Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance. The law must be changed.

170 replies

Raul57 · 18/09/2022 21:30

Me and my OH have never had a penny from our parents and never wanted a penny and never expected anything and always stood on our own feet since working.

We are an asain couple and often the daughter get nothing her parents were worth close to about 700k when they both passed away within a few months of the other and my OH's brother got it all and we were happy for him as this is what we expected and the brother was well off.
My mother died in an accident when I was 20. Dad remarried and was going to leave me some money I said thanks but no thanks as he had a new family, my step mother never worked and dad was worth about 800k when he passed away 15 years ago,

With house prices as they are in London me and my OH decided to gift around 500k 300k to our daughter and 200k to our son as he is well paid and they refused the money initially but then accepted to reduce their mortgages.

We still have a few quid to our name and property and the last thing me and my OH want is over wills overturned by so fool of court/judge.

It is our money we have paid taxes on it and still paying taxes.

It winds me up when I read news and threads about I was left out etc

The money etc belongs to the giver and their wishes should never be overturned.

The gov/uk bangs on about being a fair country - why should a parent/etc leave money to someone they do not like or could not be arsed to see them for years or call them or treat them poorly?

Wills must never be overturned unless there is fraud etc involved.

I get pissed of re news items and threads eG my ... was left xxxxxx by my parents, in-laws etc and we got xx or naf all - WHO vares it was the Will writers money their choice!

OP posts:
5foot5 · 18/09/2022 23:36

With house prices as they are in London me and my OH decided to gift around 500k 300k to our daughter and 200k to our son as he is well paid and they refused the money initially but then accepted to reduce their mortgages.

I assume you looked in to the tax implications of that. I think so long as you live for seven years after giving them the money it should be fine.

MintJulia · 18/09/2022 23:36

If a person dies, leaving it all e.g. to a cats home and excluding their school age child who is still a minor and in full time education, thankfully there is something called the Provision for Dependents Act which means that person's will can be varied. The deceased cannot leave their dependent children destitute through choice/spite. He or she has a duty to provide for the child until adulthood, and the courts will normally uphold that.

So no, I don't think the law should be changed.

whatwhhat · 18/09/2022 23:24

I think you shouldn't be able to inherit anything unless you're a spouse. Most people I know who own a house inherited it or the money to buy it/pay off a large chunk of it. Or at least be capped. The rest had to work pretty hard and make a lot of sacrifices to make it possible.

It would stop a lot of the billionaires/millionaires hoarding as much money. It would also make life a fairer battleground where you work for what you get rather than some people being handed everything on a plate. It would also help free up some houses as people who don't need/want a bigger home won't need to hold on to them just so they can pass it on.

Imagine all the family feuds it would prevent 😅

InvincibleInvisibility · 18/09/2022 23:19

In France it's very formatted.

If only one child, that child must receive at least 75% of the inheritance
2 children split at least 80% between them
3 children split a different % between them
Etc

There are different marriage contacts which impacts it too.

Its not simple but you don't have a huge amount of flexibility.

Glitteratitar · 18/09/2022 23:09

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 18/09/2022 23:00

They sound like genuinely good women. (Not being sarcastic). But that does not and should not automatically entitle them to an inheritance. Whether they deserved it or not. Their father wanted it to go to his brother and, in this instance, the deceased's wishes were met and rightly so.

It's lovely that the brother gave it to the daughters. But nobody should have an automatic entilement to an inheritance unless stipulated by the (deemed mentally competent) deceased.

But there is a legitimate question of when is someone deemed capable. The law decided he was capable but the reality is he was from it. One of his wills left £250k to his neighbour’s gardener because he once helped move bins that were blocking the pathway to his front door (Really. It was then superseded by his next will when he decided to give absolutely everything to a friend. That will was then superseded by another). So yes, he could decide who to leave his property to, and ordinarily those wishes should be respected, but it’s not always so clear cut as that.

mynameisnotkate · 18/09/2022 23:08

I wish people would stop talking about UK law when they mean English law. The Scottish legal system is completely different and much closer to the French system.

Luredbyapomegranate · 18/09/2022 23:05

What law do you want changed?

In England and Wales a spouse is entitled to a good chunk of an estate, because a married couple are seen as a partnership. Beyond that you can do what you want.

It’s extremely difficult to get a will overturned.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 18/09/2022 23:00

Glitteratitar · 18/09/2022 22:50

Those are your words, not mine. Stop shit stirring.

Those girls dealt with a lot. He had his accident when they were pre-teen, and they dealt with 30 years of verbal and physical abuse from him which they accepted because they knew it wasn’t himself and it wasn’t his fault. They looked after their dad as best as they could when no one forced them to.

They sound like genuinely good women. (Not being sarcastic). But that does not and should not automatically entitle them to an inheritance. Whether they deserved it or not. Their father wanted it to go to his brother and, in this instance, the deceased's wishes were met and rightly so.

It's lovely that the brother gave it to the daughters. But nobody should have an automatic entilement to an inheritance unless stipulated by the (deemed mentally competent) deceased.

AdoraBell · 18/09/2022 22:55

Cousin’s father was being abused by his wife, she bullied him to change his Will. Got her solicitor to witness the change so that his DC couldn’t fight it. Fortunately the solicitor was professional and when the vulnerable man said he didn’t want cut his children out, no children with his wife, they agreed to leave the original Will. They told his wife it was changed.

She had removed him from his care home just to force him to change his Will.

energybill · 18/09/2022 22:52

Is this post just to stealth brag? I don't see what the issue is otherwise

Glitteratitar · 18/09/2022 22:50

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 18/09/2022 22:45

I would argue are you joking? I can see why he wouldn't want to leave his daughters anything if they thought they deserved monetary compensation for "putting up with" their mentally disabled father.

There doesn't need to be a reason to not leave your child an inheritance. The amount you are "entitled to" is whatever the deceased has indicated. Not what you think you deserve.

Those are your words, not mine. Stop shit stirring.

Those girls dealt with a lot. He had his accident when they were pre-teen, and they dealt with 30 years of verbal and physical abuse from him which they accepted because they knew it wasn’t himself and it wasn’t his fault. They looked after their dad as best as they could when no one forced them to.

ExHack · 18/09/2022 22:50

Or even better — wealthy parents should share their excess assets equitably among their children before they die.

witchesbubblebath · 18/09/2022 22:48

It should be possible to overturn wills because some parents are not good people
Mine included. There's a place for both as with most situations.

Turefu · 18/09/2022 22:47

silverclock222 · 18/09/2022 21:55

I detest that this can happen. Why is it up to someone else to decide what I can and can't do with my money and property?

I was born in the country where children have automatic right to inherit in equal shares. It
really saves a lot of heartache. Why would you want to give everything to one child and nothing to other? And if you have no intention to, why does it matter law is as it is? Btw, disinheriting is possible in my country, but it has to be clearly stated in the will and explained why, for good reasons.

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 18/09/2022 22:47

Contesting a will is not an easy process. Someone contested the will of a relative of mine...the other relative has been now waiting for her inheritance for 35 years.

TattiePants · 18/09/2022 22:46

Raul57 · 18/09/2022 22:27

Please tell me you are pulling my leg?

I fear that you are serious and what clown made that ruling?

If that law was in England, I'd stand for election become PM and change that hideously unfair, unjust and foolish/insulting law.

Stop with the hyperbole. Working people are relying on food banks, many people won’t be able to heat their homes this winter while energy companies make record profits, the Tories may reduce the cap on bankers bonuses, yet not being able to disinherit a child is the thing that would kick you in to action!

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 18/09/2022 22:45

Glitteratitar · 18/09/2022 22:40

Is this a joke thread?

My cousin had serious issues - a bad accident when he was younger left him with brain damage and therefore he was very volatile and immature.

He changed his will every few months, depending on who he has fallen out with and was friends with. According to the law, he had enough capacity to write valid wills.

When he died he had fallen out with one daughter a few months beforehand because she spent Christmas with her mum rather than him. In his last will, he left nothing to his daughters and everything to a brother he hadn’t seen in 10 years. His daughters deserved their inheritance after all the time they spent and lost dealing with their dad and his issues, and it’s surprising people like you think otherwise because his last will said otherwise.

Fortunately his brother did the decent thing and gave it all to the daughters.

I would argue are you joking? I can see why he wouldn't want to leave his daughters anything if they thought they deserved monetary compensation for "putting up with" their mentally disabled father.

There doesn't need to be a reason to not leave your child an inheritance. The amount you are "entitled to" is whatever the deceased has indicated. Not what you think you deserve.

Travis1 · 18/09/2022 22:45

Raul57 · 18/09/2022 22:27

Please tell me you are pulling my leg?

I fear that you are serious and what clown made that ruling?

If that law was in England, I'd stand for election become PM and change that hideously unfair, unjust and foolish/insulting law.

You just sound like a walloper now tbh 🤷🏻‍♀️

blameless · 18/09/2022 22:43

An interesting case where the RSPB were left land that someone had bought to prevent developers taking land from the birds. The charity sold the land to developers! amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jun/09/new-builds-birds-rspb
Closer to home, a young widow died recently who often told us the importance of making explicit. Her husband had died intestate and had various, poorly documented business dealings with his mother which led to a lot of legal wrangling.
The lady who just died, had no children and lived for her three dogs, we were sure that a large part of her estate would go to dog charities with a requirement to look after the dogs.
Despite a detailed search (apparently), her mother was unable to locate a will, collected the lot and had the dogs put down.
Make a will that is clear and file it with a reputable firm of solicitors - much pain will be avoided.

Glitteratitar · 18/09/2022 22:40

Is this a joke thread?

My cousin had serious issues - a bad accident when he was younger left him with brain damage and therefore he was very volatile and immature.

He changed his will every few months, depending on who he has fallen out with and was friends with. According to the law, he had enough capacity to write valid wills.

When he died he had fallen out with one daughter a few months beforehand because she spent Christmas with her mum rather than him. In his last will, he left nothing to his daughters and everything to a brother he hadn’t seen in 10 years. His daughters deserved their inheritance after all the time they spent and lost dealing with their dad and his issues, and it’s surprising people like you think otherwise because his last will said otherwise.

Fortunately his brother did the decent thing and gave it all to the daughters.

Escapingafter50years · 18/09/2022 22:39

So, OP, what do you think of this situation?

My father was an alcoholic and mother is a narcissist as is my male sibling (golden child).
They were well off but put most of their money into a business for said sibling, it failed and they lost a lot of money.
While my father was alive their wills stated in the event of both their deaths, whatever was left should be divided between my and sibling (even though most of their money had been swallowed up by poor decision making), that was fair enough I thought although it was a pity so much money had stupidly gone to waste.
My father died and left everything, such as it was, to my mother.
I tried to be there for her even though she was increasingly horrible to me and had been a disinterested grandparent, regularly criticising my parenting. Sibling has always caused trouble and she has always complained about him so I have had to do more than my fair share in looking after her.
A year ago she said something so disgusting to me I had to step back, have spent a fortune on private therapy, not only has she given a non-apology but she has called me a liar. I offered to meet her in therapy but she would not.
I think it's possible she will change her will, if not already done so, in favour of golden child asshole waster sibling.

Do you think this is fair?
Sadly this sort of situation is not as rare as you might think.

Brigante9 · 18/09/2022 22:39

Raul57 · 18/09/2022 22:27

Please tell me you are pulling my leg?

I fear that you are serious and what clown made that ruling?

If that law was in England, I'd stand for election become PM and change that hideously unfair, unjust and foolish/insulting law.

It’s the same in France. A friend’s dad re-married when her mum died. The new wife has made it clear she’s after the property and it will now be shared with her children from a previous relationship rather than going to my (only child) friend. She doesn’t care about this, but is pissed off the law dictates that the stepmum’s kids have, by law, to inherit part of her childhood home when they are strangers and want nothing to do with her dad (all kids in their 40s). Knowing my friend-she’s childless-she’d give it all to a cat charity.

ExecutiveStrategyCoordinator · 18/09/2022 22:38

My father was an absolute bastard. He left my mother with three kids to raise, and never paid a penny.

We three children did not have a good relationship with him in great part because of this.
He died last year, deliberately named my siblings and me in the Will to definitely NOT receive a penny as "we are estranged from him". Nor my young children - his only GC.

In life he was a horrible man, as in death. I do think that there should be something in place to protect offspring from people like him, I don't know how you'd do that though. He left his money to his wealthy sister. I'm a single mother, my children and I are struggling (not starving, but not thriving) and she certainly doesn't need a penny of it. Unfortunately she is as horrible as he was and hasn't even bothered messaging me since the will was read. (we weren't close as she wasn't interested in us as children)

I did actually try and build bridges with him a few years before he died as he was old and lonely, but he hadn't changed and I needed to protect my kids.

XelaM · 18/09/2022 22:38

This was just an opportunity for the OP to show off how wealthy she is 🙄

ILoveMonday · 18/09/2022 22:38

Definitely hard to change a will. My ex was the primary carer to his mother before she died and in the last few years of her life supported her financially. In spite of this, she still left the lion's share of her estate to his brother because he is basically really good at a sob story.

I think where someone has been the carer, the law should recognise this otherwise leave the law as it is.