Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people post troll threads

84 replies

Dishwashersaurous · 19/09/2022 20:28

Just that really. In amongst the people cheering themselves up, asking for advice and sometimes changing their lives.

Why do you think that people actively make stuff up in order to get a bunch of strangers to comment?

OP posts:
meatballsoup · 20/09/2022 00:06

I think it's a way to live out a fantasy of a life they want but don't have. Even if it's just mundane stuff. I actually got trolled in real life a few years back. Met this really nice woman at playgroup. She was smart & funny, nice kids I really enjoyed spending time with her. We would meet with & without the kids. I never met her husband, but her story added up, he worked away! Turns out she was the kid's nanny. I found out by seeing the kids at a park, said hello & had a very weird convo with their actual mum.

Dinomummy2 · 19/09/2022 23:43

Is this why the smelling illness thread was deleted, was it a troll? I found that really interesting.and can't think why else it could be.

MayISuggestSomeThickCutSteakChipsToGoWithThat · 19/09/2022 23:40

@illiterato yes that's the one!!

MayISuggestSomeThickCutSteakChipsToGoWithThat · 19/09/2022 23:39

VanillaSpiceCandle · 19/09/2022 21:16

I don’t know. I rarely post but was on a thread about the weather that got deleted.

I kind of understand the sicko trolls that make up stuff about deaths etc they’re just sick freaks with nothing else going on. I don’t understand the mundane ones - why would you start bullshitting about nonsense and boring every day scenarios?

The vilest one I've ever read on here, was the one who's husband had being killed in a crash after he got hit head on by a Truck and his car burst into flames, the way she described everything in detail and how she wet herself at his funeral. I still can't listen to Caribbean Blue without wondering how low someone can go to make up shit like that.

AbcMurders · 19/09/2022 23:36

@PearlWithTheGirlEarring ahhhh I came across
one like that but thought it must be legit as it’s so detailed … second guessing it now…

another poster made a good point about how it’s not even trolling in the traditional sense, wonder if there’s a word for it

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 19/09/2022 23:36

Cuck00soup · 19/09/2022 21:49

There are of course people with mental health problems who sadly are unlikely to get the help they need from Mumsnet.

Then there are people wanting something; money, validation, attention.
Those on the wind up, looking to get posters frothing, journalists, people with an agenda looking for screenshots, people wanting to flog something.

Some of the wind up ones are amusing as are the more obvious fantasy uses. The begging ones less so, especially when they draw in people who perhaps don't have much for themselves.

The begging threads piss me off. They post for 'help' with ideas to make money/save money, then proceed to dismiss any and every idea given to them. They NEVER have family or friends or anything to sell, and they have already tried the many avenues that other posters suggest.

Upshot is, they are hoping someone will send money.

Then you have at LEAST one muppet on every thread who says 'I would rather lose 20/30/50 quid than think a young single mum is going hungry.'

Mugs.

audeloquipalam · 19/09/2022 23:26

TrashPandas · 19/09/2022 20:48

Attention, entertainment, a fetish, so-called "journalists" who aren't capable of reporting real news, fantasists unsatisfied with their real lives, and traumatised people trying to come to terms with some scenario that didn't play out how they wanted.

I think that covers it.

This.

Also special mention for “Trigger Warning” and/or “Name Change” as fairly reliable indicators of fictitious screed to follow.

OneTC · 19/09/2022 23:11

And also it's much easier to do it here than on many other platforms. It's pretty much set up to facilitate it with the easy name changes

OneTC · 19/09/2022 23:07

Some of the best posts on here are obvious trolling.

Most of the funny ones in classics are obvious troll threads

WagathaChristieMystery · 19/09/2022 23:04

TrashPandas · 19/09/2022 20:51

MNHQ's protection of one of the longest running fantasists certainly doesn't help. She was caught out when she posted a picture of a luxury hotel room and claimed it was her bedroom, but MN allowed her to name change and carry on.

@TrashPandas I remember them! I wonder if they’re the same troll that @illiterato mentions? Sorry if they’re totally unrelated - they might be different. I don’t want to mention their name directly, but it was the word you use for tiny little pieces of foods like bread or cake.

PearlWithTheGirlEarring · 19/09/2022 23:03

And special mentions for those dedicated to the medical profession that can research all kinds of drugs and Illnesses for their tall medical tales. Those kind I’m sure have some weird type of munchausens by Google or something.

AbcMurders · 19/09/2022 22:54

tbh that sounds like a lot of the current active threads 😬

PearlWithTheGirlEarring · 19/09/2022 22:53

They are pretty easy to spot though. The story ever escalating with each post. A cast of loveable characters brought into it, hot relatives, neighbours etc
the story always escalates at a ridiculous pace, from suspecting cheating to being half way up the motorway and leaving him within 12 hours. All designed to pull on the heartstrings and encourage the gullible who’ll will the OP on with their faux excitement.

Twos0ups · 19/09/2022 22:29

People on this forum are so gullible though, and Will believe any old crap.
i’m sure some people do it for a laugh.

HarpicHarpy · 19/09/2022 22:14

Good old fashioned attention seeking. They're the same people that sit next to you on the bus and immediately unload their entire (fictional) life story. Or the people that visit the same holiday destination for 25 years and take great pride in knowing all the waiters names and think the hotel owner looks forward to their visit and sees them as family (he doesn't). They're sad, lonely, and want to feel seen and a part of something.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 19/09/2022 22:07

Anonymity emboldens people to behave in strange ways. But it's strange that internet 'trolling' seems to have shifted in its meaning. On MN, it now seems to have come to mean something as innocuous as a creative writing exercise that's clearly a crock of old bollocks.

In the older-school forums trolling had much more sinister, unpleasant undertones, comprising content that was clearly intended to cause maximum hurt and unhappiness to others. It still exists elsewhere online, such as the doxing, death threats and bullying campaigns conducted on sites like Twitter, or malicious sites with threads designed to persecute one particular person. On MN, most of it's silly stories seemingly written for the poster's own amusement, although there are certain fetishists (look out for threads about menstruation, personal hygiene and shit) which are evidently posted to extract personal information for the author's own titillation.

Weirdos. But The world's full of oddballs; no reason why the www should be any different.

Suzi888 · 19/09/2022 21:55

Too much time on their hands, idle hands etc with an added hint of wanting to be dick?

Nameless3 · 19/09/2022 21:53

I don't think that there are complex reasons for trolling. I think people troll because they can.

Cuck00soup · 19/09/2022 21:49

There are of course people with mental health problems who sadly are unlikely to get the help they need from Mumsnet.

Then there are people wanting something; money, validation, attention.
Those on the wind up, looking to get posters frothing, journalists, people with an agenda looking for screenshots, people wanting to flog something.

Some of the wind up ones are amusing as are the more obvious fantasy uses. The begging ones less so, especially when they draw in people who perhaps don't have much for themselves.

TheCutter · 19/09/2022 21:34

I wonder this too. Very pathetic people 🤷🏼‍♀️

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 19/09/2022 21:34

Definitely attention seeking, loneliness, or insecurity, and it's very likely that their life has not turned out how they want - so they fantasise and pretend to random strangers they are very successful professionals with lots of wealth etc etc... ...

Some pretend they know famous people, or a famous Prince, etc, and a close family member works for someone famous etc etc. All kinds of crap. The very highly educated, very highly paid, living in million pound home claims are very likely mostly fake, and all lies.

The ones who have made threads up about losing a baby or a child, or having terminal cancer, and other devastating life changing things, and they're just trolling baffle me. There is something very wrong with them and they need help.

Then there are the ones who make up shit about their neighbour attacking them for not watching the Queen's funeral, and make up random parking, neighbour, work, relationship, and friendship issues that don't exist.

They usually drop themselves in it when they start posting inconsistencies, and people call them out. Then MN delete the thread, and say 'troll.'

But yeah I do think it's largely boredom, and loneliness, and feeling like a huge failure in their life, so they invent scenarios in which they have a wonderful, starstruck life with wonderful lovers, great beauty, a fabulous career, and great riches. Oh also, if they are not married, they always have multiple FWBs, they always travel extensively, and they are always upper middle class.

Much of this ^(possibly all,) is bullshit. A fantasy life created by a bored and lonely person who hasn't achieved much in life.

AbcMurders · 19/09/2022 21:26

Good point

and yeah that’s actually disgusting, it’s psychopathic - I’m always a bit weary when sometimes posts a huge sad story, but then feel guilty just in case they are true

illiterato · 19/09/2022 21:19

I guess it’s broken window theory- if they let the harmless ones go then it encourages it. There was an awful one where someone posted that their husband was an airline pilot and was so sleep deprived after the birth of their child that they fell asleep at the wheel and were killed on the way to work leaving her widowed with a 10 week old baby. Loads of people who were genuinely bereaved were offering help. Really sick.

AbcMurders · 19/09/2022 21:17

@illiterato
Thanks for clarifying that, makes sense in regard to that one with all the inconsistencies. But I wonder how they make judgement calls sometimes in regard to other ones, as it’s not like they can go check on the poster irl to assess if they’re lying, if that makes sense.
@EbbyEbs
agree, I don’t get the logic sometimes, harmless funny ones are ripped down quite quickly but they sometimes let lots of racist stuff run for ages before reacting, and posters who are clearly just winding people up and detailing threads are also left to run riot - just seems a bit inconsistent sometimes

VanillaSpiceCandle · 19/09/2022 21:16

I don’t know. I rarely post but was on a thread about the weather that got deleted.

I kind of understand the sicko trolls that make up stuff about deaths etc they’re just sick freaks with nothing else going on. I don’t understand the mundane ones - why would you start bullshitting about nonsense and boring every day scenarios?