Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want an "opt out" for funerals?

205 replies

HangingOver · 19/09/2022 11:12

Possible TW death and loss...

I've been thinking about this ever since the queen died....

If it were possible to tick a box saying "I do not want a funeral" I would probably do it...

Reason being I think funerals could be an example of something that society just carries on doing "because we've always done it" without questioning whether it's a good idea or not.

Every funeral I've been to I've found traumatic, no matter the age of the person. I barely know anyone religious (included the deceaseds) so the hymns and prayers bit seemed sort of odd. Suddenly being so close to a dead body in a box is at best strange and at worst panic inducing. Then everyone stands around afterwards saying how lovely the dead person was (when they really should have just told them when they were still alive).

I appreciate not everyone may feel this way, but is there a way of "opting out" and having the choice of having ones remains quietly disposed of by the hospital and everyone just have a nice dinner instead if they want to mark your passing?

OP posts:
UnclePastuso · 19/09/2022 22:23

Both of my grandparents donated their bodies to the university and we didn’t have funerals. The university cremated them after they had finished using them so we do have ashes. The university do a lovely multi faith ceremony for all the people who have donated, it’s attended by all the medical students and is very nicely done. The families are invited but don’t have to attend.

ddl1 · 19/09/2022 22:23

It is possible to put in writing that you don't want a funeral, preferably with a communication to your next of kin to let them know that you're doing so. Both my parents did, and now I have done so, and wish for direct cremation. I don't think it's legally binding, so you won't be able to stop your family having a funeral if they really want to (and after all you won't be there), but at least you can release them from feeling an obligation to have a big occasion if this would distress them further. It's not about not facing death; it's about not feeling up to dealing with pressures and intrusiveness from other people. A private family-only funeral is another possibility for people who do want a funeral, but can't cope with making it a big social occasion.

Blueberrywitch · 19/09/2022 22:18

Wow this sounds brilliant! I never thought it would be possible to opt out.

Although I guess it is nice to mark a passing life, share stories and hear stories about them. I don’t find funerals massively traumatic.

I do think if I was old I would like to have a pre-funeral though, a nice party for me while I was still there? Like turn 80 and insist on speeches etc, spend loads of money on it and invite everyone alive who knew you. Then when you die just have the quiet cremation.

But for those who pass away unexpectedly and young then the funeral is the only chance for people who love them to properly mark their lives isn’t it?

entropynow · 19/09/2022 22:14

HangingOver · 19/09/2022 11:12

Possible TW death and loss...

I've been thinking about this ever since the queen died....

If it were possible to tick a box saying "I do not want a funeral" I would probably do it...

Reason being I think funerals could be an example of something that society just carries on doing "because we've always done it" without questioning whether it's a good idea or not.

Every funeral I've been to I've found traumatic, no matter the age of the person. I barely know anyone religious (included the deceaseds) so the hymns and prayers bit seemed sort of odd. Suddenly being so close to a dead body in a box is at best strange and at worst panic inducing. Then everyone stands around afterwards saying how lovely the dead person was (when they really should have just told them when they were still alive).

I appreciate not everyone may feel this way, but is there a way of "opting out" and having the choice of having ones remains quietly disposed of by the hospital and everyone just have a nice dinner instead if they want to mark your passing?

Of course there is. Leave your body to science and put your wishes clearly in your will. You need a direct cremation back up plan in case they can't use your body. Simple.

AngieBolen · 19/09/2022 22:10

If you find funerals traumatic, don't go to them.

If a family are regular church goers, it can be comforting to have a funeral in a church they attend regularly. I think funerals held only at a cemetery can be difficult, as everything is unfamiliar, which is why direct cremations are becoming more popular. My funeral will most likely be at the church linked two my DCs school, so they'll have been there at least twice a week during their child hood. I hope the familiarity of the building, etc will help them. An atheist friend thinks I'm bonkers to believe this.

Honeyroar · 19/09/2022 17:50

My mum has left her body to medical science. It doesn’t mean that we won’t have a memorial or something when she dies. Then perhaps a tiny cremation when they’re done with her.

gogohmm · 19/09/2022 17:23

You can have a direct funeral but be aware that funerals are for the living. Occupational hazard, I'm involved in a lot death and there's been so much upset when direct funerals are opted for. Though a direct funeral then a memorial service later is a good option for many families dealing with a family and friends spread out geographically as that can be done much later

Ponderingwindow · 19/09/2022 17:22

You just need to let your family know your wishes. We have had members pass who wanted absolutely no funeral of any kind, members who had non-traditional memorials, and a few that had services that were so formal some of the women had veils on their hats.

I personally have found the non-traditional memorials the most meaningful for processing my grief. The religious trappings do nothing for me. The lack of any kind of gathering means there is no day to focus your grieving and let it go. A memorial tailored to the personality of the deceased is ideal because it reflects the way that person lived. It doesn’t have to be a bunch of people sitting in rows listening to speeches. For the right person, something crazy like a paintball battle that included a bit of time to reflect on the purpose of the gathering could even be the right thing.

Twizbe · 19/09/2022 17:18

You can opt out. A relation of DH didn't want a funeral.

His family weren't happy about it. They didn't know until after he died.

I suppose it's true that the funeral is for the living not the dead. It's how we say goodbye.

Witchofthedales · 19/09/2022 17:08

We had direct cremation for my MIL and I will be having the same.

Thelnebriati · 19/09/2022 17:04

I've left mine specifically to my consultant for research into a disorder I have, and if he goes first it goes to medical science. If there's anything left after they've finished with it, they'll just cremate and dispose of it.
I've asked my family to plant an oak tree in a woodland instead of a funeral.

Brigante9 · 19/09/2022 16:53

I’m donating my body, if it’s wanted then they cremate remains, I think, so no funeral. My DH wants a direct to crem funeral. I don’t want people travelling hours to mourn somebody who’s died. My dad’s funeral was the most traumatic thing I’ve ever attended. The church was packed and I found it incredibly difficult to cope with the ‘sympathy’ from people who’d not seen him in years. I’ll have to do the same for mother, but won’t be so bothered, we’re fairly low contact. I’ll just have to deal with the house, which is absolutely full of stuff.

Witchcraftandhokum · 19/09/2022 16:36

Leave yourself to medical science.

HuzzahIndeed · 19/09/2022 14:17

I've just reiterated to my husband what I would like to happen and that I was serious about a firework. He laughed and said it wasn't very environmentally friendly and can he bury me in a mushroom suit and go to a bonfire night display instead. 🤣

Teenangels · 19/09/2022 14:15

My mother in law, has just had a direct cremation.
Her death was a shock, as she was not unwell, started to feel I'll, and dead in 2 hours (a great way to go). We were away, and could not get back in time, my FIL and SIL saw her at the hospital, as they called an ambulance. The nothing, my partner did not get to say goodbye, see her. It's been absolutely brutal for him, there in a sense has been no closure.
We have had no meal, as that is not what my MIL wanted which I think is a shame.
Having been through it, I would say there has to be something to remember someone by, some closure be it a meal or party whatever you want but not what we have just been through.

bridgetreilly · 19/09/2022 14:05

The thing is, funerals are for the mourners, not the person who has died. So I think it’s better to say that they can choose, but if they prefer not to have a funeral you would be happy with that. Personally, I find funerals an incredibly helpful and important part of grieving, and when I haven’t been able to attend funerals it’s been a lot harder.

stripeyzeb · 19/09/2022 14:04

You don't have to have a 'funeral' in the traditional sense but I suspect it's good for those you leave behind to have some kind of 'ceremony'.

I'm a Christian and in the tradition I come from, we have two separate events. There's the cremation/burial (for close friends/family only) followed by a Celebration of Life service. This means that at the service, there's no coffin to look at, people aren't compelled to wear black and it becomes a really lovely thanksgiving for the person's life. We did this for my mum (as per her wishes).

The hardest part was the service at the crem, though of course if you wanted to, that part could be avoided by having a direct cremation. We followed that up with a lovely (bittersweet) celebration (of sorts) in another venue where we had food, an open mic to share stories, live music (with her favourite songs) and a lovely tribute from our minister. There were tears but also lots of smiles, hugs and community.

For us, we needed something like an event to mark that mum was gone and to honour her life. Obviously everyone is different but you can choose what you like. For me, I have stipulated in my Will that this is what I want.

mondaytosunday · 19/09/2022 13:53

I would not want a religious ceremony. My mother, a devout Catholic, and my father in law died within two weeks of each other. Her funeral was fairly impersonal, though we insisted a cousin read a prayer and her oldest friend said a few worlds too, but the priest said it was 'irregular'. Otherwise there would have been hardly a word said about my mother.
At my FIL funeral, there was no religious component so anything goes, and it was all about him. Both were cremated afterwards (my mother at later and my fil at the end of the ceremony).
I would definitely have a funeral though. Having lost both parents and my husband it is extremely important to honour and remember the dead collectively.

stayathomer · 19/09/2022 13:26

I’m so torn on this. I remember being so bitter at my dads funeral because so many people were laughing and chatting afterwards and my mum cornered me and said she hated the funeral thing and she was bitter because people who hadn’t been in touch for years were there. We hosted the wake for dh’s dad and everyone got shit faced and dh regularly said he wished they’d go and leave us alone and how he hated Ireland and it’s stupid traditions but over Covid I couldn’t go to one of my best friend’s mum’s funeral and she said her and her dad felt the absences ten fold so I don’t know that there’s an easy answer

SWSUN · 19/09/2022 13:18

I am terminally ill and I have written in a will I want a direct cremation. We did it for my dad during covid and then scattered his ashes afterwards.

It was exactly what he wanted and I am keen to avoid my family having to make all the funeral arrangements/decisions and then have to sit through the bloody thing!

PP mentioned a living funeral and as someone who hates being the centre of attention I can’t think of anything worse. Lots of people with head tilts saying nice things in an artificial way - sounds hideous!!

HangingOver · 19/09/2022 13:17

*Just send an envelope to all the people you think would turn up, telling them to open on the event if your death.

Said envelope contains a letter saying "Now I'm dead, I can tell you, I always thought you were a twat."

Problem solved with people turning up*

Lol that or "if you dare serve any non-vegan food or drinks at the wake I'll haunt you". Should put at least 50% off.

OP posts:
HangingOver · 19/09/2022 13:15

The thing is, OP...just like a wedding...you don't have to attend any funeral if you don't want to

Well...not really. If I hadn't attended DMs funeral my family would never have spoken to me again but I hated every minute of it. Especially when they put the bloody box in the ground I had this huge surge of childish terror about her being alone and cold down there without her special blanket. Still bring tears to my eyes. I e

OP posts:
BonesOfWhatYouBelieve · 19/09/2022 13:14

I don't think you're unreasonable, but there are different kinds of funeral.
For my grandad, my grandma just wanted their children, children in law, and grandchildren. No other speakers, no one leading any kind of service, just close family telling a favourite story and then back to her house for dinner and drinks. She asked the crematorium to arrange the chairs in a circle, and it was informal and lovely and I learnt a lot about my grandad I didn't know, like how they met, things about his childhood that my grandma knew etc.
I should add that when he died, my grandad didn't have any other family other than a brother who was too ill to travel, so my grandma wasn't excluding any close family.

HadEnough798 · 19/09/2022 13:01

I needed a funeral to accept my darling Dad had really gone. If I hadn't seen the coffin I don't think I ever would have really believed it. Wasn't a religious one at all - but sometimes they do serve a purpose.

sueelleker · 19/09/2022 12:55

mast0650 · 19/09/2022 11:25

Yes you can do that. You just need to let those people closest to you know and trust that they follow your wishes. Of course, there is no way of enforcing it, any more than there is a way of enforcing your wishes for a big, grand funeral.

We had a direct, unattended cremation for my father. Though we did also have memorial event (informal, non-religious, non-standard venue)

I had an unattended cremation for my husband, followed by scattering his ashes at a natual burial ground. He was a professional gardener for many years, so we thought he'd like the going back to nature bit.