Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why people post troll threads

84 replies

Dishwashersaurous · 19/09/2022 20:28

Just that really. In amongst the people cheering themselves up, asking for advice and sometimes changing their lives.

Why do you think that people actively make stuff up in order to get a bunch of strangers to comment?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Inklingpot · 21/09/2022 12:57

Because they get attention from hundreds of credulous MNers breathlessly demanding updates ‘even if it’s a troll because I neeeeeeeeed entertainment and closure’.

PrincessofWales · 21/09/2022 10:00

@TrashPandas I'm annoyed I've risen to your bait. The End.

PrincessofWales · 21/09/2022 09:55

TrashPandas · 21/09/2022 09:20

PrincessofWales Not convinced - the anti-stepmum trope doesn't stand up to scrutiny and nobody would be deleted in the circumstances you describe.

@TrashPandas

That's your opinion. Why would I lie? What a silly post.
Just read the step parenting forum if you don't think it stands up to YOUR scrutiny.

TrashPandas · 21/09/2022 09:20

PrincessofWales Not convinced - the anti-stepmum trope doesn't stand up to scrutiny and nobody would be deleted in the circumstances you describe.

AnneBoIeyn · 20/09/2022 22:00

Covid gave plenty of trolls the opportunity to shine. The covid board was full of them for months, telling us we were all going to die and that if we put chocolate in our shopping baskets we were as good as murderers. I think it did start off as genuine worry for some, but for a few it was downright trolling all along - I know that one in particular was banned. She was awful and said some genuinely upsetting things. She tried to return several times but was thankfully banned each time. I think she's given up now.

PrincessofWales · 20/09/2022 11:05

TrashPandas · 20/09/2022 10:57

I've been here about 10 years and never seen anybody banned for disagreeing in a polite and respectful way. Can you give some examples?

I've seen plenty in the 10+ years I've been here.

There was one post shortly after the schools returned from the pandemic posted by a teacher. She was 'exhausted' and one poster politely pointed out that as an NHS worker in critical care she was possibly exaggerating as schools had had months off. The poster disappeared and her posts were removed. She was one of the few posters with a differing opinion to the majority on the thread who were all teachers. She wasn't impolite.

Step mum posts always attract differing opinions. It happens less now as I think MN were pulled up on it, but there was a very anti step mum feeling a year or so ago where step mums posting their experience, etc were deleted.

That's just two examples, I've seen lots more.

TrashPandas · 20/09/2022 10:57

PrincessofWales · 20/09/2022 10:37

There's also a big difference between being a troll and just having a differing opinion to the majority on a thread. I think Mumsnet is too quick to delete and block posters who are just expressing an opposite opinion if that's done in a respectful and polite way.

I've been here about 10 years and never seen anybody banned for disagreeing in a polite and respectful way. Can you give some examples?

AbcMurders · 20/09/2022 10:54

@10HailMarys

The munchausen theory rings true - unfortunately I know someone irl who dramatises (lies) for sympathy and attention constantly. Stands to reason they prob post online too - sad.

PearlWithTheGirlEarring · 20/09/2022 10:42

OneTC · 20/09/2022 10:24

A better question would be why you all care though.

I read stuff other people write on the internet because it's a chill way to pass some time. I've never felt "invested" in a thread because the random, very likely fictional, wittering of strangers in the internet means very little to me beyond that. I don't care if they're real or not, it makes no difference to anyone.

Even the stuff that might be real is the presentation of one side of the situation who already feels uncertain enough that they need the validation of strangers, in a community where name changes and some details being changed in the story to hide ID are all accepted. So even the stuff presented in relatively good faith is biased dramatised nonsense

And that’s great. That’s how you deal with it, but that’s not true for everyone who reads here.

People are gullible, people send money, they give more of themselves to the troll than is healthy thinking they are being helpful and supportive.

some share personal details of their own lives, their children’s lives, often innocent but often playing right into the hands of the pervert that posted it under the guise of a genuine poster needing help and advice.

that’s why people care

georgarina · 20/09/2022 10:40

Just entertainment, same as when kids used to do prank calls

On the other hand I've posted really mundane threads in the past where posters have picked up on random details and decided there's NO WAY it could EVER have happened and accused me of being a troll/journalist.

PrincessofWales · 20/09/2022 10:37

There's also a big difference between being a troll and just having a differing opinion to the majority on a thread. I think Mumsnet is too quick to delete and block posters who are just expressing an opposite opinion if that's done in a respectful and polite way.

PrincessofWales · 20/09/2022 10:35

illiterato · 19/09/2022 20:34

There was a persistent and actually reasonably convincing troll on here for years. She made up this whole life where she and her husband lived in a one bed flat in zone 1 London with two perfectly behaved children and she had this amazing career and still managed to run 10k after work every day. She was v vocal on weird things like eating really late and the children going to bed at the same time as her and her DH. She kept it going for years. I can only conclude that she wanted that to be her life and possibly even almost believed it herself.

I'm interested to know how you knew she was a troll and it wasn't real?

Eyesofdisarray · 20/09/2022 10:32

Makes me think of Walter Mitty

10HailMarys · 20/09/2022 10:26

It's all sorts of reasons I think.

  • Boredom and loneliness and general desperation for attention/sympathy/praise/whatever
  • They like inventing scenarios and characters but don't have any other outlet for this, such as a creative writing class
  • They like winding people up, like a child who pulls other kids' pigtails in the playground
  • They want to make a point about a real issue, but don't actually have a genuine personal example so they make one up
  • They have some kind of psychological or psychiatric problem, akin to Munchausen's or an obsessive disorder of some kind
  • They have a fetish and want to induce people to talk about the thing that excites them
  • They want to 'expose' other posters by eliciting an extreme response from them - eg they might post something under the fake persona of a racist, to find out how many people post in agreement and thus expose them as racists
OneTC · 20/09/2022 10:24

A better question would be why you all care though.

I read stuff other people write on the internet because it's a chill way to pass some time. I've never felt "invested" in a thread because the random, very likely fictional, wittering of strangers in the internet means very little to me beyond that. I don't care if they're real or not, it makes no difference to anyone.

Even the stuff that might be real is the presentation of one side of the situation who already feels uncertain enough that they need the validation of strangers, in a community where name changes and some details being changed in the story to hide ID are all accepted. So even the stuff presented in relatively good faith is biased dramatised nonsense

FiveShelties · 20/09/2022 10:19

Most of them are really obvious and stupid posted by stupid people. They are fine, it is the ones where poster says they have terminal cancer or similar tragedy in their life which I really hate - they are evil. I have no idea what their objective is but to get sympathy from people about something they have made up is awful.

lickenchugget · 20/09/2022 10:15

Insignificant people trying to feel significant

mamabear715 · 20/09/2022 10:15

I'd probably fall for them all, lol, & my memory isn't good enough to post anything that's not true!
Can they be found out by IP addresses, or don't smartphones have those? (I'm old, lol, bear with me!)

OneTC · 20/09/2022 10:03

AbcMurders · 19/09/2022 23:36

@PearlWithTheGirlEarring ahhhh I came across
one like that but thought it must be legit as it’s so detailed … second guessing it now…

another poster made a good point about how it’s not even trolling in the traditional sense, wonder if there’s a word for it

Using the internet

TrashPandas · 20/09/2022 09:32

illiterato · 19/09/2022 21:03

She was caught out when she posted a picture of a luxury hotel room and claimed it was her bedroom, but MN allowed her to name change and carry on.

I know who you’re referring to but she was tricky as she wasn’t really a troll- she just lied / exaggerated a lot, but a lot of what she did say was true. In some ways she was very identifiable- for example she had a real photo of herself on her profile.

I'm using the MN definition of troll (which as you and MarieIVanArkleStinks say, is not the definition the rest of the internet uses). MNHQ have deleted plenty of threads and banned plenty of users who were lying, but this one is protected for some reason.

WagathaChristieMystery Yep, that's the one!

NippyWoowoo · 20/09/2022 08:35

Nameless3 · 19/09/2022 20:47

Because it's easy to troll MN where loads of posters believe them. Because troll hunting is not allowed. Because name changing is allowed.

this perfectly sums it up. the troll hunting rule means that many people are unable to spot the signs or a classic troll, and continue to get sucked in by future posts.

while trolls may think that they're unique, most have a lot of tell-tale signs that give them away.

BadNomad · 20/09/2022 03:59

The feeling of power, control and superiority by being able to manipulate many people. Plus attention and amusement.

HighlandPony · 20/09/2022 01:53

If I’m honest some of my friends in real life do this. Mumsnet has a rep for being full of hoity toity “I would never do that with my child” women, sometimes a bit of a bitchfest and sometimes they post stuff to wind you up and get a laugh at it themselves. They screenshot some of the answers and put them on group chat.

HatThatWearsYou · 20/09/2022 01:35

meatballsoup · 20/09/2022 00:06

I think it's a way to live out a fantasy of a life they want but don't have. Even if it's just mundane stuff. I actually got trolled in real life a few years back. Met this really nice woman at playgroup. She was smart & funny, nice kids I really enjoyed spending time with her. We would meet with & without the kids. I never met her husband, but her story added up, he worked away! Turns out she was the kid's nanny. I found out by seeing the kids at a park, said hello & had a very weird convo with their actual mum.

That would really freak me out if I were in that mums place and found out about that.

I think there's been more incels trolling in here in the last few years, they seem to delight in trying to upset or gaslight any woman they can. The really obvious ones get thrown out quickly thankfully.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 20/09/2022 00:21

HarpicHarpy · 19/09/2022 22:14

Good old fashioned attention seeking. They're the same people that sit next to you on the bus and immediately unload their entire (fictional) life story. Or the people that visit the same holiday destination for 25 years and take great pride in knowing all the waiters names and think the hotel owner looks forward to their visit and sees them as family (he doesn't). They're sad, lonely, and want to feel seen and a part of something.

OMG I think we all know/have known/have met people like this. Whenever some random fucker on a bus or in a queue, starts banging on about their life/their hernia/their childhood blah blah blah, they never EVER want to hear anything about you or your life. They are only interested in themselves. You try to talk but their eyes wander off, and you can see their mind working overtime, trying to think what bollocks they can bore you with about themselves next.

And yes to the holiday bores...........

Swipe left for the next trending thread