Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable finding out my longtime neighbour was once part of the KKK

168 replies

Leannery6 · 19/09/2022 18:33

Just abit of information on my backstory. I’m was born in the UK but moved to the US with my parents i was 16 and i am 38 now so i have lived most of my life here, i come back to the uk once every few years to come and visit my extended family.

I live in a nice suburban town in hernando county florida where i have lived my whole life. i have have lived in my house with my husband and two kids who are 16 and 10 for 13 years and have has no issues.
My neighbours have lived on my road for 30+ years and are both in their late 80s they are a man and wife, they were always lovely to me and my kids. Our steeet is a a really tight knit community where everyone knows eachother, we all have BBQs together quite often. My neighbours used to babysit my two kids occasionally when they were babies and i just never imagined i would find something like this out.
I always see him mowing his lawn and chat to him He recently told me out of the blue in a conversation about how he met his wife met that back in the 50s he was a part of the KKK, ive never been so shocked about anything in my life! I’m not sure if any of the other neighbours on the street know this but i would of never of thought in a million years! He is such a kind hearted person. I told my husband and he couldn’t believe it.
AIBU to feel extremely uncomfortable talking and loving next door to him now? I feel like i might be over exaggerating but i can’t look at him the same now,
From what i can see he has absolutely nothing to do with it anymore but i still feel odd whenever i see him. My husband says that i’m overreacting but i’m not sure how to feel. I can’t even avoid him or his wife either because we had quite a close relationship so it would be weird to just stop speaking to them. AIBU to feel like this?

OP posts:
Calphurnia88 · 21/09/2022 10:55

This thread is going the same way as the other one that was shut down this week.

Incredible how many Mumsnet users think racism towards black people (in this case pertaining to one of the most famous violent terrorist organisations) is a simple difference of opinion.

The mind boggles.

TeamRR · 21/09/2022 10:14

maddening · 21/09/2022 07:52

I voted yabu as his views may have changed, there is no evidence he himself committed any crimes and it is possible to speak to and even be friends with people who have differing views and histories. The fact that there has been no indication of racism in your relatively close (for neighbours) relationship indicates he does not hold those views now.

Imo the whole "never speak to" and/or alienate people with views we don't agree with is very closed minded and does nothing to further dialogue or change minds, it acts to divide and polarise and is not the way forward.

There's having different views, and there's casually mentioning that you were a member of a terrorist group.

Lycanthropology · 21/09/2022 10:06

I would assume that 99% of members of KKK still living have never caused or participated in physical harm to anyone, so some of the comments up-thread are hyperbole

I doubt that percentage is true, but in any case they all supported, encouraged and condoned such actions, which is why they happened.
Jeez.

dreamingbohemian · 21/09/2022 10:04

Well sure, if you don't think there's anything intrinsically evil about the SS, the KKK must seem like a scouts group 🙄

Getoff · 21/09/2022 09:59

I would judge someone by their behaviour now, not their past or even current claimed beliefs. He sounds OK, unless there's something OP is not seeing.

The most racist person I was at school with was the best behaved when actually interacting with the people he was racist toward. His racism was entirely a cultural belief, inherited from his parents in the same way that most people inherit their religion. It had no visible impact on how he dealt with people in real life.

A few decades ago I had a student job where the boss (and company owner) was allegedly a former SS member. As far as I knew he hadn't done anything evil in the several decades since the war ended, so I didn't regard him as intrinsically evil.

I would assume that 99% of members of KKK still living have never caused or participated in physical harm to anyone, so some of the comments up-thread are hyperbole.

dreamingbohemian · 21/09/2022 09:46

'having a racist thought' and joining the KKK are not in the same league, have a word with yourself

It might make white people feel good to be all forgiving and accepting but the best way to stamp out racism and fascism is to have zero tolerance for it. Do you not know what's happening in the US right now? An attempted coup by the far right, Republican election rallies recently have people giving fascist salutes -- this is not a 'difference of opinion', there is a massive and powerful campaign to seize control of the country permanently. Now is not the time to go around saying we need to embrace racists and it's no big deal.

No one is saying to put this man in prison or persecute him, it's hardly the end of the world if a neighbour stops talking to him.

Lycanthropology · 21/09/2022 09:40

Exactly @3WildOnes

Lycanthropology · 21/09/2022 09:39

maddening · 21/09/2022 08:21

So are you saying that once a person (of any colour) has a racist thought they can never redeem themselves and are a social pariah for the rest of their lives?

Also, by making people social pariahs how do you suggest that drives the conversation forward and helps social cohesion for our society, surely the aim is to get to a place where we no longer have a racism problem, we don't want this to go on forever do we?

There is no indication that this neighbour wants to redeem himself. If this situation occured exactly as described by OP, then her neighbour gave no further context, expressed no regret, didn't seem to distance himself from last behaviour and mentioned it quite casually and in an unembarrassed way.

Surely anyone who has been in a such a hateful and murderous group but had now genuinely changed would a) just not mention it in the first place, or b) make it very very clear that they were beyond sorry for their actions, and were a completely different person now.

So no, I'd not be friendly to my racist neighbour, thanks. Making social pariahs of racists surely sends a strong message that they're doing something wrong; having 'conversation' gives the message that their views are worthy of respect.

3WildOnes · 21/09/2022 09:36

maddening · 21/09/2022 07:52

I voted yabu as his views may have changed, there is no evidence he himself committed any crimes and it is possible to speak to and even be friends with people who have differing views and histories. The fact that there has been no indication of racism in your relatively close (for neighbours) relationship indicates he does not hold those views now.

Imo the whole "never speak to" and/or alienate people with views we don't agree with is very closed minded and does nothing to further dialogue or change minds, it acts to divide and polarise and is not the way forward.

Differing views? Are you fucking serious?

I have friends who vote for different political parties. Some friends who are Christians and others who are atheist. Those are differing views that I can respect.

Being part of a racist organisation, which not one fought to deny people their rights but also murdered people because they had a different skin colour is not a 'differing view.'

maddening · 21/09/2022 08:21

phishy · 21/09/2022 08:01

The lengths white people will go to excuse racism and racists never ceases to amaze me.

So are you saying that once a person (of any colour) has a racist thought they can never redeem themselves and are a social pariah for the rest of their lives?

Also, by making people social pariahs how do you suggest that drives the conversation forward and helps social cohesion for our society, surely the aim is to get to a place where we no longer have a racism problem, we don't want this to go on forever do we?

phishy · 21/09/2022 08:01

The lengths white people will go to excuse racism and racists never ceases to amaze me.

maddening · 21/09/2022 08:00

Calphurnia88 · 20/09/2022 14:03

If he felt remorse then he would either be too ashamed to admit it or he would have said something to imply he no longer holds these views. Not just casually drop it into conversation.

Replace KKK in the title of this thread with IRA, Taliban, Al Qu'ida or any other terrorist organisation and you can guarantee that this thread would have gone in a totally different direction.

If I met someone who had been in the ira and now wanted peace etc I would still judge them on them now as opposed to who they were a long time ago.

We allow rehabilitation and declare a punishment to be over after a set tine when a crime has been committed, forever condemning a person as a pariah due to thoughts and behaviour 70 years ago is not the right approach imo.

maddening · 21/09/2022 07:52

I voted yabu as his views may have changed, there is no evidence he himself committed any crimes and it is possible to speak to and even be friends with people who have differing views and histories. The fact that there has been no indication of racism in your relatively close (for neighbours) relationship indicates he does not hold those views now.

Imo the whole "never speak to" and/or alienate people with views we don't agree with is very closed minded and does nothing to further dialogue or change minds, it acts to divide and polarise and is not the way forward.

Cleopatra67 · 21/09/2022 07:43

@JustTheOneSwan - context isn’t really the issue here. There is no mitigating context possible.

TwinkleChristmas · 20/09/2022 17:41

slayboo · 20/09/2022 13:48

yeah your kids are @TwinkleChristmas

Was that meant to bother me? Because someone being a keyboard warrior only makes me laugh 😂 you are pathetic.

LongLivedQueen · 20/09/2022 15:08

JustTheOneSwan · 19/09/2022 18:35

So 70years ago he did daft stuff and since then he's not?

Is being a member of the KKK "daft stuff"?

Really?

3WildOnes · 20/09/2022 15:05

Tabbouleh · 20/09/2022 15:01

Actually I apologise for this comment. Lately there have been a lot of racist posts on MN and it has been getting to me, as a POC. Obviously nearly all white people would shun this man.

Anyway I should not have posted that. Should take some time off MN now.

Dont apologise. So many comments in this post have been disgusting in their excuses. I'm not surprised you would feel that way.

Tabbouleh · 20/09/2022 15:01

3WildOnes · 20/09/2022 13:42

Fwiw I am white and wouldn't be so easily forgiving.

Actually I apologise for this comment. Lately there have been a lot of racist posts on MN and it has been getting to me, as a POC. Obviously nearly all white people would shun this man.

Anyway I should not have posted that. Should take some time off MN now.

Lunar270 · 20/09/2022 14:37

Boxowine · 20/09/2022 14:16

I feel like a lot of posters are internalizing this scenario and giving this person more credit for some supposed redemption that they are assuming took place.

The OP says that he mentioned that he met his wife in the fifties while he was a member of the KKK. There is nothing said about the length of time he was involved with terrorism or what prompted him to leave or if he had some kind of come to Jesus moment and he reevaluated his racist beliefs. No information has been given about whether his association was ever terminated. Why would anyone assume that it has been?

The nicest thing that I can say is that there seems to be a lot of people who are not well informed of the true nature of race relations in the US. I'll grant that it's not your country and not your responsibility to be fully aware but I am going to say that I find the impulse to excuse this individual to be troubling.

Agreed +1

You're being very kind. "Not well informed" is way more civilized than I want to be!

As a minority I'd be mortified if a neighbour admitted that.

Lampzade · 20/09/2022 14:21

Calphurnia88 · 20/09/2022 14:03

If he felt remorse then he would either be too ashamed to admit it or he would have said something to imply he no longer holds these views. Not just casually drop it into conversation.

Replace KKK in the title of this thread with IRA, Taliban, Al Qu'ida or any other terrorist organisation and you can guarantee that this thread would have gone in a totally different direction.

This

Lampzade · 20/09/2022 14:20

Boxowine · 20/09/2022 14:16

I feel like a lot of posters are internalizing this scenario and giving this person more credit for some supposed redemption that they are assuming took place.

The OP says that he mentioned that he met his wife in the fifties while he was a member of the KKK. There is nothing said about the length of time he was involved with terrorism or what prompted him to leave or if he had some kind of come to Jesus moment and he reevaluated his racist beliefs. No information has been given about whether his association was ever terminated. Why would anyone assume that it has been?

The nicest thing that I can say is that there seems to be a lot of people who are not well informed of the true nature of race relations in the US. I'll grant that it's not your country and not your responsibility to be fully aware but I am going to say that I find the impulse to excuse this individual to be troubling.

Absolutely

Boxowine · 20/09/2022 14:16

I feel like a lot of posters are internalizing this scenario and giving this person more credit for some supposed redemption that they are assuming took place.

The OP says that he mentioned that he met his wife in the fifties while he was a member of the KKK. There is nothing said about the length of time he was involved with terrorism or what prompted him to leave or if he had some kind of come to Jesus moment and he reevaluated his racist beliefs. No information has been given about whether his association was ever terminated. Why would anyone assume that it has been?

The nicest thing that I can say is that there seems to be a lot of people who are not well informed of the true nature of race relations in the US. I'll grant that it's not your country and not your responsibility to be fully aware but I am going to say that I find the impulse to excuse this individual to be troubling.

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 20/09/2022 14:14

A very close friend was in the National Front as a late teen / early twenties. They say it was like a cult and they were very much brain washed into believing, and was surrounded by the same point of view. Luckily (very very luckily) they had a major awakening and their views did a total 180. They are now the most caring, kindest person. I judge him on who he is now, and how he has made amends. Not on who his troubled younger self was.

potniatheron · 20/09/2022 14:11

I think it's natural to feel uncomfortable. Some years ago I was involved in a community outreach project and met an older guy who I liked, nice bloke, mild mannered, witty etc. I subsequently found out (not from him but someone else) he'd been peripherally involved with the PIRA.

Yes it definitely frightened and disgusted me. When you know that someone has that sort of background, the way you feel about them and the way you feel safe to act around them, definitely changes.

In the end I reflected that his involvement had happened 30 years earlier, he would've been late teens to early 20s, and people change and evolve especially as they grow older. If forgivenes and redemption were never options then what hope is there for humanity?

I have to admit that I did give him a wider berth after that, whilst still attempting to be polite so as not to offend. It's a hard line to tread. Do what's right with your conscience and remember that we should never judge another human until we've walked a mile in their shoes.

Calphurnia88 · 20/09/2022 14:03

MyStarBoy · 19/09/2022 19:59

It was a long time ago.
Maybe he was young and stupid and now feels remorse?
Do you have black neighbours living locally? If yes, does he treat them with respect and kindness?

If he felt remorse then he would either be too ashamed to admit it or he would have said something to imply he no longer holds these views. Not just casually drop it into conversation.

Replace KKK in the title of this thread with IRA, Taliban, Al Qu'ida or any other terrorist organisation and you can guarantee that this thread would have gone in a totally different direction.

Swipe left for the next trending thread