Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think people are being childish and foolish to think smelling produce is gross?

142 replies

UrslaB · 19/09/2022 20:28

Okay, this has really caught me off guard. In another thread the act of sniffing produce (tomatoes) to check for freshness and quality was mentioned, and some people then responded that this was in some way weird. Puking emojis and hysterical exclamations that people should keep their noses away from food in the supermarket and that this is why they buy pre-packed produce soon followed.

Are people sniffing/smelling in some strange manner that makes it weird that I am unfamiliar with? A good sniff isn't sneezing on it and you should be washing your fruit and veg when you get it home anyway considering it is naive to think someone sniffing it (or squeezing it) is the worst thing to happen to the produce before you get it home. (Pickers/suppliers/packers, shop staff and a half dozen other hands handling it before you potentially, less than spotless machinery harvesting or transporting, being dropped, potential pests in Distribution and storage centers, pesticides, fertilizers, etc etc.)

To me this seems like hyperbolic hysteria. How else do you discover if fruit is good quality if you don't examine it visually, handle it and with some things like tomatoes and melons, give it a good sniff! Otherwise, you could be buying subpar food.

Always sniff tomatoes, peaches, pineapples, melons etc by the stem looking for a sweetish scent to know it is going to taste good. No scent, no taste. Also, giving veg and bread a squeeze, and meat a poke I thought was standard procedure. At least that is what I was taught growing up.

Is it a lost skill? Snobbery? What is causing such a reaction to something I consider good practice?

AIBU to think it is childish and foolish to react so negatively to the idea of someone sniffing their produce?

OP posts:
Beckyfromthecroft · 20/09/2022 09:22

As long as you don’t then breathe out all over the produce and then put it back.
Even if you breath out all over it, so what. Wash your fruit and veg, Steve or Mary doing their weekly shop and breathing all over the veg is one of the least gross things in the food chain.

KimberleyClark · 20/09/2022 09:18

Bubblebubblebah · 19/09/2022 20:41

I want to know how people who think it's disgusting sniff things. 😂 Are they aware you breath in not out and nose doesn't touch produce?😂

As long as you don’t then breathe out all over the produce and then put it back.

Brefugee · 20/09/2022 09:14

Why on earth would you sniff a tomato? You'd go by the feel/texture of that so that's weird.

because it can look ripe and juicy and feel ripe and juicy but if it doesn't smell of tomato it only tastes of water.

It's batshittery, OP, ignore and carry on.

stickygotstuck · 20/09/2022 09:12

pastabest · 20/09/2022 08:50

yes it's culturally acceptable there but it isn't here, which is why you don't ever see it happen

It's absolutely culturally acceptable here and I see it happen all the time?

I pity people who are so disconnected from their food they don't care what their tomatoes smell like.

100 times this.

Culturally acceptable? When talking about tomatoes? Really? I've heard it all now.

pastabest · 20/09/2022 08:50

yes it's culturally acceptable there but it isn't here, which is why you don't ever see it happen

It's absolutely culturally acceptable here and I see it happen all the time?

I pity people who are so disconnected from their food they don't care what their tomatoes smell like.

ArcticSkewer · 20/09/2022 08:40

LondonLovie · 19/09/2022 23:27

Good God, I would hate to see some of Mumsnet in a French supermarket or market then! It's literally a passed time sniffing fruit. I mean seriously doesn't everyone sniff a melon before buying it?!

yes it's culturally acceptable there but it isn't here, which is why you don't ever see it happen. Hth

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 19/09/2022 23:38

Everyone who thinks sniffing produce is going to introduce germs does realise that the produce has been handled by dozens of people before you get it right?

It will have been through a variety of machines to pick, pack and move it, shoved in lorries, handled between lorries and storage, then moved out onto the shop floor where customers and staff will have touched it to either pick the stuff they want to buy or redistribute it in the box.

And that's assuming the very best and trying to ignore the likelihood that it won't also have had flies land on it, mice/rats checking it out and spiders living in the box.

I never buy strawberries without checking that they smell strongly like strawberries, especially if they're out of season. Tomatoes are the same, they can look lovely but smell and taste of nothing.

Then I rinse them before eating.

xsquared · 19/09/2022 23:34

I didn't know sniffing fruit was even a thing until I read this thread! Never seen anyone IRL sniff produce in a supermarket.

If you squeeze fruit, then it bruises it, so who wants to buy that? I have seen signs in market stalls with "Do t squeeze me until.Im yours"

LondonLovie · 19/09/2022 23:27

Good God, I would hate to see some of Mumsnet in a French supermarket or market then! It's literally a passed time sniffing fruit. I mean seriously doesn't everyone sniff a melon before buying it?!

Bubblebubblebah · 19/09/2022 23:26

Ein · 19/09/2022 22:58

Yuck.

Problem is that (while the sniff test does work and I use it at home), shortly after you breathe in, you breathe out. Puffing your bacteria close all over food that someone else might have to eat. Very rude.

When you’ve paid for it, then you can breathe on it. Until then keep your sniffles away from other people’s food.

Amazing to still find this kind of behaviour when we’ve been in a pandemic for years.

I eill just recap the smelling manual from first page.

You put fruit close to your nose, breathe in, rrmove fruit from the close proximity to your face, resume normal breathing.

Thighdentitycrisis · 19/09/2022 23:09

I sniff melons, I test pineapple by pulling a leaf (bit of a sniff too). Most tomatoes don’t taste of much anymore so I skip those

Rosewaterblossom · 19/09/2022 23:01

Papirus · 19/09/2022 22:52

When you buy lose produce you don't get a use by date or in meat from the butcher?

I don't think an out of date apple or tomato is going to do anyone any harm and that's what the thread was about.

Apples and tomatoes will be effected by spoilage bacteria, which on the whole isn't nice but won't make you sick like food poisoning bacteria. The butcher will have dates they are allowed to sell that particular meat by, even it's not displayeddirectlyon the counter, and rely on stock rotation.

ByTheGrace · 19/09/2022 23:00

People have become so sanitised and so far removed from food growing and the natural world. Food is something that comes sanitised and prepacked for many people. No connections with soil and animals and the land that it is grown on. Do people realise animal shit is added to fields? It's not a sanitised process.

It's no wonder today's supermarket vegetables are bland and tasteless compared to a veg Market in Europe, or even America.
You need to sniff for taste, it's not breathing out germs, you breathe in to smell! Feeling both meat and produce tells you about freshness and ripeness. Squeezing bread will tell you if it's stale, the gentlest of squeezes, you don't need to squash or damage it.

I'm aghast that people don't know these things. I was brought up in a farming family and it's second nature. This is actually quite a depressing thread.

SausagePourHomme · 19/09/2022 23:00

i always smell tomatoes, only way to know if they will taste of anything - same with apples - i waft it near my nose i don't make contact

I also wash fruit and veg before i eat it. from what I'm told, a lot worse has happened to it than being gingerly sniffed before it lands on the shelf. it needs a good rinse anyway

Ein · 19/09/2022 22:58

Yuck.

Problem is that (while the sniff test does work and I use it at home), shortly after you breathe in, you breathe out. Puffing your bacteria close all over food that someone else might have to eat. Very rude.

When you’ve paid for it, then you can breathe on it. Until then keep your sniffles away from other people’s food.

Amazing to still find this kind of behaviour when we’ve been in a pandemic for years.

elephantoverthehill · 19/09/2022 22:57

@Papirus Me too in France. However having worked in a Greengrocer's, many years ago, sniffing is fine but squeezing is not good, especially with peaches, avocados etc. because the next person who buys that fruit has bruised fruit.

Rosewaterblossom · 19/09/2022 22:57

Bubblebubblebah · 19/09/2022 22:51

I realised we weren't even originally talking about dates and I stupidly for unknown to me reason put them in😂

If you think of it like food poisoning bacteria multiplies like 2, 4, 16, 64, 256, 1024, 4096.. you get the drift. One day, even one hour is not much time for it to multiply to unsafe levels that'll make you sick. The main issue with out of date meat is the toxins, which like I said, aren't killed off during the cooking process.

Lockheart · 19/09/2022 22:53

It's because most people are idiots when it comes to "germs", our food chain, and the natural world. If it's not wrapped in plastic and liberally sprayed with pesticides, if it's a slightly odd shape or has a small mark it's no good.

There is a vast spectrum of quality in between edible and good to eat.

Papirus · 19/09/2022 22:52

Rosewaterblossom · 19/09/2022 22:49

That's your choice I guess, I'm just there to endure the public are sold food that is safe to eat. What they do beyond that their choice, although food poisoning is horrendous!
I'd question if there was no sticker. They must have a use by date, at least if you ask them, otherwise I'd be questioning it and necessary, reporting it.

When you buy lose produce you don't get a use by date or in meat from the butcher?

I don't think an out of date apple or tomato is going to do anyone any harm and that's what the thread was about.

ChickinMarango · 19/09/2022 22:52

To be honest I didn’t realise it worked with so many different varieties 😳

I have been known to pull out all the different names varieties of strawberries on offer and give them a sniff through the holes in packaging to find the sweetest one. Pleased to say I was shopping with a friend and she now does it too. It’s a game changer!

FlorettaB · 19/09/2022 22:52

My dad grew up in a family where they turned part of their council house garden into an allotment because it was cheaper than buying the stuff. His cousin still grows some veg on the balcony of his council flat. It is about what you grow up with but it’s not automatically linked to income or class.

Bubblebubblebah · 19/09/2022 22:51

Rosewaterblossom · 19/09/2022 22:49

That's your choice I guess, I'm just there to endure the public are sold food that is safe to eat. What they do beyond that their choice, although food poisoning is horrendous!
I'd question if there was no sticker. They must have a use by date, at least if you ask them, otherwise I'd be questioning it and necessary, reporting it.

I realised we weren't even originally talking about dates and I stupidly for unknown to me reason put them in😂

Thatswhyimacat · 19/09/2022 22:50

Bubblebubblebah · 19/09/2022 22:48

Isn't it actually that the "grim" and "vom" people are being snobby or Whateber that would be called. Op isn't, it's reaction to being called grim for inhaling air near produce

No, for me the 'I just don't understand why you wouldn't!' faux naivety where OP seemingly doesn't understand that a lot of people don't have access to food education or even any fresh food in the first place, that is snobby.

Rosewaterblossom · 19/09/2022 22:49

Bubblebubblebah · 19/09/2022 22:45

It is a hill I will die on tbh that 1 day wouldn't make a difference.

Again. What do people do if it doesn't have a sticker on.

That's your choice I guess, I'm just there to endure the public are sold food that is safe to eat. What they do beyond that their choice, although food poisoning is horrendous!
I'd question if there was no sticker. They must have a use by date, at least if you ask them, otherwise I'd be questioning it and necessary, reporting it.

Bubblebubblebah · 19/09/2022 22:48

Thatswhyimacat · 19/09/2022 22:44

It's no more grim than touching it, although I'd probably prefer there weren't huge numbers of people handling my food before me in general.

Where yabu is your snobby and patronising attitude towards people who haven't had the upbringing you have. Sorry, no my parents didn't teach me how to identify quality produce from their home grown garden, because I grew up in a house where you were fed a 10p tin of basics brand ravioli for dinner and we lived in a room over a stable with one bed for mum and two kids.

Isn't it actually that the "grim" and "vom" people are being snobby or Whateber that would be called. Op isn't, it's reaction to being called grim for inhaling air near produce