Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find some language offensive about the funeral?

319 replies

Mushroo · 18/09/2022 23:50

Out at the pub tonight and talk turns to the queens funeral.

Im not an ardent royalist or anything but I will be watching as a historical event and in recognition of the queens service.

My friend is very left wing and said ‘I won’t be watching, fuck that,, fuck the monarchy, I won’t be watching to save the electric’. (This is someone who does not have to count the pennies).

AIBU to say this was a bit offensive, and a simple ‘I won’t be watching, it’s not for me’ would have been fine and respectful to people who do want to watch,

It almost seems as though being offensive is ‘cool’.

OP posts:
lemmein · 19/09/2022 06:58

I share your friends sentiment and I've really tried to work out this week why it pisses me off so much, because it does really piss me off.

Im normally a live and let live sort; I don't care what people do with their time as long as everyone involved is happy with it, but this...this 10 days of mourning...it's just so frustrating, and I think this is why:

We've been through an horrific few years, some more than others, but nonetheless very few of us would've escaped the impact of covid on some level. On top of that we've had the anxiety of Brexit, the crippling fuel costs, food prices rocketing, nhs crumbling...basically, it's hard to not feel shit about the current situation. We've had the government trolling us for the last few (12 Hmm) years, telling us to comply with their rules, even if that means not seeing dying loved ones, or your business going under,etc yet their behaviour has been fucking outrageous, and still there's been no consequences. It hard to not feel powerless in this country and the 'elite' are just taking the piss out of 'us', in plain sight and we do nothing.

Now, the queen has died we are supposed to mourn her passing and celebrate her life, but for many of us the monarchy is no more than yet another symbol of inequality, oppression and extreme privilege and it feels actually obscene to celebrate it when some are going through the worst period of a generation.

Seeing those people line up for hours just makes me frustrated (sad even) because (to me) it simply symbolises acceptance of all the bullshit it represents; a subservient, docile nation waiting in line for more of the same.

In short, it makes me frustrated that there is no public appetite for change and we'll continue to have little ones going hungry whilst prime-ministers and monarchs pick out their new gold wallpaper. It's just shit.

(Though, I've had no sleep so I could just be cranky 🤷🏻‍♀️)

ThinWomansBrain · 19/09/2022 06:58

Not remotely interested in watching it, disgusted by the amount of £££ wasted on it - but I don't choose to have such foul mouthed friends.

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 06:56

Dishh · 19/09/2022 06:44

You recognise that many North Koreans must show they idolise the President by their actions, expressions and deeds, and if they slip up in any way they and their entire family will be sent to re-education camps - or killed?

Forced adulation is not comparable to an activity that is completely voluntary. There are plenty of threads and thousands of posts on MN disagreeing with the monarchy and joining the queue; this could not even occur North Korea. That you have the freedom to agree or disagree with the monarchy and/or government of the day and even express it is something you shouldn't take lightly.

Yes I'm not saying the two countries are in any way comparable but people over there do feel genuine love (or what they think is love,) for their leader. Their grief when he dies won't be forced. They hold him in high esteem, even if they're frightened of him. They've known nothing else, not looking too deeply into why they love him, that's where the comparison is.

Tuilpmouse · 19/09/2022 06:52

Leftie republicans are a bitter and sour-faced bunch of moaners, who seem to want to suck the soul out of this nation.

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/09/2022 06:51

pinkbear95 · 19/09/2022 06:49

Absolutely this! It’s so shameful yet so many people seem happy to just go along with what’s happening.

They should have banished the monarchy as soon as the Queen died. Way too much money get’s spent on them when the rest of the country is suffering

King Charles gives his entire income and received about 30% back as sovereign grant.

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/09/2022 06:49

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 05:15

I never saw the queen as this "little sweet old grandma" type figure at all. But that's how she wanted to portray herself. Far from sweet I'd say.

Since when did HMQ want to be seen as a little sweet old grandma? I don’t agree with that at all.

pinkbear95 · 19/09/2022 06:49

StoneofDestiny · 19/09/2022 00:02

I'm more offended by ££Billions of taxpayers money being spent on promoting the royals as some sort of indispensable family.
I'm also sick of hearing about her 70 Years of Service. She was the highest paid person in the country for her 'service' - handsomely rewarded by getting jobs for life for her idle family, palaces, servants to cater for every wish and whim, and only recently started paying taxes because she was forced to! Oh and this funeral, planned by her and Charles, has not cost her 'loving family' one penny piece.
That's galling - we have an NHS on its knees, public service and transport workers demanding a living wage that keep up with inflation and that gets refused - but ££Billions on a funeral is easily found. Scandalous

Absolutely this! It’s so shameful yet so many people seem happy to just go along with what’s happening.

They should have banished the monarchy as soon as the Queen died. Way too much money get’s spent on them when the rest of the country is suffering

Numbat2022 · 19/09/2022 06:46

I would suggest she was probably trying to be offensive. And that's ok. I wouldn't be offended because I agree, to a certain extent. She has every right to believe and say what she wants, she's not hurting anyone or inciting violence.

The idea that the Queen was a sweet, innocent old granny is utterly baffling. Here is a woman who was incredibly well travelled and famously politically engaged, who saw so very much history from the most privileged of positions, and who knows all the state secrets she wanted to know - innocent she was not.

pinkbear95 · 19/09/2022 06:46

asblindasabat · 18/09/2022 23:54

You’re not alone OP. I was just talking to DH earlier about how disgusting some people’s remarks are.

she was an elderly woman who gave 70 years of her life to us. I admired her and my heart breaks that she is gone. I can’t even believe it when I think about it.

People should keep their hatred thoughts to themselves

Who is us? How embarrassing

Dishh · 19/09/2022 06:44

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 06:12

I just think a lot of it is brainwashing. I watched a documentary on N Korea. The people there hero worshiped the president. You can guarantee there'll be mass hysteria when he dies. Its bizarre.

You recognise that many North Koreans must show they idolise the President by their actions, expressions and deeds, and if they slip up in any way they and their entire family will be sent to re-education camps - or killed?

Forced adulation is not comparable to an activity that is completely voluntary. There are plenty of threads and thousands of posts on MN disagreeing with the monarchy and joining the queue; this could not even occur North Korea. That you have the freedom to agree or disagree with the monarchy and/or government of the day and even express it is something you shouldn't take lightly.

DarkForces · 19/09/2022 06:38

I think if we all stopped thinking there was a right to never be uncomfortable or offended we'd all get along a lot better and be a bit happier

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 06:31

Blossomtoes · 19/09/2022 06:15

Of course, we’re exactly like North Korea, ffs. Brainwashing because people have different opinions, oh superior one whose brain somehow escaped the national laundry?

There's nothing superior about just thinking outside of the box. Also I've read the book by Norman Baker. I think a lot of royalists would think differently if they read it.

mellongoose · 19/09/2022 06:31

It's about respect really. There's time for the monarchy/no monarchy discussion in the future. But someone has just died. Regardless of whether you like or agree with her position in life, have the decency to wait until she's buried. Others are grieving.

Blossomtoes · 19/09/2022 06:15

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 06:12

I just think a lot of it is brainwashing. I watched a documentary on N Korea. The people there hero worshiped the president. You can guarantee there'll be mass hysteria when he dies. Its bizarre.

Of course, we’re exactly like North Korea, ffs. Brainwashing because people have different opinions, oh superior one whose brain somehow escaped the national laundry?

TarasHarp55 · 19/09/2022 06:12

I just think a lot of it is brainwashing. I watched a documentary on N Korea. The people there hero worshiped the president. You can guarantee there'll be mass hysteria when he dies. Its bizarre.

Hearthnhome · 19/09/2022 06:08

ThePoetsWife · 19/09/2022 05:58

Or dumped their disabled cousins in an institute and said they were dead .

Do you mean cousins went into an institute in 1930 and were reported as dead by 1940? What did you expect the Queen to do when she was a child? Or to even know what was happening?

Is there proof the Queen even knew until much later? At which point moving them may have cause more harm than good.

Many of their own family didn’t know they were alive. You do realise this was common at the time? It wasn’t just the Royal Family that did. Sadly, it wasn’t really considered wrong to do these things.

There’s lots to criticise. So not sure why we need to make things up.

cestmoi222 · 19/09/2022 06:05

...

To find some language offensive about the funeral?
FancyFelix · 19/09/2022 06:00

StoneofDestiny · 19/09/2022 00:02

I'm more offended by ££Billions of taxpayers money being spent on promoting the royals as some sort of indispensable family.
I'm also sick of hearing about her 70 Years of Service. She was the highest paid person in the country for her 'service' - handsomely rewarded by getting jobs for life for her idle family, palaces, servants to cater for every wish and whim, and only recently started paying taxes because she was forced to! Oh and this funeral, planned by her and Charles, has not cost her 'loving family' one penny piece.
That's galling - we have an NHS on its knees, public service and transport workers demanding a living wage that keep up with inflation and that gets refused - but ££Billions on a funeral is easily found. Scandalous

This about sums it up for me. The whole fucking shitshow offends me.

Blossomtoes · 19/09/2022 06:00

Nat6999 · 19/09/2022 03:02

StoneofDesting same here, the 6 billion could be spent on better things & then when you think that we will be expected to pay out again next year for a coronation, it is disgusting.

Will “we”? I thought Truss was planning to reduce taxation, not increase it. Neither today’s funeral nor next year’s coronation will mean a penny less in your bank account or mine.

Hearthnhome · 19/09/2022 05:59

I dont find it offensive. I find it funny. Imagine a grown man being so worked up over something he doesn’t care about and won’t watch.

How much electric does a TV use a day?

I do think there’s a sense of ‘the more against the funeral I am, the better it makes me as a person.’

I genuinely don’t get why people on social media are so annoyed that people do care or that people are queuing or do see her as family. I lost my mum a few months ago. The Queen dying doesn’t make a mark on that. I haven’t watch much. I will watch the funeral. Definitely didn’t queue and don’t see the Queen as a big part of my life. But I don’t get the vitriol (especially on here) towards people who do.

They exceptionally cool have started parroting ‘forelock tugging, bootlickers’ as though they came up with themselves. There’s threads about how people have lost their minds because they took their kids, or think of the Queen like family. Again, not my point of view but not a sign someone has lost their mind. Thread upon thread that’s deleted where the super enlightened Op is telling people the Queen isn’t in there and people are paying their respects to an empty box, based on ‘I saw it twitter’ in an attempt push home ‘people who care are just stupid and wasting their time’

Theres the idiots who genuinely believe the funeral is costing the tax payer £6 billion so they can appear compassionate and wail ‘how many hungry children could be fed. Why don’t you care about that? I care, I care most’

There infinitely more people asking ‘am I allowed to do xyz’ on social media, than people actually saying your shouldn’t be doing xyz. There’s very few people saying anyone has to watch and to do anything else is disrespectful. But loads assuming people think that.

Anyone who does think going for run/not watching/ having a drink etc today is disrespectful are probably idiots over other things too and this is just the most recent thing they can use to judge people over. They will have been the ones reporting their neighbours for going for a walk, for over an hour, during lockdown.

Not sure why people feel the need to judge others for doing things that have nothing to do with anyone else.

But my experience is more the ‘anti funeral’ side that can’t let people get on with it.

Jewel1968 · 19/09/2022 05:59

I really struggle to understand the depth of feeling people have when someone they don't know dies e.g royals or celebrities. The people queuing 20 plus hours (one did it twice and one brought her dead mother's ashes with her) to walk past the coffin of someone they don't know. I just don't understand.

I agree with poster who said they feel a bit sorry for the royals - total lack of privacy and I feel don't have much control. I know they are rich but it seems a very gilded cage.

ThePoetsWife · 19/09/2022 05:58

Or dumped their disabled cousins in an institute and said they were dead .

ThePoetsWife · 19/09/2022 05:57

Your heart is breaking for someone who protected her disgusting son and paid the 9 plus millions to someone he has never met 🙄

Manekinek0 · 19/09/2022 05:50

70 years service... blah, blah... You all know there are ex service men who gave up the best years of their lives and are now suffering terribly with mental health problems and are homeless, right?

I wouldn't be rude but I would abolish the monarchy tomorrow given the choice. The funeral and coverage has been excessive and more worrying is the behaviour towards those who have protested.

Cheguevarahamster · 19/09/2022 05:43

You are offended by someone who has a different opinion and swore a bit? Goodness. No one feels the same about the Queen s death. Some may feel heart broken, other have mixed feelings sad she is gone but annoyed by the constant coverage , some couldnt give a shiny shit, some may have hated her and all she stood for. All are valid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread