Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Prince George and the Queen's funeral

309 replies

KTKismet · 18/09/2022 05:17

Can't sleep and read this:

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11222927/Prince-William-Princess-Kate-considering-taking-9-year-old-George-Queens-funeral.html

AIBU to think "palace aides" should wind their necks in and leave Prince George alone, rather than insisting he attends the queen's funeral.

He has a lifetime of service ahead of him, surely they should preserve his childhood as long as possible. I think it's hugely inappropriate, AIBU?

OP posts:
katepilar · 19/09/2022 20:00

daretodenim · 18/09/2022 05:32

Going to his great grandmother's funeral could be a healthy thing.

Going to his great grandmother's funeral when the world's cameras will be on him, he's only 9 and there's a media circus going on? No. That's entirely different.

If he was smuggled in the back of the church and could sit out of sight of anybody other than close family, then that's different. But that's not why he'd be there. The idea is to show "continuity". He's 9. His grandfather is working the "continuity" right now and his father too. Unless they're incompetent, then they should leave the child out of it.

I agree with this!

EbbyEbs · 19/09/2022 19:59

LordEmsworth · 19/09/2022 19:58

Why are those the only options you can imagine?

And who is "they"?

They: the royal family

The only other option I can think of is that he adopts a child with his husband?

Applesonthelawn · 19/09/2022 19:59

We do our children no favours by hiding them from the realities of life including death. She was his great grandmother, not his mother, so it is not comparable to William and Harry's experience. Neither were the circumstances of her death tragic. I think they are the right age to know that old people die and what it means. Most importantly, their parents guided them through it. Kids can manage pretty much anything if someone trusted shows them the way through it.

spanieleyes · 19/09/2022 19:58

He becomes King and, when he passes, the next in line comes next! Plenty of monarchs died without issue, there is always someone next in line somewhere!

LordEmsworth · 19/09/2022 19:58

EbbyEbs · 19/09/2022 19:56

Can anyone answer this …

What happens is George turns out to be gay? No natural children … no further heir …

would they just tell him he’s simply not allowed to be gay (!!?) or make him abdicate to Charlotte?

Why are those the only options you can imagine?

And who is "they"?

Missingpop · 19/09/2022 19:58

I think his parents are the best people to judge if he’s mature enough to attend his grannies funeral; it’s definitely not down to palace aide’s; William & Kate are grounded enough to choose what’s right for their family unit as will Peter Phillip & Zara Tindle.
Whatever they all choose the children will be surrounded by a loving family who will all be on hand to take good care of them.

BlueRidge · 19/09/2022 19:57

"because this lot look to be on borrowed time."

Really? You must have been watching a different Jubilee and funeral from the rest of us then.
Estimated viewing figures worldwide of over 4 billion? I don't reckon theyr'e going anywhere yet.

EbbyEbs · 19/09/2022 19:56

Can anyone answer this …

What happens is George turns out to be gay? No natural children … no further heir …

would they just tell him he’s simply not allowed to be gay (!!?) or make him abdicate to Charlotte?

carefullycourageous · 19/09/2022 19:55

Pinkpeony2 · 19/09/2022 19:48

I think that’s just your wishful thinking there.
They will be around for many generations after you have long gone.
If the last 10 days hasn’t shown you that then you have your head in the sand.

I don't think anyone knows which way the monarchy story will go from here. Today was the end of an era, we will never see funeral like it again I think.

Support for the monarchy is not what it was and it declines as you drop down the age brackets. Time will tell, I am just hoping we don't have to have yet another fabricated culture war about it.

MargaretThursday · 19/09/2022 19:54

I think actually they were a good age. Old enough to understand enough, but young enough that joining in makes them feel grown up and the pomp and ceremony exciting rather than a bore.

When dd was 5yo her beloved great grandma died. She chose to come along to the funeral, and it was the right decision for her. I can say with confidence that if it had happened when ds was 5yo he would have chosen to stay behind, and it would have been the right decision for him.

William and Kate are parents, just like me, just like most of you. They are making decisions for their children, and it will make it far easier for them to make the right decision if they don't see this sort of thing picked over on the internet/press.
Let's trust them to make the right decisions for their children-and if sometimes they do make a wrong one in our opinion, well, I've no doubt all of us have sometimes made wrong decisions for our children but with the best of intent, so we're all in that same boat.

goodbyestranger · 19/09/2022 19:53

I don't believe it's wishful thinking at all. I may well be more realistic then you. Time will tell.

goodbyestranger · 19/09/2022 19:52

Sure, here's just the most recent example. Check out the William pegging/ further affairs stuff and then trace how long it took before the kids were photographed in public doing happy family things.

NanaNelly · 19/09/2022 19:48

Craftybodger · 19/09/2022 19:16

I thought both the Wales children did incredibly well. In hindsight I think the service at Windsor would have been more than enough.

After seeing both services today I think the one at Windsor was beautiful and there was no need for the one at Westminster.

Pinkpeony2 · 19/09/2022 19:48

goodbyestranger · 19/09/2022 19:39

There's a massive charm offensive going on atm. These two kids are wheeled out as part of that, just as they were today. Every time Twitter trends with another negative story about William, the next day sure as eggs are eggs out they come with the kids holding their hands in a happy family display. I hope that George is being brought up with a there-may-be-no-throne-for-you-son angle, because this lot look to be on borrowed time. They'll still be crazy rich, may well be happier. Win win for everyone.

I think that’s just your wishful thinking there.
They will be around for many generations after you have long gone.
If the last 10 days hasn’t shown you that then you have your head in the sand.

marlathome731 · 19/09/2022 19:46

I don't see that it's anyone's business other than the children's parents, whoever they are. I certainly don't appreciate being told what is best for my children. I think people giving unwanted and unasked for opinions and advice is more harmful than parents doing what they believe is right thing. I watched the whole funeral and saw no 'media circus' or anything that warranted raising concerns regarding the safety or wellbeing of the Queen's great grandchildren. They appeared at ease and incredibly well behaved. Of course funerals are 'triggering' for the vast majority of us - many people have lost loved ones in all kinds of traumatic and heartbreaking circumstances. Death, and the paraphernalia that accompanies death, is a natural part of life. Shielding children from this is, in my opinion, misguided and harmful. The Queen's great grandchildren witnessed their parents and wider family honouring their GGM in a dignified and loving ceremony. What could be more natural than that?

ajandjjmum · 19/09/2022 19:45

goodbyestranger · 19/09/2022 19:39

There's a massive charm offensive going on atm. These two kids are wheeled out as part of that, just as they were today. Every time Twitter trends with another negative story about William, the next day sure as eggs are eggs out they come with the kids holding their hands in a happy family display. I hope that George is being brought up with a there-may-be-no-throne-for-you-son angle, because this lot look to be on borrowed time. They'll still be crazy rich, may well be happier. Win win for everyone.

Can you give me a couple of examples of this, as I genuinely haven't noticed. I know that Kate and William have been fairly sparing in the exposure of their children, and normally they are taken along to events that they would have an interest in. I've never seen it as a counterbalance to any negative press, as you suggest. Thanks.

Bebethany · 19/09/2022 19:44

It’s part of his training for when it’s his turn!!

Navigatingnewwaters · 19/09/2022 19:43

KTKismet · 18/09/2022 05:37

you are worried he's not noticed his great-grandmother has died and he'll get a shock at the funeral?

Obviously not this @AnImaginaryCat

It's more in line with what @daretodenim is saying. He's 9, it's not a usual family funeral, it is a media circus.

Both William and Harry have commented that walking behind the Queen's coffin was triggering for them/ that their mother's funeral in front of the cameras shaped much of their lives.

I'm not a fan of the usual royal stiff upper lip at funerals and have been encouraged seeing actual emotion this time round (how many of us would go to a close family members funeral and not be upset!!). However I think 9 is just too young to have to have him in front of cameras, trying to control his emotions and attend his great grans funeral.

Their mums funeral was an entirely different kettle of fish to attending your great grandmothers.

BestBeforeddmmyy · 19/09/2022 19:41

I think it is terrible to put a 9 year old through all that.
But then again, I also think that all the pomp and circumstance around the death of the Queen has been completely over the top. I think it has been an ordeal for the whole royal family and plenty of others besides. I would never want to live a royal life. It’s all ridiculous. But I know that’s a very unpopular opinion.

BlueRidge · 19/09/2022 19:40

Absolutely, @ajandjjmum
There is no way William or Kate would have let their children attend today's events if they thought they wouldn't have coped well with it, regardless of expectation.
As you say, times have changed. Remember for their wedding? When William went to the Queen to say that he and Kate didn't know any of the dignitaries invited (as protocol dictated)? She told him to scrap the list and start again, with their own wishes going first.

goodbyestranger · 19/09/2022 19:39

There's a massive charm offensive going on atm. These two kids are wheeled out as part of that, just as they were today. Every time Twitter trends with another negative story about William, the next day sure as eggs are eggs out they come with the kids holding their hands in a happy family display. I hope that George is being brought up with a there-may-be-no-throne-for-you-son angle, because this lot look to be on borrowed time. They'll still be crazy rich, may well be happier. Win win for everyone.

ajandjjmum · 19/09/2022 19:36

StolenWillowTree · 19/09/2022 19:31

I really don't believe George and Charlotte, or Will and Kate, had any say in the matter at all.

Attendance at major royal events is mandatory for all heirs. George has been trained since birth to put duty first and been moulded to his pre-destined life. He won't get the freedom to make any kind of major life choices for himself and that's why the training and moulding starts from a young age.

Nothing to do with whether children should attend funerals or not. They could have attended the private funeral. This was about optics and duty.

Duty above all things.

I think you're very wrong. I also think that William has a lot of power, and would use it to protect his children if he felt it necessary.

Times change.

StolenWillowTree · 19/09/2022 19:31

I really don't believe George and Charlotte, or Will and Kate, had any say in the matter at all.

Attendance at major royal events is mandatory for all heirs. George has been trained since birth to put duty first and been moulded to his pre-destined life. He won't get the freedom to make any kind of major life choices for himself and that's why the training and moulding starts from a young age.

Nothing to do with whether children should attend funerals or not. They could have attended the private funeral. This was about optics and duty.

Duty above all things.

Goldencarp · 19/09/2022 19:31

Where do these stories come from? It’s in the Daily Mail so it must be true 🙄

Imissmoominmama · 19/09/2022 19:30

His sister was there too, wasn’t she?