Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how many calories you eat in a day to lose weight?

66 replies

talomon · 18/09/2022 13:00

I was told by my PT to eat around 1000-1100 to lose weight. I find it almost impossible to function properly - I am losing weight very slowly, but always hungry and frankly quite miserable.

I am also told by a GP friend that this is ridiculously low.

But when I increase the calories to 1500 or so I gain weight.

I measure and weigh everything, eat healthy, lots of water and lean protein.

For reference I am 5 3' and 69kg.

OP posts:
Darbs76 · 18/09/2022 20:24

It will vary dependant on height, current weight, how fast you want to lose it, age. Best is to check TDEE - they will give you an idea how many to eat. For me I don’t lose it I eat more than 1100 as I’m very short and don’t have much to lose. I did lose 24lbs in lockdown 1, I ensured I did 15k steps a day minimum, often well over 20k. I still do around 15k a day. It’s a real effort but I gain easily due to my height

5128gap · 18/09/2022 20:21

I'm 5' 4" 8 stone 10 and 53. I only need 1600 to maintain my weight. If I put a little on I lose it by dropping to 1300 and taking long brisk walks, as I find it really hard to take in all the nutrition I need on any less.

SunscreenCentral · 18/09/2022 20:20

Age is a big factor. Metabolism slow down is a bastid.

Luredbyapomegranate · 18/09/2022 20:17

I would

Change your PT, or at any rate stop talking to them about your diet.

Use MyFitnessPal or something and experiment with 1450 a day - lots of protein and fibre to fill you up. Give it 3 weeks and if you have lost anything stick with that or otherwise drop to 1400, try again for 3 weeks.. repeat

I doubt you need to go too far under 1500, your PT is a mentalist, or at any rate not a dietician.

If you are totally foxed go see a dietitian. And then if they are foxed (unlikely) they can refer you to Gp for tests.

You have to be patient though, you aren’t very overweight, it’s going to take a while. Aim for a sustainable couple of pounds a month.

Proteinpudding · 18/09/2022 20:10

Change your PT. Yes 1100 will work, ie you'll lose weight, in the short term but it isn't healthy or sustainable. If you've got to the point that your daily energy experience means you can only lose weight by dropping under 1200 calories you need to do some foundation work first.

I used to only lose weight if I stuck to 1300 calories a day, maintenance was 1500. I was miserable. I was late thirties, 5ft2, around 58kg which isn't big, but I didn't carry it well (was all on my stomach)

I listened to a podcast called 'why women should bulk' by MindPump. I used to like doing weights at the gym so i got back to that, and ONLY that - I didn't try and eat 'healthy' (ie eat lower calories) at the same time.

My body started to change, the scales did not for a while, mentally it took some readjustment but I was happy with that as my clothes fitted better (arms a bit bigger, waist a lot smaller) I then started tracking my food out of curiosity just to see what I was taking in, and it averaged around 2200-2300 calories a day. I now lose weight if I eat 1900.

Honestly it has been a revelation for me. I am so much happier that I've got enough muscle on me to use up the food I take in, that I can eat full size meals and not worry about it. I'm approaching mid 40s and suspect it'll change a bit with menopause but it's a much better place than I was in a few years ago.

Murdoch1949 · 18/09/2022 19:47

1500 cals to lose weight.

CoastalWave · 18/09/2022 15:39

Whatever your target weight is x 12

But you need probably to eat at least 1800 cals.

cherrybonbons · 18/09/2022 15:29

I read somewhere
3500 calories = one pound of fat.

So put yourself in that deficit a week.
You should only be aiming to lose 1-2 pounds a week anyway for it to be sustainable. You want a lifestyle not a quick fix.

Your PT is shit for suggesting 1100 calories and I would lose all faith in him.

Also what are your long term goals with a PT? Are you planning on getting stronger- do you weight lift or just cardio.
She/He shouldn't be telling you calories. They should be telling you protein. You cannot train and sustain on that low calories. You will feel horrendous and your body will hold on to every single bit of nutrition.
Start eating more- 1400-1500 and you will see a positive impact

Worried234 · 18/09/2022 15:23

5 9" and 62kg. 1300 calories and around 18000 steps per day.

Theredjellybean · 18/09/2022 14:10

Everyone is different and it is well recognized that our perceptions of portion sizes and calories burnt through exercise are usually not accurate.
The bottom line is , if you are eating more calories than your body is using you will gain weight, so yoou need to lower your calories to below this to lose.
I have never lost weight on anything over 1200 calories.

ramabanana · 18/09/2022 14:09

57kg at 5’4
I would need 1200 to lose noticeable weight but it’s still slow going, 1500 is maintenance at low activity levels

It’s surprising how only a couple hundred calories can make a difference, maybe try 1300 and see how that goes

Gonewiththewindbeforelong · 18/09/2022 14:02

I did keto800, that’s 800 Cals a day which I realise may be difficult, but it worked for me. The things that were stopping me losing weight were sugar and carbs. Once I got hold of the sugar and carb addiction I started to see real results.

I can honestly say I didn’t feel hungry on it, and it was very achievable for me. I drunk a lot of water and reckon my hunger was often mistaken for thirst.

I lost two stone that I was able to sustain and everything improved; bloods, heart rate, cholesterol etc.

DashboardConfessional · 18/09/2022 13:59

I've just lost 15lb. I ate 1300 a day.

Polimolly · 18/09/2022 13:57

I need 1450 calories just to breath, keep my organs going, keep hair and nails healthy etc. Any less than that and my hair starts falling down. I'd rather keep my weight loss very slow than lose my hair

Bestcatmum · 18/09/2022 13:54

I'm 60 now and cannot eat more than 1000 calories a day to lose weight and I have to do a daily walk of at least a mile as well.I don't feel at all ill on that, I also do intermittent fasting.
When I was in my 20's I could get away with 1400 calories and still lose weight quickly.
Unless my husband was a qualified nutritonist I'd be ignoring him and doing my own research.

Coldilox · 18/09/2022 13:51

5’7, 150lb and I lose weight if I stick to 1700 calories, as long as I am fairly active

mrsmalcolmreynolds · 18/09/2022 13:47

According to an online calculator I had a look at just now, assuming you are quite active and mid 30's, about 1450 calories should result in loss of about half a kg per week. 1100 is very low indeed and as for the person who mentioned 500 to 800, I felt faint just thinking about it!

I didn't measure calories religiously when losing weight but I think it was an average of about 1700 - less Mon to Thurs and more the other days as then I had wine! I am 5'8" and started at 85kg. Lost 15kg steadily over 6 months at which point I was happy enough, although due to the eating habits I'd established another 4kg have come off without actively trying. Seems stable at 66kg now.

From my own experience I'd say viewing it as "a diet" isn't helpful - for me what worked was eating a bit less volume, and lower calorie options, at almost all meals and having very few snacks. One a day, a low calorie option like a skinny whip bar or similar.

losingit31 · 18/09/2022 13:46

I was 68kg, I'm 5ft 4 (barely) so very similar to you. I started low carb on 10th August and have already lost 11.5lbs. I am not hungry and I've been so busy studying that in those weeks since I started I have been to the gym once. I also live somewhere that is currently too hot to walk or exercise outside without melting. I have a sedentary job and my average step count is less than 5000/day. I think it's not so much about calories but about macros - when I track my calories it's about 1400 average but without the carb and sugar crashes I am simply not as hungry as I used to be.

EveSix · 18/09/2022 13:44

Depends on so many things, as PPs have pointed out, including how quickly you are expecting to lose weight.
If you're fine with a slow steady loss over many months, you definitely don't need to restrict as drastically as that.
Cut down on carbs and try some intermittent fasting. Once I cut out bread, pasta, rice, potatoes and high sugar fruit, and ate between 12:00 and 18:00, I could pretty much stop thinking about how much I ate. The weight has melted off easily (without adding any exercise bar a fortnightly swim and just everyday business) and a diet high in protein, fat and vegetable fibre meant I have never felt hungry.
Be a tortoise, not a hare if possible, OP, and good luck!

PeloFondo · 18/09/2022 13:40

5ft 10 and exercise 4 times a week (spin classes mostly)
I try and stick to 18:6 fasting and eat lunch and a small snack, so maybe 1000 cals a day. Am losing 1lb a week Sad

newsaint · 18/09/2022 13:35

The standard reference daily intake for a woman is ~2000 cals, to "stand still".

I would aim for ~1,500 but on top of that also make sure you are getting the recommended 12,000 steps in per day. Activity levels are a big part of the equation.

That activity will burn off a few hundred more cals and then you should be doing well.

The feelings of hunger and misery are more psychological. Of course we get hunger pangs and things when trying to shed weight. But you can overcome that - focus instead on the reward when you reach a healthy weight and can then enjoy food more.

Who is in charge here? You, or your appetite?

Buzzinwithbez · 18/09/2022 13:30

It's far too low. At one point I realised I don't burn much more than that without exercise, so I've got to add a walk a day to be able to eat enough to feel ok, create a calorie defecit and loose weight incredibly slowly.

However, then I started a low carb high fat diet with very relaxed intermittent fasting - I eat first in the day once I'm properly hungry, rather than aiming for a set time. So I end up going 14-18 between last meal in the evening and first of the day. I don't count calories. The weight comes off easily and I feel great.
I do quite an active sport, so started playing with this because the spikes and dips in blood sugar became really troubling.

mondaytosunday · 18/09/2022 13:29

1700 and I'll lose about 1-2lbs a week if I also increase my walking to at least 8000 a day. I'm tall and post menopausal.

oxydant · 18/09/2022 13:29

5'4" 10 stone 1350kcals a day, lift weights 2/3 times a week

garlicandsapphires · 18/09/2022 13:27

500-800 and I lose about 2 lbs per week. It’s working well at the moment and once I get into the swing of it I feel fine. One large nutrient dense meal a day.