Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be gay but stay with husband for the children?

187 replies

SadSuzie · 19/09/2022 13:38

I know people will say it’s impossible and I would probably say the same if I saw a thread like this
BUT
I can’t physically leave - the house is rented and I don’t and can’t earn more whilst the DS’s are young.
I do love him and the relationship between him and the children, they would be heartbroken without their dad and I would be heartbroken without them so it’s all a massive mess.
Has anyone stayed until the children were older so not to cause the destruction that will follow?

OP posts:
SadSuzie · 20/09/2022 15:11

He won’t change his job because this is my fault he says not his

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 20/09/2022 06:25

Has your husband always worked these long hours and days away? If you changed your hours could he then change his job to something more family friendly to provide proper 50/50 care?

HoneyIShrunkThePizza · 19/09/2022 22:53

I'm going to go against the grain. I feel desperately sorry for your poor, poor husband. But if you've told him and you've both decided to stay together for the children then....okay. No one else's business. I'm not sure what you want from this thread though as it's obvious from your responses you've made up your mind.

SadSuzie · 19/09/2022 22:52

I mean with the rental situation I cannot find anywhere that would take benefits and that’s what I would be using to pay the rent at least part of it as my wage is so low

OP posts:
lessthanathirdofanacre · 19/09/2022 22:49

It is cruel to stay with your husband and string him along. By remaining with him, you are giving him false hope that the relationship will return to what it used to be (presumably you used to love each other?). As PPs have said, it’s also terribly unfair to the children. They only get one childhood and I’m sure you want the best for them. But a childhood based on a false model of family life could be very damaging to them.

Living in a rural location is no reason not to become financially independent. If the rental house’s location is holding you back from earning more money, moving seems like the obvious solution. Of course if you get divorced your ex will have to pay maintenance or have the children 50% of the time. Either option means the financial responsibility will be divided between you.

Genevieva · 19/09/2022 22:31

I think the sexuality element of this thread is a distraction.

You got married. You don't love your husband any longer. This happens. When it happens some people get divorced. Others stick together in a different kind of co-parenting type relationship. There is no one right answer. It is up to you to work out between you. What you do need to remember though is that when you get married you make a serious commitment. I think the least you can do is try walking a mile in your husband's shoes and begin to understand how seismic your news would have been for him, how it would naturally make him emotionally less available etc. You clearly aren't communicating well at the moment, so. you need to look at options like marriage counselling. But be kind. Lots of women come on Mumsnet because of abusive relationships, unfaithful husbands and deadbeat dads. You have a lot to be grateful for.

Walkwithmetonight · 19/09/2022 22:23

This is an absolutely insane thread and I think many posters have forgotten that they should both be considering foremost what is in the best interests of the children.

That is clearly not to move into a temporary hostel. It’s also clearly not to be left with a father who can’t physically take care of them, presumably with no ability to stay with the mum who had done 90% of the childcare because she can’t afford to rent somewhere. Therefore it’s not really that unreasonable to ask him to fund towards her living expenses while they work out the best way to move forward. It could be that she moves into town and a suitable school with wrap around care, or that he guarantors the rent while she gets herself on her feet and moves towards independence.

All of these solutions prioritise what’s in the best interest of the children, not the grievances of adults who feel hard done by by their spouse.

op - whether you can stay or not is something no one else can answer for you. I chose to leave in the same situation. I decided you only get one life, and I was ultimately condemning the children to a fake and mostly miserable childhood anyway if I chose to stay.

I won’t lie - its been horrific and we still aren’t through the actual divorce process nearly 2 years in. Most of that has been caused by him. I still haven’t actually had a girlfriend (or even a date!) but then I’m emotionally broken from the divorce so probably need to wait until I’m a bit stronger anyway.

beastlyslumber · 19/09/2022 22:23

You haven't actually done anything wrong.

It's okay to fall out of love with your partner. It's okay to be gay. It's okay to want to end your marriage.

But it's not okay to stay miserable in a marriage you don't want. You're not stuck. You just need to figure out how to make it possible to break up.

SadSuzie · 19/09/2022 22:15

Your poor kids comment isn’t helpful - I feel dreadful about it and guilt ridden the entire time.
I hate myself for realising this in my mid 40s - it’s ridiculous I know.

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 19/09/2022 22:14

Rosemist1988 · 19/09/2022 22:01

But people are acting like she’s choosing it.
all this ‘that’s your problem’ and ‘you’re breaking up the family.’
she probably doesn’t want to but her options are stay in a marriage where she doesn’t actually want the sex and the relationship isn’t right for her or leave. And the intimacy part is likely pretty untenable.
Straight women - imagine having to sleep with a woman. Don’t like the idea? There you are.

she’s not choosing it. Ideally she’d have realised earlier but there you go. She’s not had an affair or behaved poorly. She’s just realised she’s gay.

, @Rosemist1988 People fall out of love with their partners all the time and they have to work out how to best navigate this. Being gay or straight is irrelevant really, the bottom line is that she doesn’t want to be with her current partner and needs to figure out a way to separate from him.

They could separate as a couple and house share if that works for them-one of them may meet a new partner and want to leave eventually anyway.

But she can’t expect him to just leave his home and children right now, because she no longer wants him, he hasn’t hurt anyone or done anything anything to warrant this. The house is jointly rented and they both have a right to live there.

Rosemist1988 · 19/09/2022 22:07

Yes but they are both difficult choices.
I wish people would have a bit of empathy.

wb3 · 19/09/2022 22:04

Rosemist1988 · 19/09/2022 22:01

But people are acting like she’s choosing it.
all this ‘that’s your problem’ and ‘you’re breaking up the family.’
she probably doesn’t want to but her options are stay in a marriage where she doesn’t actually want the sex and the relationship isn’t right for her or leave. And the intimacy part is likely pretty untenable.
Straight women - imagine having to sleep with a woman. Don’t like the idea? There you are.

she’s not choosing it. Ideally she’d have realised earlier but there you go. She’s not had an affair or behaved poorly. She’s just realised she’s gay.

She gets to choose her course of action.

Overandunderit · 19/09/2022 22:03

What a sad life unlived you'll both have if you don't split. If you stay the resentment will eat away at both of you. Your poor kids.

Rosemist1988 · 19/09/2022 22:01

But people are acting like she’s choosing it.
all this ‘that’s your problem’ and ‘you’re breaking up the family.’
she probably doesn’t want to but her options are stay in a marriage where she doesn’t actually want the sex and the relationship isn’t right for her or leave. And the intimacy part is likely pretty untenable.
Straight women - imagine having to sleep with a woman. Don’t like the idea? There you are.

she’s not choosing it. Ideally she’d have realised earlier but there you go. She’s not had an affair or behaved poorly. She’s just realised she’s gay.

ForgottenWhyImHere · 19/09/2022 21:58

My ex came out to me as bi after 18.5 years together, then said he was probably just gay, and we eventually separated after nine months of 'making it work'.

I was devastated. But, him ending our relationship turned out to be the best thing he ever did for me. It wasn't a fulfilling relationship. It was dysfunctional. There was no affection. I was not happy. I was constantly stressed and anxious because no matter what I did, he wasn't happy. He wasn't loving. But I didn't acknowledge all that until after.

What happens when you fall in love with someone else? Then you'll leave. Staying together for the kids until the gay partner meets someone else is very common. You are denying your husband (and yourself) the possibility of a real, honest and loving relationship with someone truly compatible.

Your husband can find help and support through Straight Partners Anonymous (information attached).

to be gay but stay with husband for the children?
wb3 · 19/09/2022 21:58

SadSuzie · 19/09/2022 21:51

It’s not a modern enough world for him to have the kids as he leaves for work at 6am, works away every fortnight for days at a time and is never in until 7pm!

I do all the school runs and he wouldn’t be able to actually afford to pay a childminder to cover it all.

it’s really not about me wanting him to leave the house - I want to stay under the same roof for the children’s sakes more than anything.
I was just pointing out that I physically can’t leave this rental because I can’t get another one beg cause of such a low wage.

Surely that's your problem not his?

SadSuzie · 19/09/2022 21:51

It’s not a modern enough world for him to have the kids as he leaves for work at 6am, works away every fortnight for days at a time and is never in until 7pm!

I do all the school runs and he wouldn’t be able to actually afford to pay a childminder to cover it all.

it’s really not about me wanting him to leave the house - I want to stay under the same roof for the children’s sakes more than anything.
I was just pointing out that I physically can’t leave this rental because I can’t get another one beg cause of such a low wage.

OP posts:
beastlyslumber · 19/09/2022 21:51

Well I don't think it works like that, does it? It has to be decided fairly what's best for the children. That is almost never going to be the mum leaving the family home without them.

BattenburgDonkey · 19/09/2022 21:46

beastlyslumber · 19/09/2022 21:44

OP just expects her DH to leave his home and children, because she doesn’t want him anymore.

Well, yes. Unless you think that women should be forced to stay in marriages they don't want to be in? Should only men be able to divorce their wives? I think you might have fallen into a timewarp.

No, they think SHE should leave the home, because it’s her that wants to end the marriage. Because it’s a modern world and children can stay with their dads now.

butterfliedtwo · 19/09/2022 21:46

She's free to divorce him. She can't dictate that he leaves the house just because that would be easier for her.

beastlyslumber · 19/09/2022 21:44

OP just expects her DH to leave his home and children, because she doesn’t want him anymore.

Well, yes. Unless you think that women should be forced to stay in marriages they don't want to be in? Should only men be able to divorce their wives? I think you might have fallen into a timewarp.

Cameleongirl · 19/09/2022 21:42

@Rosemist1988 I think the lack of sympathy for the OP is stemming from the fact that the OP just expects her DH to leave his home and children, because she doesn’t want him anymore.

“Compulsory Heterosexuality” has nothing to do with it, she’s trying to chuck him out, rather than leave herself. Imagine if this was reversed, everyone would be telling her that her DH is a pig and not to leave her home/children!

Devo1818 · 19/09/2022 21:25

As far as the kids are concerned, the sooner the better.

You only have one life OP.

wb3 · 19/09/2022 21:24

SadSuzie · 19/09/2022 13:43

He does know I’m gay
This came out months ago and he refused to leave, he knew I couldn’t so we just bumbled along really
Im finding it very hard - he switches between being really cross about me “ changing my mind “ 20 years into marriage and saying it’s all a mid life crisis and will pass

What do you mean "he refused to leave"?

Surely the onus is on you to leave? You're the one who no longer wants the marriage.

BattenburgDonkey · 19/09/2022 21:22

What difference would it make if he was emotionally available if you are gay? You being gay is nothing to do with how he’s behaved through your marriage.