Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be gay but stay with husband for the children?

187 replies

SadSuzie · 19/09/2022 13:38

I know people will say it’s impossible and I would probably say the same if I saw a thread like this
BUT
I can’t physically leave - the house is rented and I don’t and can’t earn more whilst the DS’s are young.
I do love him and the relationship between him and the children, they would be heartbroken without their dad and I would be heartbroken without them so it’s all a massive mess.
Has anyone stayed until the children were older so not to cause the destruction that will follow?

OP posts:
loislovesstewie · 22/09/2022 15:08

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

ForgottenWhyImHere · 22/09/2022 14:52

@Cameleongirl Thanks. When I read threads like these, I always hope the couple in question can work through the situation civilly. My ex turned into a parody of the worst parts of his character, but maybe that was who he was all along. A few people told me afterwards that they hadn't actually liked him that much, but thought if I was happy with him then that was all that mattered.

And @SadSuzie i think @hamsterchump makes a very good point. When my ex was sending mixed messages (I'm into men and need to explore that, but I don't want to break up the family) I kept hoping against hope that he was 'just' depressed or having a breakdown or even that he had a brain tumour and needed medical intervention and he would eventually decide to stay or be cured or whatever. It was only when he became thoroughly nasty that I stopped hoping we would be reconciled, but he'd already ended the marriage by then. I know a lot of straight partners who have clung on long past the point I let go because they don't want to lose the life they've been happy with. Your husband is probably the same.

I didn't realise how dysfunctional my relationship was until I met someone else (straight!) and experienced what it's like to be with someone who genuinely finds me attractive. I imagine my ex has had a similar epiphany with his boyfriend but the other way around - realising what it's like to be with someone he's actually attracted to. You and your husband would most likely both be much happier living your own authentic lives. (Not a fan of the word 'authentic' but probably the best one in context).

BeyondsEnergyObsession · 22/09/2022 14:17

I have no idea why that is italicised 🤷🏼‍♀️

BeyondsEnergyObsession · 22/09/2022 14:17

Honestly - and I know I'm going to be written off as a MN cliche here - he sounds abusive to me.

Because he is basically refusing to let you be gay. And you are in a position where you are giving his thoughts priority over yours. Which is worth looking at: why do you believe his words carry more weight than your own, what got you to that point? This is especially important to look at given you are having sex that you do not want (whats happening there, are you being coerced or emotionally blackmailed?)

FWIW I left mine, it is entirely doable and definitely worth it.

Textboxmm · 22/09/2022 13:54

Unfortunately you’ll get a lot of comments on here that aren’t helpful due to your sexuality.
You’ve got a lot to sort out, but I know SO many older lesbians who had kids with men before they came out.you are not alone.

you should call your local LBGTQ+ Switchboard/ helpline/support line to have a chat with a sympathetic ear. This isn’t your fault.

Talking to someone who can empathise with will get your head straight.

Cameleongirl · 22/09/2022 13:48

@ForgottenWhyImHere That sounds horrible, good on you for making it through and getting on with your life.

Your ex sounds like a selfish twat, tbh, it’s unbelievable that he made you sort out the divorce when he was the one who wanted to separate.

hamsterchump · 22/09/2022 11:57

@SadSuzie You should definitely read the comment by @ForgottenWhyImHere above to understand how your husband will be feeling, it's a really informative comment showing how this feels from the other side.

You still don't seem to get that you will have to be proactive and make some decisions here. It sounds like you are expecting your husband to hold your hand through this and somehow magically make everything ok but he can't and won't do that any more and you can't expect him to, you will have to stand on your own two feet and have some uncomfortable discussions about how this will work and how you will make this work.

You seem to have laid your cards on the table about your feelings but then have had absolutely no idea about what you will do practically and are instead just letting everything continue as it has. So it's no wonder your husband is confused and wondering and probably hoping against hope that you aren't serious. If you are serious and sure then you need to put your big girl pants on and state that plainly.

He will have to compromise too of course on things like childcare and working hours but you can't expect him to help you more than he has to any more, he just won't be in a position to do that or to want to do that for you.

If he moves out then you probably won't be able to afford where you live now and will likely have to find somewhere cheaper that will accept UC. It will be very difficult as it's always more expensive to run two households rather than one. You should look into what you will be entitled to and plan on receiving that and only that.

ForgottenWhyImHere · 22/09/2022 11:36

I was the straight partner in this situation (I posted details of a support group for your husband near the start of the thread).

Our DC were 6.5 and 9 when ex came out to me, 7 and 10 when we separated and 9 and 12 when ex finally moved out. Ignoring the sexuality element for a moment, I was also terrified that I wouldn't be able to survive financially. I did. You jut have to. I managed to get a new job, went full time, arranged childcare. It's not been easy but better than staying together in misery.

The two years we were separated but still living under one roof were horrific from my perspective. It was torture for me. He could have gone sooner, but I had to do all the work of sorting the divorce and getting him to leave. I thought at the beginning of it all that we would be able to stay friends. After all, he didn't choose to be gay and I loved him. But the not leaving was so cruel. It destroyed our relationship and I can just about be civil for the DC but I lost all respect and affection for him. However, I can see how that would be the case in similar circumstances, whatever the reason for the separation.

Back to the sexual orientation factor. Your husband probably still loves you. He's probably still attracted to you. You do not feel the same way about him. It's going to take him longer to get over this. One of the big differences (compared to a straight couple) with a separation where one person realises they are actually gay is that the straight person not only loses the future they had imagined, but also loses their shared history. They question what, if anything, was real about their relationship. Did they ever know their partner? They realise that the gay partner never felt the same way about the straight partner. They simply can't have if they were never into wo/men in the first place. They also feel a lot of confusion about their own attractiveness - can I only attract a gay wo/man? Would a straight wo/man like me? What does that say about me? They feel stupid. How stupid must I be to have married someone and not have realised they're gay? They nearly always experience some form of depression. Insomnia is very common. They feel deeply betrayed. Your husband is very probably going through all this, and that won't be helping his decision making.

If you really want to change your situation, then get yourselves into counselling or get mediation. Talk about how it's going to work, whether you stay together or not. But in my experience, based on the stories of lots of straight partners, staying 'together' is likely to lead to lots of resentment on both sides. Sooner or later, you will probably meet someone and that changes everything.

You know how people on here talk about 'the script' used by cheating men? It's the same in this situation. It generally plays out in much the same way, with some variation. And it nearly always starts with 'we still care about each other very much, want to stay friends and we co-parent brilliantly, so we want to try staying together'. Sadly, it almost always ends in tears.

I appreciate that this is very difficult for you. But it is exceptionally cruel to want to keep your husband in a 'relationship' that has no chance of ever being mutually satisfying because you are scared of change. It's not fair on you either, but I'm biased towards the straight partner because that was me and it is shit.

MichelleScarn · 22/09/2022 06:45

If they are 6 and 9 they can go to after school and bf club, you'll prob get sig amount of uc to pay for this and likely support for holiday clubs too. Your dh will also have to give up annual leave for his share of childcare too. Is that not how mostnl single parents manage?

loislovesstewie · 22/09/2022 05:36

@SadSuzie I did all the school runs for donkeys years because my DH was on a train to work at 7 a.m. then I went to work myself. I worked full time, in local government, and had kids with disabilities. Was it tough? Yes, it was, but I buckled down and did it because I had to. Life is like that, we make compromises and get on with things. My year so far has been rubbish, but I'm plodding on. Yours has to change, rather than moan about it, start planning, take control and get through it.

lessthanathirdofanacre · 22/09/2022 01:47

It still sounds as though you want his life to change massively and yours to stay pretty much the same. So he would have to leave the house and find new accommodation, continue to work a demanding job, have less time with the children, etc. while you stay in the house and continue to work part-time on the pretext that you have to do the school runs.

It sounds to me as though you will both need to move and make other changes. You will need to find a full-time job and a flat or house that you can afford. Your (ex) husband will also need to find alternative housing and possibly change jobs or adjust his work schedule. It may mean that your children will need to move to a new school with a provision for before and after school care.

None of this will be easy. But it seems inevitable that all of you will have to make changes as you adjust to a new reality.

Textboxmm · 21/09/2022 23:27

Discuss custody and child support. Do it via mediation. If he wants to see his kids then he wi have to change his living arrangements and job hours - just as you’re life will change drastically.

Textboxmm · 21/09/2022 23:24

You need to bite the bullet and get sorted. Sort your finances, living arrangements and do it now.
This can’t last - you’re going to make everyone miserable including yourself.

Ponderingwindow · 21/09/2022 23:19

you can force the issue on your employment. Find child care and pay for it out of the household budget which is the correct source for financing child care. Then seek full-time employment and improve your financial situation.

SadSuzie · 21/09/2022 22:29

Prioritising the needs of the children is ensuring they can get to and from school through is it not?
If he is unwilling to change his job / hours and wants me to continue doing all the school runs and having them in the holidays then this massively stops me from ever earning enough to afford 3 times the rental amount of a place!!!

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 21/09/2022 20:41

It doesn’t matter why this marriage is no longer working for the OP. The two partners in the marriage are no longer on the same page with regards to their shared goals and future. It happens all the time. The husband isn’t supposed to be more understanding because the op has declared a different sexuality instead of any of the other myriad reasons she might declare she is unhappy. His only real responsibility is to try and remain civil and prioritize the needs of their shared children. he is allowed to be personally angry and only cooperative to the minimum degree required.

MichelleScarn · 21/09/2022 20:22

As @loislovesstewie says, although the other option for him seemed to be him moving out oh his own, while funding the op to carry on living in the family home, working only Part time and still having the same lifestyle as previously.

loislovesstewie · 21/09/2022 19:05

@beastlyslumber the OP wanted to carry on living in the same house with him and all the benefits that went with that, but not have an intimate relationship with him. As I said before she called him a plodder and seemed to imply he would be OK with what she wanted because he wanted to see his children as usual. In other words she wants it all her own way, without thinking that he was unlikely to be agreeable to that. If both parties are happy then fine, but I would suggest that one will want more, and then the set up will fail. As I asked, did she not think he would look elsewhere and then what?

lessthanathirdofanacre · 21/09/2022 18:55

There is nothing remotely homophobic about saying that it isn't fair to her husband to stay with him under the circumstances or that the OP is responsible for her own housing and income. It sounds as though the husband has been trying to bury his head in the sand and pretend that nothing has changed. But obviously, things have changed. If the OP had simply said that she had fallen out of love with him and wanted to divorce for that reason, my responses would have been exactly the same.

@SadSuzieyour children are both school age. Many, many women work full time when they have children of their ages or younger. It is up to you to find housing that would make full-time work possible for you (or to find a job first and then secure housing). Your husband will of course be responsible for maintenance and care of the children, but there's no reason at all that he should fund you to stay in a house that is in such an inconvenient location that means your work options are limited.

Also, you mentioned that the idea of your children having a stepmum is "awful." Does that mean you are not planning to enter into a new relationship yourself? What would happen if you fall in love with someone and want to build a life with her?

beastlyslumber · 21/09/2022 18:42

How is she expecting him to bend over backwards? This makes no sense. He said he wanted to stay together. He said he didn't believe her that she was gay. He said she either made a full commitment to him or she told the kids they were breaking up. I get that he's hurt but it seems like he was pushing pretty hard.

She isn't about to leave her kids and it's ridiculous that people expect her to. She and her husband need to work out the terms of their split and how they will deal with childcare. At the moment she will have to stay in the marital home because that's where the kids are. She is not saying her husband needs to leave, but if he is going to do 50% of the childcare he'll need to make some changes with his work.

None of that is unreasonable and people giving her a hard time and telling her to leave her kids are being completely unfair. Not just on her, but on her kids!

OhmygodDont · 21/09/2022 18:22

She’s the one wanting to separate. The husband is at no fault here. His not done anything wrong. She’s fallen out of love for her own reason. There is nothing he could do to make her love him or improve their relationship. It’s pretty Simple. Gay or straight people fall out of love all the time. They don’t expect their partner who’s at no fault to bend over backwards for their will.

beastlyslumber · 21/09/2022 18:16

If she wasn't gay she wouldn't be getting all this crap from people. If she just said she'd fallen out of love with her husband and he kept pushing her for a resolution and giving her an ultimatum, people would be more sympathetic. But she's gay, so you're all pissed off and think she's evil and that she should have to leave her home and kids.

OhmygodDont · 21/09/2022 18:12

Thingstodotoday · 21/09/2022 18:06

She’s already said that she isn’t the same poster.

Don’t most who get called out though. Either way she is expecting everything all her way with no budge.

Thingstodotoday · 21/09/2022 18:06

Loachworks · 21/09/2022 17:52

This. If it is you it's vile. No one cares whether you're gay or straight but you sound so self-centred.

She’s already said that she isn’t the same poster.

OhmygodDont · 21/09/2022 18:02

beastlyslumber · 21/09/2022 17:52

Your sexuality is basically bugger all.

This thread is full of vile homophobia.

OP, maybe post again in relationships and we'll try to lose the homophobes and give you some actual support.

It's okay to be gay. You didn't do anything wrong.

It sounds like it's all very raw and painful for all of you right now, but it will get better. Practical questions like where you're all going to live will need to be sorted. I would get in touch with a solicitor as soon as possible, start getting things in order. As far as the emotional side of things is concerned, your kids will feel better when things are resolved. Uncertainty is horrible. You need to make sure they know they are loved by both of you, it's not their fault, and they still have a family. Family counselling can really help.

As for you and your husband, you may be able to come through this as friends. You will both meet people and move on in time.

It’s not homophobic it’s saying her being gay straight or even bi has no actual relevance to the house living together or apart. It’s just a separation. Using being a gay as the reason is to pull at heart strings. Relationships fails every day for a multitude of reasons.

Swipe left for the next trending thread