Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to decline giving a lift politely

388 replies

Anxious32 · 18/09/2022 17:37

We have moved and Son (year 4) has started a new school. We’re having work done to the house so not living there at the moment we are living about 30 minutes away temporarily. NDN son is also in my child’s new school in his class! The mother has commented in the handful of brief 5 minutes I have met her previously how hard things are for her in terms of getting to school etc. obviously hinting but as we haven’t moved there not outwardly asked yet! My Son came back from school on Friday and said “x said we’ll be travelling to school together”.

I know where all this is leading and will result in me having to provide her with free transport “just because I’m going there too”. Just for context I’m very softly spoken and can be a door mat. Also this is RL so I cannot do the usual mumsnet line of “No is a complete sentence”. I have to keep things civil as we will be NDN plus see each other at school.

how can I politely say I don’t want to? My mum who enables my doormat behaviour thinks I should “help the poor lady out”. In the past situations like that have results in so much inconvenience for me such as not being able to spontaneously just go for ice-cream after school or pop to a friends house. It’s also annoying having to be on same-time each bloody time.

OP posts:
AryaStarkWolf · 20/09/2022 10:42

Casmama · 18/09/2022 17:40

Perhaps take the bill by the horns and suggest that you could take the boys on alternate days. Say you wouldn't want to do a rota for the return trip as you like to have the freedom after school.

She doesn't want to do that though

MelodyPondsMum · 20/09/2022 10:37

She hasn't asked. It's feasible the boys have just thought this would be a good idea.
Your DS has just started a new school and seems to have made a friend next door. I'm intrigued that your first response is about how you can ward off any requests and 'not be a doormat' rather than thinking about your DS, his settling in and his friendships.
You don't need to say anything yet because nothing has been asked. But I don't understand why you wouldn't offer to give them a lift in some mornings. It doesn't inconvenience you at all and it's perfectly fine to say you can't drop him back because you usually have plans after school.

magratvonlipwig · 20/09/2022 10:27

2 choices I think...

Ignore the hint, she hasnt asked so, you dont need to answer.
or
suggest alternate weeks, so you share the load. You can of course be flexi re emergencies, but it has to work for you

If she asks outright, have your answer rehearsed, like, sorry, cant commit as i have other journeys some days.. but how about we share it ?
Rehearse, out loud, on yr own, so you can say it with confidence if needed

Cheeseandwines · 20/09/2022 10:27

Imogensmumma · 18/09/2022 17:44

That’s tough, if asked maybe say I can help pick u on Tuesday( or insert other day here) which day can you do the pick up.

therefore you are helping without completely sacrificing your freedom

See you next Tuesday then ?

Bettyswoo · 20/09/2022 10:19

Then just say so. “I would normally, but I just don’t know what I’ll be doing one minute to the next right now”

jillybeanclevertips · 20/09/2022 10:03

maybe suggest, that on the trip to school you would be willing to do it, when you move, and that you could share the cost, if she undertakes to do the pick up.If she can't do that suggest a nominal sum that would show its a shared responsibility

LookItsMeAgain · 20/09/2022 09:13

Fluffymule · 18/09/2022 17:55

You've articulated it quite reasonably already in your last post, 'I don’t know my schedule so don’t want to commit to anything'

If she asks you can just use this - "Sorry, I'm not sure of my schedule moving forward, it's going to be changeable I know so I'm unable to commit to anything".

If you wanted to be ultra polite you could add something like "if things change at any point in the future I'll let you know, but I wouldn't want you to make plans based on my availability as it really isn't feasible"

When delivering bad/unwelcome news it's best not to over explain or witter on - it makes it more difficult. Just say it simply, be pleasant and move the conversation on afterwards.

This is a perfectly acceptable response.

Don't get sidetracked into agreeing to do a lift for week or so because it will run in to every week and she will have her morning's free and you won't.

Could you say that you're considering getting a child minder who will do the drop off and collection and if you manage to find someone, you'll pass on their details (then never progress with that)?

If you've just moved into the neighbourhood, simply say "We've just moved into the area and are still finding our feet a bit. We'll just be looking after ourselves for the moment. Should that change, we'll let you know".

Nevertouchakoala · 20/09/2022 09:13

She’s not asked you yet don’t worry about something that’s not happened

CruCru · 20/09/2022 09:09

The thing is, hinting that she will need you to do the school run for her actually a really weird thing to do. She doesn’t know you from Adam - what if you were unreliable, a dangerous driver or just plain unkind?

She is relying on you being polite.

N1no · 20/09/2022 08:50

There are lots of very “British “ replies here.
You can say that you don’t want to knowing that it might not create the best relationship with your neighbour.
She should also have asked you directly instead of speaking to your DS.
I would be happy to pay you for taking my child to school as it is very difficult for me on some days. It’s a service and shouldn’t be free. As you are looking for a new job you might also need her help in the future.
Or you could all walk together and get some fresh air…

TooHotToTangoToo · 20/09/2022 07:38

The thing is I don’t know my schedule so don’t want to commit to anything

There's your response just there.

Ndn - can you take little Freddie into school with you

Op - I can't I'm afraid, I never know what my schedule is going to be so can't commit to anything.

CCC11 · 20/09/2022 03:41

I haven't rtft but you could always say you don't feel comfortable having someone that's not family I'm the car as you don't want to be held responsible if something happens with them. Maybe tell fib and say from past experiences you dont give lifts to others

marblemad · 20/09/2022 03:08

It's difficult as I absolutely think your ndn is being abit cheeky in slowly being an imposition HOWEVER, your children will literally be going to a from the same place, it's year 4 so not forever to give the lift, also could you not say you're due to start a new role and that schedules are abit all over the place but you would be open to the idea in the future? By remaining open like above said could work well you could formalise an agreement and make it easier on your schedule by only doing half the week, if either kid happens to start football etc then just say the lift wont be available on those days as you will be going to grandparents or shopping etc.

milkyaqua · 20/09/2022 02:38

Look sad, and say "Oh, I wish I could, but I don't want to."

ChellyT · 20/09/2022 02:30

Anxious32 · 18/09/2022 17:47

The thing is I don’t know my schedule so don’t want to commit to anything. I am also looking for a new job. Previously I have given so many lifts to people out of guilt or what they will think of I say no. I would never just ask people to give lifts to my kids! I just find it so cheeky but as I’ve been told by my anxiety therapist not everyone thinks the same way I do,

You have a perfectly honest and reasonable reason for why you just can't. I'm with most, just say it nicely and quickly change the subject... Good luck

sue20 · 20/09/2022 01:05

jollygoose · 18/09/2022 17:43

I'm really sorry but this won't work for me as I may not always want to come straight home .. perhaps invent elderly relative you help care for and soften it wit If in an emergency situation you wouldn't mind as a very occasional think but you can't commit to anything regular.

Don’t invent anything the boys are involved

CelestiaNoctis · 19/09/2022 23:30

I walk the same way home with a mum from school. Yes I would help her in an emergency, no question. But would I do it regularly, no. As you say its a lot to ask. You don't know her, you're already responsible for your own kid and time keeping. What if they're late, then do you wait and make your own kid late? I have anxiety too and overthink things like crazy but you have to put your foot down. Just say that you wouldn't feel comfortable doing that as you've just moved here. That puts it off into the future and she shouldn't ask again. If she does then say, I'm just not comfortable doing that, I'm a nervous driver. If she pushes anymore then she's either mega desperate or a mega CF.

PepperSprayFirstApologiseLater1 · 19/09/2022 22:51

'No that wouldn't really work for me'

Somethingneedstochange · 19/09/2022 22:41

Just say you would only do if they returned the favour and do it between you. Not be expected to do it all the time. But as you don't know her or her child well enough yet then you don't feel comfortable her taking your child. But also don't want to commit. She given a reason she's struggling? Or does she work from home and just can't be bothered taking him herself?

Ameanstreakamilewide · 19/09/2022 22:29

I'm a firm believer in 'honesty is the best policy' - sometimes with a good dash of white lie juice.

All the daft excuses are just ridiculous, especially the suggestion that you tell her that you're an alcoholic.
I mean...for Christ's sake. 🙄

You simply have to tell her the truth, that you can't commit.
You can do it. 👍

Inwiththenew · 19/09/2022 21:57

It’s difficult and I know because I’ve been in this situation helping with lifts with people who have issues with the school run themselves. In my experience, however much you help them it’s never reciprocated. In consideration that she’s your neighbour, I’d make a suggestion that you are comfortable with but keep your boundaries clear and have no guilt. If she turns out to be someone who knows how to reciprocate you won’t have to worry so much,

Stilsmiling · 19/09/2022 21:49

Don’t stress. Don’t overthink it.
If your NDN asks you outright if you can give her kids a lift to school then just smile and say that you’re sorry but it wouldn’t work for you. You don’t need to say any more. Change the subject straight away to something jovial like “I can’t believe X is the this age already….”

If she raises the issue again then say “Were you thinking of alternating lifts? To be honest it doesn’t really suit me as I’m not always coming straight home, often go to relatives visiting after school. I’m job hunting too so I don’t know how that will work out with school runs.” Then change the subject without waiting for a response.
Its lovely to help each other out but when you don’t know your NDN or their child then it’s a bit much to be asking at this stage.

sjpkgp1 · 19/09/2022 21:34

Fluffymule · 18/09/2022 17:55

You've articulated it quite reasonably already in your last post, 'I don’t know my schedule so don’t want to commit to anything'

If she asks you can just use this - "Sorry, I'm not sure of my schedule moving forward, it's going to be changeable I know so I'm unable to commit to anything".

If you wanted to be ultra polite you could add something like "if things change at any point in the future I'll let you know, but I wouldn't want you to make plans based on my availability as it really isn't feasible"

When delivering bad/unwelcome news it's best not to over explain or witter on - it makes it more difficult. Just say it simply, be pleasant and move the conversation on afterwards.

I agree with @Fluffymule here. Perfectly polite and reasonable, and sets your boundaries from the start. As you get to know your NDN and her child, you might find you can be a bit more relaxed and you may find reciprocal arrangements that can and DO work for you both, but until you get to that situation, don't feel bad. Probably notwithstanding occasional emergency situations where maybe kindness and decency trump the status quo. I'd ignore others that tell you "it shouldn't be an issue", whether it is "the mum", a friend, your mum or your therapist. It's not them giving the lift, and don't let them make you feel bad for avoiding it. I've got 4 kids, all older, and whereas I now just roll my eyes most of the time now and give lifts to all and sundry mentioning occasionally that "I seem to have become a taxi driver in my spare time", I was an anxious driver when they were young, and always told mine that "spare lifts were not on offer".

pomers · 19/09/2022 21:10

This could also escalate into other child care related scenarios; nip it in the bud now.

ADarknessOfDragons · 19/09/2022 21:07

I lift share with my 6 doors down neighbour. It's flexible. If she's taking her son for an appointment after school etc we obviously don't.

We started when we were desperate for lifts because we moved my struggling DD to a different school and obviously cannot physically pick up from 2 separate primaries. Expensive for my DTs to do after school club for essentially 20 minutes and struggling child couldn't cope with after school club so it solved all my woes.

For us it works well, is never the same week to week (amd we can actually do all the lifts every day now as struggling child continued to struggle and now does not attend at all and hasn't for months).

If you wanted to consider a reciprocal arrangement, they can work!

Swipe left for the next trending thread