Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you’ve never left where you grew up

108 replies

Lasagnafortea · 18/09/2022 14:43

Why not?

Sort of inspired by another thread.

Did you want to leave but couldn’t, never had the yearning to see more? did you want to stay, are you happy?

Just curious really!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
alanabennett · 19/09/2022 21:51

TheTeddyBears · 18/09/2022 20:58

I like where I grew up. I've saw lots of the world but never want to stay away. I live about 30mins away from where I grew up but I'd love to go bk. my dh doesn't like the area. I wish I hadn't agreed to move away from my family I miss just being able to pop in for cuppa with my mum or sister. I wld see them a lot more if I stayed in same area and wld get more help with childcare. Still see them most weeks but it's not the same.

I moved many years before I had kids though so it wasn't as important when I was younger but now I really wish we had moved closer at least.

You're only half an hour away? Surely you don't consider that "moved away from family"? You can pop in for a cup of tea!

SpringIntoChaos · 19/09/2022 08:04

KosherDill · 18/09/2022 17:21

I wanted to but a succession of family issues (family of origin) and then series of eldercare responsibilities, plus a decent job in an industry where decent jobs are few and far between, kept me here. Approaching 60 I really, really regret it and wish I'd had the gumption/selfishness to move.

Why would it have been selfish? I just don't understand this thought process at all. You are absolutely entitled to live your own life (even if other people try to make you feel guilty about it...you 💯% don't have to! That's on them, not you!) 🤷‍♀️

mac1974 · 18/09/2022 22:27

I love the town I grew up in and am happy to raise my children here. I feel they are safe and we have a good support network. We are also close to our ageing parents which has been a blessing when they have been ill. I do often ponder moving out of area to somewhere with bigger houses which would allow us to be mortgage free but my business is here, the kids are happy here, schools are good & DH work is close by. It's near a major city & airport so travel & culture is easy to access. There's not much not to like. I also think it will be more difficult for the kids when they are teens if we move to a more rural location.

Hallowbat · 18/09/2022 21:17

I’m an only child and if I’d left my parents wouldn’t have anyone else around them plus I really like my hometown

thelastgreatdynasty · 18/09/2022 21:14

I moved to an affluent village a few years ago. The closest local town has a particular area where people are born and tend to stay within a small radius. I find it really difficult to comprehend. Lots of hard working tradesmen family's that stay in the first house they lived in as an adult and generally do up to a very high standard. I grew up in a similar area and had such itchy feet to move as soon as possible z

MomJeansBumJeans · 18/09/2022 21:09

I moved away and then came back to care for my grandparents

They've died now and I'm desperate to move away again but my mum guilt trips me into staying.

How do people relocate long distances while selling a house? Looks so difficult and scary but I'd love to.

If I die here, I feel like I wasted my life! No jobs, deprivation, education could be better etc

Aconitum · 18/09/2022 21:06

I live in the same town I grew up in. Our family goes back generations here and there are loads of us still here. Parents and both sisters live 10 minutes away in the next village.
Never really travelled apart from a few package holidays but I love my house and garden and don't miss the hassle of travelling (mainly caused by DH hating anything different and being a grumpy stressy sod if he has to do anything outside of his comfort zone). Worked for the same very good company for 43 years.
I wanted DS to go to uni, travel and see the world, work abroad, go skydiving, all the things I didn't do, but no, all he ever wanted was to to be a mechanic and now runs the garage in our village and lives next door to me😁😁😁
Comfortably early retired now and on childminding duties so can't see much changing in the near future.

tsatr · 18/09/2022 21:06

I’m an only child, as is dh. Still living in area of birth. Both sets of parents are elderly and rely on us a lot, and want to see their grandchildren regularly.
If it wasn’t for a sense of obligation we’d have moved long ago, we’ve had more than one child deliberately and also brought them up to be independent and not feel that they have to look after us in old age. We have another area of the UK that we have every intention of moving to when able.

donttellmehesalive · 18/09/2022 21:01

I grew up somewhere beautiful and never wanted to leave. I went to uni and came back. I always knew I wanted to have a family here and for my children to have my childhood. I travel into the nearest city for work and go on lots of UK, short haul and long haul holidays, so I've never thought of myself as less traveled. I love that dc are attending my old schools, that they're surrounded by family, that I have so many friends here. I have friends who moved away but don't necessarily live interesting or exciting lives.

TheTeddyBears · 18/09/2022 20:58

I like where I grew up. I've saw lots of the world but never want to stay away. I live about 30mins away from where I grew up but I'd love to go bk. my dh doesn't like the area. I wish I hadn't agreed to move away from my family I miss just being able to pop in for cuppa with my mum or sister. I wld see them a lot more if I stayed in same area and wld get more help with childcare. Still see them most weeks but it's not the same.

I moved many years before I had kids though so it wasn't as important when I was younger but now I really wish we had moved closer at least.

DelilahBucket · 18/09/2022 20:55

I did leave, although not that far away, then came back to the same town, different area. My dad lives here, it was affordable, and other than my dad it was in the middle of all other parents and close to the motorway for travel. It just ticked all the boxes. Good schools for DS as well. I didn't want him going to a secondary school where we used to live.

workiskillingme · 18/09/2022 20:53

I live where I grew up as do most of my close social network- one of the least 'close minded' people you could meet

NameChangedForThis12398 · 18/09/2022 20:50

Always lived around this area that should say

NameChangedForThis12398 · 18/09/2022 20:49

Name changed as so outing. I live in Oxford in a good location. Also lived around this area. I'm close to the town centre with the universities and amazing buildings, lovely restaurants and shops. Never got bored of the museums that ive been going to since I've been tiny. Then I'm also close to the amazing countryside. I love going on walks and swimming in the river in the summer. Also its close to other beautiful places. Love walking around Blenheim palace on a sunday afternoon. I've obviously been to other places in the UK and have liked them but nowhere is as nice as here. I'm quite content.

PeaceLily2000 · 18/09/2022 20:43

HikingBoots · 18/09/2022 16:07

What a strange question.
I don't live in my home town - I went to Uni 3 hours away, then settled in my Uni city where I met DH, then we relocated to live in a national park.
But surely living where you're from, surrounded by a strong relationship network of extended family and friends, is the most natural thing in the world!?

Agree with this.
These threads always come across as condescending to people who haven't moved away as if there life experience is less valid because of that. Doesn't mean we've never left the country and are closed minded (as PP said)
Being close to family is invaluable to me. I live in a small city with lots of jobs opportunities and also in commutable distance to other larger cities. I own my home and will happily raise my family here.
I also appreciate that where I live is not for everyone - different strokes for different folks.

Strawberry0909 · 18/09/2022 20:41

I've stayed with 5 miles of where I grew up (couldn't afford to live in the same village!) I didn't go to uni, but got a job after college and professional qualification, I was lucky this was only a few miles away so I don't even have a commute.

Met DP at 16, we bought our house 8years later after doing some travelling now have 2 DC who will go to the same school my parents did

I like being close to all my family, only 2 minutes from my DGP's , its fairly common around here to not move far, only within a couple villages

KILM · 18/09/2022 20:37

Teateaandmoretea · 18/09/2022 19:24

im not stuck in the small town mindset. (Which very much does exist, weird old fashioned ideas all the way to hostility to outsiders) however i do meet city dwellers who seem to think all small town people are small minded and stupid too which i find very entertaining.

The people you describe are just narrow minded. Moving around wouldn’t help them. Insular places are actually mainly caused by poverty, not people not moving around. Poverty stops people mixing with different people, travelling, having opportunities to meet very different people through work, thinking others have more opportunities etc etc

I absolutely agree to an extent but we're actually a pretty well off town and many of the people i was thinking of have not grown up in poverty - working class yes, but not poverty.

Bitbloweyoutthere · 18/09/2022 20:20

I hated my town. Boring, miles from anywhere shithole, one street, everyone knew your business. Never, ever going to move back there.

Went to uni. Had no plan of what to do after uni. Moved in with a twat from my home town.

Left twat. Moved 20 miles away. Met dh. Ended up moving 10 miles from where I grew up, so that i could be close to gp if we had kids. Bigger sithole, but better transport.

It's not what I thought I would do, but it has its benefits:
I know the area and am local enough, but not got the history that comes with growing up in one place. I didn't go to school with anyone round here.
I'm pretty much 20 minutes, max, from anyone I want to see.
I appreciate that everywhere is boring when you grow up there.
I'm 30 minutes from the beach in one direction, forests in another and cities in another. Granted, you need a car though.

Ori1 · 18/09/2022 20:18

I left my village to go to Uni, in London. Didn’t enjoy living in London, missed my family & the place I grew up in. Moved back home, met myDH n a night out with friends at a pub 2 miles down the road & the rest as they say, is history. Now I live in the neighbouring village to my parents and his are in the village less than half a mile in the other direction!! We live a stone’s throw from the hospital we were both born in & where our two sons were born.

Before meeting me, DH lived in America for a time, working there for a big company. I lived in France for a while & travelled extensively in Europe beforehand as well. We both had failed relationships in our pasts, so it does feel a little bit like destiny!!

CoreyTaylorsbiggestfan · 18/09/2022 20:10

I also think it totally depends on what makes you happy and what you want out of life. (Also as I've said previous I do love the area I live in!)
The biggest part of my life is my family and if I don't see them at least weekly I miss them. I love how my niece comes to my house and it's like her second home and my daughter is the same at my sisters house.
My family and my in laws aren't 'in each other's pockets' we would always text or ring before going to each other's houses. When grandparents weren't/aren't well we have been there.
I work as a nurse in the community and see a lot of families struggle with relatives living far away, sons and daughters stressed as they can't get to their parents quick enough to help in situations etc and as I've got older I do appreciate family being close.

Pollyforever · 18/09/2022 20:08

Most people I know live in the city we were born in. People I work with from other local towns commute back to their town. I can't fathom how many people on MN don't live where they grew up because that's completely different to my life experience.

SilverGlassHare · 18/09/2022 20:00

It does depend very much on the kind of work you do as well. My husband has a tech-y job that could be done at many different firms all over the country, but I’m in an industry that’s very centred around London and a few cities in the south, so until Covid and wfh became so widely accepted, I couldn’t have stayed where I was born (in the north west). My cousins all have jobs like teaching, admin, cooking, building, shop work etc which aren’t region specific, and I have often felt envious that they have the family all around them - especially once I had DS and had no local family support.

Suetwo · 18/09/2022 19:56

Still live in my home town in Essex. Like most people who stay, it certainly isn’t out of affection. I hate the place. I stay because of loved ones (ageing mother, disabled sister).

When I was a kid, this was a fairly peaceful little town, quite rural actually. Now it’s an overcrowded dump. The population has trebled since I was young, and developers have squeezed ghastly rabbit hutch ‘houses’ onto every available piece of land. The roads are a nightmare, and 24/7 you can hear the screeching and explosions of modified exhausts. Even driving to Tesco is stressful and exhausting. God knows what it will be like in 20 years. Uninhabitable I should think. I will urge my daughter to get her degree and then emigrate somewhere peaceful, somewhere she can actually move and breathe and enjoy nature.

scrivette · 18/09/2022 19:51

I didn't go to university and got a job straight away. I bought a house 5 minutes from my parents when I was 24, I married my husband when I was 26 and he was the brother of my friend and also loved locally (despite him going to uni and living elsewhere).
When we purchased a house we were still within 5 minutes of both sets of parents and both sets of siblings.

I don't feel I have missed out, I love the area we live in and don't want to move elsewhere.

SilverGlassHare · 18/09/2022 19:51

I was chatting to my hairdresser about this. She was saying she’d recently separated from her partner and now lived in a house right between her mum and her gran, and I thought how lovely that must be, for her and her children, and for her mum and gran too.