Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I hadn’t got a dog

111 replies

Ihatemydogbmnamechange · 17/09/2022 23:41

Before people say what a horrible arsehole I am, I didn’t want a dog but gave in to years and years of pressure from everyone else in my family and now I am stuck with a dog who is ruining my life. still a puppy but is showing some possessiveness around food and I wish with all my heart I had never got him. My daughters are so happy my wife is happy but the dog can be awful to them too.

i hate everything about having a dog.

when is it ever going to get better z

ive sat and cried tonight becssue i wish I could go back in time

OP posts:
OldWivesTale · 18/09/2022 10:54

To all those saying just rehome - you do realise that rescues are bursting at the seams right now and many dogs are being euthanized because of irresponsible owners.

BeyondMyWits · 18/09/2022 10:52

It is normal...

I always say I love our dog... he's 11, he grew on me.

But I hate HAVING a dog... all the extra cost, work and lack of spontaneity.

Both emotions can coexist.

Won't get another, but wouldn't wish this one gone.

Soymocha · 18/09/2022 10:47

To add what I've already said and advice given by others above, I always thought I would bond immediate with my dog. I didn't and that was largely because puppies are hard work (and my puppy was actually quite an easy one too. Quick to sleep through, toilet train and crate train). I was the one that didn't want the dog - love dogs but didn't want the responsibility and life change. I'd say that the dog probably has the closest bond with me now and pretty much does everything with me. If I can take her, I do. I look into her eyes and I swear she knows what I'm thinking.

Lucky we have bonded now because mine is going through teenage regression!

Pollydon · 18/09/2022 09:51

My ddog is 8 now.
We absolutely adore him, he is fantastic, had him from 9 weeks.
I have already told DH that I would happily get another dog , preferably a rescue ( live in spain so no shortage of rescue dogs, unfortunately) but under no circumstances will I ever put myself through raising a puppy again. Its fucking hard, for months, then they can get teenage regression like mine did.

Theluggage15 · 18/09/2022 09:32

A couple of years ago our wonderful old boy died at the age of nearly 15. Several months later we felt ready to get another dog and got puppy of same breed and from same breeder. I’d forgotten how bloody awful puppies are and he was actually quite good in some ways, always sleeping through the night was a bonus. But puppies are such hard work, I’d have gladly rehomed him several times during that first year, but he’s now 18 months, well behaved and and lovely, am so glad we have him.

Sounds like you’re doing the right things, he’ll probably turn into a great dog but if you really don’t like him or really hate having a dog then you need to think about rehoming for both your sakes.

RoachTheHorse · 18/09/2022 09:22

Our dog has been hard work. Really hard work. He's got allergies, steals food, used to chew everything he could. There were times when he was little I wondered what the fuck we had done. Teenage puppies are the worst.

He's 3 now and, while dog ownership remains hard and a big commitment, I wouldn't be without him. We have worked with a trainer to help us learn how to solve some of the problem behaviours, and worked with the vet to get his allergies under control.

Now he's a big lump of uncoordinated ridiculousness that I couldn't imagine being without.

If you put in the effort you might be surprised.

Mindymomo · 18/09/2022 09:00

Puppies and dogs are really hard work, by 8 am, we must have told our 4 year old border collie he’s hard work 3 times already today. It takes time to bond with a puppy and yes, we said at around 4/6 months have we done the right thing. It also kicks in around that time that this is your life now, yes it gets better, but the commitment is there very single day and an understanding that your life will never be the same.

neverbeenskiing · 18/09/2022 08:56

I don't have any advice OP but just wanted to say YANBU, I'd hate to have to share my home with a dog. Your DW should not have pressured you into agreeing to a pet she knew you didn't really want. In your position I'd be upset too and more than a little resentful.

There was a thread not long ago from a woman who was "desperate" for a dog but her DH had said no as he really didn't like them, so she was considering getting one anyway against his wishes. Lots of responses from devoted dog owners telling her to go ahead and get the dog, that her DH was a selfish twat, that once the dog is there he'll learn to love it and if he doesn't he can leave, why should his feelings trump hers? etc etc. I was really surprised by the number of posters who couldn't see, or didn't care, how awful it would be to have to live with an animal you didn't like and never wanted, to have to care for it and be jointly responsible for it.

Given the responses on here describing what a nightmare a puppy can be, and how even those who very much wanted a dog often bitterly regret it in the early stages I don't know how anyone could justify pressuring or guilting their DP into such a massive commitment.

OhWelllWhatever · 18/09/2022 08:53

Perfectly normal to feel this way - dogs are such hard work. I'd take a newborn over a puppy any day but rehoming would be the very Iast thing, on a very long list of things I would try to make this situation liveable.

You can fix this but you need the help of everyone in the household. Have a sit down with your partner and children, explain how you are feeling, and outline what you expect of them while training the dog. Take no excuses. This is a family pet and the responsibility falls on everyone's shoulders.

I understand you felt pressured into this decision and it must be awful for you at the moment but he/she is here now and this is fixable. It will be a hard slog over the next few months but will absolutely be worth it in the end. If you still feel the same after the dog is trained then perhaps your partner and children can do most of the care since it is them who wanted a pet but i suspect you will come around once the dog is better behaved.

Living with a puppy is a nightmare but if you're not actively trying to fix this then you're setting yourself up for 15 years of frustration and resentment.

Good luck

Noteverybodylives · 18/09/2022 08:51

I think the more you resent it, the more difficult it will be.

You have to just accept that it’s part of the family now and make the most of it.

FWIW I’ve had dogs all my life but they’ve always been adult rescues. I then got a puppy and I struggled so much!
It was like having a baby all over again!

Puppies/young dogs are cute but they can be hard work.

Carry on putting the effort in now and in a few months time you’ll have a completely different dog.

MoggyMittens23 · 18/09/2022 08:49

Charlize43 · 18/09/2022 08:35

Oh that poor dog! Please rehome and at least give it the chance to have a great life with an owner who loves it instead of hates it. The kindest thing you could do would be to find it a good home.

But then they'll get judged by people for seeing the dog as disposable and giving up on it. Can't win!

Velvian · 18/09/2022 08:48

Can you throw some money at the problem? Get a really experienced dog sitter/walker to take the dog out on a long walk 2 or 3 times during the working week. Yiu would get a break and the dog would come back tired out.

I sympathise a bit, we rescued an older dog, as the DC love dogs. I WFH, so I am the dog's favourite person 😅. It gets a bit much at times.

We deliberately went for an older dog to try out dog owning for just a few years.

Y7drama · 18/09/2022 08:47

I really wanted a puppy, had grown up with dogs and really wanted own. But I didn’t realise how hard it was. Mine was an arsehole until 18 months!

OrangeKettle · 18/09/2022 08:42

To the posters with their snidey comments “oh look, another one who got a lockdown dog and now sees them as disposable”….. 🖕

I wanted one for 3 years. Then lockdown came so I delayed. I used the time to put money aside to see if I could afford the insurance, food, dog walker etc. I found training classes. Researched dog sitters and found out who would be willing to help me.

I spent a year deciding on the breed and talking to dog owners.

I got him as we were coming out of lockdown (and actually I still worked and kids went to school so our routine didn’t change anyway).

I cried every day for weeks. Up until a year of having him, I’d have quite happily have given him away.

Now, I love him and wouldn’t be without him. He has a couple of issues that stress me out - chasing / barking at men and reacting to bigger dogs (he’s been attacked 4 times by bigger dogs). But I can live with that because he’s such a good boy otherwise.

Puppy blues are a thing and snide comments are unhelpful and actually show how much you don’t know about people.

Charlize43 · 18/09/2022 08:35

Oh that poor dog! Please rehome and at least give it the chance to have a great life with an owner who loves it instead of hates it. The kindest thing you could do would be to find it a good home.

twistyizzy · 18/09/2022 08:33

Either train it or re-home for the safety of everyone. Sounds like the start of resource guarding and if not handled correctly can seriously escalate. Everyone has to be on board and be consistent for the training and contact a qualified behaviourist to help.
If you don't want to do this then please, please re-home so the dog can be placed with people who actually care about it.
Agree with the comment about pets being seen as disposable, this has resulted in the growth of puppy farms etc. Dogs are massively time consuming in the first few years and I wish people did their research thoroughly prior to getting one, the rescue centres are currently full to bursting with surrendered dogs.

BatteryPoweredMammy · 18/09/2022 08:31

Tigofigo · 18/09/2022 00:01

The impression I get is that a lot of people feel the same way about their dogs.

Lots of owners I speak to sound exhausted and resentful about their dogs.

I know a few that sold their dogs after a few months as couldn't cope.

What I'm confused about is how your wife and children are happy, but you're not? Is the dogs behaviour aimed at you? Or is it because you just don't like dogs? If it's about the responsibility can you not just tell them they need to do everything dog related?

Not everyone loves dogs. 🤷🏻‍♀️

We have a dog who’s 5 years old. My DH loves him to bits and he’s perfectly well behaved etc. but I’ve realised I’m not really a doggy person. I treat him well enough but I much prefer the cats.

Ylvamoon · 18/09/2022 08:29

What exactly is bothering you and what exactly is the dog doing that makes life difficult?
Is there anything positive about having the dog? Like do you enjoy your walks, love seeing your family happy...

Dogs are absolutely amazing creatures. I often think it is a privilege to own one.
But yes, they are predators, they can be stubborn and are often misunderstood.

itsjustnotok · 18/09/2022 08:27

@CherryGenoa my DH and both DD’s desperately want a dog. I’ve refused so far because although everyone says they will take it for walks and clean up etc I know the reality will be different. I work part time and study part time so I can guarantee it will be me doing the work most of the time because I’m at home most. They don’t get it. DH told the kids last night perhaps after Christmas!! He knew from the look I gave him I wasn’t impressed with being railroaded. Idea and reality are so different.

cushioncovers · 18/09/2022 08:18

How long have you had the dog op? Have you told your wife how you feel?

MoggyMittens23 · 18/09/2022 08:17

Wombat100 · 18/09/2022 00:13

It never fails to amaze me how many people on these threads simply see dogs and other pets as disposable. Really sad.

So would you rather someone hold their hands up, say they have made a mistake and find the dog a new loving home?

Or keep it out of duty for the next 10 or so years and find the dog such a burden that life is utterly miserable for all involved, including the dog?

LondonWolf · 18/09/2022 08:15

I'm a massive dog lover, always had one since my twenties, as soon as I had a home of my own. I really relate to your post though OP as the puppy months/year can be utterly horrific. I know what comes once the dog is grown, and how worthwhile it is but for those who don't it can be life changing and soul destroying.

Re-home through a reputable rescue asap. Your children can have dogs when they're older, in their own homes. Don't let MNetters make you feel guilty about it either.

MissyB1 · 18/09/2022 08:09

Wombat100 · 18/09/2022 00:13

It never fails to amaze me how many people on these threads simply see dogs and other pets as disposable. Really sad.

This!!!! I mean bloody hell sometimes I regret becoming a parent, but I’ve never thought about giving the kids away! Well ok I’ve had the odd daydream….. 😜

OP you have to try and bond with your dog. And the whole family have to train the dog. Get a few lessons from a trainer that comes to your house, it will be money well spent.

Wereeaglesdare · 18/09/2022 08:08

Oh and never leave food down all day for a possessive dog. Let ur dog eat and go play take its bowl away and give back at meal times then it does not need to guard it.

wetotter · 18/09/2022 08:08

Puppy blues are normal and not a reason to rehome.

This creature is still a baby, not long away from mother and littermates, learning so much about the world and forming its first attachments to its new owner.

I don't actually think your family should have got a puppy in the first place - that should never be done unless everyone is fully on board with the idea. But you can't change the past.

You need to keep going with the training, getting expert, individual advice sooner not later.