Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect food to still be there if I've said no to eating it?

365 replies

User3billion · 19/09/2022 10:53

Is it OK to have food in the house that belongs to a specific person?!

For instance this weekend eldest was away on camp & two youngest wanted crepes (just a cheap packet of ready made ones). Last night when eldest got back he asked if he could have one.... I said no as it was nearly dinner time and they'd been bought for the little ones.

There were two left in the pack - went to get the youngest one this morning as she asked for it for breakfast and eldest has eaten BOTH. He's also denied it but it couldn't be anyone else.

I've had chocolate bought for my birthday recently and eldest has helped themselves (I wouldn't mind but I've shared it when I've been eating it so it's not as if I've been selfish). They don't care that it's not theirs, if it's not hidden, they eat it.

There's plenty of other food in the house that they're welcome to help themselves to.... bread, cooked meats, cheese, a selection of cereals, fruit, yogurt etc

So am I being unreasonable saying that if something is bought for someone else it should still be there for them to eat?!

OP posts:
Autumndays123 · 20/09/2022 13:02

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/09/2022 12:56

@Autumndays123

its a crepe! He was asked not to eat it. He had had special weekend treats so had his siblings , just cos his siblings didn’t eat all theirs in one go doesn’t mean that it’s fair game for their older brother to have them! There is such a thing as saving for another day you know

likeiwse his mums birthday chocs - he shouldn’t have eaten them as they were a present to his mum

I think you’re overstating

You're right, it is just a crepe!

The OP is trying her very hardest to make her son out to be the bad guy 'but, but he was in camp', 'but but we went for a milkshake because one was in a sleepover'. I think she knows full well she was being unreasonable and posted a thread on here hoping that a load of randoms would start telling what a horrible child her son is. Very odd behaviour in itself. If OP had asked for opinions and then said something like "I hadn't thought of X or Y, that's a good point, perhaps I will reflect" I'd understand, but nope she wanted posters to slag off her son. Very very odd behaviour.

The crux of the matter is, she bought treats for two of her children. If they'd eaten those treats before the son arrived home, that's fine. Literally not a problem. That is not what happened. The other children each had two pancakes each. The son arrived home and there were two left. He wanted them so asked if he could have them. OP said no, you have to do without so your siblings can have three portions (even though one of them wasn't even going to be there the next day as they were off for a sleepover).

It's all about control and a certain element of victim mentality.

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/09/2022 12:56

Autumndays123 · 20/09/2022 12:51

She is. If some people on this thread have no issue with favouritism, over zealous control and disregard of the child's feelings in their parenting, then they will obviously not see it as an issue.

@Autumndays123

its a crepe! He was asked not to eat it. He had had special weekend treats so had his siblings , just cos his siblings didn’t eat all theirs in one go doesn’t mean that it’s fair game for their older brother to have them! There is such a thing as saving for another day you know

likeiwse his mums birthday chocs - he shouldn’t have eaten them as they were a present to his mum

I think you’re overstating

Autumndays123 · 20/09/2022 12:51

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/09/2022 12:49

@Autumndays123

she isn’t being unreasonable though

She is. If some people on this thread have no issue with favouritism, over zealous control and disregard of the child's feelings in their parenting, then they will obviously not see it as an issue.

Autumndays123 · 20/09/2022 12:50

User3billion · 20/09/2022 09:44

@Autumndays123 I think you need to speak to someone about your issues hun. You've clearly not processed your childhood trauma.

The fact that you just used the word 'hun' I think can bring this thread to a close. We all know now exactly the type of person you are.

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/09/2022 12:49

Autumndays123 · 20/09/2022 08:19

And again, you clearly do not think you're being unreasonable in the slightest and have become defensive towards anyone who has pointed out that you are.....so the point of this thread was?

@Autumndays123

she isn’t being unreasonable though

User3billion · 20/09/2022 09:44

@Autumndays123 I think you need to speak to someone about your issues hun. You've clearly not processed your childhood trauma.

OP posts:
HopingNotCoping · 20/09/2022 09:41

Most of the food in our house is kept in the kitchen and is for everyone (with a general expectation of fairness - no one should be snaffling all of something in one go without checking no one else wants it!).

But we all have some food (and drinks for adults) that are specifically our own (we keep it separate from the kitchen to make it clear). Presents, party bag sweets, Halloween hauls etc.

If one of my children is having one kind of treat (like a camp!) I have no issue with giving other children a different one (like crepes) and I wouldn't expect them to have to share if they didn't eat it quick enough. I think teaching children self control around food is a really valuable lesson.

CornishGem1975 · 20/09/2022 09:19

Imagine living in a house where you WEREN'T allowed to have something for yourself.

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/09/2022 09:00

TheOrigRights · 19/09/2022 23:38

I agree with you steppmum

I've also just done my online shop.
DS2 gets a cereal bar that he has every morning. I'm not going to just help myself. Same with his isotonic drink. He'd be rightly upset if he went to get one for a football match and some bugger had taken the last one.
I've got a pack of 2 finger kitkats. I'll keep them hidden so they last a few days.
There's a yoghurt I like for my breakfast, so I've got 5 of them. DS2 knows not to eat them.
Isn't that how all families work?
It breaks down at times when e.g. he'll eat the cooked chicken legs cold for lunch when I was planning on making an evening meal with them, but that's an issue of meal planning rather than helping himself to something specifically for someone else.

He'd ask if he could have a Birthday chocolate.

And it's not about the crepe, it's the respect for others that the issue.
If I asked him not to take my Sensodyne toothpaste overnight I'd be mad if he did, even if he left the regular toothpaste. Doesn't mean I am controlling or have a toothpaste disorder. Same with my special hair conditioner. He doesn't need to use my fancy one.

Surely no one can see this as unreasonable ?!

and those that say every single item in the house is for everyone …. Well it can’t be really can it?!

Oblomov22 · 20/09/2022 08:25

Yes of course this is ok. And everyone knows deep down if it's bought for someone else. It's just wrong.

Autumndays123 · 20/09/2022 08:19

And again, you clearly do not think you're being unreasonable in the slightest and have become defensive towards anyone who has pointed out that you are.....so the point of this thread was?

Autumndays123 · 20/09/2022 08:18

User3billion · 20/09/2022 07:13

Some of these responses have been hilarious & some quite frankly a little concerning.

Thank you to those who've realised it's not simply about the pancakes, they were just an example. 🤦‍♀️

I love how as adults we apparently shouldn't have a stash of chocs for ourselves but a bottle of whiskey would be OK (I'm sure my teetotal husband would whole heartedly agree).

My eldest is definitely not hard done by, he took 2 packets of sweets on camp plus £5 spending money, guess what, he didn't bring any of the sweets back for his siblings (nor would I have expected him to) and in part why I didn't think he should be allowed to just tuck straight into their stuff.

On the way home from camp we'd called at a local dessert shop, eldest & youngest had a milkshake - middle one got nothing as she was already with DSis - by mumsnet reckoning I should have also bought her something to to have on her return then?!

He doesn't have to ask for every snack, there's always food available. I thought I'd made that clear but evidently not seeing as how controlling I apparently am. 🤷‍♀️

If you think the pancake situation is the same as taking two of your children for milkshake when one is at a sleepover, you're either deliberately being obtuse or a total lost cause.

Sorry most of the people of this thread didn't jump on the bandwagon to slag your 14 year old off OP. You must be disappointed

User3billion · 20/09/2022 07:13

Some of these responses have been hilarious & some quite frankly a little concerning.

Thank you to those who've realised it's not simply about the pancakes, they were just an example. 🤦‍♀️

I love how as adults we apparently shouldn't have a stash of chocs for ourselves but a bottle of whiskey would be OK (I'm sure my teetotal husband would whole heartedly agree).

My eldest is definitely not hard done by, he took 2 packets of sweets on camp plus £5 spending money, guess what, he didn't bring any of the sweets back for his siblings (nor would I have expected him to) and in part why I didn't think he should be allowed to just tuck straight into their stuff.

On the way home from camp we'd called at a local dessert shop, eldest & youngest had a milkshake - middle one got nothing as she was already with DSis - by mumsnet reckoning I should have also bought her something to to have on her return then?!

He doesn't have to ask for every snack, there's always food available. I thought I'd made that clear but evidently not seeing as how controlling I apparently am. 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
GlitteryUnicornSparkles · 20/09/2022 01:27

My DS is 13 and exactly the same. Its very frustrating.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/09/2022 00:29

And I agree with those saying one person can’t just hoover up all the nice stuff because they get to it quicker. There should be fair shares for everyone, and those who eat “treats” slower shouldn’t miss out.

This is why I think OP is unreasonable- the little ones had had their share of pancakes. Those if anything should have been being saved for the eldest.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/09/2022 00:27

I think you were unfair not to let the eldest have any pancakes when the younger two had already had two helpings. Of course, it’s fine to say not right before their dinner, but if the other two had already had pancakes twice (and these are considered a treat) I would have considered those two remaining pancakes as “earmarked” for the eldest. They obviously like pancakes so I’d have saved them some.

In general I think food can belong to one person - birthday chocolates or something a parent has bought just for themselves (particularly if it’s something they really liked, and as the parent they have fewer nice things day to day, for example)

But I don’t think that there should be food one child can have and not another if the children all like said food.

Is there any reason why the eldest is expected to have those other foods instead but not the younger ones? Why do they have to be more easy going?

SillySausage81 · 20/09/2022 00:04

steppemum · 19/09/2022 23:28

I'm going ot say it again, because there are so many bonkers comments obsessing about one crepe etc.

The point is he was asked not to.
he was directly asked not to eat it and he did.

That is selfish.
Who cares if it was a crepe, or anything else?
he was asked not to.

Are there so many people on her who are OK with their teen directly doing exactly what they are asked not to?

And all this crap about - all food in the house is for everyone.
I've just done the online shop. dd2 specifially asked me to buy a specific thing for her to have on sat and sun for lunch. I am happy to buy it for all of them, but right now she is the only one who wants it. She then immediately asked me where she can put it to stop anyone else pinching it before sat. I find that perfectly reasonable. It has been bought for a reason. Her preference is a perfectly valid reason!
To say everything is for everyone is really, really unfair on the ones who don't just hoover up all the nice stuff.

100% everything you say here.

My god I'm glad I don't live with some of the people on this thread. I'm the sort of person who can make a big pack of Minstrels last 4-5 days. If I lived with people who thought they could hoover up everyone else's treats I'd quite simply never have any treats as they'd be gone before I got to even try them.

cocog · 19/09/2022 23:56

Remove the malt loaf and when they ask where it is start the topic of having a treat for each person how they feel when someone has taken it. Make them aware they are being unreasonable taking everybody’s treat and ask them to stop doing it also could have treats on a separate cupboard shelf. Sounds silly but possibly name them to make it obvious those are all treats and the rest belong to other family members until they stop. Teenagers are very self absorbed so unless you make a point of it they will continue to do it!

TheOrigRights · 19/09/2022 23:41

Think about him explaining to a teacher or friend that his mum got angry because he ate two pancakes for breakfast. I would be concerned to hear that

But that's not the issue. He should say "my Mum got angry because I ate the last 2 crepes my Mum was saving for my younger siblings and had asked me not to eat. I'd been away at camp and had a great time. She also remembered the time I helped myself to her Birthday chocolates, which didn't help the situation".

TheOrigRights · 19/09/2022 23:38

I agree with you steppmum

I've also just done my online shop.
DS2 gets a cereal bar that he has every morning. I'm not going to just help myself. Same with his isotonic drink. He'd be rightly upset if he went to get one for a football match and some bugger had taken the last one.
I've got a pack of 2 finger kitkats. I'll keep them hidden so they last a few days.
There's a yoghurt I like for my breakfast, so I've got 5 of them. DS2 knows not to eat them.
Isn't that how all families work?
It breaks down at times when e.g. he'll eat the cooked chicken legs cold for lunch when I was planning on making an evening meal with them, but that's an issue of meal planning rather than helping himself to something specifically for someone else.

He'd ask if he could have a Birthday chocolate.

And it's not about the crepe, it's the respect for others that the issue.
If I asked him not to take my Sensodyne toothpaste overnight I'd be mad if he did, even if he left the regular toothpaste. Doesn't mean I am controlling or have a toothpaste disorder. Same with my special hair conditioner. He doesn't need to use my fancy one.

steppemum · 19/09/2022 23:28

I'm going ot say it again, because there are so many bonkers comments obsessing about one crepe etc.

The point is he was asked not to.
he was directly asked not to eat it and he did.

That is selfish.
Who cares if it was a crepe, or anything else?
he was asked not to.

Are there so many people on her who are OK with their teen directly doing exactly what they are asked not to?

And all this crap about - all food in the house is for everyone.
I've just done the online shop. dd2 specifially asked me to buy a specific thing for her to have on sat and sun for lunch. I am happy to buy it for all of them, but right now she is the only one who wants it. She then immediately asked me where she can put it to stop anyone else pinching it before sat. I find that perfectly reasonable. It has been bought for a reason. Her preference is a perfectly valid reason!
To say everything is for everyone is really, really unfair on the ones who don't just hoover up all the nice stuff.

JazbayGrapes · 19/09/2022 21:49

not all kids are greedy and selfish and those that are can be encouraged out of it with good parenting

of course not all, but its pretty much inevitable every now and then. They know they should ask before helping themselves to treats, they know they are supposed to say that something is running low, they know they are supposed to take an apple for a snack instead of scoffing down entire tub of ice cream. But... they conveniently "forget". Oh well... nag, rinse, repeat...

RainingRubies · 19/09/2022 21:37

Could you not have just made some more pancakes for the younger one's breakfast? Takes 5 mins. All seems like a bit of an overreaction.

madaboutsaffron · 19/09/2022 20:25

OP I think it would interesting to remember what rules were in place around food when you were growing up.your son eating two pancakes has really triggered you. Was there a shortage of food or a lot of control around food when you were growing up? You see this food as a reward - not just food. It’s a lot of emotion to put on a breakfast food. how are you with eating and control?* whatever the route of this - break the cycle. Yes he should’ve have eaten your birthday chocolates but most people have said eating two pancakes for breakfast is completely different.sometimes it helps to see how these issues seem to the outside world. Think about him explaining to a teacher or friend that his mum got angry because he ate two pancakes for breakfast. I would be concerned to hear that*

😂😂😂😂😂

SillySausage81 · 19/09/2022 20:24

@LuckySantangelo35

or c) just let the other younger / less greedy / less selfish kids go without nice treats because they're "too slow" (i.e. eat at a normal pace or have a healthier attitude to treats), which I don't think is on at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread