Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how your life would have been different if you had only had one child

172 replies

Sowetoutside · 19/09/2022 16:37

Obviously some people have chosen this and please do tell me why.

I always wanted two children but really struggling with TTC. I’m slowly coming round to the fact I may only have the one.

Im trying to think of the positives so hit me!

OP posts:
Jetsun3456 · 20/09/2022 18:56

Well said @TempsPerdu

TempsPerdu · 20/09/2022 18:49

@anotherdayanotherpathlesstravelled
@AlwaysMunching
@NCFT0922
@Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow

No intention at all to be smug - apologies if it came across that way - and I don’t mean to imply that parents of multiple children can’t be organised, or offer them plenty of opportunities; of course they can do those things, and many clearly do. There is no ‘right answer’ when it comes to family size, and there’s obviously no inherent moral superiority in having one.

It’s also true to say, though, that in my own circle (which, to answer your question @NCFT0922, is fairly privileged middle class) the parents themselves are often citing their multiple children, especially younger ones, as the reason they’re not taking them swimming, or out to dinner, or on day trips, or having holidays. It’s the expense, or the hassle, or the prospect of them potentially bickering once they finally reach the museum/restaurant/wherever. Fair enough; I’d probably feel it was all too much like hard work too, but as it stands DD genuinely has travelled more extensively and had more extra-curricular opportunities than her peers, and our friends have been very open in citing additional siblings as a significant factor in not doing this stuff. Many of them, for example, won’t take 2 or more DC out alone, so everything has to be crammed into weekends and holidays when both parents are on hand.

Same in our nursery and Reception WhatsApp groups - parents of multiple kids complaining that they can’t find 3 costumes for World Book Day, or they’re late because logistics of drop-off/pick-up are too difficult with kids in different classes, or saying they accidentally sent their son to school with their daughter’s reading book. Of course the parents aren’t uncaring or feckless, just frazzled, and it’s not unreasonable to suggest that there might be less stress, last-minute flapping and potential mix-ups with just the one child. It’s also not being ‘smug’ to state that there’s quite a body of evidence that only children often outperform those with multiple siblings in school - it’s just citing the research that’s available.

I’ve acknowledged there are pros and cons to having one child, and one-child families do face specific challenges, but my issue with threads like these is that it’s difficult to come on to state the positives of having an only child without posters inevitably coming on to negate it all by claiming that things like more money, less stress, easier planning for the future, higher academic achievement, environmental awareness, more focused parental attention etc are all trivial and ultimately cancelled out by some vague idea of ‘loneliness’ and the imperative to give an existing child a sibling. Or that any pros of having one are purely selfish and only benefit the mother.

There’s no right answer, and there is no ‘ideal’ childhood. It is not inherently morally superior to have one, but neither is it necessarily optimal to have more. And there is nothing wrong with making choices that benefit the mother or the wider family - happier, calmer, less exhausted parents are a good thing, and mothers have every right to focus on themselves and foster their own identity, rather than martyring themselves to additional children they’re not sure they want for the sake of giving an existing child a sibling.

ancientgran · 20/09/2022 17:19

When I was a young mum, many years ago, an older lady said be very careful about having a second. She said if you aren't 100% sure your marriage will last you have to remember that you will get offered lots of support with one, far less with two and less again as the numbers go up.

Cynical? I think so but when I got divorced with 2 children I could see her point.

De88 · 20/09/2022 16:19

I'd be loaded!

Mommabear20 · 20/09/2022 16:17

I'd definitely have more time and money to spare 😂

Bootsandcat · 20/09/2022 16:16

The above is in response to @Firemansamagain

still figuring out how the site works!

Bootsandcat · 20/09/2022 16:15

Second pregnancy just took a toll on me, hospital also messed up which lead to a massive complication. Thankfully no permanent damage. My husband had a mental breakdown after that as he couldn’t cope with all that… completely changed my life.

looks like there’s another poster here with a horrific second birth, I’m so sorry to hear what had happened to you @Ohdofuckofdear

Ineedcoffee2021 · 20/09/2022 15:09

I have 1 by choice - hated pregnancy and birth, only just survived baby and toddler stage
She is now 12, me and DH only 34 and 37
We have so much more freedom and not too tired to enjoy it. Money is still tight but would be impossible with another
Sleep ins are normal
She wont have the drama DH has with his siblings and everything we own will be hers, no fighting over it - which will set her up
Our 4 bed house has heaps of room for the 3 of us, DD has her own hang out room plus bedroom, Me a WWE/Aussie rules footy memorabilia room

waffless · 20/09/2022 15:01

Can afford things easily for one. Private school, foreign summer camps, birthdays, trips, quality clothes.

Only need to think about one 11 plus. One university place and can focus more in helping one child.

In case of a divorce. Much easier with one than with two or more.

Same with helping to get a car or a deposit for a house.

naughtymonkey · 20/09/2022 14:13

I had a bit of a realisation about this just last night. I can see that my mum is feeling really stuck in the middle trying to support both me and my sister while we're going through tough times. My DD will always have my full attention and support, and I found that to be a comfort as I can't have any more due to infertility/circumstances.

ChessieFranceLynch · 20/09/2022 14:06

JudesBiggestFan · 20/09/2022 13:24

I'd be bored. I'd have missed out on the joy of seeing the relationships my boys have built with each other. I'd be overly focused on my eldest which wouldn't be healthy for any of us. Holidays/Christmas would mean he would never have shared the excitement with another child. I'd always worry he'd have too much responsibility for looking after us when we're older. But mostly, just the fun of raising all these different characters, seeing them playing on the beach together, my eldest reading bedtime stories to the youngest...no bigger house or more holidays would replace that. Although actually, I think we've done better in our careers as we've had the drive to buy a bigger house/bigger car etc for the kids, I may have taken more of a laidback attitude to career progression perhaps.

That's all very nice for you but you might have worded it differently when thinking of those you may only have one or none because they didn't have a choice.
Also, in truth you don't know that you would be bored as it's a life you haven't lived. Perhaps you would, perhaps you might have felt differently.

PoorPaddington · 20/09/2022 13:37

@JudesBiggestFan The way you’ve written that feels a bit sad for me, who can only have one, to read.

Ohdofuckofdear · 20/09/2022 13:36

I wouldn't have nearly died twice and I wouldn't have been left disabled with damage to my brain and my body and I wouldn't need to use a wheelchair.

But I don't regret my DC.

JudesBiggestFan · 20/09/2022 13:24

I'd be bored. I'd have missed out on the joy of seeing the relationships my boys have built with each other. I'd be overly focused on my eldest which wouldn't be healthy for any of us. Holidays/Christmas would mean he would never have shared the excitement with another child. I'd always worry he'd have too much responsibility for looking after us when we're older. But mostly, just the fun of raising all these different characters, seeing them playing on the beach together, my eldest reading bedtime stories to the youngest...no bigger house or more holidays would replace that. Although actually, I think we've done better in our careers as we've had the drive to buy a bigger house/bigger car etc for the kids, I may have taken more of a laidback attitude to career progression perhaps.

ChessieFranceLynch · 20/09/2022 11:10

bookworm14 · 20/09/2022 10:34

I have one child, largely through choice. I love that I can devote so much time and attention to her, and we have a really close relationship. She has lots of toys due to very generous grandparents and other relatives, but isn’t spoilt and others have commented on her nice manners.

She does have cousins close to her in age and we try to spend as much time with them as we can, as well as having lots of sleepovers and play dates with her friends. As a parent of an only you do have to be prepared to get involved in their games, so you might struggle if you dislike pretend play.

I do feel guilty sometimes for not ‘giving’ her a sibling, but then I remind myself that a person isn’t a gift, and should be wanted in their own right!

This is exactly how I feel. I have a 5 year old DS and at times have felt so guilty about not giving them a sibling. That's not the right reason to being another little life into the world.
As much as I would have loved another one, it just hasn't worked out and instead of feeling guilty I am starting to see the opportunity in DS being an only, I will certainly be able to be more financially stable then if I had to go back to paying nursery fees etc.

confusedlots · 20/09/2022 10:52

My two are still young but taking them out together to shops/supermarkets etc can be a nightmare. They act all silly, run around, and I spend all my time trying to control the circus. When I get the chance to go somewhere with just one of them it's an absolute dream, they always behave like a model child!

Dumbo18 · 20/09/2022 10:48

If I only had one my life would feel a lot emptier but that’s because I couldn’t imagine my second not being here if that makes sense! Yes I’d be less tired and have more money but I couldn’t imagine my son not having a sibling, I have 2 and my partner has 3 so there was no question about us not trying for a second. He entertains her while I cook, she shouts him at the school gates and they absolutely adore each other (for now)

CrispsnDips · 20/09/2022 10:47

Probably more boring..at 58 our teenagers keep us young at heart ..otherwise I’d perhaps be knitting every night LOL

BillyBearTriumphs · 20/09/2022 10:40

I have one, I did want more but it didn’t happen, now split with his dad, the pros for me are:

More time
More money
Family more likely to babysit one than multiples
Can work more
I get a break as fell “lucky” with his dad and his dad has him every weekend
Only one birthday to fork out for
Only one lot of christmas presents
Less laundry.

I have chosen to not have anymore children going forward even if I meet someone new, as I thought my child’s dad was “forever”, he wasn’t. So I worry if the same happens again, the next child’s dad won’t be as supportive or hands on. I’m happy with the one!!

Crumpleton · 20/09/2022 10:38

I'd probably still have my sanity.

bookworm14 · 20/09/2022 10:34

I have one child, largely through choice. I love that I can devote so much time and attention to her, and we have a really close relationship. She has lots of toys due to very generous grandparents and other relatives, but isn’t spoilt and others have commented on her nice manners.

She does have cousins close to her in age and we try to spend as much time with them as we can, as well as having lots of sleepovers and play dates with her friends. As a parent of an only you do have to be prepared to get involved in their games, so you might struggle if you dislike pretend play.

I do feel guilty sometimes for not ‘giving’ her a sibling, but then I remind myself that a person isn’t a gift, and should be wanted in their own right!

Firemansamagain · 20/09/2022 10:22

@Bootsandcat That’s awful, so sorry 😞 what happened

lawandgin · 20/09/2022 10:22

Great thread and really interesting responses. Following as I am still very much on the fence (although DD is only 5mo!)

Bootsandcat · 20/09/2022 10:20

We would be richer. I wouldn’t have nearly died. My husband wouldn’t have had a mental breakdown.

Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 20/09/2022 10:19

@TempsPerdu how long has your DD been in reception - a couple of weeks?! - and you’re already patting yourself on the back for being better than the other parents?

Fwiw I’ve got 2 kids (4 and 2) and have done every single thing on your list with them both.

In answer to the OP I think the thing that would be different if I’d only had one is more time and money for myself. I am happy that my kids don’t want for anything in terms of time, money, attention (so far), but I don’t have as much time for my own hobbies/seeing my friends as I used to, and I’m sure that has a knock on impact on my mood/relationship. I’ve felt a bit isolated over the past couple of years but covid has had a big role to play in that too.