Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inheritance. The law must be changed.

170 replies

Raul57 · 18/09/2022 21:30

Me and my OH have never had a penny from our parents and never wanted a penny and never expected anything and always stood on our own feet since working.

We are an asain couple and often the daughter get nothing her parents were worth close to about 700k when they both passed away within a few months of the other and my OH's brother got it all and we were happy for him as this is what we expected and the brother was well off.
My mother died in an accident when I was 20. Dad remarried and was going to leave me some money I said thanks but no thanks as he had a new family, my step mother never worked and dad was worth about 800k when he passed away 15 years ago,

With house prices as they are in London me and my OH decided to gift around 500k 300k to our daughter and 200k to our son as he is well paid and they refused the money initially but then accepted to reduce their mortgages.

We still have a few quid to our name and property and the last thing me and my OH want is over wills overturned by so fool of court/judge.

It is our money we have paid taxes on it and still paying taxes.

It winds me up when I read news and threads about I was left out etc

The money etc belongs to the giver and their wishes should never be overturned.

The gov/uk bangs on about being a fair country - why should a parent/etc leave money to someone they do not like or could not be arsed to see them for years or call them or treat them poorly?

Wills must never be overturned unless there is fraud etc involved.

I get pissed of re news items and threads eG my ... was left xxxxxx by my parents, in-laws etc and we got xx or naf all - WHO vares it was the Will writers money their choice!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
prh47bridge · 03/10/2022 12:46

GermanFrench22 · 02/10/2022 23:35

One thing that confuses me about this is marriage.
If you divorce the assets have to be split fairly. How is it ok to make a will leaving all the marital assets to charity or someone else?
Surely the surviving spouse should be entitled to around half as they would have done on divorce. I am thinking of cases where one spouse has kept most of the assets in their name.
Does anyone know the answer?

In England & Wales, the surviving spouse would be able to make a claim under the Inheritance Act and would receive at least as much as they would have done had the marriage ended in divorce. If it was a short marriage, they may receive significantly more than they would have done in divorce.

GermanFrench22 · 02/10/2022 23:35

One thing that confuses me about this is marriage.
If you divorce the assets have to be split fairly. How is it ok to make a will leaving all the marital assets to charity or someone else?
Surely the surviving spouse should be entitled to around half as they would have done on divorce. I am thinking of cases where one spouse has kept most of the assets in their name.
Does anyone know the answer?

Supersimkin2 · 02/10/2022 23:12

I know two unconnected people who were disinherited for the same reason - they are mixed race.

Both sets of grandparents said ‘It’s our money to do as we like’. The law supports them.

GP were especially disgusted one GD is called Lily ‘cos she’s black’.

This was last year. Female disinheritance is still rife, goes without saying.

I’m not sure I do believe that 100 per cent testamentary freedom is a great idea, because 100 per cent of people aren’t great. A third of us over 80 will have dementia, for a start.

Tinkity · 02/10/2022 04:04

I agree with the OP because no one really knows what goes on behind closed doors.

Situation:

My grandparents left my uncle out of their wills and left everything to my dad. My dad is financially well off and didn’t need the money whereas my uncle doesn’t have a penny to his name and gets by on benefits. He lived with my grandparents until they passed away (he’s now in council housing).

My uncle goes around telling anyone who will listen how hard done by he is. How my dad is the golden child & he the lowly scapegoat. How my dad is an awful bully who cut him off 30 years ago because he finally dared to stand up for himself. How he gave up his job and life in a foreign country to move back to England to look after my grandparents in their old age & did everything for them yet they left him penniless because my dad is very greedy & so dripped poison in their ear to get everything even though he doesn’t need it. Everyone of course is outraged by how badly he’s been treated & told him to get a solicitor, challenge the will etc.

The truth:

My uncle is a paedophile. He had a decent job but spent all his money going to Thailand several times a year - I’m sure you can guess why. My dad cut contact with him when he found out what was really going on and reported him to the police, the ones here couldn’t / wouldn’t do anything and neither would the Thai police who according to my aunt (his wife who left him) were fully aware of the activity in the area but turned a blind eye to it. Anyway when he was made redundant he moved to Thailand on his redundancy money and it breaks my heart to think what he was up to there. When the money ran out he moved back here and my grandparents took him in because he was destitute (and still their son). My grandparents were fit and healthy right up to their deaths & he had no caring responsibilities whatsoever, in fact it was the other way around & they took care of him. My grandparents were adamant that my uncle was not to get a single penny as they knew he would be right back to Thailand.

The reason he never challenged the will was because he was afraid the whole sordid business would come out but he explained it away to outsiders like he was not money minded / it wasn’t in his nature / he didn’t want any unpleasantness which just made him look like more of a saint.

Sometimes there’s more to a story then you might think.

Brefugee · 02/10/2022 01:45

in some countries you can't just cut your children or living spouse out of your will without jumping through a lot of legal hoops.

Lioness100 · 02/10/2022 01:42

This… just this… the end.

entropynow · 19/09/2022 23:21

FreddyHG · 19/09/2022 10:14

But that goes against my idea of meritocracy. People should advance based upon their own free choices and work. My money will go to either the government or to a conservation charity.

And my disabled son who will struggle all his life through no fault of his own? You bet he's going to get a chunk of my money.
Meritocracy is a lie. People do not start off equal and hard work doesn't equal success.

Raul57 · 19/09/2022 16:11

hewouldwouldnthe · 19/09/2022 13:07

As for the OP. Pretty disingenuous to criticise disinherited children who have done nothing wrong to the parent and who would have loved some financial help, when the OP could afford to gift £500K. OP clearly is not in and will never be in the position of disinherited children who post here.

on the contary. We have a lot more, we live in London and own more than one property no mortgages etc and good savings. The reason we gave away the 500k is two reasons, IHT reasons and more importantly our children are good and have never asked for a penny since in employment otherwise they would have got nothing.

trust me if our children and or grandkids were nasty or did not bother with us and I don't mean come around at the drop of the hat, we would not give them another penny.

It is my and my OH's hard-earned money and prudent lifestyles that has resulted in this money. When I was 18 I wanted a brand new BMW and dad pulled me up and told me to remeber what they had been teaching us, ie not to run before we could walk, the BMW's, Mercs, Range Rovers arrived when we had learned to walk very safely and not really had to look back but we were not doing big hols abroad, new cars eating out like others we knew - as they say, money makes money and if you and family has their health there is no reason why people have to live from hand to mouth or dream about money being left to them in the UK

It is our money, we decide whom it goes to other than the tax office, lol.

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 19/09/2022 15:27

Choconut · 19/09/2022 15:09

You weren't upset because it was what you expected following tradition (you also chose to tell one set of parents you didn't want any) and by the sounds of it are extremely well off already yourself. Most people are not in any of these situations and so are entitled to be upset as they feel unloved and left out. Are you really so far up your own arse that you can't understand that?

I don’t think anyone said they’re not entitled to feel hurt at the perceived unfairness. Of course they can. They shouldn’t however be entitled to someone else’s money if that person didn’t want them to have it.

incidentally, I’m not sure how challenging a will removes that hurt though, because at that point the wishes of the deceased have been made quite clear.

Dingledangletheteabag · 19/09/2022 15:23

The person who makes the will should have their views reflected and this should only be challenged if criminality can be proved. Otherwise another personal right is taken away.

And I say this as someone who was almost left out of my extremely wealthy parents will because they didn’t think my choice of partner was right (tho time has softened their view - but it’s taken long enough).

Choconut · 19/09/2022 15:09

You weren't upset because it was what you expected following tradition (you also chose to tell one set of parents you didn't want any) and by the sounds of it are extremely well off already yourself. Most people are not in any of these situations and so are entitled to be upset as they feel unloved and left out. Are you really so far up your own arse that you can't understand that?

mynamesnotMa · 19/09/2022 15:08

Thank fully the law isnt based on your misogynistic views...why on earth should a son inherit more?

whumpthereitis · 19/09/2022 15:03

hewouldwouldnthe · 19/09/2022 13:07

As for the OP. Pretty disingenuous to criticise disinherited children who have done nothing wrong to the parent and who would have loved some financial help, when the OP could afford to gift £500K. OP clearly is not in and will never be in the position of disinherited children who post here.

She doesn’t need to be. The opinions of disinherited children aren’t somehow more valid.

Not having done anything wrong and wanting financial help does not mean you’re entitled to someone else’s money if they don’t wish to give it.

Minimalme · 19/09/2022 15:02

"Btw - more than a million jobs waiting to be filled but many can't be bothered to work as they are used to their lifestyle"

Their lifestyle? Of poverty? You and your wife come from affluent backgrounds and will have had every benefit that comes with that.

You have money and own more than one property. You have afforded your children many thousands of pounds.

You just came on here to feign outrage so you can let everyone know how disgustingly rich you are.

How about doing something useful and given all the excess cash you have but don't need to help feed children in this country who go hungry and will be cold this Winter.

I am reporting you as your views are disgusting.

strengthinnumber · 19/09/2022 13:33

My BIL (husbands brother) was disinherited by his aunt as she disapproved of him being gay. DH and his sister were left everything and made executors.
They are decent people so they simply made a deed of variance (?) or something like that and made sure BIL got 1/3. Myself and MIL were very proud of them. Aunt was bigoted, racist and really not nice and honestly it gives me joy when BIL and his husband post many pics of them on holiday in the lovely holiday apartment they bought somewhere sunny.

deedledeedledum · 19/09/2022 13:31

OP it's not just Scotland. In many parts of Europe there is a formula for how much is left to children and spouse upon death. It doesn't all go to the spouse even. To disinherit a child one has to prove various legalities. Not just 'coz I don't like them'

Turefu · 19/09/2022 13:18

hewouldwouldnthe · 19/09/2022 13:04

Legally no. I'm talking about inheritance and how, (to disagree with the OP that what the giver wants to give is their business), before the inheritance act 1975 husbands (or wives) could completely disinherit the spouse in favour of adult children. Don't quite see your point?

I asked question, thank you for clarifying . Why it has to be point?

hewouldwouldnthe · 19/09/2022 13:07

As for the OP. Pretty disingenuous to criticise disinherited children who have done nothing wrong to the parent and who would have loved some financial help, when the OP could afford to gift £500K. OP clearly is not in and will never be in the position of disinherited children who post here.

hewouldwouldnthe · 19/09/2022 13:04

Turefu · 19/09/2022 12:41

The law was changed in part because many Asian women were regarded as nothing and were virtually thrown out of their homes after their husband died, because he would leave it to the sons.

So sons are not expected to look after their mothers? Or stepmothers ? Or sisters?

Legally no. I'm talking about inheritance and how, (to disagree with the OP that what the giver wants to give is their business), before the inheritance act 1975 husbands (or wives) could completely disinherit the spouse in favour of adult children. Don't quite see your point?

HappyPeach · 19/09/2022 13:01

My neighbour was left destitute by her dh of many many years. He left his entire estate to charity. She had to go to court and was awarded enough to buy a house in her own name plus all the contents of their former martial home. So his acidic wish to hurt her never worked.

Turefu · 19/09/2022 12:41

The law was changed in part because many Asian women were regarded as nothing and were virtually thrown out of their homes after their husband died, because he would leave it to the sons.

So sons are not expected to look after their mothers? Or stepmothers ? Or sisters?

hewouldwouldnthe · 19/09/2022 12:18

Of course it should be possible to overturn a will if it is unfair. My elderly brother in law was left enough for a tiny flat to live in after his wife left almost everything to her two daughters with immediate effect. He has had the will overturned, secured a decent home for life, with the estate (which he contributed massively to over 12 years). In effect they all get equal shares.

The law was changed in part because many Asian women were regarded as nothing and were virtually thrown out of their homes after their husband died, because he would leave it to the sons.

Raul57 · 19/09/2022 12:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Raul57 · 19/09/2022 12:00

Bearsan · 19/09/2022 11:57

I think people should stop relying on inheritances. Most people won't receive them until they are in their 60's anyway. We made sure early on that one of our priorities was sorting out our finances. We've been able to retire early and have a great life funded by ourselves. If we do receive inheritance in the future - fairly likely, it won't matter that much. We'll treat ourselves and our dc/gc with it. I've seen so many people try to manipulate parents and relatives regarding their money/wills. I find it very distasteful. Nobody can play games with us because we don't need their money.
I particularly hate the "I'd give it all back for one hug" bollocks.
Like hell you would.

Agreed totla first sentence of your post and this is what our parents taught us ie stand on your own two feet. They I did not want to work I knew the only wy to get a nice home, the flash car was via work and sensible spending.

Never did I dream that we too would own more than one property via our hard work and thank our parents for our upbringing

OP posts:
Raul57 · 19/09/2022 11:58

warrior101 · 19/09/2022 10:13

I have to say I disagree with you.
my mum is from an Asian family and her and the sisters have been completely cut of will even though they have contributed to their parents the most. My grandmothers house is being left all to my uncle. I think it is tragic that sexist customs such as this can prevail in this so called "western" society. It means Asian women stay poor and dependent whilst the men get richer. Disgusting.

Thanks As per my OP, I'm Asain as well and it is culture and even applies to some of the younger people. Hence my wife not getting a penny for their big estate but to reiterate we did not expect nor want their money.
As you may have noted we've already given 500k in cash to our son and daughter and as per OP daughter got the larger share of the money as she earns less and has a bigger mortgage on her BTL.

My parents motherland it was tradition to give to boys only and in some way it made sense as it was often land and at the time all of the marriages we hetrosexual. However, in the western world/modern world for people not living of the land there is no need.

Thankfully my sisters are like me and will be splitting their money as they see fit and does not matter if it their sons or daughters.

The bottom line is it is their money and their choice

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread