Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ukraine weapons vs UN and sanctions AIBU anonymous vote

37 replies

newdaynewdawn0 · 19/09/2022 09:24

This is an AIBU vote so that people can express how they feel about this by anonymously voting. I hope that this is allowed! Some people feel wary of posting or talking about it but may want to anonymously vote.

My AIBU:

We should be negotiating to send UN peacekeepers to Ukraine NOT weapons or soldiers which are doing nothing but escalate problems, and sanctions should stop as they are not working and might be disastrous for the UK and the UN going in would be more effective than sanctions = YANBU

Weapons and sanctions are good = YABU

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pointythings · 29/09/2022 10:30

@newdaynewdawn0 nah, the referendums were not supported because it is impossible to have a free and fair referendum in a country where an occupying force which has killed thousands and trashed the country is running the referendum. I really hope that's simple enough for you.

You're pro Russia, we get it. You think Putin was right to invade Ukraine. You won't get a lot of support here.

newdaynewdawn0 · 29/09/2022 10:26

KrisAkabusi · 21/09/2022 19:09

The key thing here - if Ukraine is supporting the Ukrainian people, why not propose referendums in Crimea and Donbas and the rest of Ukraine before bombing and get involved to satisfy itself that the referendums are legitimate?

It was reported that 2 million Ukrainians have been forcibly removed from the occupied area, taken to Russia . How fair do you think a referendum would be when the legitimate voters are in a different country against their will?

It was reported, where? I have seen Red Cross and other independent reports as well as eye witness accounts etc etc that some or even the majority of people from Donbas were of Russian ethnicity and were trying to get into Russia or Crimea from Mariupol and other areas. I have also seen reports that some were taken to Russia against their will and put in housing where they were fed and warm and dry etc, but were allowed to leave, many then returned to Donbas or other areas of Ukraine. There are films online about this.

Things have moved on, but in terms of making sure everyone saw it as fair would have been part of the process, had the international community supported the concept of referendums. They didn't, Russia went ahead, the west has said the outcome is a sham, is what has happened since I was posting here last.

I think the answer why referendums were/are not supported by the west might be because of the geopolitical issues.

OP posts:
newdaynewdawn0 · 29/09/2022 10:15

DesMoulinsRouge · 21/09/2022 13:58

Russian hasn't mobilised yet. This is still at SO level. So I think what you are saying is likely to be wrong, but clearly if there is risk to people in Crimea and NATO soldiers and equipment continue to act then it is likely things will escalate.

I don't know how to quote so I've copied and pasted.

Are you on the Kremlin payroll? Yes or no.

I haven't been on MN because of other life commitments, work, etc. The answer is no, I am not on Kremlin's payroll. I think it was a bizarre question but I have answered clearly all the same.

OP posts:
DesMoulinsRouge · 22/09/2022 05:52

@DdraigGoch Yes you're probably right, or been sent to the front

DdraigGoch · 21/09/2022 23:57

I notice that the OP has been AWOL for a while. Probably being transported to Siberia in punishment for their incompetent attempt to portray Ukraine as the villain here.

DomesticShortHair · 21/09/2022 20:29

KrisAkabusi · 21/09/2022 19:09

The key thing here - if Ukraine is supporting the Ukrainian people, why not propose referendums in Crimea and Donbas and the rest of Ukraine before bombing and get involved to satisfy itself that the referendums are legitimate?

It was reported that 2 million Ukrainians have been forcibly removed from the occupied area, taken to Russia . How fair do you think a referendum would be when the legitimate voters are in a different country against their will?

After Argentina invaded the Falkland Islands in 1982, they planned on holding a referendum for the resident islanders over the issue of sovereignty.

Their definition of islanders would have included anyone who was resident on the islands at the time, i.e., all of the Argentinian armed forces and civilian staff, who vastly outnumbered the actual residents.

Never happened because it was overtaken by events. But, just as in Ukraine, it fools no one- except for those who are wanting to be fooled because it suits their own agenda.

KrisAkabusi · 21/09/2022 19:09

The key thing here - if Ukraine is supporting the Ukrainian people, why not propose referendums in Crimea and Donbas and the rest of Ukraine before bombing and get involved to satisfy itself that the referendums are legitimate?

It was reported that 2 million Ukrainians have been forcibly removed from the occupied area, taken to Russia . How fair do you think a referendum would be when the legitimate voters are in a different country against their will?

DesMoulinsRouge · 21/09/2022 13:58

Russian hasn't mobilised yet. This is still at SO level. So I think what you are saying is likely to be wrong, but clearly if there is risk to people in Crimea and NATO soldiers and equipment continue to act then it is likely things will escalate.

I don't know how to quote so I've copied and pasted.

Are you on the Kremlin payroll? Yes or no.

DdraigGoch · 21/09/2022 13:00

I have equivalent level qualifications and in addition expertise in high level negotiation
You're being very vague there. Having qualifications at an "equivalent level" could just mean that you have a PhD in metallurgy, art, or some other field completely unrelated to foreign policy or defence. As for "expertise in high level negotiation", for all we know that could just mean persuading a toddler to eat his broccoli rather than throw it from the tray of his high chair.

There was no special operation or invasion between 2014 and 2022, that is the point. As well as the fact that much of this was speculation. Russian soldiers disguised as civilians wouldn't be much help on the battle field, as they wouldn't have guns.
Oh give over, just as an unmarked police car is still a police car and a Trojan horse is full of Greeks, an unmarked Russian convoy of armoured personnel carriers with logistics support still contains armed combatants.

ChilliBandit · 21/09/2022 12:41

Putin announced mobilisation of reservists yesterday, but they have already thrown the best of their regular army plus conscripts at Ukraine and have struggled to annex the Donbas region. That negates your point that they could easily do it now or in 2014.

I am all for discussion but the language you are using gives you away. “Special Operation” is the term only the Russian government uses for what is happening. The referendums in Donbas were widely considered not to be free and fair even by the UN you think are the saviour of this situation. Putin has been very open in the past about his opinions on Ukraine as a sovereign nation. To pretend this is a civil war or to stop extremism (again only Russia is touting the extremist line) is disingenuous at best.

Nice to see the posters of Mumsnet aren’t being taken in by the propaganda.

Muddays · 21/09/2022 11:52

I have to agree with @dreamingbohemian.
Your UN Peacekeeping 'solution' isn't going to amount to a hill of beans in the face of Russian allies like China taking a tougher stance with Moscow after watching the disordered, increasingly failing invasion of the Ukraine and the subsequent collapse of its reputation as a 'security patron'. Even Kazakhstan has tried to remain neutral over Russian-controlled east Ukrainian territories. The balance of power has shifted and the UN is way out of its depth here.
To quote Temur Umarov, (Carnegie Endowment for International Peace), "many central Asian countries see that Russia needs them more than ever before, and they're now trying to squeeze as much as they can."

DesMoulinsRouge · 21/09/2022 11:02

Perhaps they should have lobbied for a referendum instead of invading back in the day?

newdaynewdawn0 · 21/09/2022 11:01

DesMoulinsRouge · 21/09/2022 10:44

There are Russian soldiers in Donbas disguised as civilians. It's not really a secret.

I would suggest that Putin is worried that the current Ukrainian offensive will eventually retake Crimea which was illegally invaded by Russia and expel Russian mercenaries from disputed regions. He is playing for time while he trains convicts and conscripts.

Of course all this could also lead to his own people removing him from power.

You can't negotiate in good faith with him.

There was no special operation or invasion between 2014 and 2022, that is the point. As well as the fact that much of this was speculation. Russian soldiers disguised as civilians wouldn't be much help on the battle field, as they wouldn't have guns.

Russian hasn't mobilised yet. This is still at SO level. So I think what you are saying is likely to be wrong, but clearly if there is risk to people in Crimea and NATO soldiers and equipment continue to act then it is likely things will escalate.

I think the idea that people will remove Putin from power and that this will solve the problem is complete wrong thinking on many, many levels. Russia is huge and there are people supporting more intensive conflict as well as those supporting less.

OP posts:
newdaynewdawn0 · 21/09/2022 10:53

dreamingbohemian · 21/09/2022 10:35

OP I'm a lecturer in conflict studies specialising in civil wars (including those in the former Soviet republics). Everything you are saying is wrong, I'm sorry but it is.

There's obviously no point trying to convince you, and I have to get back to work now, but I'm just pointing out for anyone else reading this thread that the OP's arguments are based on very fundamental misunderstandings of what's happened in Ukraine in the last 10 years, as well as modern civil wars generally.

See my last post which responds to what you have said. What I have said is not wrong, and I have equivalent level qualifications and in addition expertise in high level negotiation. I know exactly what I am talking about here in relation to Ukraine, the issue is that your arguments in the main have been political rather than objective and what you have said is not correct. However, your last post was the most useful one and I have responded in kind.

My question to you - is your solution to keep NATO backing Ukraine in hitting Donbas? And watch escalation and more death and inhumane situations?

The key thing here - if Ukraine is supporting the Ukrainian people, why not propose referendums in Crimea and Donbas and the rest of Ukraine before bombing and get involved to satisfy itself that the referendums are legitimate?

OP posts:
DesMoulinsRouge · 21/09/2022 10:44

There are Russian soldiers in Donbas disguised as civilians. It's not really a secret.

I would suggest that Putin is worried that the current Ukrainian offensive will eventually retake Crimea which was illegally invaded by Russia and expel Russian mercenaries from disputed regions. He is playing for time while he trains convicts and conscripts.

Of course all this could also lead to his own people removing him from power.

You can't negotiate in good faith with him.

newdaynewdawn0 · 21/09/2022 10:41

dreamingbohemian · 21/09/2022 10:22

Russia might accept the UN coming in to stand on the frontline in the Donbas. This would prevent Ukraine from attacking them and give Russia a permanent presence there. It would create a de facto border there, as has happened in other conflicts around the world where peacekeepers come in. This has the opposite effect of resolving the conflict, it becomes a frozen conflict instead.

Ukraine would absolutely accept UN peacekeepers but on the official Ukraine-Russia border, i.e. Russia needs to withdraw its forces, then you can put peacekeepers on the border while diplomacy does its work.

So what's wrong with that? Why do you object to Russia withdrawing from Ukraine? I mean if you really want peace, why not just push for Russia to withdraw?

Thanks for this, I note your points. The value of the UN in other areas has been the cessation of fire in those areas, an arms amnesty which means people are not suffering to anywhere near the same extent. I don't know what Russia would agree to or what Ukraine would agree to here, but for UN peacekeepers to go in there would need to be an arms amnesty.

You ask "so Russia leaves, what is wrong with that?" - basically you have a situation here where no proposals have been put forward by Ukraine or the west about how the bloodbath in Donbas would be ended. Russia is not going to withdraw while people are being tied to poles, for example. That is just one example, obviously.

The UN going in would mean that would stop happening. The problem is, this as a solution isn't even being mooted by the west at the moment.

It may be being mooted by the UN behind closed doors, I don't know.

There is footage and witness statement about hospitals etc being shelled even now in Donetsk by Ukraine. There has been denial by the US that the Ukraine government is responsible for the mistreatment of ethnic Russians - but no solutions put forward for the fact that they are being mistreated, de facto - and again the UN going in with all parties agreement would stop that. There has been denial that there has been a problem with extreme nationalism, but there clearly has been and is a problem.

OP posts:
dreamingbohemian · 21/09/2022 10:35

OP I'm a lecturer in conflict studies specialising in civil wars (including those in the former Soviet republics). Everything you are saying is wrong, I'm sorry but it is.

There's obviously no point trying to convince you, and I have to get back to work now, but I'm just pointing out for anyone else reading this thread that the OP's arguments are based on very fundamental misunderstandings of what's happened in Ukraine in the last 10 years, as well as modern civil wars generally.

newdaynewdawn0 · 21/09/2022 10:30

KrisAkabusi · 21/09/2022 10:17

How much is Russia paying you for this propaganda?

How much are you being paid for writing posts which try to shut down discussion?!

OP posts:
newdaynewdawn0 · 21/09/2022 10:28

dreamingbohemian · 21/09/2022 09:57

Almost everything in your last post is factually incorrect so yes, I stand by saying your argument is naive and/or ignorant.

Yes, there were local grievances in the Donbas, but war did not break out there until Russia invaded in 2014 and funded local militias. The Russian annexation of Crimea violated the most fundamental principles of international law and was clearly illegal.

Most civil wars of the past 30 years have not involved a US vs Russia aspect. You are thinking of the Cold War.

The UN has been terrible for conflict resolution as often as they've been beneficial.

You are entitled to your opinion but at least be honest that you are repeating Kremlin talking points and not speaking from any in-depth knowledge of Ukraine or indeed modern warfare.

As I said in the previous post, my concerns are about the future of the people in the UK as well as what is going on in Donbas.

You are incorrect about what started the conflict in 2014, the referendums in 2014 in Donbas (as distinct from Crimea) were about autonomy within Ukraine. If you think Russia went in in 2014 (even though the OSCE reports say it did not) then what do you think happened in Feb 2022? Russia annexed Crimea in 2014, do you not think it could just have easily annexed Donbas? Why the years and years of diplomatic attempts in relation to the Minsk accords? There is just a lack of joined up thinking here.

In relation to fighting between Ukrainians in Donbas, there have been independent reports about breaches of human rights. This thread was prompted by the lastest video emerging showing people being tied to poles, now in Kharkiv.

You have had Russia vs the US in every single civil war in the last 30 years, and every time it has only been when the UN has gone in that there has been amelioration of suffering for the people. Look it up. The UN is not great, I agree, but its involvement and an arms amensty would be better for the people than sending in more guns and soldiers.

OP posts:
BonjourBonheur · 21/09/2022 10:24

OP is either extremely ignorant or a Russian propagandist. It’s not a civil war.

Also I’m chuckling at the big set up for an anonymous poll then giving one of the options as “weapons and sanctions are good”.

dreamingbohemian · 21/09/2022 10:22

Russia might accept the UN coming in to stand on the frontline in the Donbas. This would prevent Ukraine from attacking them and give Russia a permanent presence there. It would create a de facto border there, as has happened in other conflicts around the world where peacekeepers come in. This has the opposite effect of resolving the conflict, it becomes a frozen conflict instead.

Ukraine would absolutely accept UN peacekeepers but on the official Ukraine-Russia border, i.e. Russia needs to withdraw its forces, then you can put peacekeepers on the border while diplomacy does its work.

So what's wrong with that? Why do you object to Russia withdrawing from Ukraine? I mean if you really want peace, why not just push for Russia to withdraw?

Wnikat · 21/09/2022 10:19

Hi Vlad.

newdaynewdawn0 · 21/09/2022 10:18

DesMoulinsRouge · 21/09/2022 09:51

You are being disingenuous calling the Donbas a civil war and you know it.

Why do think it isn't a civil war? Ukrainians have been killing and harming Ukrainians, how is this not a civil war? I assume what you are suggesting is that Russia caused it. Russia say the US caused it. This has been a recurring theme for many years.

I believe that Russia would support the UN going in because if Russia had wanted to annex Donbas it would have done so in 2014. Instead for eight years it has pursued the Minsk accords which allowed for autonomy within Ukraine - the policy was not imperialistic. The question of NATO vs Russia is quite a different.

When you say I am being disingenuous you are wrong and you are being simplistic. This thread was about stopping the bloody violent conflict which has been going on for eight years and threatens to escalate, I am not being at all disingenuous. (Nor naive or stupid, wrt the previous poster).

Donbas has suffered horrifically, it will not stop unless all parties including Ukraine support the UN going in, whatever side you are on.

What happens there affects us in the UK not just because of the potential escalation, the financial consequences, but also because there is a rise of out of control extreme nationalism/domestic terrorism in western Europe. This is not a simple "Russia is a bear" situation.

OP posts:
KrisAkabusi · 21/09/2022 10:17

How much is Russia paying you for this propaganda?

dreamingbohemian · 21/09/2022 09:57

Almost everything in your last post is factually incorrect so yes, I stand by saying your argument is naive and/or ignorant.

Yes, there were local grievances in the Donbas, but war did not break out there until Russia invaded in 2014 and funded local militias. The Russian annexation of Crimea violated the most fundamental principles of international law and was clearly illegal.

Most civil wars of the past 30 years have not involved a US vs Russia aspect. You are thinking of the Cold War.

The UN has been terrible for conflict resolution as often as they've been beneficial.

You are entitled to your opinion but at least be honest that you are repeating Kremlin talking points and not speaking from any in-depth knowledge of Ukraine or indeed modern warfare.

Swipe left for the next trending thread