Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is impossible to lose weight unless you have 1) time & 2) headspace?

135 replies

TuesdayBliss · 19/09/2022 18:09

By which I mean:

  • You are getting enough sleep
  • You are not anxious about anything happening in your life
  • You are not stressed
  • You are not overwhelmed with work
  • You are not worried
  • You have free time to plan, exercise, cook and so on

If any of the above factors are an issue in your life, then I think it’s simply not possible to have the energy, time, and positive attitude that make up the necessary commitment to losing weight. AIBU?

OP posts:
YourLipsMyLipsApocalypse · 20/09/2022 12:00

I've slowly lost about 30 pounds over the last year, and here's what I do:

  • On a sunday make a huge pot of soup
  • Eat it every day for at least one meal.

It's very filling, healthy, and easy to do. It's working - slowly, but working.

AlwaysTheBrideNeverTheBridesmaid · 20/09/2022 11:59

TuesdayBliss · 20/09/2022 10:54

There is an interesting theme coming through about being able to lose weight during lockdown. Presumably as well as time and space, there was also the lack of socialising and meals/drinks out at the weekend. Food for thought, no pun intended!

I lost 30lb during lockdown as I wasn't having meals out with friends, hanging out in the coffee shop, had more free time to exercise. I'm surprised to hear so many gained during the lockdown, unless it was just like mindless weight creep from a change in habits.

Agrudge · 20/09/2022 11:56

How much time do you need to eat less?

MarshaBradyo · 20/09/2022 11:52

Yes I’ve seen many more posts and heard discussion irl about lockdown weight than the opposite

It was a terrible motivator for health improvement for many

SuperCamp · 20/09/2022 11:50

TuesdayBliss · 20/09/2022 10:54

There is an interesting theme coming through about being able to lose weight during lockdown. Presumably as well as time and space, there was also the lack of socialising and meals/drinks out at the weekend. Food for thought, no pun intended!

There was also no barrier between me and my fridge and bread bin. Unlike at work. The temptation to get through lockdown on toast, alcohol and home made baked goods (the sourdough craze, anyone?) was high. Which is why I decided to take a pro-active stand to eat healthily.

LOADS of people put on weight during lockdown, despite the lack of socialising.

TuesdayBliss · 20/09/2022 10:54

There is an interesting theme coming through about being able to lose weight during lockdown. Presumably as well as time and space, there was also the lack of socialising and meals/drinks out at the weekend. Food for thought, no pun intended!

OP posts:
TuesdayBliss · 20/09/2022 10:53

RudsyFarmer · 19/09/2022 20:29

Well that’s obviously not true is it 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️. You might not have been able to stick to it but as a mechanism for weight loss not eating works incredibly well.

Well, yeah, it is true…

I tried the time limited version (only eat within an eight hour window), and it didn’t work presumably because I ate too much within that window.

I also tried the alternate days one, where you fast for X days and quite severely limit your calorie intake, then eat normally on the other days. Again, it didn’t work, again presumably because I ate too much on the ‘normal’ days.

Why would I lie? It didn’t work for me.

OP posts:
misskatamari · 20/09/2022 09:38

Do you follow rebelfit at all? I think you'd find their approach really interesting, as they basically believe this exact thing. They share loads of great content on Facebook.

I would say I agree with you.

I imagine it is possible to lose weight in spite of the factors you mention. However I think that to lose weight AND MAINTAIN IT, is nigh on impossible if you are facing the things you state. And really, that's the key isn't it. Losing weight isn't a win if you then revert to old eating habits, up the shame, and regain lose weight and add some more along for the ride. Diet culture has so much to answer for. I think we would all be a lot healthier if we sorted out the things in your list, and weight wouldn't be much of an issue (especially if we weren't constantly bombarded with the bullshit notion that we're only worthy and beautiful if we're thin enough).

BlooberryBiskits · 20/09/2022 09:03

TuesdayBliss · 19/09/2022 19:15

I’m looking for reasons and links actually. I’m interested in cause and effect. And the thread has already made me consider different stress responses.

Hello @TuesdayBliss : I don’t think you are wrong actually, what you describe are ideal circumstances, it is MUCH harder (perhaps not impossible) to lose weight when tired/stressed/anxious etc - losing weight is habit change, & the weight loss some people have because they can’t eat when stressed is terrible for your body (I’ve experienced that too)

I would actually suggest focusing on just a few small changes to help you feel better/healthier/more energetic- these would reduce the need to comfort yourself with high calorie foods (which often mess with blood sugar and create a vicious cycle)

There is a LOT of evidence that elevated cortisol (stress hormone) contributes to weight gain especially tummy fat

For me some helpful changes are:

  • enough sleep a night (actually track how many hours you sleep to work out what you need/a cheap fit bit will also do this). When you wake up feeling refreshed: that’s the right amount. Try to keep a consistent sleep/wake time daily
  • drink more water (eg 1-2l a day). Start with a glass when you wake up, a glass an hour later- makes a difference
  • more vegetables especially & fruit and unprocessed foods in general- some things take time but eg an omelette with veg & new potatoes is quick as are lots of other meals
  • Try to walk for at least 20 mins a day - preferably a set time (to work, the school run, the shops)
  • take 5 mins of peace for yourself first thing in the morning (preferably before others get up) - have a cup of tea or whatever in peace & start your day in an uncrazy way , preferably do the same at night (or something for you - have a shower or bath or watch a short tv show - anything to relax)

Do this for a week or 2 with a focus on feeling better/less stressed (the sleep, water, vitamins from better food & a bit of relaxation all helps) and then you may find it easier to plan healthy meals & to set limits on unhealthy ‘empty calorie’ foods (especially sugar/white flour which messes with blood sugar, also fried foods as just so calorific)

By focusing on what would make you FEEL better you would start to shift the cycle and focus more on your health

I would also think about if there are things you can change to adjust your stress: I changed jobs earlier this year as my previous job was too much and making it tough for me to manage my health and weight : appreciate it’s quite a big change but ultimately if you are not healthy life is so much harder so why not try for a better balance

AlwaysTheBrideNeverTheBridesmaid · 20/09/2022 08:44

YABU.

To lose weight you need to be in a calorie deficit. So if you want to keep it very simple, you just need to eat less of the usual things you eat. You don't need to plan, you don't need to do additional cooking, and certainly don't need to exercise. You can lose weight without doing any exercise at all very easily.

Also, regarding your points about not being stressed or tired, lots of people stop eating when they're stressed or tired rather than overeat to cope.

Weight loss is simple but it isn't easy, it takes discipline, and whether someone has the necessary discipline depends on a lot of factors but it's certainly not true that it's 'impossible' without the perfect set of circumstances. When you want it badly enough you will make it happen and if you're just not there yet then that's fine.

Of course there are many people in situations where the few pleasures they have in life are food and therefore they overeat because they get very little pleasure elsewhere. But that doesn't mean it's impossible for them to lose weight. Everyone who loses weight makes the same decision at the offset: what's more important to me? Being a lighter weight, or continuing to eat as I please?

5128gap · 20/09/2022 08:11

gwenneh · 19/09/2022 22:43

Eating less of what is available isn't a "short term fix". It's the only way to sustainably lose weight in a realistic way that relies on the resources you already have. No "special diet", no adding meal prep or counting carbs or exercise regimens you may or may not have the time and physical or mental capacity for at the moment.

Have only sub-optimal food available? Fine. Put less of it in your body. You will lose weight without having to change anything else.

Balance your nutrition when you can, exercise when you have the time and energy, but when you can't just balance it with the conscious decision to fuel your body a little less than it requires to maintain the status quo. It is the most straightforward way to lose weight and keep it off.

I don't advocate special diets. But eating less of what's available is only going to be good for some people if what is available is nutrient dense. Some people due to age, small stature and sedentary jobs have very low calorie requirements. If you're one of them, if you want to stay healthy, every calorie needs to count. Obviously you could lose weight by eating smaller amounts of your usual diet if your only goal is to become thin. But if that consists of mainly empty calories you're going to end up hungry and malnourished.

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 20/09/2022 07:18

I agree OP, assuming you mean using a programme like Noom or WW or Joe Wicks or something. That takes time out of you day, planning and shopping, often more and different food to what your picky / beige food only kids eat. I also struggle with this as a FT working SP. It just feels like an extra "thing". Eating a bit less and no alcohol and will stop gain, but not bring about real substantial loss. I make small changes, fruit instead biscuits, cauliflower rice instead of pasta but when I have lost weight in the past its been through having a rare period of calm when neither kid is having a crisis or issue with school, everything settled at work, no DIY needing doing etc. Those saying they lose weight when stressed or depressed or whatever, well yes but that's when you just utterly lose your appetite and stop eating - hardly a healthy or sustainable approach.

StinkyWizzleteets · 20/09/2022 00:36

Time is a big one for me.

I managed to lose 3 stone during 2021
lockdown but it was because I had the time to exercise and make all food from scratch. For me, exercise was imperative because it suppressed my appetite so I didn’t want to snack or binge. As soon as lockdown ended I didn’t have the time to exercise and I started craving crap food again. I didn’t have the time
to be making all meals from scratch and so it went back on again. I was stressed at being back in the real world and no longer being able to shield… it just add piled up again.

I know it’s possible but I do think time and headspace are imperative or it’s a losing battle.

Idontknowwhatto · 19/09/2022 23:52

I'm one of the first people to say the old 'calories in v calories out'. I lost 4.5 stone 20 years ago, and only put it on when I got pregnant with my two children. Got it off again no problem, both times.

Had third baby at the start of the year and honestly just cannot do it. I am just so, so exhausted quite a lot of the time and just keep going for high calorie food as a stress response. I think in the past I would have smoked but don't do that anymore. Plus I'm breastfeeding and feel so exhausted and drained from that. I zero in on high calorie food the way I used to when I had my period.

I often feel like I'm in survival mode and realised how exhausted I was when I realised I was falling asleep with my eyes open while pushing the pram. Like dreaming while awake. I've never felt like this before and always thought that people were just making excuses about losing weight but I feel like I'm under some kind of spell. I have been losing, just very very slowly.

My mum is the most weight conscious, passremarkable person. She would never let an opportunity to tell me to lose weight go by, and even she recently told me not to stress about weightloss until I've stopped breastfeeding at least. I've never felt like this before. It's juts like I've no fight left during my waking hours and I just go into a frenzy of hunger.

I adore my kids by the way and only have 4 kg to lose. I've already lost 10kg since I had the baby, but it has been slow. 3.4 of those kg was the baby.

wouldthatbeworse · 19/09/2022 23:20

I think at least one your bullet points applies to most adults all of the time. Find me a parent who has enough sleep and no worries. So kindly, as weight loss is hugely difficult, YABU as on your logic no one would ever lose weight

Cazziebo · 19/09/2022 23:20

Nope. Stress, anxiety and lack of time make me lose weight rapidly. I eat when I'm bored. If I'm busy and preoccupied I lose my appetite.

OneTC · 19/09/2022 23:17

Those bullet points, particularly sleep and stress, interfere with and lower my appetite and interest in food, in turn lowering my energy, in turn losing weight. My struggle is keeping weight though.

My OH is the exact opposite, stress and poor sleep and the other things listed makes her want to eat more and then what follows is weight gain/struggle to lose weight

WoodlandWalks123 · 19/09/2022 23:15

totally agree! But similarly my response to stress is eating!

Deereemer · 19/09/2022 23:10

If you look at what puts the weight on in middle age it is unarguably sugar in all its guises and processed foods. If you make a huge effort to cut these 2 out for 6 months you will lose all the weight. You don't have to do anything else whatsoever so just get on with learning about how to eat with those two rules in mind

gwenneh · 19/09/2022 22:43

5128gap · 19/09/2022 21:18

All the people telling the OP she can lose weight by eating soup, eating nothing, eating less of whatever is available...Well, obviously. But I assume the OP wants to lose weight in a way that is healthy and sustainable. Which if you're overweight typically involves major lifestyle changes. Which take time and being in a certain headspace. When people don't recognise this and go for short term fixes they generally put the weight back on.

Eating less of what is available isn't a "short term fix". It's the only way to sustainably lose weight in a realistic way that relies on the resources you already have. No "special diet", no adding meal prep or counting carbs or exercise regimens you may or may not have the time and physical or mental capacity for at the moment.

Have only sub-optimal food available? Fine. Put less of it in your body. You will lose weight without having to change anything else.

Balance your nutrition when you can, exercise when you have the time and energy, but when you can't just balance it with the conscious decision to fuel your body a little less than it requires to maintain the status quo. It is the most straightforward way to lose weight and keep it off.

Glitterbomber · 19/09/2022 21:39

As someone who has lost 5 stone this year I don’t agree with this….There is never a right time.

And strangely enough as I lost the weight most of my daily anxieties and worries disappeared and my sleep improved.

I shudder to think if I hadn’t have powered through this year and stuck to my guns (after 100s of failed attempts).

roarfeckingroarr · 19/09/2022 21:35

I think if you're starting from a place of being overweight for a long time with poor eating habits, little or no exercise and not much motivation, then you're quite right.

If you really want to lose weight and have a basic understanding of how to do so, the things you mention become excuses not reasons.

YouLookinSusBro · 19/09/2022 21:27

I agree. In fact I'm fairly sure the only way I'm going to lose weight and beat my sugar addiction is by going on a detox/retreat for a week or 3. Or failing that have someone lock me in a room, just give me healthy food, assure me life is being dealt with and refuse to let me work.

So so many attempts over last few years and each one failed. Actually feel pretty down about it

Fairislefandango · 19/09/2022 21:19

You don't have to exercise to lose weight, and lower calorie/carb etc meals don't have to take any longer to prepare than other ones. I don't think it's a question of time available.

5128gap · 19/09/2022 21:18

All the people telling the OP she can lose weight by eating soup, eating nothing, eating less of whatever is available...Well, obviously. But I assume the OP wants to lose weight in a way that is healthy and sustainable. Which if you're overweight typically involves major lifestyle changes. Which take time and being in a certain headspace. When people don't recognise this and go for short term fixes they generally put the weight back on.