Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think skincare is a con

190 replies

Hannahbsnana · 18/09/2022 21:55

i occasionally have a cup of tea and a natter with a woman who lives a few doors down from me. She’s 79 but quite young minded and totally on the ball. She also has pretty good skin.

We were moaning about the price of stuff in the shops a while back and I was telling her how much I spend on cleansers, toners. serums,, moisturisers etc. She said she’d never used anything of the sort - only suncream when she’d gone abroad. She washes her face with ‘soap and water’.

it got me thinking…..I’m getting on for 50 and have used skin products all my adult life and I’m pretty sure I look at least my age.

So I made a decision, I used up the last of my products and then didn’t replace any of them except my cleanser.

For the first week to ten days my face felt dry, especially after washing. But I persevered. It’s now been about 7 weeks. My skin no longer feels dry. I honestly believe it has balanced itself out and is producing iits own oils as required.

my skin is not suddenly amazing or anything.it’s no better than it was before when I was spending a fortune on products. But….it’s definitely no worse either!!

iI’ll carry on using suncream when needed, but other than that, I’m done. I’m going to save myself about £60 a month.

AIBU to think us women are being conned? Clever marketing and misogyny has made us terrified of not slathering chemicals on our mugs every day!

OP posts:
Calphurnia88 · 19/09/2022 08:09

From experience, less is more.

Wear SPF everyday
Soap too drying for me so I use a Cerave cleanser. I double cleanse at night to ensure any residual makeup or suncream is removed before bed
I used to use retinol nightly but paused when pregnant and will reintroduce once baby is a bit older and not near my face so often (it's strong stuff but works)

GeekyThings · 19/09/2022 08:05

Yes it's a con. The products are produced in order to make you feel that you need them, it's THEM drying your skin out, which is why you need to keep on using them once you start!

I read a fascinating book on life in Tudor Britain, the person who wrote it actually lived like them for months as an experiment, including using their recommended cleaning routines. They barely washed themselves; they used rags to wipe themselves down daily, and changed clothes reasonably frequently, but no products, little to no soap and water, no washing of hair - and after an initial time of discomfort, it was all fine. The writer said her skin ended up with a nice complexion overall, and her hair smelled and felt fine.

Her friend did the opposite - he washed himself every day for a month or two and used his usual modern products, but didn't change his clothes or run himself down, just as a comparison. The result was he stank, you could smell him from quite far away.

Chocolatefreak · 19/09/2022 08:03

Definitely agree that decent sleep, exercise and diet are the main things that show skin improvement. I do have sensitive skin though, so I use gentle, unperfumed soap cleanser and moisturiser. La Roche Posey, not the cheapest but not super expensive and lasts a long time, e.g. the cleanser I buy lasts three months. Altogether I guess I spend around 20 quid a month. Plus sun cream in summer.

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 19/09/2022 08:01

Firefin · 19/09/2022 07:56

Please don't use sunscreen in late autumn, winter (unless there is a huge blanket of snow and it's sunny), or early spring if you live in Britain.

There is a reason why rickets is on the rise again in Britain, and it's all to do with lack of exposure to sunlight - excessive clothing in some religious groups, lack of outside activities, especially for children, and the over-use of sunscreen are all contributing factors.

I'm not sure that's supported by evidence

www.skincancer.org/blog/sun-protection-and-vitamin-d/

www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/6-things-you-should-know-about-vitamin-d

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 19/09/2022 07:58

I think skin will always look best when it's cleaned, hydrated skin looks glowing, and long term skin protection is highly advised.

They do new research all the time. Tretinoin is well documented to be anti aging and effective for acne. So I have this in my routine. It's also well known that sun damage has a negative impact on the appearance of skin, so it makes sense to protect this. My mum is 60 and her generation sunbathed extensively, I see lots of her friends with pigmentation and sun spots which are very hard to fade.

I get a lot of pleasure from looking after my skin and massaging it, but my routine is usually 3 steps which I don't think is excessive.

Firefin · 19/09/2022 07:56

Please don't use sunscreen in late autumn, winter (unless there is a huge blanket of snow and it's sunny), or early spring if you live in Britain.

There is a reason why rickets is on the rise again in Britain, and it's all to do with lack of exposure to sunlight - excessive clothing in some religious groups, lack of outside activities, especially for children, and the over-use of sunscreen are all contributing factors.

Natsku · 19/09/2022 07:56

I just wash my face with water and that's it. Sometimes I need to put a bit of moisturiser on my chin when its cold windy weather as it gets dry then/jacket rubs on it but that's it. Never use make up so don't need to use anything special to clean it off. I was lucky enough to never suffer from acne as a teenager so never felt the need to get into a skincare routine. My mum used some Nivea cream and I absolutely hated the smell, made me feel sick, so I was never going to put that on my face!

ladydoris · 19/09/2022 07:54

sfp 50 is the way to go. My grandma has better skin then me... I have learnt the lesson to late.

apintortwo · 19/09/2022 07:52

interested in people who say SPF every day though - I do this in the summer but feel in the winter I need the Vit D exposure and the sun isn’t strong enough to damage my skin (in Scotland). Should I be using it year round?

Maybe in Scotland it's not necessary (but I'm not sure you will get a lot of vit D during the winter there anyway).

I use it year round as it's more practical to use the same moisturiser all the time than having one for summer and a different one for winter (also they don't go off while not in use, etc)

Firefin · 19/09/2022 07:51

Skin is meant to be an impenetrable barrier, otherwise we'd be in all sorts of trouble.

The only way to really change how your skin looks long-term is from within - plenty of selenium, zinc, iron and a good amount of vitamins B (in all its subvariants), C and D are what is needed to have healthy skin.

Sunscreen to slow down ageing, as well as smokefree and alcohol-free, both of which dry the skin out and age it prematurely.

Genetics also play a role, of course, as does hormonal balance.

So yes, OP, you have been wasting your money. I wash my face with water and use blue Nivea straight afterwards as my skin is naturally quite dry, but other than that I leave it alone and it's lovely.

Nellynoo182 · 19/09/2022 07:48

Oops I mean sun cream x

Mybeautifulfriend22 · 19/09/2022 07:48

I’ve only ever used cheap skincare like simple or Nivea since my teens. Sometimes face masks. I’m now on the aldi versions which I love. I do now use serums like vit c/hylaronic and retinol but not every day. I alternate them and they aren’t expensive brands just from Superdrug. Takes ten mins at night or in the morning.

I follow a dermatologist and she pushes that moisturisers that don’t need to be expensive, cleansing but exfoliating with acid rather than exfoliating with harsh face wash for example. She’s also big on spf daily and adding moisture with hylaronic.

My skin is minimally wrinkled( eyes are going mainly) and I do think it looks better with the added things and it certainly doesn’t cost me a fortune or time. I won’t be going down the fillers or Botox route. I do get comments about my age as I don’t look 43 but my genetics is that even as smokers my family have aged ok until their 60s/70s and I have a round face.

I do think diet, water consumption, not smoking etc have a big part to play!

Stichintimesavesstapling · 19/09/2022 07:47

Thatswhyimacat · 18/09/2022 21:58

I actually think the current trend for loads of acids and exfoliating products is going to cause a lot of problems long-term. It makes people look really glowy at the total expense of their skin barrier and natural cell turnover, which will worsen ageing in the long run.

I agree, especially retinol which can make skin look thicker and more leathery over time. I think there will be obvious 'retinol faces' in ten years.

Nellynoo182 · 19/09/2022 07:47

Totally agree! I am only 27 but all my friends are obsessed with skincare. Whenever I put anything on my skin I end up breaking out. My husband (in fact, every male I know!) doesn’t use any skin care products and all have great skin. I decided to stop using skincare products other than SJ dream about 5 years ago and have really good skin. I think drinking lots of water and sun protection is really the only thing that matters (I might live to regret this in 30 years time!) 🤣

TravellingSpoon · 19/09/2022 07:46

I remember reading somewhere that the only products you need are cleanser, moisturiser and SPF. So these are the only things I use and my skin looks pretty good. It feels soft, although 2 years of mask wearing hasn't helped.

Tabbouleh · 19/09/2022 07:46

Prescrription tret is a miracle and also the only thing proven to really work ( plus sunscreen) Everything else is a con that preys on women's insecurities.

mondaytosunday · 19/09/2022 07:45

Sun, pollution and smoking are enemies of the skin. Genes help. My mother had lovely skin and she kept out of the sun, used Ponds Cold Cream to remove make up
and Oil of Olay as a moisturiser. I wash with Dove soap, use whatever moisturiser is on sale (currently Revitalift) with 30 sof (which was not around when I was a young adult). I notice my daughter (17) is religious about sunscreen.
Being a bit plump also helps with wrinkles!

megletthesecond · 19/09/2022 07:43

For most people it is.
My skin is good so I only use a facial soap, flannel and moisturiser. Sunscreen in high summer. I own a clear mascara and that's it.
I eat well, don't drink and exercise which helps.

mynameisnotkate · 19/09/2022 07:43

I barely did anything my whole life and my skin was fine. I started letting my grey grow out a couple of years ago and suddenly felt like I needed to make more effort to avoid looking like an old woman, so have the full No7 routine (exfoliation, serums, eye cream, day and night creams, retinol, firming cream) and started wearing make up.

This thread is reminding me that this is silly and I should go back to just using a cheap moisturiser.

interested in people who say SPF every day though - I do this in the summer but feel in the winter I need the Vit D exposure and the sun isn’t strong enough to damage my skin (in Scotland). Should I be using it year round?

Gingerwarthog · 19/09/2022 07:41

My Mum is in her 70s and has used blue pot Nivea for all of her adult life. She has great skin - really smooth and unlined and looks years younger.
I use Nivea Soft. My skin is pretty good - I went through a phase of getting red patches on my cheeks but switching from cows' milk to oat milk sorted that out. That's been the biggest factor for me - what I eat and drink, rather than what I put on my face. Fruit, veg and water = better skin (for me).

ScarlettSunset · 19/09/2022 07:41

I wear make-up pretty much everyday as I don't like how my face looks naturally.

I wash my make up off using an 'erase your face' cloth with water. I suspect any flannel would work equally as well though.

And I use moisturiser with SPF and on really sunny days, a separate sun cream too. Skin seems fine.

I did used to use lots of separate cleaners, make-up removers etc but I stopped mainly because I felt guilty about all the plastic bottles and tubs I was using (yes I still use some but far less than I once did). My skin hasn't improved for stopping but it's certainly no worse either.

apintortwo · 19/09/2022 07:39

Lots of water and a varied diet (enough collagen from meat plus fruits and vegetables) is what's most important for good skin. And sleep also

apintortwo · 19/09/2022 07:37

YANBU

Inexpensive cleanser (like Ponds) and a daily SPF moisturiser (like Nivea) work just fine.

Serums and harsh exfoliating must be awfully irritating to the skin.

Iknowforsure1 · 19/09/2022 07:37

@prescribingmum
Acne is a medical condition and requires treatment. I don’t think OP’s post is about that. It’s about being conditioned to think that we need all the expensive routines to somehow make our skin look younger for longer, which is I believe is a con.

Wouldloveanother · 19/09/2022 07:35

I think a few well chosen products that suit your skin type - cleanser, moisturiser and a gentle exfoliator - will pay dividends but some people seem to have a 10-step skincare routine now and that many chemicals can’t be great.

That said I don’t buy the whole ‘my 80 year old nan doesn’t have a single wrinkle and all she’s used is dettol soap’ thing. Most elderly women really look it (nothing wrong with that), and in videos from the past even younger women look so much older in the face.