Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to decline giving a lift politely

388 replies

Anxious32 · 18/09/2022 17:37

We have moved and Son (year 4) has started a new school. We’re having work done to the house so not living there at the moment we are living about 30 minutes away temporarily. NDN son is also in my child’s new school in his class! The mother has commented in the handful of brief 5 minutes I have met her previously how hard things are for her in terms of getting to school etc. obviously hinting but as we haven’t moved there not outwardly asked yet! My Son came back from school on Friday and said “x said we’ll be travelling to school together”.

I know where all this is leading and will result in me having to provide her with free transport “just because I’m going there too”. Just for context I’m very softly spoken and can be a door mat. Also this is RL so I cannot do the usual mumsnet line of “No is a complete sentence”. I have to keep things civil as we will be NDN plus see each other at school.

how can I politely say I don’t want to? My mum who enables my doormat behaviour thinks I should “help the poor lady out”. In the past situations like that have results in so much inconvenience for me such as not being able to spontaneously just go for ice-cream after school or pop to a friends house. It’s also annoying having to be on same-time each bloody time.

OP posts:
LookItsMeAgain · 20/09/2022 17:29

Brava @creamwitheverything !!! Brava!!!!

creamwitheverything · 20/09/2022 17:03

Well bugger me OP! I left you a comment today at 12 ish and I have just been to collect my dd 10 yrs from school where I too got collared by a mum! She was so glad to bump into me as she had been thinking about our kids going to high school next year and she had had the most wonderful idea to share with me, Now she says to me you know cream I have 3 kids and 1 of them in a different school well when xxx goes to high school I cannot be in 3 places at once,and i was thinking you have a car and pass our road everyday and you will be taking babycream to school so you coulld call at my house every day and pick up xxx it would really save me so much time and bother, Not would you mind?,could you? is that ok with you? but it would save her the trouble if I took on the responsibility of her kid getting to school, I immediately thought of you!!!! I suggested to her that as it was only september now and they dont go til next september that would give her plenty of time to sort it all out and get herself organized,said see you later and got in my car and went without looking back!!! Not a prayer am I doing it or getting involved,not my issue. not my problem ,not going to be either! You couldnt make it up!!

PammieDooveOrangeJoof · 20/09/2022 16:58

Cheeseandwines · 20/09/2022 13:16

Could you stuff old clothes with paper and put hats on balloons to give the impression that you car is already full each day. Each day you would have to shrug as you drove past with a sort of "what can you do?" Expression. This is probably the simplest solution.

love this 😂

LookItsMeAgain · 20/09/2022 16:51

Equally then @FinallyHere , why hasn't the neighbour said "Oh I've noticed that you're bringing little David to school every day and he is in the same school as my Matthew, so I'll bring them to school every day" (this is in relation to your message "If you live next door and travelling to the same place, I don’t understand why you wouldn’t give them a lift?").

There is absolutely nothing wrong with wanting to bring your child to and from school without any one else's children tagging along. I find it to be a great time to chat to my kids while we drove home to find out how their day went. Some might be a bit uncomfortable in really opening up while there are others in the car that aren't family.

FinallyHere · 20/09/2022 16:47

If you live next door and travelling to the same place, I don’t understand why you wouldn’t give them a lift?

If they are established and OP is the newcomer, why aren't they offering to take her child to school? Why is OP being told to be helpful, why isn't the NDN offering? Not offering anything at all.

It's the lack of reciprocity that screams CF. Who honestly asks for favours without even pretending to offer something in return.

If you know you are not good at saying no, @Anxious32 I would encourage you to do it more often. Just say no.

The more you do it the better you will be at it and the less headspace it will occupy Saying no is a great way to find out what people are really like. Decent ones will have no problem with it. The others ... will remind you why it's not a good idea to do them favours.

Serenitymummy · 20/09/2022 14:35

Anxious32 · 18/09/2022 17:47

The thing is I don’t know my schedule so don’t want to commit to anything. I am also looking for a new job. Previously I have given so many lifts to people out of guilt or what they will think of I say no. I would never just ask people to give lifts to my kids! I just find it so cheeky but as I’ve been told by my anxiety therapist not everyone thinks the same way I do,

You've answered it yourself right here, if they ask outright it's "ah I can't commit I'm afraid as I don't know my schedule in advance and won't always be coming straight home, sorry about that". As pp have said, an occasional favour is fine but no committing.

Buttonjugs · 20/09/2022 13:51

Aside from the cheek of her telling her child he will be travelling to school with you, I would avoid her as much as you can. Don’t get friendly with her because she sounds like the type who will take advantage. I speak to my neighbours but just a hello or a quick comment because in the past I have been taken advantage of by neighbours or forced to socialise with them when I didn’t want to. Just be polite but a little standoffish and if she asks you directly tell her you’d rather not, sorry.

KarmaStar · 20/09/2022 13:34

Just agree what a tie it is and that you find it especially hard with so many commitments and job seeking that you'll be unable to help unless it's an emergency.

Trainbear · 20/09/2022 13:23

“Oh sorry my insurance does not cover it”

SleepingAgent · 20/09/2022 13:18

VroomVrooom · 18/09/2022 21:19

All the people saying ‘you’re going anyway, where’s the harm?’ - you do realise people are much more open to helping others out when:

  • it’s prefaced with some sort of suggestion of it being completely reciprocal
  • it’s asked by someone you’ve known more than quarter of an hour.

Most people - especially people like the OP - want to help others out.

They don’t want to be taken advantage of. And that’s OK.

How hard is this to understand?

Exactly!! She's a CF as OP isn't even living next door to her yet, and she's already making plans to use her.

Cheeseandwines · 20/09/2022 13:16

Could you stuff old clothes with paper and put hats on balloons to give the impression that you car is already full each day. Each day you would have to shrug as you drove past with a sort of "what can you do?" Expression. This is probably the simplest solution.

WhisperGold · 20/09/2022 13:08

Get in first snd ask her.

NoDairyNoProblem · 20/09/2022 12:53

@Anxious32 i am a complete people pleaser, it gives me anxiety saying no… but it also gives me anxiety turning myself inside out to accommodate people who would not do the same for me.

I would say ‘I’m afraid that won’t work for us’ and if pressed ‘my week varies and there is simply no way’.

No lies, no excuses, just no.

CactusBlossom · 20/09/2022 12:51

She hasn't asked, so you don't have to respond yet -- it gives you time to prepare.

You might want to wait until you get to know her better, it could work out if you find you get on well.

If you don't want to do it, just say it won't be possible (if you find saying "no" too difficult). Alternatively, say you have "other arrangements" without saying what they are.

You might want to consider whether she would share the task -- so if you are unwell, she could take your DS, perhaps?

creamwitheverything · 20/09/2022 12:26

No sorry ..
Why not?
Cos I dont want to
would be my suggestion but thats not what you want to hear I am guessing!
Do not lie,be clear be firm.Do not start soething you will regret fo rthe sake of keeping the peace, These situations are so easy to fall into but really hard to get out of, Man up,sort it get it off your mind!Start now by hint dropping,hopefully this will head her off before she starts..I love spending time on my own on a morning with my son,its our special catch up time,Do you do the same with yours? I wouldnt change that time for all the tea in china. Oh isnt it a lovey day today must dash...or something similar!

Shade17 · 20/09/2022 12:25

Absolutely do not use the word “sorry”. You’ve nothing to apologise for!

DiWoo · 20/09/2022 12:25

I got into a lift share with parents I knew (from my child being friends with the other children), it didn’t go well, for me that is. One of the parents was frequently unable to fulfil his part but didn’t seek to arrange anything else, just left us to it, then said that his job role was changing so couldn’t do his share at all. One of the kids didn’t even go to the same school as mine. It would have worked out that I was basically subsiding their travel, costing me more. I think they got a shock when I said I was sending my child to school by train then as it worked out cheaper for me (and more expensive for them!). I still took/picked them up when there were issues with the trains though but to add insult to injury, I saw one mum picking up her child from the same school mine was at but she hadn’t offered to bring my child home.

12LuDo · 20/09/2022 12:21

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 20/09/2022 12:17

Reasons not to give a lift

  • I enjoy the travel time with my child. It is when we have the best talks.
  • I don't want the responsibility. I'm an anxious person and worry.
  • I've tried it before and it didn't work for us or the other child in the end.
  • I can't commit as I don't have a regular schedule and will be making spontanious changes to my routine.
  • I can't collect as I don't always come straight home and wouldn't be able to warn you when I wasn't available.
  • I really value peace when driving and find looking after another child distracting.

Seriously though, all of these are brilliant and perfectly fair. It's not just 'giving a lift' when it's a child, it's childcare, totally different thing

CamelFlarge · 20/09/2022 12:20

There are some people being very rude and dismissive towards the OP here. If you've had an upbringing where saying No to anything makes you A Horrible Person then it has a huge and lasting impact, and can make you very anxious about trying to say no to other people's requests. Unless you've experienced that absolutely visceral, gut-churning anxiety about Doing The Wrong Thing then sure, you might think the OP is exaggerating and being a wimp. But as she's already explained her mum actively tells her to ignore her own feelings and "help the poor lady out", you can see how a lifetime of this programming has a deep and lasting impact. Stop being snide about how "everybody has anxiety these days" and try some basic empathy and compassion.

OP, I literally practice out loud to myself when I have something like this to tackle. Spend some time saying "no thank you, that doesn't work for me/us". Ignore all hints however heavy, and be ready when the question comes with your line and no further explanation.

12LuDo · 20/09/2022 12:18

Disclaimer: This is a joke

Have you considered 'Happy to help, be good to get some practice in, now I'm finally allowed to drive again!' This should avoid the situation ever arising :)

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 20/09/2022 12:17

Reasons not to give a lift

  • I enjoy the travel time with my child. It is when we have the best talks.
  • I don't want the responsibility. I'm an anxious person and worry.
  • I've tried it before and it didn't work for us or the other child in the end.
  • I can't commit as I don't have a regular schedule and will be making spontanious changes to my routine.
  • I can't collect as I don't always come straight home and wouldn't be able to warn you when I wasn't available.
  • I really value peace when driving and find looking after another child distracting.
singingintheshower · 20/09/2022 12:17

I currently do a lift-share with one person (year 10 - my DS & 1 boy in same form he's known since Nursery but they aren't really friends anymore). It works fine until my DS is ill (covid or whatever) & then it's REALLY annoying having to get up early just to take someone else's kid to school. It's also irritating when it's my turn to collect but my son has detention & I'll then have to go twice in the same afternoon. I agree that lift-shares work well in the mornings (though you are depending on the other parent being punctual etc & being a safe driver). It can also be a major pain when the kids fall out/decide they aren't friends anymore or if one child does lots of after school clubs etc etc. Can make life VERY complicated. But out of 10 school runs per week I only do 5 so there is that 😁 I would also say that my DD was anxious about going into school when she was in infants and would have HATED it if a random NDN she didn't know was taking her to school! They often want last hug from Mum/Dad & little whispered words of comfort to get them through the day - not some harried stranger dragging them through playground because they are late/nowhere to park etc

lottiegarbanzo · 20/09/2022 12:14

My Son came back from school on Friday and said “x said we’ll be travelling to school together”

'Oh how lovely, is his Mum offering to drive you both?'

Just tell her you're unreliable and can't commit.

FinallyHere · 20/09/2022 12:12

The golden rule is not to give any kind of excuse. Just say that you are sorry it won't be possible. Keep smiling and keep moving.

Anyone trying to 'make a sale', to get you to do anything you don't want to do will pick up on any excuse you give and either try and solve it for you or get you to agree that once that is sorted l, you will do whatever it is that they want.

If you are not good at keeping your boundaries, it's much better to not get involved in the first place. Especially someone who appears to be pushy, eg telling their child they will be travelling with someone else.

It's very sad, because I do like doing things to help others, it makes me feel good. If there is any chance that it might all go wrong then far better not to start.

Also, make sure you vary your routine so don't always go out at the same time or even go the long way round to avoid meeting them.

Good luck and meanwhile do get into the habit of saying no to someone just because. It's good to keep that muscle in trim. No one should react badly, anyone who does, is not worth doing reciprocal favours for. Good life lesson.

Please take it from someone who is, though I say so

AryaStarkWolf · 20/09/2022 12:10

fruitbrewhaha · 20/09/2022 12:09

But why not do a lift share? If there's another child in the area make it between 3 of you then you only need to travel to school 3 or 4 times a week. If someone is away, or off sick then there's still two to do it. I do this and we set a rota each Sunday so if someone has meetings or appointments etc we can work around each persons diary. Plus if something comes up we support each other.

If she is just looking to get you to do all the lifts then say no, I will find someone to reciprocate with, why would I cart your child around if you're not offering anything.

She's already said she doesn't want to do that