Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how to encourage younger people to join in church

353 replies

Ihatecocomelon · 18/09/2022 16:46

Just that really. I'm not entering debate about what exists etc.

What would draw your children or teenagers into going to church regularly?

Our church has plenty of the older generation but only a couple of younger children and maybe 2 young couples with babies.

Thank you 😊

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/09/2022 19:35

My dd is 17. She doesn't actually believe in God, but she is certainly extremely interested in all things spiritual. We have talked about this subject quite a lot, so I have a pretty good insight into her thinking on this.

I think she would really like the spiritual side of following a religion, as well as all the ritual of a church service, the wider community aspect and even all the music/singing etc. However, I can't see her ever wanting to go to a Christian church, because her perceptions of the church are generally very negative. There are a few reasons for this.

  1. She perceives a lot of Christians as being quite smug/arrogant. This is primarily based on a few Christians she knows who are very much of the view that Christianity is the only path to God/ the only way to salvation etc. She perceives them as being a little bit stupid for this, as if they somehow think that they've got it all worked out while the rest of the world's population are wrong, or worse, damned for eternity. She strongly dislikes people who are arrogant/consider themselves to be superior to others, and so she wouldn't want to associate herself with the church because that's how it comes across to get her. (To be clear, I fully understand that lots of Christians don't actually believe that Christianity is the only right path or that they have all the answers, but dd has been exposed to a few quite vocal people who are very much of this way of thinking.)
  1. She perceives the church as homophobic and misogynistic. Again, very off-putting for her, and probably for many other young people who may share this perception. (And again, I fully appreciate that this doesn't apply to all Christians but honestly speaking, it is the way that she sees it.)
  1. She is bemused by the people who deny basic science, such as evolution. She does understand that not all Christians take the bible literally, but again, she has been exposed to some who do, and she cannot begin to get her head around why anyone would believe that.
  1. She dislikes the way in which some Christians seem to believe that they have a monopoly on morality, as if people can't just behave well without any reference to a deity. She is also utterly bemused by the concept of original sin - it makes no sense to her that even a young child would somehow be guilty just by being human. And she has a perception that religious people can often be very judgemental towards others (e.g. on issues like abortion etc).
  1. She finds it hard to believe in a god who allows so much suffering in the world, and isn't remotely convinced by any of the Christian explanations or justifications for this. She also thinks that the Christian God comes across as being quite cruel in a lot of the Bible stories that she has heard...asking Abraham to sacrifice his son, for example, or repeatedly testing Job. She finds this very difficult to reconcile with the concept of a loving father.

I am not sharing the above to cause offence, but to give you an honest account of what would deter my dd from ever getting involved in the church, despite her interest in all things trivial.

It's tricky because I don't know how you could begin to go about changing perceptions like this. You can't change the entire church, no matter how hard you try. I have met a number of Christians over the years who have been amazing advocates for their faith - never through words but always through the power of their actions and the depth of their care and compassion for the most vulnerable people in our society. Those people are truly inspiring. Sadly, they tend to be outnumbered by the more vocal people who like to talk a lot about Christian values but don't really live by them in any meaningful way.

So, I guess my conclusion is that the best way of encouraging others to take an interest in your faith is not to actively try to encourage this in any way, but merely to inspire them by your own quiet example of a life lived in service to others.

Jet888 · 19/09/2022 19:33

Main thing, don't make anything difficult. I was raised religious then dropped off. Wanted my child to be baptised as I do still believe in God. One church was, 'come to this service for x number of weeks, find x person then we can sign you up a for this long course...' unwelcoming. One was, 'hi, lovely to meet you! Here's our lovely vicar for a chat, we'd love if you could make it, this weekend is a special kids service...' guess which church I've started attending...

missverstaendnis · 19/09/2022 19:32

you could always try waving some candy at them?

Annualleavecancelled · 19/09/2022 19:31

@CapMarvel Oh dear, it seems that teachers never go off duty.

"Like I said, if you can't follow a conversation maybe step away from the keyboard."

In a previous post I was given a 'D' and told to "try harder", so I did do, now I'm told to stop posting 🤔

What's next - the Naughty Step ?😮

CreepyDibillo · 19/09/2022 19:30

AloysiusBear · 19/09/2022 19:19

Also for church service attendance do you have local schools to engage with, invite pupils to services as part of education during school hours.

Please do NOT do this. Parents really do not want churchgoers evangelising to their impressionable children at school. Children are at not at school to be indoctrinated with religion. Most parents of children in c of e schools in the UK are not practising Christians but attend the school due to distance & lack of choice, particularly in rural areas.

You beat me to it, @AloysiusBear ! It's a terrible suggestion and would surely need parental permission as would technically be a 'field trip'.

Jet888 · 19/09/2022 19:29

Make your services memorable too for young people. My church brings the animals in for harvest blessing. Big nativity puppet show at Christmas and dressing up. Big free buffet and eggs at Easter. Advertise them in a 'not in your face religious' way on fb local mums groups etc ie come along and have fun at...one local church hosts a massive family fun day with bouncy castle etc. Most people that go aren't religious, but they know that church congregation is involved in their community

jellybeanteaparty · 19/09/2022 19:28

I think with heating concerns and cost of living offering a warm space and welcome (optional activities?) Would help your local community

AloysiusBear · 19/09/2022 19:19

Also for church service attendance do you have local schools to engage with, invite pupils to services as part of education during school hours.

Please do NOT do this. Parents really do not want churchgoers evangelising to their impressionable children at school. Children are at not at school to be indoctrinated with religion. Most parents of children in c of e schools in the UK are not practising Christians but attend the school due to distance & lack of choice, particularly in rural areas.

PolkaDotMankini · 19/09/2022 19:17

I haven't RTFT but responding to the OP from my experience as a young church-goer, you'll have more success attracting new people if your regular attendees are happy and engaged. Some observations from me:

  • all the activities for women are based on crafts, while the men do camping and fun stuff like that. If it's all about including the older women, then the principle should apply equally to older men. Branch out. Go to crazy golf or paintballing or do literally anything other than crafts.
  • actively engage in discussion about doubts. Everyone has them at one point or another and for many women it will be a life-long struggle of faith vs doubt. Pretending we're all perfect, devout Christians pushes doubters away because they think they don't fit.
  • ease up on the responsibilities for young families. It's not ok to make a father of a young baby have to choose between his family and his responsibilities at church. Family should always come first.
  • on the same note, please don't put mums of young children in charge of the crèche or kids' Sunday school. They need a break from looking after kids, not more of it.
AloysiusBear · 19/09/2022 19:16

Just so there are other people my age to meet. Social situations are difficult for me unless I'm in a 'safe place '

I think OP, while this may be scary and difficult for you, you need to come at this from a different perspective.

It sounds like you want more opportunity for social contact with people your age. Church is your safe space, so you want people to come to church. I think you need to put your energy into developing a broader spectrum of places you consider "safe", as religion is in decline in the UK. Do you have any special interest where you might get social exposure? A sport or hobby etc?

Noviembre · 19/09/2022 19:12

Nothing. Younger people are becoming less and less religious and are probably fourth or fifth generation atheists by now. You can't present Christianity to people who have no interest. They're not going to believe now. Religion means hypocrisy and paedo priests. The only thing you can offer are the usual methods of threatening hellfire, always a winner.

It's dead, let it go with dignity. Bothering teenagers with your personal faith is considered rude.

CapMarvel · 19/09/2022 19:12

Annualleavecancelled · 19/09/2022 18:34

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

Thanks for your interesting response re correlation/causation - much better than calling a theory "utter bullshit" !

I believe I said horseshit AND provided reasons why.

Like I said, if you can't follow a conversation maybe step away from the keyboard.

LetMeSpeak · 19/09/2022 19:11

What type of church is it that you go to. Usually evangelical “born again” Christians tend to have a lot of young people and few older people. Im not religious but what would help is if the church talked about what God can do in their lives. Too many older churches is about simply following rules that many think don’t make sense.

goinback · 19/09/2022 19:09

The scouts and cubs moved from our local church due to the cost and the bureaucracy, too many self important committee members imposing rules. Just hired a local hall instead.
Also for church service attendance do you have local schools to engage with, invite pupils to services as part of education during school hours.

Fundays12 · 19/09/2022 19:07

One of our local churches runs an outdoor toddler group, learning events like budgeting etc, free lunch for the elderly once a week, a winter activity club for kids, bbq in the summer and has a family support worker. They are very community driven and the community like them because of it. Everything is free. They also have a cheap but yummy cafe.

Annualleavecancelled · 19/09/2022 19:05

@ShodanLives

"You heavily implied it."

And the statisticians have de-bunked it, so what is the issue ?

Greensleeves · 19/09/2022 19:04

Ihatecocomelon · 18/09/2022 17:00

Yes we have baby groups and several things on during the week as well as nursery. It just seems people don't believe anymore. It used to be a large turnout and had Sunday school where we would make stuff and play games and stuff for the older kids...but now nothing.

Societies grow and mature just as people do. This society is gradually outgrowing belief systems that hinge on all-powerful deities and the supernatural - it's a normal and healthy process of development. I don't think anything you could do would seriously impact it.

ShodanLives · 19/09/2022 19:01

Annualleavecancelled · 19/09/2022 18:45

@ShodanLives "Does claiming atheism is responsible for crime count as intolerant?"

I never claimed that ^.

I put forward a theory using some figures. The statisticians have already pounced on it.
It all makes for good debate. 😀

You heavily implied it.

missverstaendnis · 19/09/2022 19:00

either people of faith will join or not,
you shouldn't want them to be lured into it??

Annualleavecancelled · 19/09/2022 18:45

@ShodanLives "Does claiming atheism is responsible for crime count as intolerant?"

I never claimed that ^.

I put forward a theory using some figures. The statisticians have already pounced on it.
It all makes for good debate. 😀

Annualleavecancelled · 19/09/2022 18:34

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

Thanks for your interesting response re correlation/causation - much better than calling a theory "utter bullshit" !

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 19/09/2022 18:22

Annualleavecancelled · 19/09/2022 14:41

@Ihavehadenoughalready
"I think it's entirely possible and possibly more likely for a great many to be decent human beings who cares for their fellow humans without formal religion and church"

The last statistics I saw said that 38% of UK population considered themselves Christian and 9% were "other faiths".

We are being told that now we are becoming an increasingly secular society.

At the same time the ONS (office for National Statistics) reports U.K. crime rate & statistics for 2016 was 1.19, a 20.21% increase from 2015. U.K. crime rate & statistics for 2015 was 0.99, a 9.96% increase from 2014

In 2021/22 the number of crime offences recorded by the police in England and Wales rose to approximately 6.3 million, compared with 5.43 million in the previous reporting year. This was the highest number of crimes recorded in the provided time period, with the low number of crimes reported in 2020/21 likely due to the Coronavirus restrictions in place throughout that reporting year.

So it seems that as religious belief has fallen, crime has risen. 😬

Been a while cince I've been able to roll out this old classic but "correlation does not imply causation".

You are implying that less religion belief = more crime. Surely then, the inverse must also be true and more religious societies should have less crime. Yet a quick look around the world will tell you otherwise. Of the top 10 countries with the highest crime rates all have populations where the majority identify with a religion.

  1. Venezuela - 88% Christian (92% identify with a religion)
  2. Papa new guinea - 95% Christian (98.5% identify with a religion)
  3. South Africa - 68% Christian (90% identify with a religion)
  4. Afghanistan - 99.7% Muslim (100% identify with a religion)
  5. Honduras - 87% Christian (90% identify with a religion)
  6. Trinidad and Tobago - 63% Christian (97.5% identify with a religion)
  7. Guyana - 63% Christian (97% identify with a religion)
  8. El Salvador - 82% Christian (85% identify with a religion)
  9. Brazil - 81% Christian (90% identify with a religion)
  10. Jamaica - 67% Christian (79% identify with a religion)

So, based on the above could I argue that more religion = more crime? Of course not, because correlation does not imply causation.

InMySpareTime · 19/09/2022 18:14

Only if this does too:

"In fact, I think you're more likely to be a decent person if you're not blindly following religious edicts, given the brain-washing and judgement that happens among people who claim they love God but end up hating their fellow humans."

There have been far more slurs against Christians and their beliefs on this thread than the other way round.

I'm happy to welcome, accept and love people whatever they believe. That's how Christianity is supposed to work.

I'm saddened that the bad experiences people have had with church and churchgoers have coloured their view of the faith in general, but that's not my experience of church and the Christian faith.

ShodanLives · 19/09/2022 17:45

InMySpareTime · 19/09/2022 09:41

@Thepeopleversuswork If that's an issue, then this thread shows it works the other way round.
The only people on this thread being intolerant of other views are the atheists/agnostics. The Christians on here are understanding of other belief systems and know that most people are not Christians.

Does claiming atheism is responsible for crime count as intolerant?

lap90 · 19/09/2022 17:38

I guess all Churches start somewhere but IMO all the young people potentially interested in attending Church would attend the Churches which already have people of their age group e.g the Hillsongy, HTB style Churches which tend to have contemporary worship, groups (youth, women's, mums, dads etc) and socials (bowling, pizza night, bbq, youth group, weekends away).

Usually these Churches have a contemporary website and are active on the likes of instagram so prospective Church goers can have a feel of what to expect and the demographic of who attends.