Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want an "opt out" for funerals?

205 replies

HangingOver · 19/09/2022 11:12

Possible TW death and loss...

I've been thinking about this ever since the queen died....

If it were possible to tick a box saying "I do not want a funeral" I would probably do it...

Reason being I think funerals could be an example of something that society just carries on doing "because we've always done it" without questioning whether it's a good idea or not.

Every funeral I've been to I've found traumatic, no matter the age of the person. I barely know anyone religious (included the deceaseds) so the hymns and prayers bit seemed sort of odd. Suddenly being so close to a dead body in a box is at best strange and at worst panic inducing. Then everyone stands around afterwards saying how lovely the dead person was (when they really should have just told them when they were still alive).

I appreciate not everyone may feel this way, but is there a way of "opting out" and having the choice of having ones remains quietly disposed of by the hospital and everyone just have a nice dinner instead if they want to mark your passing?

OP posts:
ARoyalSubject · 19/09/2022 11:44

A direct cremation is what you are wanting.
.... but I think YABU, as the funeral is for the people left behind, not for the deceased. They should plan what works for them.

shewhomustbeEbayed · 19/09/2022 11:44

I can see both sides, when my dad died 30 years ago he was married to my step-mum so we as his children had no say in his funeral.
Fast forward to my mum dying in February this year and it was really important that us as her grown up children were able to have the funeral we wanted for her.
We chose a family only service and picked a brilliant celebrant and we all talked about our personal memories of her, her service in the WRENS during the war, her favourite readings and played a couple of her favourite songs.
Everybody commented how lovely it was, a real celebration of her life and it really helped us to have closure.

ManateeFair · 19/09/2022 11:44

You don’t have to have a funeral. My dad doesn’t want one so we won’t be having one for him.

Lovelycupofcoffee · 19/09/2022 11:44

@gamerchick Agree 100% .

AStar98 · 19/09/2022 11:43

I will opt out of a funeral, I don't see the point of them. Sometimes a nice to remember loved ones and tell others about their life but really, whomever you lose is personal to you. You can't convey that in a service, religious or not.

whosaidtha · 19/09/2022 11:43

I also think it's selfish to write it in a will and deprive your grieving loved ones of saying goodbye in the way they want. Be that funeral or not. I'd be devastated if a family member did that.

Honeyroar · 19/09/2022 11:43

The other thing I think about this, is I’ve been to quite a few funerals where I’ve learned something about the person, some amazing thing that they did before I knew them. My dad’s dying now so I’m thinking about his funeral. He doesn’t want it to be religious, which I’m totally ok with, but I want it to celebrate him. Show off what an amazing person he is, the incredible things he’s done. Lots of photos etc to make people talk/smile.

soberfabulous · 19/09/2022 11:43

So interesting you raise this. My grandmother recently died and both her and my mum decided they didn't want a funeral. They simply collected her ashes from the crematorium and scattered them afterwards.

We are a small family and it suited us all perfectly.

itwasntmetho · 19/09/2022 11:41

This thing it’s for everyone else, doesn’t make a difference to you is a bit horrible I think. There’s something really undignified and ghoulish to me about being carried around in a box. I don’t consent.
i want a direct cremation not an awkward social affair where people who don’t really know each other but only know me dispose of me and talk about me.
id like my son to go somewhere that he has a nice memory of me to remember me.

BorgQueen · 19/09/2022 11:41

Water cremation is where a body is basically boiled in an alkali solution until all that is left are bones that are then crushed to ash. Apparently 90% more enviromentally friendly than normal furnace cremation and family can have any jewellery back as it’s unaffected.

DutchessOfMuck · 19/09/2022 11:40

Am not having a funeral and definitely not spending crazy money. I want put in the cheapest no frills box and buried only no service. with only dh and kids, grandchildren there. Then they can have a cup of tea at my house after.

Cheap and fuss free.

whosaidtha · 19/09/2022 11:39

The funereal isn't about or for you. I want my relatives who are still around to decide what they want. It's for them and their grieving not me. I'm dead.

gingercat02 · 19/09/2022 11:39

That's partly what a will is for. You can request everything or nothing!

ParentallyUnprepared · 19/09/2022 11:39

I just said this to my niece.

Don't waste money on me. I'll be gone. I won't know. Get rid and use the money to get drunk.

InstantMagic · 19/09/2022 11:38

Themselves = those

InstantMagic · 19/09/2022 11:38

I have a family member who opted for direct cremation.

I respect that choice, but for me, a funeral is such an important part of death. Humans have had rituals to mark death forever. They are incredibly important for themselves left behind.

I do think the wait between death and the funeral in the UK now is too long. There is a much quicker turnaround in Ireland, where my family are from, and it all feels more of a natural progression rather than a traumatic limbo.

Pieceofpurplesky · 19/09/2022 11:38

My uncle died recently and was insistent beforehand that he would not have a funeral. Not even his own children. He was cremated.

He hated funerals. He said he had seen enough in the war.

Manicpixidreamgirl · 19/09/2022 11:37

YABU. Funerals aren’t for the dead, they’re for the living.
I will be advising my loved ones to do what they hell they’d like. I won’t know about it so won’t care.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 19/09/2022 11:37

I thought this, genuinely. My db died recently. There was no funeral as apparently he wanted direct cremation. I have struggled with it hugely.
No coming together of his numerous friends. No exchange of stories, no out pouring of love, no special songs sung or shared.
It was his choice.

Honeyroar · 19/09/2022 11:37

I completely get what you mean, I find them traumatic too. But really they’re for other people. My best friend died. She didn’t want a service, just to be cremated and then to have a party when her ashes were back, with her there. TBH I found it much more upsetting. There were five of us at her funeral, no eulogy, one song played, done. Then at her party everyone was sad, wanting to grieve, it felt wrong. We really tried, put her fave tracks on a CD etc, but it didn’t work. I honestly think if people had gone to a short crem funeral first, to cry and let the sadness out, so to speak, the wake would’ve been better.

Proudboomer · 19/09/2022 11:37

My mum is now 85. She has outlived all her friends, sisters and other contemporaries. When she goes there is only 5 direct descendants plus 3 possible in-laws to attend a funeral so when the time comes any funeral will be a quite trip to the cremation with just the basics.

MagnoliatheMagnificent · 19/09/2022 11:37

Water cremation?

Bestcatmum · 19/09/2022 11:37

I have already written in my will and my DS knows I don't want a funeral. I loathe funerals. I have only ever been to one that was in any way meaningful where it was for a friend with no relatives.
All of us - his friends - he died young, cared for the body, dressed him and carried his coffin, did our own service and kissed him goodbye in his coffin and then scattered his ashes in his favourite place. It was a wonderful day.
All other funerals I have attended have been awful.
I have paid for my own pure cremation and I want to be scattered on Glastonbury Tor where I live by my DS. No service, no words.

HelpMeGetThrough · 19/09/2022 11:36

I've said that I don't want one and hope its the case that I don't have one.

If I do, I'm coming back and haunting the buggers relentlessly!! 👻

Poppins2016 · 19/09/2022 11:35

My father in law was adamant that he didn't want a funeral service. As per his wishes we opted for a direct cremation. We then scattered his ashes with closest friends and family in a place that he loved and went for afternoon tea. In some ways it was more intimate and special than an official funeral would have been.

Swipe left for the next trending thread