Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help for people on Universal Credit

84 replies

Bellysmackers · 19/09/2022 19:34

OK so I'll more than likely get shot down in flames, fully prepared for that! But...it often feels to me like the more you work and try to create a decent life the more you're penalised. No handouts and help for people who are really trying in life.

My old aunt worked until retirement. She now pays ridiculous fees for her own care home. The lady in the room next to her barely worked a day in her life and it all gets paid for.

It annoys me! A lot!

Why are we not rewarded for trying to do well?

Thoughts??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dreamwhisper · 20/09/2022 10:31

What annoys me is the ones who could work yet choose not to and rely on handouts

As others have pointed out though, do you know how vanishingly small this demographic actually is? The UC system is fine for people like me on a regular salaried income which rarely changes and is paid in equal instalments. For anyone else it can be very draconian. There is no "lazing about" anymore. You have to be actively pursuing work and you have to accept any job offer made or else you will be sanctioned. You are expected to put the same number of hours into job seeking as you would be expected to work. And again, if a job offer came up you would have to accept it even if unsuitable due to the sanction system.

There simply isn't scope for being a "layabout" on the system. So anyone who is doing that is going to be in a minority so tiny it's not worth thinking about. And anyway, the UC entitlement for someone not working and with no dependents is very small. It's not much of a life living like that, is it really worth getting so indignant about?

Porcupineintherough · 19/09/2022 23:16

what should happen to the old lady

She should be fully subsidised by the state, not part subsidised by the fee-paying residents. This would mean the contributions paid by the tax p@ayer would go up but care home fees for self-funders would go down. The current system just takes the piss.

Thelnebriati · 19/09/2022 23:09

You can have my life on benefits OP; you have to take the shitty lifelong disability that goes with them. Your call.

OP's like this one suck all of the fun out of Mumsnet.

Gilead · 19/09/2022 23:00

I won’t be able to afford a care home. I’m lucky enough to own my house. I’m a wheelchair user, currently in hospital. I had an excellent job, and a very nasty divorce which meant I had to retire early. I’m now a benefit scrounger. Perhaps I shouldn’t have married an arsehole, but you know what, I didn’t know it would turn out this way and this autistic woman was unable to recognise the red flags.
#shouldhaveplannedbetter
😡

Cw112 · 19/09/2022 22:58

Also, instead of blaming the people with less income etc why not blame the big companies who avoid their taxes and the tory gov who haven't exactly helped the rest of us who are actually in a position to make changes? Blaming people on UC is just a way to distract from the real problems with the cost of living and lack of increase in wages. Typical scapegoating that takes pressure off the government

NameChangedForThis12398 · 19/09/2022 22:56

Yanbu. I'm worse off as a single working parent working 9am-3pm than I was when I only worked 9:30am-1pm. I'm about £60pw worse off. Taught me not to increase my hours again.

Cw112 · 19/09/2022 22:55

Bellysmackers · 19/09/2022 19:38

Often tempted 🙄🙄

Let me know how you get on with budgeting will you? I work with lots of young people in UC and with the way things are going even I'm struggling to make ends meet in their budget plans with only basic expenses included so I look forward to seeing how you do it.

Gilead · 19/09/2022 22:52

well my neighbours three children aren’t. 🤷🏼‍♀️😂 They live in a VERY nice house- all claim UC and live off mummy and daddy. One works part time.
They will have to show they’re actively looking for work, they won’t get much because they will not be paying rent, 79 quid a week doesn’t go far.

VladmirsPoutine · 19/09/2022 22:39

And who is to even say that the lady had all 7 children willingly. Birth control and women's bodily autonomy is actually only recent. All that aside you are a tory's wet dream - part of a demographic who will exist on the wheel with no real prospect of riches but will resent absolutely everyone in the same boat as you.

bruce43mydog · 19/09/2022 21:14

I can't believe your calling a lady who brought up 7 children lazy. Having all them children to take care of is very hard work. If the lady didn't work a payed job then good for her, that was her choice and is absolutely none of your or anyone elses concern. The Lady with 7 children will of struggled all her life financially.
Your Aunt worked and provided herself a comfortable life. If your Aunt has the funds to pay care home fees thats amazing and your Aunt should be proud of that fact, but also understand that not everyone is in the same boat & some people need extra funding.

Givenuptotally · 19/09/2022 21:02

That's her problem to deal with. She should have planned better

So youbare advocating a judgement based system which leaves those judhed not to jave planned adequately for retirement left on the streets? I mean, it is clear you are happy with that but you realise that would result in higher levels of crime, that many neighbourhoods would become totally unsafe, gated communities would become the norm for those who can afford it (which wouldn't be many of us). People with dementia are unpredictable and sometimes a danger to others, that's before they are tired, cold and hungry. You're happy to live in that society?

BattenburgDonkey · 19/09/2022 21:01

Bellysmackers · 19/09/2022 20:30

My aunt has regularly spoken to the other woman, who openly admits she rarely worked during her life, had a council property and had 7 children that she admits she could barely afford to bring up. Clearly my Aunt feels upset that she worked full time until she was above retirement age, worked hard to pay off her mortgage, saved and tried to plan and now gets to pay £700 a week for care fees, whereas the other lady pays absolutely nothing. I will never change my viewpoint on this. To me it's unfair a day long. Be lazy - get rewarded.

So why should your aunt be eligible for hand outs? She planned for old age and it’s worked out well as she can pay her care home fees, good for her! What are you bothered about if your not after the inheritance? You don’t no that ‘lazy’ woman’s whole story, why she had so many kids, what stopped her from working, and your auntie may well be as miserable as you so her version of this ladies life may not be accurate anyway.

Why be so miserable about someone else surviving in the world?

QueenieL1 · 19/09/2022 20:58

From what your Aunt says about this lady, she's had a very hard life and would have been living in deprivation while bringing up her children.

WhiteFire · 19/09/2022 20:56

You are conflating lots of different issues.

I could, if I so desired, earn a lot of money, rent rather than buy and party hard and therefore have no assets when I require a place in a care home.

Am I better than that other woman? Am I more deserving because at least I earnt money? Or do I get left in the gutter too?

NotABeliever · 19/09/2022 20:46

cadburyegg · 19/09/2022 20:41

Why do people who are working ft earning good salaries not get help you mean? Fairly simple - their earnings are over the threshold. Of course people on lower incomes qualify for more. Do you want people to starve or freeze? A life as a higher earner is still much more financially comfortable than someone on benefits even if they are entitled to more.

I'm a single parent, I get some help from UC, I work part time, I would like more hours but my requests have been refused so far. I did and do work hard, I got good GCSEs and A levels and a degree, I work in a job that requires a degree and experience in the field. HTH.

Rachel MacLean would tell you to simply get a better paid job. What's the problem??
I wonder if the OP agrees?

cadburyegg · 19/09/2022 20:41

Why do people who are working ft earning good salaries not get help you mean? Fairly simple - their earnings are over the threshold. Of course people on lower incomes qualify for more. Do you want people to starve or freeze? A life as a higher earner is still much more financially comfortable than someone on benefits even if they are entitled to more.

I'm a single parent, I get some help from UC, I work part time, I would like more hours but my requests have been refused so far. I did and do work hard, I got good GCSEs and A levels and a degree, I work in a job that requires a degree and experience in the field. HTH.

QueenieL1 · 19/09/2022 20:40

Bringing up seven children must be hard work I'd imagine.

Sunnyqueen · 19/09/2022 20:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oysterbabe · 19/09/2022 20:38

Lazy??! She had 7 fucking kids. I have 2 and barely sit down.

ilovesooty · 19/09/2022 20:36

Bellysmackers · 19/09/2022 20:19

That's her problem to deal with. She should have planned better.

Cop out. I knew you wouldn't have a viable answer.

Bellysmackers · 19/09/2022 20:34

Dreamwhisper · 19/09/2022 19:59

Ah, of course, it all makes sense now!

The irony of being angry at others they perceive as money grabbing..

🤣🤣 She has 2 children she is very close to so doubt I'd cop for any inheritance nor would I ever expect to or want to! So....you are incorrect on this point, but excellent try beaut!

OP posts:
NotABeliever · 19/09/2022 20:30

"And the rest"

Bellysmackers · 19/09/2022 20:30

GrannyPantsAreGreat · 19/09/2022 20:24

'The lazy woman'..how is it that you have reached this conclusion about this woman?
You sound thick as a brick, OP.
I will work hard all my life. My family members have worked hard all their lives, often working in care homes.
Though none of us will ever have the money to pay those fees. It's incredibly difficult to save when you're on a pish wage topped up by UC.

My aunt has regularly spoken to the other woman, who openly admits she rarely worked during her life, had a council property and had 7 children that she admits she could barely afford to bring up. Clearly my Aunt feels upset that she worked full time until she was above retirement age, worked hard to pay off her mortgage, saved and tried to plan and now gets to pay £700 a week for care fees, whereas the other lady pays absolutely nothing. I will never change my viewpoint on this. To me it's unfair a day long. Be lazy - get rewarded.

OP posts:
SkirridHill · 19/09/2022 20:29

"If they would rather die they'd better do it, and decrease the surplus population".

NotABeliever · 19/09/2022 20:28

OP I work in the field. Let me tell you that you can't be on benefits without a "valid" reason: parent of a very young child, carer, highly disabled are all accepted as grounds for not needing to be available for work. Do you object to that? If not read on.

The people who don't fit these categories - and I am referring to working age population - don't get benefits. They are sanctioned or just don't qualify unless they are actively looking for work. There is no "lazy" or "not lazy". The system is designed to help those in the categories above abd the test only temporarily while they go back to work.

Is that wrong?? Of course not. That there are people who cheat the system does not mean that no one should be on benefits. And you'll be surprised how small the number of cheats actually is.

Additionally please do consider that in a civil society we pay for things we don't necessarily use through taxation because it is the right things to do. That way we can support the lady in the care home who hasn't worked because of a valid reason (see reasons above) instead of leaving her to die on the street.

Swipe left for the next trending thread