Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ukraine weapons vs UN and sanctions AIBU anonymous vote

37 replies

newdaynewdawn0 · 19/09/2022 09:24

This is an AIBU vote so that people can express how they feel about this by anonymously voting. I hope that this is allowed! Some people feel wary of posting or talking about it but may want to anonymously vote.

My AIBU:

We should be negotiating to send UN peacekeepers to Ukraine NOT weapons or soldiers which are doing nothing but escalate problems, and sanctions should stop as they are not working and might be disastrous for the UK and the UN going in would be more effective than sanctions = YANBU

Weapons and sanctions are good = YABU

OP posts:
DesMoulinsRouge · 21/09/2022 09:51

You are being disingenuous calling the Donbas a civil war and you know it.

newdaynewdawn0 · 21/09/2022 09:50

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

newdaynewdawn0 · 21/09/2022 09:47

jetadore · 19/09/2022 09:33

I think UN peace-keepers are used in internecine conflict, rather than wars/invasions between sovereign states? Also if we should have done anything it would have been not to try to expand NATO to Russia’s borders then provide no response or support when Russia started annexing territories over the past decade. Anyway looks like this invasion will fail sooner or later anyway.

There has been a violent and bloody civil war there (as in Ukrainians vs Ukrainians) for eight years. The situation in Donbas has been hell for the people there for eight years, steadily getting worse as the years go by, whichever side you blame it has been internecine for eight years.

In most civil wars over the last 30 or so years you have had Russia on one side and the US on the other, and in relation to all of them the best results in relation to ending a bloody conflict has been where the UN has gone in, though clearly that does require all parties including Ukraine's approval here. Different parties refer to the situation in different ways or blame different parties for the cause. But there are a number of independent sources including the UN and Amnesty reports and OSCE reports, and also a lot of footage including archived footage from the BBC. I assume from these replies that people are just not aware.

The NATO issue isn't going to be resolved by the UN going in, as you say, but the fighting between Ukrainians would stop in eastern Ukraine which would then allow discussions around NATO and geo politics.

OP posts:
dreamingbohemian · 19/09/2022 17:44

I'm sorry but this is a ridiculously stupid naive question

There is zero possibility of a genuine UN intervention in Ukraine. Russia will never agree to something that would disadvantage it on the battlefield. When they talk about negotiations and peacekeeping, it is just stalling for time so they can consolidate the territories they have occupied (what do you think they've been doing since 2014?)

This month, Ukraine has recaptured 6000 km2 of its territory. So it's no surprise Russia is pushing all these narratives to undermine Western support for Ukraine, because it's actually working.

Russia has conducted a brutal and horrific invasion of Ukraine, look at the evidence of mass graves and atrocities in the liberated territories. Ukraine has every right to defend itself and we have the right to help them. If Russia wants peace, they can withdraw any time.

DomesticShortHair · 19/09/2022 17:31

newdaynewdawn0 · 19/09/2022 17:23

Russia has asked for international help and UN input in relation to the situation in east Ukraine consistently over the last eight years, and has asked the UN to go in recently, in March or April or around about then.

And Russia would withdraw their occupying forces from Ukraine first (including Crimea) to their own borders? And then encourage and facilitate a substantial UN peacekeeping force, mainly made up from Western (i.e. NATO countries) armed forces, as they are only ones who have the credible capability to patrol and enforce the Ukraine/Russia border, and give the Ukraine the security guarantees that’d they’d need?

Well, that sounds brilliant. In that case. I’m with you. Let’s do that.

ChilliBandit · 19/09/2022 17:28

I think any attempt at UN peacekeeping without sanctions/weapons help would be a “Peace in our time” moment. Putin is not coming from a place of logic, he doesn’t think Ukraine should exist independently of Russia, you can’t negotiate with that as a starting point.

Hawkins001 · 19/09/2022 17:25

newdaynewdawn0 · 19/09/2022 09:24

This is an AIBU vote so that people can express how they feel about this by anonymously voting. I hope that this is allowed! Some people feel wary of posting or talking about it but may want to anonymously vote.

My AIBU:

We should be negotiating to send UN peacekeepers to Ukraine NOT weapons or soldiers which are doing nothing but escalate problems, and sanctions should stop as they are not working and might be disastrous for the UK and the UN going in would be more effective than sanctions = YANBU

Weapons and sanctions are good = YABU

I would need to read the files of the intelligence services, to gain a better analysis of what's happening their, before committing to a specific perspectives.

pointythings · 19/09/2022 17:25

newdaynewdawn0 · 19/09/2022 17:23

Russia has asked for international help and UN input in relation to the situation in east Ukraine consistently over the last eight years, and has asked the UN to go in recently, in March or April or around about then.

I think that Russia has no business asking for international help re Eastern Ukraine and the Crimea. If they were genuinely asking in good faith, they would not have taken the Crimea and Ukraine in the first place. Putin's Russia is a bad faith actor.

newdaynewdawn0 · 19/09/2022 17:23

DomesticShortHair · 19/09/2022 09:38

On a purely practical note, any move to send a UN peacekeeping force would be vetoed by Russia, as a permanent member of the UN Security Council. Though that isn’t by any means the only issue I have with your position.

Russia has asked for international help and UN input in relation to the situation in east Ukraine consistently over the last eight years, and has asked the UN to go in recently, in March or April or around about then.

OP posts:
brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 19/09/2022 09:44

You can’t negotiate with a bear, it needs to feel pain or it will keep coming back to eat from your bins.

DomesticShortHair · 19/09/2022 09:38

On a purely practical note, any move to send a UN peacekeeping force would be vetoed by Russia, as a permanent member of the UN Security Council. Though that isn’t by any means the only issue I have with your position.

jetadore · 19/09/2022 09:33

I think UN peace-keepers are used in internecine conflict, rather than wars/invasions between sovereign states? Also if we should have done anything it would have been not to try to expand NATO to Russia’s borders then provide no response or support when Russia started annexing territories over the past decade. Anyway looks like this invasion will fail sooner or later anyway.