Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I hadn’t got a dog

111 replies

Ihatemydogbmnamechange · 17/09/2022 23:41

Before people say what a horrible arsehole I am, I didn’t want a dog but gave in to years and years of pressure from everyone else in my family and now I am stuck with a dog who is ruining my life. still a puppy but is showing some possessiveness around food and I wish with all my heart I had never got him. My daughters are so happy my wife is happy but the dog can be awful to them too.

i hate everything about having a dog.

when is it ever going to get better z

ive sat and cried tonight becssue i wish I could go back in time

OP posts:
Wereeaglesdare · 18/09/2022 08:07

Day 1 put food in bowl take a chair sit by the door
Day 2 put food in bowl move chair closer
Day 3 take a handful of food drop it in to the bowl
Day 4 take two handfuls of food drop it in to the bowl
Day 5 put food in the bowl and then have a handful of food let ur dog take it out ur hand.
Repeat day 5 for a few days

If your the hand that feeds and not the hand that takes away the dog learns to not be insecure about its food.

Tumbleweed101 · 18/09/2022 08:03

I always stroked mine from small
puppies while they were eating and
added food to the bowl so they saw contact while eating as a positive thing.

Dogs are very hard work through the puppy and teenage stage but once through it they are much easier and if you have trained them
well then this is the point it starts
to be worth it.

Sometimes I think how easy life would be without the dog but he does bring an element of fun and companionship to the family that we would all definitely miss if he was no longer here.

My dogs worse trait is that he barks a bit too much, including at dogs on TV! Can’t watch anything that might involve dogs while he’s in the room.

HikingBoots · 18/09/2022 08:02

"Sigh. Another muppet who got a dog to keep up with the Joneses and will end up dumping...sorry rehoming...it."

This is super helpful thanks so much. I wish you nothing but the kind and helpful attitude you’ve shown here to be reflected at you in everything you do.

Oh sorry, my bad. I forgot about the 'Be Kind' movement that we women must adhere to at all times 🙄

BirmaBrite · 18/09/2022 07:45

How old is the dog ?
What do you mean by 'My daughters are so happy my wife is happy but the dog can be awful to them too' ? What is the dog doing ?

Darbs76 · 18/09/2022 07:15

Sounds like resource guarding. This needs to be very carefully managed. You need the help of a behaviourist. If your wife and kids wanted the dog so much they can do the walking / feeding etc. Please keep help on the resource guarding now

Riverlee · 18/09/2022 07:13

Lycanthropology · 18/09/2022 00:06

Puppies are a nightmare. I didn't like dogs but caved and got one. Getting through the puppy stage and toilet training was a nightmare and took longer than expected. I had regrets, to put it mildly.
But then it all clicked into place: dog grew up and got into good habits, and became the softest, most affectionate and well behaved friend. I absolutely adore my dog.
I hope you can have my experience, but if things don't start to improve soon then you should probably re-home the poor thing.

Looking forward to this! At disturbed-night sleep stage at the moment.

ThePoetsWife · 18/09/2022 07:09

Please make you use reward based training. Nave take things of value like toys or food from the dog - do a swop instead with something of a higher value.

Mai sure the DC know never ever to go near when dog is eating. Drum this into them. Same with their friends. Even better keep all high value toys and food out of reach. .

rookiemere · 18/09/2022 07:08

How long have you had the dog and what age is it ?

We have a dog because DH and DS wanted one. Luckily he's a docile breed, provided he gets lots of walking. But the house is mucky and it's expensive.

I really resented having the dog for about a year. I'm still a tiny bit annoyed about it, but I do love rookiedog so it's ok.

Its easy to say rehome the dog, but then you'll forever be the person that rehomed their dog. I don't know what the answer is - maybe some time stepping back from it. DW becomes main instigator in sorting out training etc. for a while ?

Soymocha · 18/09/2022 07:07

Agree with everything said by @Furries and @PriOn1 .

Puppy blues is a real thing. Please don't be too hard on yourself. I was in a similar situation to you. I spent much of the first few weeks crying and regretting that we had a dog. Before I am flamed for this, puppy blues is a real thing. Looking back, despite all the intensive researching and prep , knowing what you are getting yourself into isn't the same as the actual experience of it. It's a huge lifestyle change.

To get over my puppy blues, I threw myself into training to raise the dog that we wanted. It really helped. It provides a different focus for you and it's also important for everyone to have a well mannered dog.

We've always hand fed kibble from day one. We still do almost 9 months later. We always make her sit and wait for permission before she can eat. As well as the basic commands in @Furries post, training a release word is also a useful one for self discipline. You can do this daily when feeding or playing ball games. E.g. put dog in sit and wait, chuck the ball and dog doesn't go for it until you give the release word. Our release word is "okay". Training self discipline really helps create a calm and well mannered dog.

We do a lot of mental training and enrichment too. Short bursts definitely tires our dog out more than walks. Our breed was chosen because of its trainable nature though. All of this helps to create a calm puppy which means dog is happy and we're all happy.

Get your wife and kids onboard. Hopefully, it isn't all falling on you which might be contributing to how you're feeling. My DH and kids insisted on the dog. I'm pretty firm that we are all in it together and not just the fun times and cuddly times. Even my 8yo will pick up dog poo. They also have to train the dog daily (ours is not quite 9 months so training is still constant). I want the dog to see my DH and kids also as the source of all good things so it listens to all of us.

Before I got my dog, I spoke to lots and lots of friends who had dogs. Nobody ever mentioned any regret but only positive things. Once I got my dog, they all confided that they all found the puppy stage horrendously hard and were filled with regret. Not sure why they didn't tell me before I got the dog but I think there's some shame around admitting puppy regret. Or worries about the responses they'll get especially judging by some of the posts on here.
The good news is that it does pass. They would all say the dog is their life. I only know one person who gave their dog back to the breeder after 8 weeks.

There are lots of FB groups that can provide emotional support and advice too, including from dog trainers. Might be useful to join some? There's likely to be one specific to your breed as well. I found this hugely helpful and felt less alone and overwhelmed discovering that everything I was feeling and going through was shared by so many dog owners. I got a lot of great advice, encouragement and support as well.

We all love our dog so much but, goodness, the first couple of months was so hard!!! If you can, do join a puppy group or find a support group. It really will make it a lot easier to be surrounded by others going through the same stage or who have been there and can understand.

Carla2601 · 18/09/2022 07:05

This is normal with a puppy, it’s like a new baby it makes you tired and jaded and frustrated but it will get better!

definitely get a trainer in so you can nip any issues in the bud early and good luck

ChagSameachDoreen · 18/09/2022 07:02

Rehome it. Dogs are a nightmare.

Ihatemydogbmnamechange · 18/09/2022 07:00

to answer some questions.

  1. everybody does their bit
  2. i walk the dog at least once a day for at least twenty minutes but normally between half an hour and an hour
  3. i can feed the dog it’s food one piece at a time and it will sit patiently
  4. i know I can rehome it but I said yes and I have made my bed and I have to lie in it
  5. the dog is very good in a lot of ways
  6. the dog is very large but a very gentle breed
  7. se have had a dog trainer
  8. I am due on my period so it’s possible I’m having a bit of an emotional reaction to it’s behaviour
  9. the dog is only possessive around it’s food and toys in some circumstances and we are trying to work on thie
  10. i have spent hours training rhe dog
  11. i do not like dogs in general but I agreed because everyone else did. If I had said no we would not have one. I have no one to blam e but myself
  12. i need
OP posts:
OperaStation · 18/09/2022 07:00

LovelyDaaling · 18/09/2022 00:02

Possessiveness around food? Bad sign that none of you are handling that dog well. You have to speak up now and rehome it asap.

Or just train it properly, like all people with dogs should be obliged to do for the safety of their families and the general public.

Ihatemydogbmnamechange · 18/09/2022 06:51

HikingBoots · 18/09/2022 03:01

Sigh. Another muppet who got a dog to keep up with the Joneses and will end up dumping...sorry rehoming...it.

This is super helpful thanks so much. I wish you nothing but the kind and helpful attitude you’ve shown here to be reflected at you in everything you do.

OP posts:
mycatisannoying · 18/09/2022 06:32

The puppy phase was one of the hardest times of my life. It does get better. I wouldn't be without my dog - he's the best. even if he is naughty

PurpleFlower1983 · 18/09/2022 06:32

Puppies can be a nightmare! Take some puppy classes and dedicate some time to training and you will be fine. Hopefully you researched the breed before you got one.

dewisant2020 · 18/09/2022 06:29

It's so so common to feel like this when you get a new puppy, I remember when I got my dog and despite always wanting one I absolutely regretted it for the first few months.
The puppy stage is tough going, all I can suggest is bearing with it, try and remember they are a baby and will grow up soon enough.
I love our dog with all my heart now and wouldn't be without him but if someone offered to take him a few years ago I would have jumped at the chance.
Lots of owners feel the same and if you research it on the internet it is such a common feeling at first

Furries · 18/09/2022 06:28

BooseysMom · 18/09/2022 03:20

Exactly why I haven't caved in and joined the masses. I'm not having our home stinking, endless barking, chewing, pooing, weeing, jumping up at people ..and all that after paying over a grand for the privilege.. and that's before any trips to the vet.

The neighbours are dog sitters. The barking really grates at our nerves.. DH works from home so it's worse for him. Their home stinks and the dogs are untrained, boisterous yobs that jump up at people and they appear to think that’s perfectly normal.

Completely get where you’re coming from. But there are breeds that have low propensity for barking. And you train them to wee and poo outside!

And it’s fairly simple to train dogs NOT to jump up at people.

Vet trips shouldn’t be too much of a problem. Insurance isn’t too expensive.

Furries · 18/09/2022 06:21

OK - a few things to unpick first:

What breed is the dog? This is the most important thing. Most breeds have inherent traits which will affect the best way to train/motivate them.

How old is the puppy? Again, depending on breed, age matters.

How many are in your family? Am guessing 2 adults and x children. The age of your children will have an impact on how to manage your puppy.

What is your home set-up? Are you rural? Are you in the suburbs/a town/a flat? Do you have a secure garden? Etc

The “puppy blues” are a real thing. Pretty much everyone I’ve interacted with over time has had that “what the fuck have I done” feeling at some point during the puppy stage. So DO NOT beat yourself up for feeling like this. What you need to do is get practical. Having answers to my questions above would help, but in the absence of info specific to your set-up, some basic advice would be as follows:

For the food possessiveness. When dog is given its food, train it to sit before bowl is put down and wait until you give the signal for it to eat. Manners are really important! If you have young kids, do not let them near the dog when eating. Do not let anyone in the family feed scraps from the dining table etc. if your dog is in the room with you when you are all eating, do not let him beg/pester at the table - teach them early to move away and lie down elsewhere. If you do want to give them some scraps, it should be once everyone has finished and those scraps go in their bowl along with their usual dinner.

With regards to training, the best thing you can do as a family is to agree on your commands. The absolute basics are “sit” “down” “stay” plus “wait”. If possible, look into videos demonstrating hand signals for those four commands. Try to develop those if possible. Every voice is different - on top of that, every voice in a different emotional state is different. But hand signals remain constant, no matter how frustrated you are. Also, I see/hear too many people yelling “sit down” to their dogs - poor dogs are likely thinking do you want me to sit or lay down?!

Researching the breed of your puppy will be a big help. You need to know what they were bred for - that will give you guidance as to what their strengths are. There is no point trying to get a terrier to retrieve something with a soft mouth! Different breeds will have different motivators - you need to know yours to give you a starting point as to how best to channel their training.

Also, look into recommended puppy schools in your area. They can be a great way to learn some of the basic training methods whilst getting your pup to interact with other dogs in a controlled environment. And also a good way for new owners to vent with each other!

I had a giant breed who posed a few challenges as she matured. The best advice I got was to be consistent with your training/commands. It can be a PITA to begin with, but it’s worth it. My girl sat automatically for her food, she sat and waited for me to step out the door before she followed. She knew not to jump up at people - she’d get fuss if all four paws were on the floor. If you’re consistent with your basic expectations, they will become second nature for your dog.

As an aside, it’s a bit disappointing the amount of “rehome him” posts. Its a puppy - the owner hadn’t had time yet to get over the shock of how much of a responsibility it is. As I said earlier, most people I know who’ve had a puppy have had that “wtf” feeling for a while. None of us told each other to rehome said puppies.

mynewname25 · 18/09/2022 06:09

I was just coming on to post almost exactly what PirOn1 has just said.

If you can do this for a while then the food issues should resolve. I hope things improve and you start to experience some of the nice parts of having a dog.

PriOn1 · 18/09/2022 05:51

“is showing some possessiveness around food”

I used to sit on the floor with a handful of his (dried) food. My hand stayed closed until he stopped worrying at it and drew back a little. Then he would get a piece. Gradually I worked up until he could sit and see the food in my hand and still wait until I fed him it piece by piece.

I’d also sometimes feed him from a bowl, again dried food) and keep my hand on it when he started eating. I would then take the bowl away and add something better than dried food (a small amount of liver pâté or squeezy cheese from a tube) and give it back to him, so he knew that if I took something away, he’d likely be rewarded with something better.

He’s pretty good now with food.

Mehhhhhhh · 18/09/2022 05:26

You are not obligated to keep it, despite what people say. It could live for another 15 years.

BooseysMom · 18/09/2022 03:20

Exactly why I haven't caved in and joined the masses. I'm not having our home stinking, endless barking, chewing, pooing, weeing, jumping up at people ..and all that after paying over a grand for the privilege.. and that's before any trips to the vet.

The neighbours are dog sitters. The barking really grates at our nerves.. DH works from home so it's worse for him. Their home stinks and the dogs are untrained, boisterous yobs that jump up at people and they appear to think that’s perfectly normal.

Lizzy1980 · 18/09/2022 03:17

Wombat100 · 18/09/2022 00:13

It never fails to amaze me how many people on these threads simply see dogs and other pets as disposable. Really sad.

This. When you have a dog they become part of your life but you are their whole life and you need to be worthy of that devotion. Far too many people want a dog but aren’t prepared to put the work in.
Rehome the dog. Whatever you do don’t just give it away to anyone that’s willing to take it. Make sure it’s going to a home where it will be loved and kept for life. I have a friend that fosters dogs and it’s heartbreaking how many dogs are just passed around from one owner to the next. They’re not disposable and the poor things have no control over their own lives. I wish people would stop treating them like toys

MissingNashville · 18/09/2022 03:09

But you did agree to having a dog, you shouldn’t have done this if you didn’t want want one. It’s done now and your wife and kids are happy. Suck it up is all you can do.

Learn to say no and stick to it in future. If your wife doesn’t respect you saying no and puts pressure on you to do things you don’t want, you have bigger issues than a dog.