Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Prince George and the Queen's funeral

309 replies

KTKismet · 18/09/2022 05:17

Can't sleep and read this:

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11222927/Prince-William-Princess-Kate-considering-taking-9-year-old-George-Queens-funeral.html

AIBU to think "palace aides" should wind their necks in and leave Prince George alone, rather than insisting he attends the queen's funeral.

He has a lifetime of service ahead of him, surely they should preserve his childhood as long as possible. I think it's hugely inappropriate, AIBU?

OP posts:
LouLou198 · 18/09/2022 08:48

I've never understood why children are kept away from funerals. As I child I wasn't allowed to attend the funeral of my great grandmother. I was 11 at the time. I felt excluded and that I didn't have chance to say goodbye properly. My dc have always been given the option and have attended. I think it really helps them process what has happened.

YennefersDress · 18/09/2022 08:48

People are not thinking of the best interests of the child.

I'm sure his parents are better placed to judge what is best for him than Mumsnet.

LiveInSunshine · 18/09/2022 08:47

My first reaction was ‘of course he should go!’, it’s normal for a 9 yr old to go to their Grandmother’s funeral.
But having dwelt on it I changed my mind. It’s not normal to go and be filmed throughout and televised for the world to see. One inappropriate smile or yawn on camera and he’ll be 50 and still having that picture analysed. He’d be 60 and making a gaffe and probably have it brought up that he was an inattentive/ rude child too.
A private goodbye is enough. I wouldn’t expose my 9 yr old to the pressure in front of possibly the UK’s biggest ever TV audience and the worlds press. I’d protect them. My 9 yr old is a lovely thoughtful child, but I’m sure they’d lose their composure briefly at points and look tired or inappropriate briefly- that’s what kids do. And he won’t understand the consequences of not being perfectly composed.

Nocaloriesinchocolate · 18/09/2022 08:43

George’s parents wouldn’t be able to grieve properly (in their heads - I’m sure they’ll strive not to show emotion - though why not is a different topic) if they were worrying all through the service about their 9 year old child and alert to his every wriggle;

TeenDivided · 18/09/2022 08:41

The state funeral is 1hr, though there is the coming and going. The length of itself is not unreasonable for a 9 year old. There are of course masses of other factors. I trust W&K to make the decision they think is best for George.

CatsandFish · 18/09/2022 08:39

knittingaddict · 18/09/2022 08:36

There's a big difference between a mother of young children who died in a tragic and preventable accident and a very elderly woman dying of old age.

Both of my children went to family funerales around the age of 9. Neither have been damaged in any way by it. I think by the age of 9 children have some understanding of death and funerals can be helpful in the grieving process.

There is also a big difference in a small civilian funeral, and a massive televised one that will last for I think at bare minimum 2 hours (not including wake and then another private interment later on). It's too long for a 9 year old. It's just not fair on him. People are not thinking of the best interests of the child.

sponsabillaries · 18/09/2022 08:38

My DC1 is almost exactly the same age as George to within a few days and I wouldn't hesitate to take them to the funeral of a grandparent or great-grandparent who had had a natural death at the end of a long life. However obviously we are not royals and our family funerals are not televised.

I think there are ways that they could protect him here - bringing him in through a side entrance, seating him discreetly with a trusted adult like a maternal grandparent - but that would defeat the object of making him 'visible' at the service. No nine-year-old, no matter if he is second in line to the throne, should be used in that way.

knittingaddict · 18/09/2022 08:36

KTKismet · 18/09/2022 05:37

you are worried he's not noticed his great-grandmother has died and he'll get a shock at the funeral?

Obviously not this @AnImaginaryCat

It's more in line with what @daretodenim is saying. He's 9, it's not a usual family funeral, it is a media circus.

Both William and Harry have commented that walking behind the Queen's coffin was triggering for them/ that their mother's funeral in front of the cameras shaped much of their lives.

I'm not a fan of the usual royal stiff upper lip at funerals and have been encouraged seeing actual emotion this time round (how many of us would go to a close family members funeral and not be upset!!). However I think 9 is just too young to have to have him in front of cameras, trying to control his emotions and attend his great grans funeral.

There's a big difference between a mother of young children who died in a tragic and preventable accident and a very elderly woman dying of old age.

Both of my children went to family funerales around the age of 9. Neither have been damaged in any way by it. I think by the age of 9 children have some understanding of death and funerals can be helpful in the grieving process.

Abraxan · 18/09/2022 08:28

MrsDThomas · 18/09/2022 07:49

People die. Kids know that. They need to attend funerals to understand that dead people aren’t taken to heaven by angels!

especially with his future. This is what it is.

There is private service later which he could attend, along with the other great grandchildren.

It's the large scale, mass televised one that he doesn't need to be going to, simply to be paraded in view to appease the public who want to see a 9 year old boy grieving at his great grandmother's funeral,

You only have to see how some of the media focused in on the 14y grandson at her vigil yesterday, or his mum's face - simply to fill papers and websites of 'grief stricken child and mum' type headlines and photographs. It's just not necessary for a young child to do this in the public gaze, especially when there is a private service for the family he can attend.

Fizbosshoes · 18/09/2022 08:24

DS came to my Dads (his gd) funeral when he was 9. We explained what it would be like and gave him the choice, and he wanted to come (he didn't come to the crematorium)

However the service was probably less than an hour,( plus a wake afterwards) we could cry, laugh, hug, hold hands without anyone (hopefully) judging and it wasn't filmed and broadcast all over the world. And the Queens funeral looks like it will last (and hence they will be "on show") all day

hollyivysaurus · 18/09/2022 08:19

The private family burial, absolutely fine for him to attend. As a mother I don’t think any of the children should have to go through that media circus.

KTKismet · 18/09/2022 08:16

The private funeral at Windsor is obviously very different to the State funeral.

My comment about preserve his childhood has nothing to do with hiding the fact his great grandmother has died... As a previous poster has said that would be some feat if they had managed to keep that hidden. It's about the fact it seems unnecessary for a child to be wheeled out for optics. Particularly when there are so many rules about who walks where/ sits where etc and as someone else said, it's unlikely that he can be nestled between mum and dad for a snuggle if he gets upset or overwhelmed.

At Wimbledon, the weather and heat were unseasonably warm, he was still expected to dress "appropriately" royal... Shirt and tie! That seemed ridiculous to me! I get it prepares him for the life ahead where there is a lot expected of you but, as a mum of two, it was shorts and t-shirt weather for kids not shirt and tie! Sometimes the optics seem to take precedence.

Again in relation to shielding from death, I was raised Catholic and attended many funerals where the coffin was brought home, open casket for prayers for days before, so it's not about hiding death. We openly discuss it, and my 5 year old chats about the fact the queen died, and is going "into her grave" on Monday.

OP posts:
GhostFromTheOtherSide · 18/09/2022 08:15

Christ I am sick of hearing about harry and William walking behind Diana’s coffin.

A, it was their mother.

B, there was a lot of publicity surrounding her death based on the manner in which she died.

C, she was 33.

The queen was 96. She had reached the natural end of her life. And the children will already be aware that A, their great granny is likely to die soon, a child of 9 is going to know that whoever great granny is, I remember hoping mine would at least live to 100 so she could get a telegram from the queen. Also their great grandad died recently so they know about old people dying.

And b, there are protocols surrounding these things.

toomuchlaundry · 18/09/2022 08:15

@TeenDivided the afternoon Windsor service is being televised too

EbbyEbs · 18/09/2022 08:13

NewYorkLassie · 18/09/2022 08:12

even his own wife

What century are you stuck in?!

You think they’d let him marry Sharon the barmaid from Croydon? Come on.

And do think they’d let him marry a bloke?

carefullycourageous · 18/09/2022 08:12

Sirzy · 18/09/2022 08:07

As with any funeral it is up to the parents to decide what they feel is best for the children.

Well yes but also part of 'what is best' in the thought process of the parents in question is 'will attending increase or reduce George's chances of becoming monarch'!

NewYorkLassie · 18/09/2022 08:12

even his own wife

What century are you stuck in?!

NewYorkLassie · 18/09/2022 08:10

This funeral is going to go on for hours

It’s not. It’s scheduled to last an hour. Much shorter than some of the other formal occasions he has to sit through.

TeenDivided · 18/09/2022 08:09

toomuchlaundry · 18/09/2022 08:04

@TeenDivided there is another service in Windsor in the afternoon and then the internment in the evening. It’s not just an hour

Well yes, but that's not 'The Funeral' we are talking about. Or at least not what I was talking about. There are various bits to the day, but the public bit is the State Funeral 11-12.

ShepherdMoons · 18/09/2022 08:07

@hopeishere watched by millions. It's a very unusual situation for a funeral so not typical of the usual experience.

Sirzy · 18/09/2022 08:07

As with any funeral it is up to the parents to decide what they feel is best for the children.

CatsandFish · 18/09/2022 08:05

My tv guide shows the coverage will be several hours, just for the funeral.

hopeishere · 18/09/2022 08:05

There's a huge difference between walking behind the coffin of your mum who died in a terrible accident, with your dad, who she was divorced from and during a weird unexpected outpouring of public love and going to the funeral of your great granny who died peacefully of old age.

lavenderlou · 18/09/2022 08:04

Sorry, great-grandparent's funeral

toomuchlaundry · 18/09/2022 08:04

@TeenDivided there is another service in Windsor in the afternoon and then the internment in the evening. It’s not just an hour

Swipe left for the next trending thread