Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance. The law must be changed.

170 replies

Raul57 · 18/09/2022 21:30

Me and my OH have never had a penny from our parents and never wanted a penny and never expected anything and always stood on our own feet since working.

We are an asain couple and often the daughter get nothing her parents were worth close to about 700k when they both passed away within a few months of the other and my OH's brother got it all and we were happy for him as this is what we expected and the brother was well off.
My mother died in an accident when I was 20. Dad remarried and was going to leave me some money I said thanks but no thanks as he had a new family, my step mother never worked and dad was worth about 800k when he passed away 15 years ago,

With house prices as they are in London me and my OH decided to gift around 500k 300k to our daughter and 200k to our son as he is well paid and they refused the money initially but then accepted to reduce their mortgages.

We still have a few quid to our name and property and the last thing me and my OH want is over wills overturned by so fool of court/judge.

It is our money we have paid taxes on it and still paying taxes.

It winds me up when I read news and threads about I was left out etc

The money etc belongs to the giver and their wishes should never be overturned.

The gov/uk bangs on about being a fair country - why should a parent/etc leave money to someone they do not like or could not be arsed to see them for years or call them or treat them poorly?

Wills must never be overturned unless there is fraud etc involved.

I get pissed of re news items and threads eG my ... was left xxxxxx by my parents, in-laws etc and we got xx or naf all - WHO vares it was the Will writers money their choice!

OP posts:
Bearsan · 19/09/2022 11:57

I think people should stop relying on inheritances. Most people won't receive them until they are in their 60's anyway. We made sure early on that one of our priorities was sorting out our finances. We've been able to retire early and have a great life funded by ourselves. If we do receive inheritance in the future - fairly likely, it won't matter that much. We'll treat ourselves and our dc/gc with it. I've seen so many people try to manipulate parents and relatives regarding their money/wills. I find it very distasteful. Nobody can play games with us because we don't need their money.
I particularly hate the "I'd give it all back for one hug" bollocks.
Like hell you would.

whumpthereitis · 19/09/2022 11:56

Do you think this is fair?

Sadly this sort of situation is not as rare as you might think.

When it comes to how people choose to distribute their money, it doesn’t need to be ‘fair’. It’s their money, it’s doesn’t belong to their children unless it’s bequeathed to them upon death.

I stand to inherit, but it’s not ‘my inheritance’ unless its in my possession. Until then, it’s someone else’s and they can do what they like with it. It’s not my money, and as such I’m not entitled to it.

Minimalme · 19/09/2022 11:47

The allocation of funds after death is an excellent indicator of how much someone valued you in life. I'll get nothing from my Mum because I chose NC over putting up with her abuse.

She is a very rich woman and I'm not. However, I am loved by my husband and children and also have a very close relationship with one of my siblings who also chose to cut her off.

Two other siblings are standing by, presumably for the inheritance.

steppemum · 19/09/2022 11:43

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 18/09/2022 21:37

A good friend of my parents was written out of his mother's will even though he had been giving his mum 5k a month. His sister had poisoned the mums ears and wanted all the money for herself.

So yeh, you're wrong.

but the whole point of the OP is that the parent gets to decide where to leave their money. Even if that decision is poor, unfair, and unkind.

In this scenario, the brother gave the mother money. He had a choice. He could have written that giving into more formal arrangement where he got paid back once the estate was settled. He didn't, and sadly, fair or not, money once given is no longer yours to do what you want with, but the recipients to give away as they wish.

Your scenario and the one above it both prove the OPs point. Only the owner of the money gets to decide, no-one else has any right to do that.

Crunchingleaf · 19/09/2022 11:18

Very few things in life are black and white. There are definitely older people who are manipulated into changing wills so they should be some way to dispute. I don’t think there is should be an entitlement to inherit though. Many of us have nothing to get from parents. Some adult children are assholes and abusive to their parents so there should be a way to cut them out.
In real life I have seen adult children give up careers, move location etc to mind a sick or elderly parent only to be cut out of will entirely and the golden child who visits a couple times a year has gotten everything. That isn’t right.
Some families have very toxic dynamics whereby the parents play favourites with their children or use the will to punish a particular child by cutting them out.

Riv · 19/09/2022 11:05

The giver should definitely decide who gets their things, but can be open to coercion and bias.
it’s easy to say inheritance is not that important when you have enough (or in ops case a lot more than you need) Not so easy when you are really struggling, often due to providing care to the deceased, and the inheritors is well off and not seen until the reading of the will!

Reallyreallyborednow · 19/09/2022 10:55

I think this only applies to biological and formally adopted children, not step children. So you dh leaves his assets to his bio dc and you leave yours to your bio dc

Technically though my house will now be a marital asset. If I did not have a will, everything would go to DH, and then split between his bio children.

i don’t know how it works in countries where you can’t disinherit children, but logically if you’re looking at it as a “marital pot” then they should inherit their share of his half. Same as if we got divorced he would be entitled to half my house.

I am anticipating a fall out if anything does happen. And I am fully expecting to be labelled with the money grabbing second wife titles.

Turefu · 19/09/2022 10:28

My dad always used to say, that parents should treat children equally and give them equal amount of money. However, if they have very little money to share, they should help daughter more, as in the mens world son will cope better anyway.
Very realistic thinking.

FreddyHG · 19/09/2022 10:14

blameless · 19/09/2022 09:59

I'm happy to PM my bank details. You can be confident that I'll spend your money wisely.

But that goes against my idea of meritocracy. People should advance based upon their own free choices and work. My money will go to either the government or to a conservation charity.

warrior101 · 19/09/2022 10:13

I have to say I disagree with you.
my mum is from an Asian family and her and the sisters have been completely cut of will even though they have contributed to their parents the most. My grandmothers house is being left all to my uncle. I think it is tragic that sexist customs such as this can prevail in this so called "western" society. It means Asian women stay poor and dependent whilst the men get richer. Disgusting.

averageavocado · 19/09/2022 10:06

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 18/09/2022 21:53

Firstly it wasn't my friend. Secondly he was because if the sister hadn't paid lip service to the mother the shed have split it half and half.
It's a slap in the face to give your mum 5k every month just to be written out of the will and that money all went to the sister and her children.
What about his children?
And I believe if he contests it he is automatically entitled to something.
This is in Scotland

If he could afford to give her 5k a month, I'm sure he's not hurting for money

Yes, it's a kick in the teeth, but maybe she thought he didn't need it

MorrisZapp · 19/09/2022 10:01

Don't worry about Scotland. The children are legally entitled to a third share of the movable estate, which means cash, shares etc and not property. Surely most people's largest asset is their house, to which the children have no protected entitlement to.

PoseyFlump · 19/09/2022 10:00

It always tickles me when people post in AIBU rather than say, the money section and then get defensive at the replies.

The fact is that a large majority of the nation right now are worried about heating and eating and may see this as a stealth boast.

Take your money and see a good solicitor who can advise you on setting up trusts, wills etc. For the rest of us we don't have to worry too much other than who will feed the cat after we're gone.

blameless · 19/09/2022 09:59

FreddyHG · 19/09/2022 09:03

I would set inheritance tax at 100% therefore it isn't a problem. I worked hard from nothing to get where I am now, I believe in meritocracy so would replace income tax with inheritance tax my kids apart from education will get nothing from me they need to work for it.

I'm happy to PM my bank details. You can be confident that I'll spend your money wisely.

DoctorManhattan · 19/09/2022 09:59

The person giving the money has the final say on who gets it. Too often this gets confused by familial structures and emotions, people develop an expectation that they ‘should’ get something because they are related by blood or did the person a favour or whatever. And so many families have ended up falling out over inheritances.

IMO the only scenario where a will should be challenged is if it is suspected the person who made it wasn’t mentally capable of drafting or altering said will.

My father is very well off, his car collection alone is worth over £750k. But I left home at 19, have earnt my own money since then and bought my own house, never took a penny off him, and I have no expectation that I ‘should’ inherit any of that. He is not stingy, but he raised myself and siblings to work hard and some of us have stuck with that. I live in the belief that my own money is the only money I will ever have and if he decides to leave his to a pig farm in Mongolia, that’s his choice. My sister has a very different opinion on things though so I do anticipate that she will have a lot to say when that day inevitably comes.

Raul57 · 19/09/2022 09:51

starrynight21 · 19/09/2022 06:46

I don't think it's a major problem, really. If you get your will written correctly, and cover all eventualities, it's very unlikely to get overturned. My DH has three sons, one of whom is a major "black sheep", has behaved appallingly and has totally disrespected his father. My DH has left his money to his other two sons, with only one pound to the "black sheep", and with a short description of why he has done that. The solicitor told us that no judge would overturn it because 1) son hasn't been actually left out, and 2) son has been left something.

You contradidcted yourself with respect.
You 2dont see a will being overturned..really" but then you cite "something was left" to ALL/son - So if the other son had not been left something and there was big money involved that is when it goes to court and risk of overturning

A Will made by a person of sound mind that leaves out completely some or all family is the persons choice that was making the Will.

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 19/09/2022 09:49

Regarding stories of parents abandoning children then leaving nothing in the will...the problem isn't that they aren't forced to give you money in death, the problem is a lack of system to make sure they support their kids in life.

Raul57 · 19/09/2022 09:48

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 19/09/2022 07:35

I understand its hurtful to purposely exclude somebody. But I think it should always always be upto the individual to decide who should inherit their assets.

Exactly that and what I have posted several times, thanks.
To reiterate the only time a Will should be looked at if there is evedence of malpractice/fraud etc otherwise it is their money

When dad died all the money went to his new family she hardly had a penny to her name when she married dad but it was his choice. I was happy but not my sisters as they felt our mums money should have come to us but they too understood it was his choice just frustrated

I dislike my step mother but am diplomactic/civil to here as she is a greedy money grabber reasons I won't disclose as i could be identified and I would not want her to get a penny of mine of my half siblings but not written that into the will yety.

OP posts:
Raul57 · 19/09/2022 09:43

Escapingafter50years · 18/09/2022 22:39

So, OP, what do you think of this situation?

My father was an alcoholic and mother is a narcissist as is my male sibling (golden child).
They were well off but put most of their money into a business for said sibling, it failed and they lost a lot of money.
While my father was alive their wills stated in the event of both their deaths, whatever was left should be divided between my and sibling (even though most of their money had been swallowed up by poor decision making), that was fair enough I thought although it was a pity so much money had stupidly gone to waste.
My father died and left everything, such as it was, to my mother.
I tried to be there for her even though she was increasingly horrible to me and had been a disinterested grandparent, regularly criticising my parenting. Sibling has always caused trouble and she has always complained about him so I have had to do more than my fair share in looking after her.
A year ago she said something so disgusting to me I had to step back, have spent a fortune on private therapy, not only has she given a non-apology but she has called me a liar. I offered to meet her in therapy but she would not.
I think it's possible she will change her will, if not already done so, in favour of golden child asshole waster sibling.

Do you think this is fair?
Sadly this sort of situation is not as rare as you might think.

Sorry but when you "spent... money" on your family - it was YOUR choice. Just like the Will writers choice to leave the money to whom they wanted.

When we gifted close to 500k to our children read my OP as they did not want it - if we fall out, I know for a fact it is their money and can't get it back

The money we have earned paid taxes on and still are is ours and us to decide to to leave it too, simple as that.

OP posts:
Raul57 · 19/09/2022 09:39

ExecutiveStrategyCoordinator · 18/09/2022 22:38

My father was an absolute bastard. He left my mother with three kids to raise, and never paid a penny.

We three children did not have a good relationship with him in great part because of this.
He died last year, deliberately named my siblings and me in the Will to definitely NOT receive a penny as "we are estranged from him". Nor my young children - his only GC.

In life he was a horrible man, as in death. I do think that there should be something in place to protect offspring from people like him, I don't know how you'd do that though. He left his money to his wealthy sister. I'm a single mother, my children and I are struggling (not starving, but not thriving) and she certainly doesn't need a penny of it. Unfortunately she is as horrible as he was and hasn't even bothered messaging me since the will was read. (we weren't close as she wasn't interested in us as children)

I did actually try and build bridges with him a few years before he died as he was old and lonely, but he hadn't changed and I needed to protect my kids.

Sorry, but his money, his choice.
As per my OP I never expected or wanted a penny from my father as my mum died when I was younger. As per my OP dad did write me into his Will but I declined. My OH did not get a penny even though they were well off like my dad as asain often do not leave women anything and we expected this and were happy with this

It's the person's money/etc it is tHEIR cHOICE

With respect you say your dad was a "bastard" - I'll take your word for it but FYI there are people I dislike but some of my other family like ie two side to every story and IMO a Will must never be overturned unless there is evidence of fraud/deceit etc.

OP posts:
Sandinmyknickers · 19/09/2022 09:30

OnTheBoardwalk · 18/09/2022 22:14

can you really not disinherit a child?

what if that child was Damon and tried to kill your entire life?

my inheritance is my money that I’ve paid lots of tax when it's been earned and even more when I die

why shouldn’t I leave what’s left to who I want

I think children are a lifetime commitment. Yes they grow into adults that you are no longer legally responsible for. But it frustrates me when people don't realise that they have no control really over who their children will become....yet they are their responsibility until they are 18. Having a child is a massive gamble guven they are independent humans that you can't control, and even if they turn into horrible adults, then I do kind of see why they are still entitled to a share of their parents estate

Turefu · 19/09/2022 09:14

Why there's always presumption should someone inherited large amount of money will not work? There're many examples when people inherited family businesses and made it to the next level.

Getoff · 19/09/2022 09:09

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 19/09/2022 08:26

Get more angry about the fact the RF don’t pay inheritance tax. The law was passed so as not to ‘erode their wealth’ (direct quote) How the fuck is their wealth ever going to be eroded if they’re nicking all our money 😡 😡

Money is portable debt. Every pound in existence is an IOU that relates to borrowing by some person or institution in the economy, an IOU which is free to be passed from one person to another, for any reason the current owner chooses. There isn't a fixed amount of it, the amount in the economy is free to go up or down at any time, depending whether on average borrowers are increasing or decreasing their debts. It is therefore never the case that one persons shortage of money is caused by someone else hoarding it.

Not matter how many millions someone has, if they haven't committed a crime acquiring it, they're not depriving anyone else of anything that person is entitled to. Not legally, but not morally either.

ReneBumsWombats · 19/09/2022 09:04

FreddyHG · 19/09/2022 09:03

I would set inheritance tax at 100% therefore it isn't a problem. I worked hard from nothing to get where I am now, I believe in meritocracy so would replace income tax with inheritance tax my kids apart from education will get nothing from me they need to work for it.

What are you going to do with your assets?

FreddyHG · 19/09/2022 09:03

I would set inheritance tax at 100% therefore it isn't a problem. I worked hard from nothing to get where I am now, I believe in meritocracy so would replace income tax with inheritance tax my kids apart from education will get nothing from me they need to work for it.