Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect food to still be there if I've said no to eating it?

365 replies

User3billion · 19/09/2022 10:53

Is it OK to have food in the house that belongs to a specific person?!

For instance this weekend eldest was away on camp & two youngest wanted crepes (just a cheap packet of ready made ones). Last night when eldest got back he asked if he could have one.... I said no as it was nearly dinner time and they'd been bought for the little ones.

There were two left in the pack - went to get the youngest one this morning as she asked for it for breakfast and eldest has eaten BOTH. He's also denied it but it couldn't be anyone else.

I've had chocolate bought for my birthday recently and eldest has helped themselves (I wouldn't mind but I've shared it when I've been eating it so it's not as if I've been selfish). They don't care that it's not theirs, if it's not hidden, they eat it.

There's plenty of other food in the house that they're welcome to help themselves to.... bread, cooked meats, cheese, a selection of cereals, fruit, yogurt etc

So am I being unreasonable saying that if something is bought for someone else it should still be there for them to eat?!

OP posts:
Whiskeypowers · 19/09/2022 13:16

User3billion · 19/09/2022 12:32

And yet here you are commenting on the thread! 🤔

yes becuase I think you are off your rocker frankly

MichelleScarn · 19/09/2022 13:13

Ah just saw 14 yo denied eating the crepe, but why so sure OP it was 14yo and not other children who were also there? Can they not access the fridge? (Maybe knowing 14 yo would be scapegoat?)

BrutusMcDogface · 19/09/2022 13:12

I agree yabu re: the crepes, but yanbu re: the birthday chocolate.

Autumndays123 · 19/09/2022 13:12

This reminds me a lot of a situation that happened to me as a child. I came home from school once and noticed an amazing looking cake in the kitchen. Later, my dad cut a slice each for my two younger siblings. I asked if I could please have some and was told no. Instead I just watched my siblings eat theirs. I was quite upset about it and felt totally excluded.

The next day I came home from school and my dad was in work. I cut myself a tiny sliver of cake, an amount so small I didn't think anyone would notice. He did notice and he went absolutely ape shit.

My father was an abusive, nasty piece of work. I sense strong similarities here.

MichelleScarn · 19/09/2022 13:11

Testina · 19/09/2022 13:06

Honestly, the fact you’re asking this on here is why your teen is selfishly walking all over you. You shouldn’t need to ask us how to set rules in your own house. You know your son is thoughtless, rude and a liar. I would deal with that instead of prevaricating on here for a reason not to.

Bloody hell extreme reaction much? Also those who have decided the 14 yo is a liar? Wheres that come from?

PeekAtYou · 19/09/2022 13:08

It is strange that being at camp is considered a treat in itself when presumably the other children would be allowed the opportunity if they were at the same age and attended the same club/school organizing the camp?

The birthday chocolates is unreasonable. I'd find the crepe situation annoying because the supermarkets aren't open today but it sounds like you have other breakfast items available. One crepe isn't going to be filling enough for a 14 year old but if you don't normally buy them I can see why he'd take 2.

Testina · 19/09/2022 13:06

Honestly, the fact you’re asking this on here is why your teen is selfishly walking all over you. You shouldn’t need to ask us how to set rules in your own house. You know your son is thoughtless, rude and a liar. I would deal with that instead of prevaricating on here for a reason not to.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 19/09/2022 13:05

When I was in my teens I loved snack food (wait, I still do). If the house was full of healthy fruit and veg, cold meat, cheese, etc...and an open box of chocolates, I would have gone straight for the chocolates. Or crepes. Or Pringles. I don't find that strange, and I get the feeling that in the OP's house there is a wide range of excellent foods, but a very very tight control on "bad" snack foods.

The lying I do find disturbing, but I suspect it is less about disobedience and fear of punishment, and more about unwillingness to admit to shameful greed (as the OP would see it).

Basically I would keep a few snacks in for the voracious teenager, and hide my birthday chocolates in the high cupboard rather than leaving them on the counter. It's like leaving a steak out and then being surprised the dog ate it.

Autumndays123 · 19/09/2022 13:05

Stripedbag101 · 19/09/2022 13:03

OP I think it would interesting to remember what rules were in place around food when you were growing up.

your son eating two pancakes has really triggered you. Was there a shortage of food or a lot of control around food when you were growing up? You see this food as a reward - not just food. It’s a lot of emotion to put on a breakfast food.

how are you with eating and control?

whatever the route of this - break the cycle. Yes he should’ve have eaten your birthday chocolates but most people have said eating two pancakes for breakfast is completely different.

sometimes it helps to see how these issues seem to the outside world. Think about him explaining to a teacher or friend that his mum got angry because he ate two pancakes for breakfast. I would be concerned to hear that.

Agree with this. OP could well have an eating disorder, it's not normal to restrict and monitor your children's food intake. The only other possibility is terrible parenting.

Stripedbag101 · 19/09/2022 13:03

OP I think it would interesting to remember what rules were in place around food when you were growing up.

your son eating two pancakes has really triggered you. Was there a shortage of food or a lot of control around food when you were growing up? You see this food as a reward - not just food. It’s a lot of emotion to put on a breakfast food.

how are you with eating and control?

whatever the route of this - break the cycle. Yes he should’ve have eaten your birthday chocolates but most people have said eating two pancakes for breakfast is completely different.

sometimes it helps to see how these issues seem to the outside world. Think about him explaining to a teacher or friend that his mum got angry because he ate two pancakes for breakfast. I would be concerned to hear that.

TwinkleChristmas · 19/09/2022 13:01

User3billion · 19/09/2022 12:26

The other 2 didn't get 2 nights away on camp, am I being unfair to them too then?? 🤦‍♀️

How is this even valid? Are you not planning on letting the younger two go on camp when their time comes…

EasilyAmused · 19/09/2022 12:59

NameChangedForThis12398 · 19/09/2022 11:44

If it was a single bag of haribo then fair enough, they are the other child's. Pancakes are not a treat they're just general food in the house. Of course they will eat them.

It's not for you to decide which foods are classed as treats in someone else's house.

lunar1 · 19/09/2022 12:59

The 14 year old found the packet, seen that the others had already had theirs and had their own share.

Iheartmykyndle · 19/09/2022 12:56

User3billion · 19/09/2022 12:26

The other 2 didn't get 2 nights away on camp, am I being unfair to them too then?? 🤦‍♀️

But at some point they will get two nights at camp when it's their turn to do this age appropriate activity? That's how it goes if you've got children of different ages isnt it?! It's completely irrelevant to the crepe situation. The kids all had two crepes each. It's fine.

He shouldn't have eaten your birthday chocs though and should be buying you a replacement.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 19/09/2022 12:52

Surely the younger ones will go to camp when they are old enough? Why is the eldest going to camp somehow used a reason he can't have a third of the pancakes (given he is a third of the children)?

Batshit.

Rowen32 · 19/09/2022 12:52

Why can't all the food in the house be for everyone? That seems the most fair.. Like a PP said I think it's got the potential to create issues around food...if you set up these rules that to me don't make sense and are mean and unfair...

On the birthday chocolate did you specifically say no one is allowed to eat this? I still think its mean though, why can't you share? Or else don't let them see it at all and only take it out when they're gone to bed..

BonesOfWhatYouBelieve · 19/09/2022 12:52

I think it is unreasonable to finish a pack of something nice without checking. And I think it's massively unreasonable for a 14 year old to eat your birthday chocolate, they're old enough to understand that it's not theirs.

Gozleme · 19/09/2022 12:52

Birthday chocolate is wrong.

Crepes - you were in the wrong.

I have an older teenager (17) and younger ones. When I buy something in a pack that is seen as a treat food the rule is one each and they to ask if they want one after that, and only one a day (thinking of things like yazoo milkshake drinks, or innocent smoothies where one of them would drink 6 in a day of they get the chance!)

The same with something like a big pack of raspberries - have some but don’t have a whole pack without checking to see if anyone else had some already.

I could argue that some of them are more “children’s snacks” or that the 17 year old is working and can buy his own snacks/I bought him festivals tickets but not the little ones etc... but they are all my DC and it would be a bit mean to behave like that towards him about food.

Your DS was probably hungry after camp. Next time just pop into Lidl and get several packs, they aren’t expensive

mountainsunsets · 19/09/2022 12:50

User3billion · 19/09/2022 12:26

The other 2 didn't get 2 nights away on camp, am I being unfair to them too then?? 🤦‍♀️

The camp issue is irrelevant to the crepe situation, though.

The youngest had already had two crepes - it's only fair that the oldest got two as well. YABVU.

Jaaxe · 19/09/2022 12:47

I think there’s a few things reasonable and unreasonable….
I think it’s unreasonable for you to say he can’t have any crepes at all in the first instance he asked. My kids have things that I buy that one child likes more than the others but they have to share everything and wouldn’t deny one child out of 3 something.
i think it’s reasonable for you to be annoyed he disobeyed you and ate both so there was none for the other child which you’d told him they were for so he essentially didn’t care.
i think it’s unreasonable he’s eaten your birthday chocolates without asking and you are reasonable to be annoyed he did that.

Summerfun54321 · 19/09/2022 12:47

What are you teaching your kids allowing some to have treats and not others? Have you forgotten the concept of sharing? Your eldest was right to ignore your ridiculousness.

Stripedbag101 · 19/09/2022 12:41

User3billion · 19/09/2022 12:26

The other 2 didn't get 2 nights away on camp, am I being unfair to them too then?? 🤦‍♀️

This is odd. I am really puzzled as to why crepes aren’t considered a treat to make up for an age appropriate trip? Will the younger ones not get this trip when they are older?

your son are two pancakes. I think a lot of teenage boys would eat a huge breakfast. Getting. So worked up about two crepes sounds like you have control issues around food.

i remember being shamed a lot about food when I was a teen. I spent a lot of time with younger cousins and there was always this talk about how much I ate compared to them. People do so much damage around food with kids and teens.

he ate two pancakes. He didn’t steal their Santa toys.

please let this go. Two pancakes is perfectly reasonable for a teenage boy. Saying he can’t have pancakes because they are a special treat for his younger siblings is really odd - it’s fairly standard food.

Paparazzicrap · 19/09/2022 12:40

Aargh why do people do this? Restricting kids' food can lead to so many issues. In our house, it's help yourself but put it on the list so it can be replaced for everyone else.

Hopeandlove · 19/09/2022 12:40

Food for one but not for the other no
food that’s a present taken eg chocolates would be theft here

if I buy myself a really nice steak as a treat I buy us all steak

Tsort · 19/09/2022 12:39

User3billion · 19/09/2022 11:39

I'm using "they" to mean eldest in this instance. Eldest is 14 and was away for the weekend on camp (with spending money for the tuck shop) when the crepes were bought for the younger ones.

Middle slept out last night with my DSis & cousins so there were 2 kids in the house this morning. If eldest had eaten just one pancake & offered the other one to the youngest I'd have been fine with that. It was eating BOTH that was the issue. It definitely wasn't DH as he was still in bed.

There are very few foods in the house that are "off limits". The eldest had malt loaf in the house too (I'd forgotten until he came to get a slice around 11ish), that's something that eldest requests and is just for them. No-one else will take it, so I don't see why the same respect isn't returned.

So, they’ve stolen something (I consider this stealing) and lied about it.

What are you going to do about it?