchup etc but actually if you buy supermarket own brand then you end up with the same product for a fraction of the price. Some products that doesn’t work, but with others it most definitely does, e.g. spending £1. £1.50 on domestos bleach when you can buy supermarket own for less than £1, and there is literally 0 difference in the product you have been drawn in by branding if you then go for the domestos.

So while I wouldn’t necessarily scrimp, I would look at whether I am spending that money wisely or whether I could actually get the same shop for less by cutting down on some of the branded products.

She wasn’t asking for your advice on how to cut down was she, any idiot can work that out.

She was asking if in the context of their household earnings, is it unreasonable to spend that much per person. And it’s clearly not.

£33 per week, or £4.72 per day per person, in total for everything is not a lot at all.

The Jack Monroe’s of the world who maintain you can do it for less are utterly deluded tbh. Nowhere near enough calories - and pretending that I’m this climate, with food prices going up, you can as she has said feed one child and two adults, enough calories to live on for circa £20 per week, is plain rubbish.

GhostFromTheOtherSide · 20/09/2022 08:39

You can obviously afford it but tbh I think that it’s all to easy to be complacent about spending when you can afford to just spend.

Just because you can afford to spend £200 a week on groceries doesn’t mean that you have to.

The reality is that a lot of spending is based on branding and advertising. You can buy Heinz tomato ketchup etc but actually if you buy supermarket own brand then you end up with the same product for a fraction of the price. Some products that doesn’t work, but with others it most definitely does, e.g. spending £1. £1.50 on domestos bleach when you can buy supermarket own for less than £1, and there is literally 0 difference in the product you have been drawn in by branding if you then go for the domestos.

So while I wouldn’t necessarily scrimp, I would look at whether I am spending that money wisely or whether I could actually get the same shop for less by cutting down on some of the branded products.

BlancmanegeBunny · 20/09/2022 08:39

It seems a lot to me if it doesn't include pet food and cleaning products!

With regard to ariel pods / washing powder you need to point out to him the cost per wash!!!

The difference between spending £160 a week and £180 a week does not sound a lot but it is £1040 over a year!

BlancmanegeBunny · 20/09/2022 08:39

It seems a lot to me if it doesn't include pet food and cleaning products!

With regard to ariel pods / washing powder you need to point out to him the cost per wash!!!

The difference between spending £160 a week and £180 a week does not sound a lot but it is £1040 over a year!

Quincythequince · 20/09/2022 08:37

And FWIW my Ocado shop is being delivered this morning, my bill is over >£340 and our last big delivery shop was circa two weeks ago, so we spend similar.

Three adults and three teenagers boys live here.

Quincythequince · 20/09/2022 08:35

Has he ever had money issues in the past, where he didn’t have enough?

We earn very well in my house but as my life was difficult as a teenager (money-wise) I have to remind myself that we have enough and it’s ok, because I probably often think what he does, but I rarely vocalise it.

Rewis · 20/09/2022 08:34

Why would your weekly shopping be less than £200? You can afford it. Would saving £50/week make any difference to you? I don't think £200 for 6 people is not excessive. Why not spend a bit more on food than the bare minimum if you can afford it.

Have him do the shopping for a few months. Do not do top ups. Every complaint should be aimed at him.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 20/09/2022 08:32

Dh wouldn’t dare suggest what food we buy as I do the shop.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 20/09/2022 08:31

We’re a family of 5 but 3 dc ages 11-14. 14yo is taller than me and eats loads. We spend about £180 a week on the big shop then top ups will probably take us to £200 if I added it all together.

BashfulClam · 20/09/2022 08:27

I’m struggling to keep it under £100 per week for just two of us. 21 meals a week, snacks, cleaning things and toiletries adds up. I used to do it on £45 a week. DH is also extremely picky and won’t eat reheated food so batch cooking is out although I do it for myself so usually gave dinner for next in the freezer if we aren’t eating together. It was £97 this week.

MaChienEstUnDick · 20/09/2022 08:12

I think Tesco in particular (which is the only decent sized store in my wee town) has gone through the roof recently so I get the frustration of 'oh this trolley-load used to cost £100 and now it costs £130' because that is frustrating and worrying, no matter what your income.

But I would expect a fully grown adult human to appreciate that a £20 box of washing powder is going to last a lot longer than a £7 box of 15 washing tabs, and that if your partner wants some chocolate they can have some chocolate ffs!

I cannot stand meanness though, it's my absolute red flag.

HardLanding · 20/09/2022 08:12

YANBU. I spend roughly £120 a week for me, two teens and a dairy free 6YO. My income is around 42K.

That doesn’t include the c.£60 a month I spend stocking the pantry with cereal bars, brioche, other snacky bits, or the c.£20-40 a month I spend on toilet rolls, toiletries, cleaning products.

I buy a massive box of laundry powder - the 75 wash ones - cost around £20, I last bought one at the end of July, will need to replace it around the end of October. I’ve got a metal laundry tin to decant it into, which has its own scoop, is less than the box tells me to use but our clothes come out clean.

Rapidtango · 20/09/2022 08:03

Could do it for less, certainly, but don't think £33 per person for a week's meals is excessive. Your DH sounds like a knob. Why not just hand it all over to him for a month and see if he still feels the same way after shopping for, preparing and cooking 3 meals a day for 6 people.

Adventurine · 20/09/2022 08:02

That sounds fair. Mine is £120 a week with two adults, one dustbin of a teen, one teen with a bird like appetite and one picky primary school kid.

serenghetti2011 · 20/09/2022 08:00

Depends where you shop op, I am a single parent to 4 lads from 11 up to 21 and I spend nowhere near 200 per month that’s with catfood and cleaning stuff probably 90-100 at the absolute most
mine eat me out of house and home too it’s expensive but 200 per week would be my entire wages just on food

SkankingWombat · 20/09/2022 07:54

MrsLargeEmbodied · 20/09/2022 07:11

i came on to say it was far too much,
i had a family of 5
a couple of years ago we were all home and we spent less.
otoh this was 2020, so lower prices?
and i am not an extravagent cook
and it sounds like you can afford it

You definitely can't compare to 2020 prices. Our spend has increased 50% since the start of the pandemic, with most of the increase being this year.

OP £200/wk seems a fair amount given the number and ages of your household, whilst still maintaining a reasonable quality and variety. You could of course make some savings if needed, but you don't need to and it is important to buy the best quality food you can afford IMO as it maintains our health and is literally the building blocks of our body.
FWIW we spend around ~£140/wk for a family of 2 adults, 2 primary-aged DCs (with large appetites) and a cat. That includes all food, a bit of alcohol, the cleaning products, and any small top ups of basics mid-week. I meal plan, bulk buy where possible, we eat little meat and most of what we do buy is yellow sticker that I buy when I see it and freeze. We already eat a lot of pulses and I cook from scratch, and the only food waste is the odd small piece of fruit/veg that has rolled off and hidden itself under something else, and remained unspotted.

mrsbyers · 20/09/2022 07:54

If my husband spoke to me like a child about some chocolate bars I’d buy six packets and eat them until I was sick

LiveInSunshine · 20/09/2022 07:51

The answer to ‘is it high’- yes it is. In the house we are 4 adults and 3 kids and it’s nearly double ours.

The answer to ‘can I as a woman with a job in charge of my own life spend £200’ is of course you can. If you shop in Tesco/ Sainsburys etc and want nice food/ eat meat it’s not wildly unexpected, and you don’t have to answer to anyone.

Mascia · 20/09/2022 07:50

mamabear715 · 20/09/2022 07:29

I send £200 pw EASILY, me & 3 kids.
I'm not prepared to stand in the kitchen for 24 hours grilling a lentil, we eat what we want, we don't go out much.
Tbh, I agree with a PP, the problem is your DH, not the amount spent! But I suppose if you take over all the food shopping, he'll be going round the house turning all the radiators down or something!

“Grilling a lentil” 😁
We‘re similar - although we do go out occasionally, we‘ve been doing it a bit less recently.
We cook from scratch a lot, so we buy mostly staples, but also get a fair amount of „treats“ like nice bread and cheese, crisps, nuts and dips.

Hippyatheart58 · 20/09/2022 07:47

When you go food shopping with him it costs HIM more money? How exactly does that work when you have joint expenses for household essentials like feeding the family. Also am confused as to why the pet food comes out of your personal allowance.

No in regards to this situation you are not being unreasonable. However as you stated in your first post this is one of the issues you have with him. You won't win this disagreement no matter how logical you are. His mindset is worrying. If your wanting to focus on your marriage I suggest getting some outside help to try and work on these issues. I honestly couldn't handle being told to put chocolate back and it not being a joke. When I read it I imagined myself throwing 3 bars in the trolley.

I would also make sure you have a handle on all your finances and know where all the money is and going. The HIS money has me thinking he might be planning a nest egg for himself. Your DC are teenagers. He might be thinking of leaving. I hope am not right here but being controlling with money is such a red flag. Buy the chocolate 🍫 OP x

1litreofwater · 20/09/2022 07:47

JudgeRindersMinder · 20/09/2022 07:42

It’s 3 meals a day x 6 people so it’s 18 meals a day!

If I can keep a food shop for 3 adults under £100 it’s a good week, so I don’t think £200 for 6 adults is unreasonable, although there may be some slight economies of scale.

If you change to washing order from pods you’ll notice a huge difference! I used to use Persil liquid so was about £7 every 3 weeks or so. I changed to Bold powder (other cheaper brands are available!) which is about £7, and I get at least 3 months out of a box!

18 meals a day plus drinks, snacks, cleaning products, laundry stuff and toiletries/toilet roll. I think £200 is quite good actually considering the cost of things like laundry powder and the size/ages of OPs family!

YumYummy · 20/09/2022 07:45

We are a family of 4 and I can’t get our food shop to under £280, normally it’s up to £330 or so.