Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU friend comparing us all the time

214 replies

FriendWoes · 17/09/2022 20:38

I'm not sure if I'm just being a hormonal grump or whether my friend is being unreasonable at this point

NC due to my old account being quite outing

Background -

My best friend of 15 years had her first baby 5 months ago, I had my first baby 4 weeks ago

Since being pregnant she has been low key comparing us and at the time it was awkward but not annoying, it's now getting to me

Examples -

She was very sick in her first trimester, I didn't have any sickness at all - constant comments about it, 'oh you're so lucky, I couldn't even go out in my first trimester' 'I wonder if you'll feel as great in your second trimester since you didn't have a tough first trimester like I did'

Her DH is a bit of a prick (whole other story) and refused to do any SPL, my DH couldn't wait to share the leave and we are doing 50:50 (6months each), after we spoke about that I had weeks of 'oh you're so lucky your DH could take the time off work' (I did at the time think, your DH could also take the time off but refuses to as he thinks his job is more important than yours - he has said that)

She had a pretty shit birth, ok really shit. She asked for a c section and was brushed off, she didn't fight it. Ended up with 4th degree tear, surgery, due to being separated from her DD for ages due to the surgery she wasn't able to establish BF either

I had an elective (as I fought for mine) and was out of hospital in 2 days, and can BF

As you can imagine this has then led to even more comments around my 'luck'

At this point it's annoying me as most of this (except the sickness) isn't luck at all

I chose not to procreate with a twat, I chose to fight for my c section and so many other things she things I'm lucky for.

I was close to telling her it's not luck just better life choices when she was yet again going on about how lucky I am that DH does most of the night feeds, and cleans the house.

AIBU to be annoyed at her constant comparing. I understand her journey to parenthood wasn't fun, but I was there mopping her toilet floor when she was sick in the day (as her DH was useless) going to scans - being as supportive as I could, I'm now just getting pissed off about this insinuation that I am lucky when in most of the situations she refers to it's not luck at all. I just did something different, by choice

OP posts:
mamabear715 · 18/09/2022 08:45

Wow. Had to skip from page 1 to page 7 because of all the posts telling you @FriendWoes that YOU were the unreasonable one!
I have a family member continually telling me how 'lucky' I am. Drives you CRAZY, doesn't it? We all have choices, some of us make better ones than others.
Hopefully your friend will mellow a little, but I personally would start edging back just a little, to preserve your sanity..

happy66 · 18/09/2022 08:14

Comparison is the thief of all joy!!

happy66 · 18/09/2022 08:13

Comparison is the the their of all joy. Repeat that every time that every time she starts.

Patapouf · 18/09/2022 08:01

Sounds like you don't really like each other OP. It's hard when a friendship no longer works, especially after such a long time.

I think the fact she had such a horrendous labour is not her 'life choice' by the way. It is very unlikely she didn't 'fight' hard enough for a c-section, maternity care is abysmal and women are not listened to. If her baby is only 5m old she's probably still processing what happened, a 4th degree tear must be horrendous!!!

If these comparisons bother you now, just wait until the babies start crawling, walking and talking- it will be endless but it's also pretty normal.

Fair play regarding her DH though, he sounds a twat.

Lunabun · 18/09/2022 07:01

Worldwide2 · 17/09/2022 21:25

I wouldn't be pissed off with someone telling me I'm lucky all the time no. Many more things in the world to be pissed off about.

This is where I'm confused too. Why do you even care? Who cares what's luck and what isn't? Yes well done you for making whatever choices you did - is it that you want a pat on the back and are upset she's not doing so?

I think YABVU to be annoyed about this. It sounds like she's just struggling.

Cowhen · 18/09/2022 07:00

Your friend has plainly had a bloody hard start to mothering, and your implication that by not fighting for a C-section she is somehow culpable for having a grade 4 tear is fucking horrible. Your decision to fight (like the deserving winner you are!) was probably informed by her terrible experience anyway.

I couldn't have put it better myself, @Mwnci123

OP, you also had a supportive partner backing you (as other PP have pointed out). It's great that you advocated for yourself, but you also don't know the level of pushback she was getting compared to what you got.

I do agree that some of the other comments would be annoying, especially the dog one.

mycatisannoying · 18/09/2022 06:50

God, give the woman a bloody break. YABU.

Swimminginthelake · 18/09/2022 04:09

Why does it bother you that much though?

You think everything that has gone well for you in life is down to your hard work and good choices. Fair enough.

She thinks you're lucky. Maybe it's easier for her to believe that or to create that narrative in her head because her life is hard or harder than yours.

I'm going to assume that you believe that people who are poor or struggling did not make good life choices or work hard enough.

whumpthereitis · 18/09/2022 03:38

I imagine OP is being ‘catty’ because it’s in response to the level of catty that’s being thrown in her direction.

Calling something ‘luck’ denies personal agency being a factor at all, painting someone who isn’t lucky as merely being a powerless victim of circumstance when in fact they could have made different choices. And yes, i can absolutely see how it would get fucking draining being a sounding board for a friend that whilst moaning about their shit situation, makes no attempt to get out of if it or fight for themselves. It must be especially draining when you’ve had this for months if not years, on top of dealing with all the upheaval of having a baby. It doesn’t sound like a mutually supportive friendship, it sounds like OP is the one constantly looked upon for support.

Lucyintheskywithrubies · 18/09/2022 01:17

FriendWoes · 17/09/2022 23:48

Because I wanted one

And what do you mean 'is this a thing now'

It's been a 'thing' for years

I sincerely hope this thread isn’t going to turn into questioning a woman’s right to choose a c section. Which has RIGHTLY been a “thing” for years.

MummyIsJustDoingThis · 18/09/2022 01:04

Bloody hell! I’m still struggling to see what you did wrong, OP! Awful that people are choosing to side after you’ve also had a baby. You just enjoy for your baby and wait for your mate to come to her senses. If she doesn’t, then you’ll have to adjust to being a friend down xx

hellosunshineagainxxx · 18/09/2022 00:53

Her having a shit birth isn't her fault. I had a csection and haemorrhaged and had an infection after was in intensive care. I couldn't establish bf. This could have happened to you. Advocating harder for a csection isn't why your birth went well-it is somewhat the luck of the draw.

You don't sound like a very nice friend.

Annoyingkidsmusic · 18/09/2022 00:42

You sound awful.

MummyIsJustDoingThis · 18/09/2022 00:39

Regardless of the pregnancy and the birth, we are mothers, and it’s bloody hard. How awful that, at a time when you should share experiences, she’s choosing to alienate you. I reckon she feels pretty shit about her partner and is putting it all down to luck on your part.
Im alway someone who wishes to dismiss people out of my life after a small grievance. If I were being nice, I’d ask her if she’s okay or has a problem. If she says no, then she’s a nob that you just can’t help. Being a mum is hard enough but when your best friend is the villain, you’re in a bad way

Confusion101 · 18/09/2022 00:00

You sound increasingly catty in every post. Ultimately your question is are you being unreasonable for finding your friend's comments annoying... Yes! Yes you are!!

Talk to her and tell her if you don't like what she's saying instead of coming here telling us how great you are at life with your amazing choices.

FriendWoes · 17/09/2022 23:48

YellowTreeHouse · 17/09/2022 23:48

Justify it however you want.

Justify what?

Answer the question - do you judge everyone who goes back to work before their child is 2?

OP posts:
FriendWoes · 17/09/2022 23:48

Sarahcoggles · 17/09/2022 23:40

Why did you have an elective section OP?
Is this a thing now - people requesting sections just because they want them? With all the attendant risks?

Because I wanted one

And what do you mean 'is this a thing now'

It's been a 'thing' for years

OP posts:
YellowTreeHouse · 17/09/2022 23:48

Justify it however you want.

FriendWoes · 17/09/2022 23:47

@YellowTreeHouse

Oh now you're spouting inaccurate BS about attachment now

This should be fun

Specific attachment is well established in babies by 6 months, which is when their non specific attachments begin to develop - just in time for dad to take over for us.

A full attachment is rarely developed until 2 years old

So unless you sit there and judge everyone who goes back to work before their baby is 2 you can kindly bugger off

OP posts:
YellowTreeHouse · 17/09/2022 23:41

FriendWoes · 17/09/2022 22:31

I don't think I'm lucky at all

50:50 is what most should expect from their partners imo

My friend considers me lucky as she wanted 50:50 spl as she wanted to get back to work but not put her DD in childcare that early

But can't do that since her DH won't do the 50%

I feel sorry for you that you can't understand not everyone needs to dominate the first year after their babies birth

I agree, 50/50 is the minimum anyone should expect from their parenting partner.

However, that’s not related to SPL. It’s nothing to do with “dominating the first year”.

Baby doesn’t even realise they’re a separate person to mum at 6 months old, yet you’re happy to jeopardise your attachment and shirk mothering. Well you do you 🤷‍♀️ But secure attachments are not made from mum disappearing when baby still thinks they’re the same person.

Sarahcoggles · 17/09/2022 23:40

Why did you have an elective section OP?
Is this a thing now - people requesting sections just because they want them? With all the attendant risks?

FriendWoes · 17/09/2022 23:34

EmeraldShamrock1 · 17/09/2022 23:08

Are you sure you're not being sensitive and overreacting.

Comparisons like this can be an awkward compliment.

It sounds like she is feeling low and finding things difficult whereas things have worked out better for you, not your fault but you could offer some sympathy.

Well that was what I was asking

I'm 4 weeks post having a child sliced out of me so not sure if I'm over reacting or not

Others have said they'd be pissed too though so am feeling more validated, as it's been 7 months of it and it's really draining at this point

OP posts:
santorinii · 17/09/2022 23:32

You don’t come across well op. Saying someone is lucky isn’t a bitchy thing, don’t take it badly. She’s clearly had a very shit time. Just try to not get offended cause she’s clearly hurting.

FriendWoes · 17/09/2022 23:28

Natty13 · 17/09/2022 23:07

Bloody hell these comments.

I'll be your friend OP, we can be heartless bitches together (jk thought because I don't think you are and I'm not either)

My friends wanted ad has worked already! Brew
Welcome to heartless circle!

OP posts:
FriendWoes · 17/09/2022 23:27

Bananarama21 · 17/09/2022 23:04

As I have repeatedly told you, I've posted her comments here. Im factually writing what's been said.

I thought you changed details not to be outing? You're contradicting yourself now. This will be picked up by the media if your not careful.

Yep I've changed details

Do you understand that details of the situation are different to comments/quotes

At this point you're only adding more and more irrelevant crap so I won't be reply to you going forwards - a total waste of my time

OP posts: