Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave my 16yr old for a day

117 replies

Hamandeggs1 · 18/09/2022 08:27

My daughter has recently turned 16 and has recently started college. Her dad and I have been invited to an event next Saturday and then to a friends for dinner and drinks, we will be away from around 12pm to 10.30pm. We will be around 25mins away in the next town. My daughter is outraged that we will be leaving her on her own and makes me feel guilty. She has friends at college and some still at school but will rarely meet up with them outside of this although i try to encourage it, so she spends all her weekends, holidays and nights either with me or in the house.
She is confident with us at home but shy and quiet around others, especially other adults. She is desperate for a part time job but finds it difficult to speak to others.
She isn't clingy with her dad, just me and would be quite happy if it was just me and her together all the time.
I try to encourage her to join clubs etc and have even joined a few hobbies with her but she either won't do them or gives them up after a few weeks.
I take her out and spend time with her as much as I can outside of work but she is annoyed when I go to my hobby because I am not doing something with her, even although she refuses to join the hobby with me.
I will leave her dinner which she is perfectly capable of heating up herself but aibu to leave her most of the day. She will have college work to do next weekend so we wouldn't be going out that day anyway.
And how do I get her to be more independent, I feel I've tried everything.

OP posts:
LAWinterofOurDiscountTents · 18/09/2022 15:50

JustDanceAddict · 18/09/2022 08:41

At 16 that’s fine in theory, but it sounds like she won’t be happy. We def left alone all day at 16, but we also worked up to that stage.
At 17 we started leaving overnight.

Is this a joke? At 17 I lived in my own apartment in a different country. At 17, my DS was in college across the country.
Such babying

Lcb123 · 18/09/2022 15:38

It sounds like a big jump compared to your usual life/contact. Maybe you need to work towards a whole day. I was left home alone at 16 for a week but had very independent relationship with my parents

Singleandproud · 18/09/2022 15:05

If there are no SEN then you need to get her some counselling to learn coping strategies for her anxiety.

What hobbies does she do? Something that helps build resilience would be good although it's a bit on the late side possibly look into guides, scouts, cadet groups etc.

What hobbies do you do away from the house? Perhaps you need to start leaving her alone at home regularly, either go to an exercise class or something or you and your DP go to an evening theatre/cinema show or restaurant or even an evening walk.

misskatamari · 18/09/2022 14:55

Lol, so true @Aixellency We were on holiday recently and the rental didn't have Netflix etc, so had a look in the local (giant!) supermarkets to see if they had any cheapie dvds, as we'd forgotten to take any. They just didn't seem to exist anymore! Checked our local Tesco when we got home too, nope, not a sausage!

Aixellency · 18/09/2022 14:36

Nothing useful to add.

I was just so struck by some words in a post:

buy a dvd that she wants

and rather felt I’d wandered into some time slip novel - Tom’s Midnight Garden, perhaps!

spagbog5 · 18/09/2022 13:54

Our dd is a real home body and has lots of friends but isn't that keen on doing much at the weekends.
She has been very anxious in her life from tiny but is in sixth form now and definitely much more independent.
She would have her friends round or adore the house to herself in your dd situation.
It's difficult as the parents of a needy child to step back and allow them to experience things they are not comfortable with as we are almost programmed by the situation to make it easier for them but it's really really important for their self worth and esteem to allow them to get on with it.
It has taken time and patience on our part to get dd to a place of being confident in herself and not needing us - mainly me - constantly.
Don't cave in this instance and have a serious chat with her about why she feels so reliant on you and what she thinks will happen when she's alone ?
Our dd likes us being around but would have no problem with what you are proposing and I would never have thought it possible that next month we are leaving her at home while we go away for a couple of days and she will have her friends over.
It's hard to change the dynamics but you need to be tough and kind and things will improve.

Oucht · 18/09/2022 13:21

When I was 16 I was going to over 18 and 21 nightclubs every weekend. Worked a weekend job and my parents would leave me to go on holiday!

mountainsunsets · 18/09/2022 13:20

While most 16yo's would be absolutely fine, it's clear that your DD suffers from some extreme anxieties and IMO it actually wouldn't be fair to just go ahead and leave her for 10+ hours as things stand.

Her behaviour (calling you constantly when you're out) is extreme - what have you done to address this? She needs to see the doctor and potentially get started on some medication to help her cope with normal life.

beachcitygirl · 18/09/2022 13:16

A little of both. Clearly shes anxious & that wont be fixed overnight. Is there a compromise ? Could you afford to all make an overnight of it? Hotel room in the town. A premier inn or the like?
She can relax there with a movie & room service & you could maybe nip past for 10
Mins thhroughout the day? At very least you would both feel more comfy being so close? If the event is in a hotel - is there a possibility of a day room there? X

Yanbu for wanting to go
She is nbu for being anxious

Good luck to you both op Flowers

Norriscolesbag · 18/09/2022 13:01

Although it’s lovely you are so close you must be desperate for a break OP.

It is probably because it’s my life every single day (single parent of 3 autistic children)… but something is screaming out to me here with the very limited info I have read. It might be worth speaking to the SEN department at your school about this and any other concerns you have and seeing what they and her teachers think.

Oblomov22 · 18/09/2022 12:53

I can't believe you even need to ask. Seriously? If no SN, surely you must know all the answers given.

Friarclose · 18/09/2022 12:34

I'd be OK with leaving my 12yo for that long.

She's being silly, you need to go and be cruel to be kind otherwise she'll never learn to be independent

Anothernamechangeplease · 18/09/2022 10:38

I think maybe you need to change your own mindset about this, OP.

Right now, you are understandably feeling sorry for your dd because she doesn't seem to have the kind of life that you had at that age, so you're bending over backwards to make up for that in other ways. And you're feeling guilty about the idea of leaving her to fend for herself for an evening.

I think you need to shift that guilt and recognise that, actually, you'll be giving your daughter a valuable opportunity to push outside her comfort zone and learn that she will actually be fine on her own for an evening. Help her to plan it out...buy a dvd that she wants, or something, invite a friend over etc. She needs this opportunity to build up her confidence and it's your job to help her cope with it... not cave into her fears and believe her when she says she can't do it. She needs you to believe that she will be fine... because she will be fine.

Sapphire387 · 18/09/2022 10:38

I refused to go on a family holiday at 16, so I spent a week at home alone. I enjoyed the independence (and no, I didn't throw any house parties!).

A day is fine.

mumonthehill · 18/09/2022 10:31

She is lacking essential life skills and you now need to start giving her responsibilities and building her confidence. I would certainly go, she needs to know that your life is not wrapped around hers. Perhaps give her times during the day where you will message to check in, get her to have a friend round. She cannot depend on you forever and you need to step back to let her grow up. In 2 years she might be off to uni or entering the job market and she needs to start building the skills to do this.

ultimateforks · 18/09/2022 10:30

YANBU op but you need to follow through with this

She will never learn to be ok with being alone if she isn't forced to get used to it even when uncomfortable

Just a word of warning, my mum did this for my brother who was anxious being left alone at 16, so she never left him if he was upset. He is now 26 and still calls crying when she is on holiday because he is home alone. She hasn't had a stress free holiday in over a decade.

RIP the plaster off. If she needs help with the anxiety then also tackle this at the same time. Either with medication and/or therapy.

Butterfly44 · 18/09/2022 10:22

Normally yes but it sounds like your 16yo is quite anxious and that's the issue at hand here.

Skinterior · 18/09/2022 10:17

She's 16!

What the hell do you think is going to happen? The biggest worry should be that she's going to have a party and trash your house, not that she's going to feel lonely or a bit scared.

She's a whole life time of sometimes being alone ahead of her. She's certainly got a whole lifetime of sometimes being a bit scared. Part of being an adult is accepting and navigating that.

Unless you live somewhere very dodgy I'd go. This will do wonders for her confidence, even if she's not happy about it now.

INeverSawAPurpleCow · 18/09/2022 10:15

At 16 I used to stay with a friend (also 16) while her parents went away and she babysat her younger siblings. This was 45 years ago. Why not suggest your daughter have a couple of friends over to keep her company?

Marvellousmadness · 18/09/2022 10:10

She sounds very very immature.

And you? You enable her behaviour op

Sorry to say it but you do

She is 16.

We used to go out clubbing all evening and night at 16!
She should be able to be by herself for the day or something is fundamentally wrong

But I feel like this is her having not a lot of friends and you stepping in to be her bestie.

You are not her friend. You are her mum. And you are going to need to act like one op. To help her.
Because all you are doing now for her? Isnt helping

It is keeping her small. It is keeping her sheltered
It is bubblewrapping her and not preparing her for life.

Step up by stepping away. Gradually over the next weeks/months. Shell be better of for it

misskatamari · 18/09/2022 10:08

On the face of it, of course you're not being unreasonable, and at 16 she should be fine with this.

However, it seems like there is a lot of anxiety on her part, and that's something i can really relate to. I had awful separation anxiety as a child/young adult. It's not something you can control, so the fact that she "should" be fine with this, doesn't magically make it so. This is something you guys need to tackle, as she needs to learn to manage her anxiety and become more confident in these situations. I would really really recommend you both read the book Dare by Barry McDonagh. I had debilitating anxiety for years, and this has been the most helpful thing i have read (it is super accessible and simple, and might help her understand how she is feeling, and feel empowered that she can tackle it, and feel more confident and okay). In terms of next weekend - I would make a plan with her of how she can fill her time, maybe get some nice treats in, help her structure the day and evening a bit, mentally, so she feels prepared and not abandoned and aimless etc. If it would help, maybe have a couple of times when you will check in with her (this isn't ideal of course, and is something you want to work on reducing, but as it's so soon, and she's feeling so uncomfortable about things, it might help provide some comfort and reduce the chance of her calling you etc).

Overall, i think you should go, but do your best to prep your daughter and help her feel safe and confident before hand. oooh and i really recommend rescue remedy for anxiety as well. Maybe it's the placebo affect, but who cares, it does really help with calming. Good luck, and i hope you have a fab day

AluckyEllie · 18/09/2022 10:04

The day away from you becomes irrelevant in a way- however that goes you need to start cutting the apron strings to prepare her for adult life unless you still want her living with you at 30! Therapy to get to the bottom of it, would she go if you went together?

Could you stop answering the phone to her when you are out? Meet up with friends more so she gets used to you being less available? Does she help around the house- do laundry/know how to cook etc? Could you start asking what her plans are for when she finishes school to prepare her/plant the idea that she will be an adult and you’d like her to fly the nest?

You’ve got a couple of years but good to start now so you aren’t coming back on the board in a few years to say ‘my 18 year old won’t leave and wants to do everything with me.’

orangeisthenewpuce · 18/09/2022 10:03

Just leave her. She's 16 not 6. And ignore her complaining about it.

Anothernamechangeplease · 18/09/2022 10:00

I really don't think it's just the dd being selfish. There is clearly something else going on. The OP said that her dd is "desperate" to find a PT job but that she struggles to talk to people so has been unable to pursue this.

It sounds to me like she has crippling anxiety, or something similar, that is really holding her back. The GP would be my first port of call.

cestlavielife · 18/09/2022 09:59

Hamandeggs1 · 18/09/2022 09:27

I did work when she was younger, I had her young and she was in nursery full time from 18 months but I though it was good foe her to be interacting with other children. Perhaps I was wrong, but I was doing what I thought was right for our family at the time.

You did fine
There is something else at play here
Get some professional input
Encourage her to get out volunteering or working on saturdays