Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Prince George and the Queen's funeral

309 replies

KTKismet · 18/09/2022 05:17

Can't sleep and read this:

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11222927/Prince-William-Princess-Kate-considering-taking-9-year-old-George-Queens-funeral.html

AIBU to think "palace aides" should wind their necks in and leave Prince George alone, rather than insisting he attends the queen's funeral.

He has a lifetime of service ahead of him, surely they should preserve his childhood as long as possible. I think it's hugely inappropriate, AIBU?

OP posts:
ajandjjmum · 19/09/2022 19:28

I thought they were brilliant, and it was clear that their parents know them well, and knew they'd handle it.

It is an occasion they will remember for the rest of their lives.

Pinkpeony2 · 19/09/2022 19:21

PotatoHammock · 18/09/2022 06:12

"Optics", or whether billions of adult viewers would like to see him there shouldn't come into it. This shouldn't be framed as whether he would cope (he probably would) but whether it would be beneficial TO HIM.

I've found it "triggering" just watching Harry and William this week. I feel very strongly that childhood grief should be kept away from the cameras. I 100% would not want him trotted out for the supposed benefit of "us", the public- it would make me feel guilty for watching, knowing that I was in some small way feeding into that decision.

Oh jeez. It’s NOT about him! This whole funeral is not about any ordinary old lady passing away. I’m sure in another life none of the queens children would be wanting to be watched by billions of people attending their mothers funeral.
It’s not about them. It’s not about William or the children or even Elizabeth. The crown comes first, second and third. The tradition and duty and service come first. Why don’t people realise this? If the children can possibly manage then they will be expected to, particularly George. It’s not an ordinary family where the individuals needs might come first. That’s the pay off. You don’t matter so much as a human. The crown matters.

Craftybodger · 19/09/2022 19:16

I thought both the Wales children did incredibly well. In hindsight I think the service at Windsor would have been more than enough.

LucilleDarlingtonUnexpectedly · 19/09/2022 19:10

Having been through trauma himself and being aware of the issues I highly doubt William would have taken George if he wasn’t sure his son would be able to cope with it.

gnilliwdog · 19/09/2022 19:09

Poor little mite. he's probably seen hundreds of animals killed and dying in front of him now, since he apparently has been going on hunts since the age of 5. At an age when most kids want to make friends with animals and read stories about them. This is just another step in the toughening up process. Yes, I know it's a way of life and he's got to learn how to be royal, but I feel sorry for him all the same.

MissAmbrosia · 19/09/2022 19:08

The children were certainly old enough to go and to understand what was happening. I'm getting so fed up with all the "why are they doing this, why are they doing that, how very dare they?" stuff. People inventing motives for people they don't know from Adam.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 19/09/2022 19:04

W&K would not have taken both of their eldest children had they not thought they would manage. Get a grip.

antelopevalley · 19/09/2022 19:04

The private family funeral afterwards fine.
The state funeral that is for the media and public, no.

maeveiscurious · 19/09/2022 18:59

My DCs have been attending family funerals since they were small. Death is part of life

WhiteFire · 19/09/2022 18:55

I personally think the children (G+C) were included in a very sensitive manner in the end. This morning I had read that they would be walking behind the coffin but I am pleased that they were actually in the car. There was also very little camera focus on them. Catherine was always by their side.

hoopmatrix · 19/09/2022 18:52

Remember the royal family are going through change now and things can get shakey- popularity etc. I believe they want to show the future king to let us know they will be around for many years!

Hearthnhome · 19/09/2022 18:39

joles12 · 19/09/2022 18:24

I don’t understand why everyone thinks this is about optics? William & Katherine care deeply about the children- like all parents - as PPs have noted it is not a surprise that the Queen died and she is their Great grandmother - who knows what the next funeral might be? Better to go along now - perhaps George asked why he didn’t attend Philips funeral? George is definitely old enough to know his own mind.

Because the Op wrote that the Palace aides should ‘wind their neck in’ and not be encouraging the children to attend.

But advising is exactly their job. And they are advising on Optics. That was the story the Op linked. Palace aides wanted George to attend to send a powerful message. ie optics. Why would they wind their necks in, when they are doing their jobs?

However, I would be a years salary that if William or Kate thought it would be too upsetting for the kids they wouldn’t have let them attend. Of course it should be their final decision. And yes, George and Charlotte likely did want to attend.

All decisions the RF make, including this one would consider the optics. To pretend it’s not part of it is quite naive.

joles12 · 19/09/2022 18:24

I don’t understand why everyone thinks this is about optics? William & Katherine care deeply about the children- like all parents - as PPs have noted it is not a surprise that the Queen died and she is their Great grandmother - who knows what the next funeral might be? Better to go along now - perhaps George asked why he didn’t attend Philips funeral? George is definitely old enough to know his own mind.

Hearthnhome · 19/09/2022 10:29

Of course optics are important. Why would you believe they aren’t?

But I am sure that Optics aren’t the main consideration of the parents. It will be for the Palace aides, because that’s their job.

It’s entirely likely that in this case that what the parents of the children, think is best also works for the Optics.

KTKismet · 19/09/2022 10:26

Porcupineintherough · 19/09/2022 09:59

Does anyone really believe these clickbait articles in the gutter press ? "Insider of the palace/friend of Prince Harry says" is the new licence to journalistic (and I use the word lightly) invention.

Grow up OP you are too credulous.

Now now @Porcupineintherough no need for insults! I am grown thank you.

As it happens... It appears George and Charlotte will attend the circus state funeral... Clearly optics more important.

Enjoy your day!

OP posts:
HRTQueen · 19/09/2022 10:26

I agree it’s almost impossible to do the right thing for children of the most senior royals they are open to public scrutiny and the pressure they are under to do what is considered right for the monarchy will clash with what is right for the child

no protective parent would want the press at their child’s first day at school or have their every moment watched while in public but this is what they are being prepared for. It’s must be very difficult for Kate and William and I can completely understand why Harry and Megan made the decision they did

Georgeandzippyzoo · 19/09/2022 10:12

Should children go to GGP funeral ? Yes if they WANT to but let's be realistic todays events are not a 'funeral' that 99.9999....% would be going to.
They are on the world's stage, being recorded, watched probably by billions of people , the family may have the stiff upper lip but thousands are lining the way and there will be mourning/tears from them. They will have to act with expected protocol and that is nothing about saying goodbye to a beloved ggm or understanding death of a loved one.
I know they have their personal service which will be good for them, but as others have said I don't need to see a child trotted out behind the cortege because it's 'protocol', 'establishment' or expected.

maddening · 19/09/2022 10:04

I think the Palace aids should be more discreet and stop chatting to journalists every 2 seconds

Porcupineintherough · 19/09/2022 09:59

Does anyone really believe these clickbait articles in the gutter press ? "Insider of the palace/friend of Prince Harry says" is the new licence to journalistic (and I use the word lightly) invention.

Grow up OP you are too credulous.

BellaCiao1 · 19/09/2022 09:34

@sponsabillaries @Hearthnhome @Willbe2under2

Thanks for the reply. I suppose I thought it was strange (and I did have to google) that Princess Margaret's son and another cousin of the Queen took precedence over grandchildren.

Anyway, as you say all the precedence, pomp and ceremony overrule what we deem normal.

User287264 · 19/09/2022 09:14

This is a family who bow and curtsy to each other even in private according to a strict order of precedence. What we would consider normal family precedence doesn’t apply here

Thank goodness I'm just a commoner.

5128gap · 19/09/2022 09:04

I think its impossible to do the right thing by a 9 year old child within the institution of the monarchy. I think W&K do their best but their decisions can't be seen through the lens of ordinary parents.
Few parents would decide their child's role and lifetime commitment at all, much less without thought to the child's wishes, personality and aptitude. Prince George was born into a family where his role is more important than he is as a person, and parental decisions will reflect that.
I'm not sure why people are so concerned about this one decision, while ignoring snd upholding the more disturbing context in which it's been made.

sponsabillaries · 19/09/2022 08:33

BellaCiao1 · 19/09/2022 03:57

If I have read the Order of Service correctly, it seems none of Zara Tindall or Beatrice, Eugenie or the Wessex children are taking part in the procession? It doesn't seem right George and Charlotte take precedence over the Queen's actual grandchildren.

This is a family who bow and curtsy to each other even in private according to a strict order of precedence. What we would consider normal family precedence doesn’t apply here. The grandchildren’s relationship with the Queen was acknowledged in their vigil.

Blossomtoes · 19/09/2022 06:27

Being there makes no difference to us adults watching, but I do feel the adult George as a future King most definitely would value looking back and being able to say that he was there at the funerals of all the monarchs that lived in his lifetime.

Spot on. He’s now second in line to the throne. The constant implied criticism of the Wales’ parenting is pretty offensive. They appear to me to be doing a pretty good job.

ThinWomansBrain · 19/09/2022 05:10

Given his fathers experience of the media circus for his Mother's funeral when only a few years older, I can understand why he would want to protect his son from that.