Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to decline giving a lift politely

388 replies

Anxious32 · 18/09/2022 17:37

We have moved and Son (year 4) has started a new school. We’re having work done to the house so not living there at the moment we are living about 30 minutes away temporarily. NDN son is also in my child’s new school in his class! The mother has commented in the handful of brief 5 minutes I have met her previously how hard things are for her in terms of getting to school etc. obviously hinting but as we haven’t moved there not outwardly asked yet! My Son came back from school on Friday and said “x said we’ll be travelling to school together”.

I know where all this is leading and will result in me having to provide her with free transport “just because I’m going there too”. Just for context I’m very softly spoken and can be a door mat. Also this is RL so I cannot do the usual mumsnet line of “No is a complete sentence”. I have to keep things civil as we will be NDN plus see each other at school.

how can I politely say I don’t want to? My mum who enables my doormat behaviour thinks I should “help the poor lady out”. In the past situations like that have results in so much inconvenience for me such as not being able to spontaneously just go for ice-cream after school or pop to a friends house. It’s also annoying having to be on same-time each bloody time.

OP posts:
ThorsBedazzler · 18/09/2022 19:38

If she asks, and there's no guarantee she will as let's face it, kids make fantastical arrangements all the time, just remind her that you haven't actually moved in yet. Then you can always say how you're doing all the stressful things at once - house move and job hunt - so won't know if you're coming or going in the next few months.

Then just a brisk cheerio.

Funkyblues101 · 18/09/2022 19:37

Anxious32 · 18/09/2022 17:47

The thing is I don’t know my schedule so don’t want to commit to anything. I am also looking for a new job. Previously I have given so many lifts to people out of guilt or what they will think of I say no. I would never just ask people to give lifts to my kids! I just find it so cheeky but as I’ve been told by my anxiety therapist not everyone thinks the same way I do,

You say, verbatim, "I don't know what our schedule will be so I don't want to commit to anything." It's telling your neighbour you are nice and not a "no is a complete sentence" person, but also being totally honest. YOU DO NOT WANT TO MAKE COMMITMENTS YOU WILL REGRET.

Rainbowdrops2021 · 18/09/2022 19:37

I have two dc at two separate schools who start and finish within 20 minutes of each other and the schools are a good car journey apart however I still would never ask anyone to help. I have been that person to give a lift to someone else’s child who was in the same class as mine and it was a nightmare, every time they were late or we were running a bit behind or if my child was sick or theirs was and they forgot to contact me so I’d be sat waiting to take her to school. In the end I had to bite the bullet and just say I couldn’t do it any more. Not sure how you should approach this but it’s not suitable to constantly rely on someone else for free child care and lifts.

PuzzledObserver · 18/09/2022 19:36

Whatever you do, don’t invent elderly relatives you need to care for, broken seatbelts or nerves about driving. Elderly relatives can die and seatbelts can be mended.

Also, not knowing your schedule, while it’s a perfectly valid reason not to want to make a commitment, is also a temporary situation. Eventually you will know your schedule and then what will you say?

If I’ve read your posts correctly, the real reason is that you don’t want to be tied down to a regular lift because you value the flexibility of being able to take and collect your child at a time that suits you, and with the freedom to go on to other places if you want to. So - unless sharing lifts is something you would value for financial reasons, in which case it needs to be reciprocal, or her to contribute to your costs if she doesn’t drive - then just tell her that.

Giving a regular lift would tie me down, and we need the flexibility. So - sorry (if you want to be a polite) - it’s a no.

Genevieva · 18/09/2022 19:35

I think you are making a mountain out of a mole hill.

Firstly, you don't live there yet, so it is not a possibility any time soon.
Secondly, you do't know what your work circumstances will be.
Thirdly, lift sharing might actually be helpful for you for all you know.

I think you would be crazy to turn down the possibility of a lift-share. It could mean that on 2 or 3 mornings a week she collects your son from home and saves you the journey. But if you are adamant that you don't want to be neighbourly then just say that, because of work commitments you are unlikely to be able to lift-share.

bringbackveronicamars · 18/09/2022 19:32

I agree with others. Tell her your schedule is unpredictable, you're job hunting, and you don't want to take on the commitment. If she pushes, ask her why she's not offering to do the running with the boys since she's going there as well and has done for the past 3 school terms.

herecomesthsun · 18/09/2022 19:31

"I'm so sorry, but that doesn't work for us" is fine. Said quietly but positively and repeated if needed.

It is very difficult when coordinating lifts if a child takes time to get ready or needs reassurance about some aspect of school and that can be hinted at if needed.

It is difficult because some people can be very entitled, but you just need to hold your position.

gillybean2 · 18/09/2022 19:31

You’ve not moved next door yet. Shut it down before you move in. Say there’s been a misunderstanding, you aren’t able to help as per the reasons you already gave. Then she has time to get over it before you become neighbours.

solvendie · 18/09/2022 19:30

i think I would say ‘I’m very sorry but I just can’t commit to that as I have other things I need to do’

KosherDill · 18/09/2022 19:29

That sounds like a nightmare. She certainly didn't waste any time, did she?

Does she live with a partner/the child's other parent? Are there other school mums in the vicinity?

I wouldn't feel the slightest bit guilty in responding "Sorry, our schedule is such that we can't take on any more commitments."

Do not give her hope for the future or mention "emergencies" because you can be sure that emergencies will arise with increasing regularity.

Doubledenimrocks · 18/09/2022 19:29

I don't see why you can't to be honest. It seems ab absolute waste of time and money for two people to drive to the same place on the off chance you might fancy an ice-cream. Make sure the arrangement is reciprocal and be clear that there are times when you can't and want to be flexible.

LondonLovie · 18/09/2022 19:29

Then wouldn't you just say: no, I don’t know my schedule so can not commit to anything. ..?

CharmingChinchilla · 18/09/2022 19:28

Pre-empt her and turn it around on her. Say, "DS said he would be travelling to school with <NDN's DS>. How cheeky of him to assume! Awfully kind of you to offer but my schedule is so unpredictable right now that we'll have to make our own arrangements. We must arrange for a play date for the boys soon..."

Also, if you're a doormat, it can be easier to refuse via text. Gives you breathing space to come up with an answer so you don't agree out of awkwardness. Get her number ASAP!

Wibbly1008 · 18/09/2022 19:26

Mum198000 · 18/09/2022 18:49

How about “ that’s so funny I was just about to ask you to take my child in as you are going there anyway”. Watch them back away quickly.

…this!!! I do wish I’d thought of this, it’s perfect!

Comedycook · 18/09/2022 19:25

The thing is I don’t know my schedule so don’t want to commit to anything

Say this.

Arenanewbie · 18/09/2022 19:24

I don’t know my schedule so don’t want to commit to anything'
replace don’t want with can’t and you will have perfect polite and reasonable answer.
It will give you actually some room for changes in the future if boys become best friends or you need help with school runs for some reason.
Also tell DS that the boy is mistaken without focusing on it too much. You don’t know what mum’s said to him and how much of it is his wishful thinking and how much is her cunning planning.

Bookworm777 · 18/09/2022 19:23

Don't get sucked into any kind of formal arrangement just because a bunch of MNetters say you should be the bigger person. Sod that! IF she asks, just say, no, it's too much of a commitment being responsible for taking someone else's child to and from school every day.

AnnieSaxophone · 18/09/2022 19:22

I was railroaded into alternate pickups at one point, but the other mother was never actually able to and kept pulling last minute ‘I’m stuck at work can you get them?’ calls. It drove me potty, so I said to her after 2 weeks that the arrangement wasn’t working for me and I was pulling out.

Echobelly · 18/09/2022 19:21

Anxious32 · 18/09/2022 17:47

The thing is I don’t know my schedule so don’t want to commit to anything. I am also looking for a new job. Previously I have given so many lifts to people out of guilt or what they will think of I say no. I would never just ask people to give lifts to my kids! I just find it so cheeky but as I’ve been told by my anxiety therapist not everyone thinks the same way I do,

I'd just tell them this; it doesn't work for you for those reasons.

Wibbly1008 · 18/09/2022 19:21

Anxious32 · 18/09/2022 17:47

The thing is I don’t know my schedule so don’t want to commit to anything. I am also looking for a new job. Previously I have given so many lifts to people out of guilt or what they will think of I say no. I would never just ask people to give lifts to my kids! I just find it so cheeky but as I’ve been told by my anxiety therapist not everyone thinks the same way I do,

You find it cheeky… because it is bloody cheeky! You don’t owe this woman anything. Life is tough with kids, it’s tough for everyone- so please don’t take on the mothers load of other woman as you will simply drown and when you can’t do it any longer you will be the bad guy for letting her down. If she asks say I’m sorry, I’m getting a new job and have to sort my own transport out…. I bet she doesn’t bloody offer to help you!

AnnieSaxophone · 18/09/2022 19:20

Honestly - I think your child would benefit so much from having the one to one time with you on the way in and journey home from school - and that in my book is worth protecting fiercely. I personally would say ‘sorry but that’s our one to one time’.
And if she comes back and makes excuses about you being able to do that at other times, I would just repeat ‘sorry but that’s our one to one time’. And add ‘it’s non-negotiable’ if needed.

Hiphophippityskip1 · 18/09/2022 19:20

Her arrangements for getting her kids to and from school are her problem. You could say perhaps we could share the mornings but unfortunately I cannot commit to afternoons because we often have plans and I don't know my working hours going forward.

Geppili · 18/09/2022 19:19

Do not do this. The child might be a nightmare. Protect your child. Say to the cheeky fucker neighbour:

No. The one to one time in the car with my child is precious to me and I do not want any added responsibility during that drive.

Fundays12 · 18/09/2022 19:17

I understand your concerns would alternative days works for you? I know it’s difficult I have been hinted at to take neighbours kids to school. I don’t mind here and there or in an emergency but I actually don’t want to be relied on to take other people kids to school when they are perfectly able to take them. I haven’t got the time, energy or dedication plus have 3 of my own kids to get to school.

Honeysuckle16 · 18/09/2022 19:16

This is a classic situation where a quiet person can be railroaded into doing something they’d rather not do.

There’s a great assertiveness technique called the ‘broken record’ which can help a lot. It can be learned by anyone and used in tough circumstances.

If the other mum drops hints or asks for a lift, this should trigger using the broken record.

Start by showing that you appreciate her side of things by saying something like, ‘ I can see that a lift would be a help to you’.

Then go on to say ‘However’ (better than ‘but’), ‘that’s not something I can offer.’ (or use your own words.) No need to apologise or explain or offer excuses or anything further.

If the other mum questions your decision, just repeat the two stages of empathy and your decision. This is what gives the broken record its name.

Throughout, be sincere and friendly and avoid raising your voice, appearing angry or hesitant. Make it clear from your polite refusal that you’ll not change your mind but that you are a kind and courteous person.

I’ve taught this technique to hundreds of people who have used successfully. Practise it beforehand with someone until you feel comfortable with it. Lots more info on the internet about assertiveness generally.