Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is impossible to lose weight unless you have 1) time & 2) headspace?

135 replies

TuesdayBliss · 19/09/2022 18:09

By which I mean:

  • You are getting enough sleep
  • You are not anxious about anything happening in your life
  • You are not stressed
  • You are not overwhelmed with work
  • You are not worried
  • You have free time to plan, exercise, cook and so on

If any of the above factors are an issue in your life, then I think it’s simply not possible to have the energy, time, and positive attitude that make up the necessary commitment to losing weight. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
superplumb · 06/10/2022 20:21

I think it depends. Some are stressed and lose weight as a result. When I stressed I hit the sugar and carbs hard. This make some feel crap and tired and then I dont want to exercise. I need to lose about 2 stone and I'm really struggling. I'm also yo yo dieting which is the worst thing I can do

MilkToastHoney · 06/10/2022 17:41

Yes! I'm so glad it's not just me. This 16/8 thing makes no sense to me as it's essentially how I eat anyway. 16/8, really, is just skipping breakfast and not snacking in the evenings... right?

Well, yes!! I’ve always ‘fasted’ long before I heard of IF.
I do have dinner early and then eat brunch late-ish and then dinner. I wouldn’t say I’m fasting though, just not snacking in the evening and then eat late-ish when I get up.
If you have dinner at 5pm then breakfast at 11am that’s not really a long time to go between meals.

I think a lot of people’s perception of food is really skewed and unhealthy. If you are eating a huge amount of calories/unhealthy food in an 8 hour window then that’s not ok just because someone has sold a ‘diet’ calling it IF.

InCheesusWeTrust · 06/10/2022 16:41

fellrunner85 · 06/10/2022 16:36

With the fasting, to me an 8 hour eating window is normal or a bigger window than I would eat in

Yes! I'm so glad it's not just me. This 16/8 thing makes no sense to me as it's essentially how I eat anyway. 16/8, really, is just skipping breakfast and not snacking in the evenings... right?

Quite, but that doesn't sell books 😁

fellrunner85 · 06/10/2022 16:36

With the fasting, to me an 8 hour eating window is normal or a bigger window than I would eat in

Yes! I'm so glad it's not just me. This 16/8 thing makes no sense to me as it's essentially how I eat anyway. 16/8, really, is just skipping breakfast and not snacking in the evenings... right?

Hbv9988 · 06/10/2022 16:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MilkToastHoney · 21/09/2022 12:54

Interesting… maybe it’s about how stress responses differ then. If those bullet points apply to me, then I ‘cope’ through junk food, buying ready meals instead of cooking, spending time on my phone as I feel I don’t have the energy to exercise.

If you are eating junk food, heavily processed ready meals etc, you are bound to feel lethargic and not in a good mentally because you’re putting all that rubbish into your body.

You don’t have to spend large amounts of time cooking but eating unprocessed foods will make you feel so much better and it will be easier to lose weight. If I don’t have much time to cook, I’ll make a quick salad or something like scrambled eggs that takes a few minutes. You don’t have to cook a big elaborate meal.
Just don’t buy junk at all, there is really no reason to have junk food in the house. You’ll feel SO much better for not putting it into your body.

With the fasting, to me an 8 hour eating window is normal or a bigger window than I would eat in. If you are eating a huge amount of calories and/or processed junk foods in an 8 hour window then it’s common sense you wouldn’t lose weight.

I think you are overthinking. It doesn’t have to be hard or complicated. Throw out all your junk food. Stick to foods that are naturally derived.
Eat dinner early and don’t snack in the evening. Eat breakfast/lunch late when you get up to naturally reduce your eating window. No sugar.

RIPWalter · 21/09/2022 11:16

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen
I have a morbid fear of being hungry, totally out of proportion to the danger

I can really relate to this. I've always struggled (yoyo) with my weight due to childhood issues and sugar addiction, however a "fear of being hungry" was never an issue, I even lost a good amount of weight in my early 30s with 5:2 fasting. Then I got pregnant with DD, the nausea started at 3 weeks and ended, after some dramatic projectial vomiting in labour, once DD was born. The form it took for me was that I lost ALL normal hunger signals, even mild hunger became severe nausea, and in the 1st trimester I would vomit if I hadn't eaten for 2 hours (I could set my watch to it), but by 3rd trimester it was a much more manageble 4 hour window. This at least had the advantage that I was vomiting on a near empty stomach, so much less messy, and that I didn't become clinically unwell due to dehydration or malnutrition, and therefore avoided hospitalisation.

Since having DD, I have as your describe, a "morbid fear of being hungry, totally out of proportion to the danger", I know that nausea is no longer a problem, but the flashbacks to stuffing chicken nuggets from the hot meat counter in tesco, down my throat in a desperate attempt to not throw up whilst other shoppers looked on judgementally, are real. I don't know how to work round it. I've tried fasting again but it makes me cranky and panicky.

I think this is a hard thing for anyone who hasn't experienced it to believe let alone understand.

ElizaCBennett · 20/09/2022 23:23

I’ve struggled with my weight all my life. I’m in my early sixties now. I’ve never been huge but always at least a couple of dress sizes too big for my frame. I’ve done every diet out there, lost it - put it back on etc. Very recently I’ve cut out all refined carbs and seed oils due to a close family member having another health scare on top of an ongoing serious condition. My sister also is on medication for rheumatoid arthritis and I realized that I could be next. So I changed my diet completely.
I have lost 30 pounds in less than 3 months. My body shape has changed, I’ve lost 5 inches off my waist, I have had no IBS symptoms since and I couldn’t be happier.

Banana7 · 20/09/2022 23:12

I lose weight when I'm crazy busy at work but lack of sleep /stress /anxiety and not having time for exercising do the opposite.

Bubblebubblebah · 20/09/2022 22:49
  • i said the healthy will come when people are more motivated
  • eating less is not starving yourself...
  • not everyone has ED

For a person who says they cannot lose weight because they don't have time, all what I wrote applies.

This is another thing. Doing "but my unusual circumstances" to a post which clearly talks simply about people who don't have time, doesn't talk about ED, is not helpful imho.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 20/09/2022 22:42

@Bubblebubblebah

What is the point of losing weight if it doesn't make you more healthy??

Seriously starving yourself is very simple. But it will fuck up your metabolism, energy levels etc. This is the basis of the yoyo dieting that afflicts so many.

Not to mention people with problematic eating can't just "eat less" because it's simple. I have a morbid fear of being hungry, totally out of proportion to the danger (prob due to weird childhood stuff). So eating less of food that actually makes me feel hungrier (refined carbs etc) will just mean I end up binging at some point, sure as night follows day. Whether you judge me for not having "willpower" will make not a jot of difference to this fact. So if I'm going to eat healthily I need to eat a LOT of nutrient dense, low calorie foods, like bean salad, chicken breast, tons of veg, nuts and seeds etc - so I feel full and don't give in to the urge to binge, without having too many calories. All that takes prep and thought, far more so than popping to the shop and grabbing a meal deal. And ROFL at the idea I would buy one of them then leave half the sandwich 😂 - spoken by someone who clearly doesn't have a problem saying no to food!!

BlooberryBiskits · 20/09/2022 21:11

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 20/09/2022 20:50

@AlwaysTheBrideNeverTheBridesmaid

Just eating less of whatever you are already eating is not healthy or sustainable if you don't already have a healthy nutritious diet. Yes ok you'll lose weight if that was literally what you did; but for myriad physical and psychological reasons that simply isn't going to be sustainable for most people, and if it were as simple as you make it sound we wouldn't have an obesity epidemic. The "just eat less and move more" mantra is so so boring and simplistic and so lacking in understanding of the many factors that drive overeating, poor nutrition and obesity. If human beings were programmable machines it would be super useful advice. But if they were, no-one would need the advice.

^ I really agree with this. To loose weight and be healthy (because some slim people are horribly unhealthy and it does catch up with you), people need to eat mostly healthy, natural & not overly processed odd

There is lots of academic research (eg Barbara Rolls Volumetrics, The End of Overating etc) that people are used to eating a certain volume/weight of food every day and ‘expect’ that /feel unsatisfied if they don’t

So eating a large quantity of food but reducing the calorie level (by bulking up with veg , more fibre on beans/whole grains, & water containing food like soups, stews, fruit etc) gives you that satisfaction/volume with more nutrition & fewer calories

A huge number of diets fundamentally switch you to eating more veg/unprocessed foods as a means of reducing the calorie level in a sustainable way

Understanding how different foods affect your blood sugar levels & so hunger/cravings is also important for managing your weight. In my case the more bread/baked good I eat the more I want so I aim to have those a couple of times a week vs daily, & know I’m overdoing it when I crave those so have a few days without

I’m not willing to give up my favourite foods (bread/baked goods in my case) entirely but being aware of how they affect me/can start a spiral of overeating has helped me set some limits

I think you can lose weight and eat ‘anything you like’ as long as that is only say once or twice a week for calorie dense and less nutritious foods (fried foods, cakes etc) & if you are overweight it’s more likely than not you have a strong appetite/hunger and don’t eat tiny servings so would not be happy to do so long term/might be setting yourself up for a binge/starve cycle if you try

Bubblebubblebah · 20/09/2022 21:11

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 20/09/2022 20:50

@AlwaysTheBrideNeverTheBridesmaid

Just eating less of whatever you are already eating is not healthy or sustainable if you don't already have a healthy nutritious diet. Yes ok you'll lose weight if that was literally what you did; but for myriad physical and psychological reasons that simply isn't going to be sustainable for most people, and if it were as simple as you make it sound we wouldn't have an obesity epidemic. The "just eat less and move more" mantra is so so boring and simplistic and so lacking in understanding of the many factors that drive overeating, poor nutrition and obesity. If human beings were programmable machines it would be super useful advice. But if they were, no-one would need the advice.

People keep talking about sustainable. You need to eat less to lose weight then you up your intake when you don't need deficit anymore. It is that simple to start with. So of course being in x thousand calories deficit is not something you will be able to or have to sustain forever.

And do not confuse simple and easy though. Different things. It is that simple, it may not be easy, it is not impossible though.

It may be boring mantra but at the end of the day, no one lost weight while eating more their body needed🤷🏻 While it is absolutely agreeable that people need to look at nutrition, that can come bit later when they are more motivated. Most claims here are "I don't have time to think about what I am going to eat" hence the answers of, just eat less of what you are eating.

Honestly, I am so glad I kept off all diet threads here when I was starting because they are so demotivating.
"You must to look at nutrition" "you can't eat x" "you can't eat before time/after time" "you can eat pizza and lose weight 😳". People need to stop. No time, fine, just eat less of what you are eating now. Then when you have time, start looking at nutrition, then exercise. Just start with something, there is no need to wait until the perfect moment when you got you BSC in nutrition and children graduated and left 🤷🏻 People just need to start with something. The rest will follow. Just get yourselves some multivitamins for time being and possible energy boost.

You could lose weight eating just maccies. Would you be healthy? No. But you would lose wieght if you calorie controlled it🤷🏻 Yes

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 20/09/2022 20:50

@AlwaysTheBrideNeverTheBridesmaid

Just eating less of whatever you are already eating is not healthy or sustainable if you don't already have a healthy nutritious diet. Yes ok you'll lose weight if that was literally what you did; but for myriad physical and psychological reasons that simply isn't going to be sustainable for most people, and if it were as simple as you make it sound we wouldn't have an obesity epidemic. The "just eat less and move more" mantra is so so boring and simplistic and so lacking in understanding of the many factors that drive overeating, poor nutrition and obesity. If human beings were programmable machines it would be super useful advice. But if they were, no-one would need the advice.

Hbv9988 · 20/09/2022 20:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

AlwaysTheBrideNeverTheBridesmaid · 20/09/2022 20:02

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 20/09/2022 18:26

People keep talking about making it a priority and finding time but that really doesn't help if you're a single working parent with absolutely everything else to do as well that needs to be a priority. To the pp that said "how much time does it take to eat less" you clearly haven't the faintest idea. In the process of getting us all out of the house I may well end up not eating, because I'm not hungry first thing and once I am it's time to leave, so then mid morning you grab what you can and depending on work, that might be be fruit or yoghurt or it might be something I can very quickly shovel down while walking, like a biscuit. That's just one example but it's not just a case of eating less.

If you’re having a biscuit for breakfast that’s fine lol. Most biscuits are less then 100 calories. If you’re eating fruit and yoghurt for breakfast then that’s unlikely to be the main thing pushing you into a calorie surplus.

whatever you normally eat, just eat less of it. It really, really is that simple. Too busy to make lunch? Get a meal deal and have half the sandwich. Or pick something lighter. Making dinner as usual? Cool, have less. Getting takeout? Eat what fits on a side plate and drink water beforehand. Losing weight honestly isn’t rocket science and if someone is literally too busy to eat and they’re not fibbing they’ll be losing weight anyway.

BlooberryBiskits · 20/09/2022 19:26

WoodlandWalks123 · 20/09/2022 18:58

@BlooberryBiskits brilliant advice re getting in the right mindset - thank you!

Thanks @WoodlandWalks123

i actually paid a £££ mindset coach/trainer to help me lose weight at the start of the year as I was too overwhelmed with work (and feeling sluggish with the extra weight).

These changes she suggested eased me into losing weight: I’m now 2 stone down and would like to lose 1 more

Instead of trying to lose weight fast, I now focus on eating healthily/stress relief/moving (a 30/50 min workout &/or an hours walk every day).

Once those things become routine (esp I would say eating more unprocessed food, cutting way down on sugar & being more active ) I’ve found I feel ‘bleurgh’ if I skip too many days /eat junk for days on the trot

I think people who have never been overweight also underestimate how difficult it is to exercise when you have extra weight to carry : today I did a workout with 2 x 5kg dumbells and was tired: in Jan I was carrying that and more around all day every day

WoodlandWalks123 · 20/09/2022 18:58

@BlooberryBiskits brilliant advice re getting in the right mindset - thank you!

coodawoodashooda · 20/09/2022 18:27

TuesdayBliss · 19/09/2022 18:09

By which I mean:

  • You are getting enough sleep
  • You are not anxious about anything happening in your life
  • You are not stressed
  • You are not overwhelmed with work
  • You are not worried
  • You have free time to plan, exercise, cook and so on

If any of the above factors are an issue in your life, then I think it’s simply not possible to have the energy, time, and positive attitude that make up the necessary commitment to losing weight. AIBU?

I agree. 100%

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 20/09/2022 18:26

People keep talking about making it a priority and finding time but that really doesn't help if you're a single working parent with absolutely everything else to do as well that needs to be a priority. To the pp that said "how much time does it take to eat less" you clearly haven't the faintest idea. In the process of getting us all out of the house I may well end up not eating, because I'm not hungry first thing and once I am it's time to leave, so then mid morning you grab what you can and depending on work, that might be be fruit or yoghurt or it might be something I can very quickly shovel down while walking, like a biscuit. That's just one example but it's not just a case of eating less.

Hbv9988 · 20/09/2022 17:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 20/09/2022 15:01

Agrudge · 20/09/2022 11:56

How much time do you need to eat less?

Being constantly stressed and knackered makes you hungry, and tends, in my experience at least, to make you want less healthy foods - cheesy pasta say, rather than a salad. Comfort foods.

AlwaysTheBrideNeverTheBridesmaid · 20/09/2022 12:51

RIPWalter · 20/09/2022 12:29

Most people I know gained, or a few maintained during lockdown, but most people I know either had toddler children during lockdown (DD had just turned 2 in March 2020), or work in frontline (Ambulance/ ED) NHS, so didn't get the luxury of furlough.

Same, all of my local friends have toddlers/babies and 80% work in the NHS/frontline so were either working throughout or on mat leave for some of it with partners who were working too. I wouldn't have got furlough anyway had I not been on mat leave for a chunk of it, I'd have hated to have been off work.

RIPWalter · 20/09/2022 12:29

AlwaysTheBrideNeverTheBridesmaid · 20/09/2022 12:01

A few people I know gained big-time during the lockdown, I barely recognised them when I saw them again at the other side. Took a few minutes to adjust to seeing them look so different. But yeah, otherwise most people I know maintained or lost. Especially as the news was full of how being obese was such a risk factor, a lot of people had a damn good reason to lose weight NOW instead of at some stage in the future. It made the risks of being obese a lot more real and immediate.

Most people I know gained, or a few maintained during lockdown, but most people I know either had toddler children during lockdown (DD had just turned 2 in March 2020), or work in frontline (Ambulance/ ED) NHS, so didn't get the luxury of furlough.

AlwaysTheBrideNeverTheBridesmaid · 20/09/2022 12:01

MarshaBradyo · 20/09/2022 11:52

Yes I’ve seen many more posts and heard discussion irl about lockdown weight than the opposite

It was a terrible motivator for health improvement for many

A few people I know gained big-time during the lockdown, I barely recognised them when I saw them again at the other side. Took a few minutes to adjust to seeing them look so different. But yeah, otherwise most people I know maintained or lost. Especially as the news was full of how being obese was such a risk factor, a lot of people had a damn good reason to lose weight NOW instead of at some stage in the future. It made the risks of being obese a lot more real and immediate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread