Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find some language offensive about the funeral?

319 replies

Mushroo · 18/09/2022 23:50

Out at the pub tonight and talk turns to the queens funeral.

Im not an ardent royalist or anything but I will be watching as a historical event and in recognition of the queens service.

My friend is very left wing and said ‘I won’t be watching, fuck that,, fuck the monarchy, I won’t be watching to save the electric’. (This is someone who does not have to count the pennies).

AIBU to say this was a bit offensive, and a simple ‘I won’t be watching, it’s not for me’ would have been fine and respectful to people who do want to watch,

It almost seems as though being offensive is ‘cool’.

OP posts:
CaptaNoctem · 19/09/2022 23:08

Tryingtokeepgoing · 19/09/2022 19:43

@CaptaNoctem I realise that, but I said “to put it [the cost] in context…” when I made the comparison. People obsess about what things cost when it’s visible, and draw meaningless comparisons. So i thought I’d do the same. The cost is tiny in the great scheme of things; if the NHS were to find 1 minutes worth of efficiencies a month, it’d free up the best part of quarter of a billion pounds a year to help the poor, the starving, the homeless. But no one seems bothered about that…and that amount of money would make a real difference, unlike £10 million…

So? This thread is not about the inefficiencies and cost of the NHS.

£10m or whatever the cost turns out to be (more than that I expect) would make a difference to the poorest cold and hungry families this winter.

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 19:49

vera99 · 19/09/2022 17:34

To the knockers, a 1-star review doesn't hold back ...

What I read, literally from Chapter One, was pure, unreserved bile, venom and anger, often written in a snide-personal manner. A personal bug-bear of mine is his description of staff - decent hard-working people doing a decent job for the head of state being denigrated and described as 'flunkies.' Look up the definition "a person who performs relatively menial tasks for someone else, especially obsequiously." The sub-title 'What the Royal Family Don't want you to Know...' says it all really? Norman believes in conspiracy theories - it's all a big cover-up and our friend Norman intends to uncover it and expose the Royal family as the Cuckoo in the nest of democracy - Good 'old Norman!

He repeats every slur, derogatory report, unflattering newspaper article and every piece of tittle-tattle that has ever existed and presents the whole as factual. Despite his claims to balance and objectivity neutrality - there is none, or at least none that I could find. There is no attempt to present a counter-argument at all. As an ex-Liberal Democrat MP, he exemplifies, in my opinion, the elite 'I know best' position of a party that struggles with liberal values (being fair and treating all human beings, including the Royal family, with respect and dignity) and accepting Democracy (polling suggests 80% support for the monarch) don't trouble this Lib Dem. It is no surprise that Mr Baker is an ex-MP.

So a poor book that has, of course, a legitimate aim, but spectacularly fails to deliver on its promises. I can usually appreciate some value in all books, even those whose premises I don't agree with, but not this time, I gave up serious reading halfway through. If you want to write a book supporting Republican principles please have the confidence to say so on the cover and please do not lie - and pretend you want to be balanced or neutral on a subject to get people to buy your book.

Sorry can't agree, it's a book I'd recommend to everyone. Hard hitting, factual, no holds barred. Of course a strong royalist will find it hard to swallow. "Flunkies" is how they see us, and I don't call pandering to the needs of a rich pampered prince a "decent job". I mean how worthwhile it must feel to scurry round after someone picking up after them and squeezing their toothpaste out.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 19/09/2022 19:43

@CaptaNoctem I realise that, but I said “to put it [the cost] in context…” when I made the comparison. People obsess about what things cost when it’s visible, and draw meaningless comparisons. So i thought I’d do the same. The cost is tiny in the great scheme of things; if the NHS were to find 1 minutes worth of efficiencies a month, it’d free up the best part of quarter of a billion pounds a year to help the poor, the starving, the homeless. But no one seems bothered about that…and that amount of money would make a real difference, unlike £10 million…

CaptaNoctem · 19/09/2022 17:57

@Tryingtokeepgoing

I didn't mention the NHS?

Wrinklydinkly · 19/09/2022 17:48

People are a little over sensitive about the royals (my opinion) and too easily offended on behalf of others ,your friend was just expressing strong feelings. I didn't watch the funeral, and have been actively avoiding any mention of it. It's difficult though because it's rammed down your throat all the time. It almost feels like we're being compelled to mourn for someone we didn't know, Things need to get back to normal as soon as possible,there are other things happening in the world.

vera99 · 19/09/2022 17:34

To the knockers, a 1-star review doesn't hold back ...

What I read, literally from Chapter One, was pure, unreserved bile, venom and anger, often written in a snide-personal manner. A personal bug-bear of mine is his description of staff - decent hard-working people doing a decent job for the head of state being denigrated and described as 'flunkies.' Look up the definition "a person who performs relatively menial tasks for someone else, especially obsequiously." The sub-title 'What the Royal Family Don't want you to Know...' says it all really? Norman believes in conspiracy theories - it's all a big cover-up and our friend Norman intends to uncover it and expose the Royal family as the Cuckoo in the nest of democracy - Good 'old Norman!

He repeats every slur, derogatory report, unflattering newspaper article and every piece of tittle-tattle that has ever existed and presents the whole as factual. Despite his claims to balance and objectivity neutrality - there is none, or at least none that I could find. There is no attempt to present a counter-argument at all. As an ex-Liberal Democrat MP, he exemplifies, in my opinion, the elite 'I know best' position of a party that struggles with liberal values (being fair and treating all human beings, including the Royal family, with respect and dignity) and accepting Democracy (polling suggests 80% support for the monarch) don't trouble this Lib Dem. It is no surprise that Mr Baker is an ex-MP.

So a poor book that has, of course, a legitimate aim, but spectacularly fails to deliver on its promises. I can usually appreciate some value in all books, even those whose premises I don't agree with, but not this time, I gave up serious reading halfway through. If you want to write a book supporting Republican principles please have the confidence to say so on the cover and please do not lie - and pretend you want to be balanced or neutral on a subject to get people to buy your book.

Blossomtoes · 19/09/2022 17:21

If you think that’s well written you have extremely low standards. It just reinforces what you already thought.

vera99 · 19/09/2022 17:18

Or read a well-researched and written book by an ex-MP, Minister of State and member of the Privy Council who sheds light on the true nature of wealth and power of the British Royal Family. Got to be worth a read if you are of a curious mind and republican bent. Sounds like kryptonite to royalists, and anyway I have had enough fawning, breathless praise to last for the rest of my lifetime, thank you very much.

deviatedseptum · 19/09/2022 17:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

vera99 · 19/09/2022 16:48

You can read the introduction for free on the link below quite an eye-opener!!

www.amazon.co.uk/What-Do-You-Royal-Family/dp/1785904914

We have our Willy Hamilton for the modern era. He was a lone voice for studious anti-monarchical research when I was growing up.

I guess Elizabeth Windsor now gets to know whether her unshakeable belief in Jesus and God were justified and if so will the rich man/eye of needle terms and condition cut in?

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Willie_Hamilton

deviatedseptum · 19/09/2022 16:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

vera99 · 19/09/2022 16:17

Just ordered it off Amazon obviously over the target!

www.amazon.co.uk/What-Do-You-Royal-Family/dp/1785904914

A forensic examination of what the Royal Family means to Britain.--
Sussex Express

With our democracy in turmoil, it's right to be asking questions about constitutional reform, and that includes the role of the royal family. Norman Baker tackles the subject with his trademark energy and in forensic detail looking at the facts beyond the headlines. An important book for anyone serious about questioning how our country is run.
--Caroline Lucas MP

They are the pinnacle of privilege, leading enviably gilded lives, but how much do we really know of the royal family's cosy, taxpayer-funded existence? Norman Baker goes behind palace walls to shine a much-needed light on this most secretive of institutions and expose the greed, hypocrisy and yes disregard for public money which keeps it afloat. Filled with fascinating detail and insight, ... And What Do You Do? is an essential primer for understanding the myth of modern royalty. --Richard Kay, royal writer for the Daily Mail

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 15:35

DdraigGoch · 19/09/2022 09:28

Lots of people get born into wealth. Not me, admittedly, but singling out one person for vitriol is a bit daft.

Yes lots of people are born into wealth, but not wealth that comes off the taxpayer.

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 15:33

Blossomtoes · 19/09/2022 14:17

Ah yes, the famous Norman Baker book, ie biased republican rant. Every anti monarchist relies on it as if it was the Bible, you’re just thinking in a different box.

A book that blows the lid off what really goes on described as a biased rant? I wonder why that would be. Oh yes because the truth hurts and royalists don't want to hear it. It doesn't matter if you call it biased or not, it's a factual book. If not he'd no doubt have been sued by now. The book must really rankle with royalists. That pesky truth shattering all those illusions eh. How dare he.

Branleuse · 19/09/2022 15:33

Hearthnhome · 19/09/2022 12:20

Surely she would have needed to that even if the Queen hasn’t died or had a direct cremation?

Are you serious?
Way to miss the point

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 15:22

Hearthnhome · 19/09/2022 14:46

My exh grandmother was in the ATS. She loves the Queen, exactly for what she did during the war and she did infact work as hard as others and was just as skilled

Whilst having to go back and forth for other duties, obviously.

So where does that leave us?

As someone just pointed out the queen only started her training in march 45. The war passed her by. So I don't know who your ex's grandmother was talking about but it certainly wasn't the queen. My mum loved her time in the ATS, it was her whole world. It's an insult to her to imply the queen did as much as her. She didn't. So that's where that leaves us.

AndTwoFilmsByFrancoisTruffaut · 19/09/2022 15:21

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 19/09/2022 11:43

Guarantee it is the same people who spaffed the word "selfish" all over the place during covid. They have switched from covid policing, to waving ukranian flags, to weeping in the streets over the death of a rich old stranger.

👏🏼 👏🏼 👏🏼 👏🏼

Blossomtoes · 19/09/2022 15:19

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 15:10

*My mum was in the same service, you couldn't get a better source than that. Like someone just said, the idea that she was there in a meaningful capacity is ludicrous. It's understandable that she wasn't going to be treated like the rest of them, but I don't see why she should be given credit for something she hadn't done.

The royal family have always been good at accepting credit for something they haven't done to earn it. You only have to look at their ridiculous array of medals they adorn themselves with.*

Oh give over. That’s like me saying I know someone I’ve never met is a skiver because we both work in the NHS. You’re being ridiculous.

Branleuse · 19/09/2022 15:16

BorgQueen · 19/09/2022 09:47

Like it or not, this is a huge boost for Britain, we are centre stage and there is no other country, not one, that does these events as well as us. The whole world is watching this, in some part to see how it is (and should be) done.
If you aren’t proud, there is something wrong with you.

The whole world is watching us to see how what should be done? Funerals?

Why the fuck do you think theres 'something wrong' with people who dont feel proud of this complete pantomime

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 15:10

Blossomtoes · 19/09/2022 14:48

My source is interviews with women who served alongside the Queen, not just happened to be in the same service - which had 190,000 members.

*My mum was in the same service, you couldn't get a better source than that. Like someone just said, the idea that she was there in a meaningful capacity is ludicrous. It's understandable that she wasn't going to be treated like the rest of them, but I don't see why she should be given credit for something she hadn't done.

The royal family have always been good at accepting credit for something they haven't done to earn it. You only have to look at their ridiculous array of medals they adorn themselves with.*

LongLivedQueen · 19/09/2022 14:52

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 14:42

My mum was in the ATS, was yours? therefore I probably knew better. Where's your source? My mum didn't lie.

Why would your mum know anything about it?
The facts are well known..she began mechanic training in March 45, finished in April 45, and the war ended 3 weeks later in early May 45. She slept at home in Windsor Castle instead of on the camp with everyone else.

The idea that she actually served in a meaningful capacity is ludicrous!

Blossomtoes · 19/09/2022 14:48

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 14:42

My mum was in the ATS, was yours? therefore I probably knew better. Where's your source? My mum didn't lie.

My source is interviews with women who served alongside the Queen, not just happened to be in the same service - which had 190,000 members.

Hearthnhome · 19/09/2022 14:47

Loved not loves. She died in 2010

pleasehelpwi3 · 19/09/2022 14:47

ReneBumsWombats · 19/09/2022 14:03

Because all the evidence is that she did, including contemporary accounts from the time, and the armed forces wouldn't have it any other way. (And will you people stop assuming I'm a royalist just for pointing out a few facts? There was a twit a few days ago who was bitching about me being a royalist because she asked whether most Brits were in favour of the monarchy and I linked YouGov polls that gave her the answer. I'm not a royalist just because I'm not a bloody liar.)

I don't know why this is so impossible for you to believe. The royals have a long history of national service. The Queen, then princess, signed up at 18, trained as a mechanic and drove ambulances as part of the war effort. You don't have to be a royalist over it but it's plain paranoid rubbish to claim it didn't happen or if it did, it didn't count.

And it's one reason why I thought she was rather badass. Which is why I mentioned it to the poster who thought I couldn't possibly have any legitimate reason.

Driving an ambulance around Windsor Great Park or wherever it was with some jolly hockey sticks pals doesn't count as 'service.' In fact I've always found it insulting to those who actually did serve in the field of war eg Dunkirk, Arnhem, Stalingrad when they hyperbolise and eulogise the queen's war record.
Service for me isn't being paid billions of taxpayers' cash to turn up and open a museum, or go to a charity gala, but it's the careworkers, refuse workers, police, NHS, teachers etc who actually make this country a better and safer place.
Strange to think you call people 'bloody liars' as they don't share your political opinion.

Hearthnhome · 19/09/2022 14:46

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 14:42

My mum was in the ATS, was yours? therefore I probably knew better. Where's your source? My mum didn't lie.

My exh grandmother was in the ATS. She loves the Queen, exactly for what she did during the war and she did infact work as hard as others and was just as skilled

Whilst having to go back and forth for other duties, obviously.

So where does that leave us?