Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave an 11 year old alone for 6 hours?

193 replies

MamMedusa · 17/09/2022 20:11

DH has a work thing on Monday that I'm "expected" to attend. DD is 11 (12 in Nov) & is adamant she isn't coming. She started secondary school this year, she's been letting herself in around 4pm and is alone until I get home from work around 5pm which has gone well so far, she's even started dinner on a couple of occasions, so her reasoning is that if she's capable of doing that then she's capable of spending a day alone.
She's pretty sensible for her age & can't see any major disasters happening, however we live on military camp so she has the guard room number for emergencies as well as obviously knowing how to call for an ambulance etc. We'll be around a 25 min drive away.

DH thinks she's too young & wants to make her come with us, however he'll essentially be working the entire time & it'll be me who's left to deal with her sulking & attitude, which in all honesty I really cba with atm.
I could stay home with her but this is one of the few of his work events I actually want to attend.
Genuinely not sure what to do for the best.

OP posts:
funtycucker · 18/09/2022 08:36

Mimi1313 · 17/09/2022 21:50

I was pretty responsible age 11 and my mum once left me at home for 3hrs with my older sibling age 13. I'm not gonna lie ... it was fun during the first hour but was terrifying by the time the third came. We ended up under the table quivering out of fear of the unknown. I think it's best to do things in stages.

Are you for real?

blubberball · 18/09/2022 08:21

I think it's fine. You can text/call during the day, you're pretty close by and she has the military to call on.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 18/09/2022 08:16

I would, and did at that age. My youngest is 14, so not that long ago.

Hellothere54 · 18/09/2022 08:10

She sounds confident that she will be fine, but you know your child - I would not have coped at 11 as hated being alone in the house and would end up sitting in a corner crying with a kitchen knife next to me for protection! (Ever the drama Queen!) My little brother, on the other hand, wouldn’t even notice parents were gone!

Waspo · 18/09/2022 07:59

I'm amazed by all the people saying it's too long etc, what on earth do you all think working parents do with their secondary age children in the holidays? I'm a single mum working full time, with 5 weeks annual leave. So yes my daughter had to be at home alone in school holidays from age 11. What is the other option?
Do people still use childminders for secondary kids? Because surely by the time they are in year 7 most people are back to work full time (and not everyone can do magical shift work fitting perfectly around children!)
So confused by some of these replies 😂

JenFres21 · 18/09/2022 07:55

6 hours during the day would be absolutely fine. Not in the evening though as she may get spooked.

To the posters saying no way, why not?

FourChimneys · 18/09/2022 07:44

She sounds more than capable and will be fine. She can call in the military in an emergency.

I was left at home for a few hours at a time at that age and absolutely loved it.

No wonder teenagers are often helpless, they never get challenged to be resourceful.

OP, I would just maybe run through a few ideas to keep her occupied. Can you buy her anything today? In your circumstances I would have considered getting my DD a new (safe!) craft kit to keep her busy.

Softplayhooray · 18/09/2022 07:02

Neverfullycharged · 17/09/2022 20:26

I think it’s fine, to be honest, and I’m generally on the cautious side with these things.

I'd agree ..if you think your area is safe, and she'd be happy with the food and snacks she has and will just chill with a couple of movies then it's ok! Wouldn't make a habit of it, though.

Musti · 18/09/2022 06:58

I think it is fine. I started leaving my eldest at home at 11 when he didn’t want to come with my to sit and watch his siblings do their sports. Got left for 5 ish hours most weekdays (4-8:30). He had a phone and knew our neighbours. Told him not to cook

BCBird · 18/09/2022 06:52

In my opinion it's too young. See if she can go elsewhere, if not she goes with you both or you choose not to go.

mycatisannoying · 18/09/2022 06:46

Totally fine to leave her.

UmbilicusProfundus · 18/09/2022 04:41

I read those NSPCC guidelines and was surprised. I’ve never left my kids alone for any length of time, but I feel I need to start doing this with the oldest one (Year 5, but with some SEN). Would start with just 15minutes (eg when picking the other kids up) DH is more cautious than me and I can foresee arguments about it. What age do people start leaving kids for these very short periods?

antelopevalley · 18/09/2022 02:35

@Sarahzb Not all boys are the same. Some are very sensible.

Sarahzb · 18/09/2022 02:21

Young women/girls are usually very sensible. I woudn't l leave a boy.

fUNNYfACE36 · 18/09/2022 02:18

Of course it's fine. Some posters seem determined to infantilise their dc.This is why so many teens ha v e anxiety

antelopevalley · 18/09/2022 02:00

NSPCC are way over cautious. The idea you can't leave an 11 year old ever alone for any time is frankly nuts.

Bubbleguppette · 18/09/2022 01:47

ManateeFair · 18/09/2022 01:05

The guidelines are for leaving them for extended periods, not a few hours. Six hours isn’t an extended period; it’s an afternoon.

That's not what their website says - it doesn't mention time frames for this age group.

It literally says
We would always recommend leaving a child younger than 12 years old with family, a friend or in childcare.

However, even if they had mentioned times, I'd certainly consider 6 hours to be an extended period of time in the context of leaving an 11 year old home alone.

alphons · 18/09/2022 01:20

Trusting her to stay home alone for 6 hours, and learning that sometimes you have to attend things you don’t want to attend - those are two totally separate things.

I think she should go with you (minus a moody face) because that’s life. AT THE SAME TIME, I’d be telling her this is absolutely not related to not wanting to leave her home alone, that you trust her as a responsible child.

So, I’m with your DH re Monday, and with you re leaving her home alone.

Just fyi, from a child’s perspective, 6 daytime hours is a long time. Sounds like she can do the necessary in terms of keeping herself safe and fed etc. But the emotional coping side of things…. they can unexpectedly freak out about that. Speaking from experience here.

antelopevalley · 18/09/2022 01:08

ManateeFair · 18/09/2022 01:01

It’s real life in 2022, not the opening 10 minutes of Casualty in 1986. Most people don’t even own a chip pan.

OP, she’ll be perfectly fine.

It depends so much on the child. Some are incredibly sensibly and would never get ideas to do something risky. My teenagers are more sensible than some friends husbands and more trustworthy.

ManateeFair · 18/09/2022 01:05

Bubbleguppette · 18/09/2022 00:30

Also the NSPCC guidelines recommend leaving children under 12 with family, friends or in other childcare rather than leaving them alone.

The guidelines are for leaving them for extended periods, not a few hours. Six hours isn’t an extended period; it’s an afternoon.

ManateeFair · 18/09/2022 01:01

Murdoch1949 · 17/09/2022 22:16

You must not leave her alone for more than an hour. Anything could happen, kids get stupid ideas, oh I'll make some lunch, chip pan on, kid gets distracted in other room, FIRE. She's a child, take her with you and be a parent. If she misbehaves deal with it.

It’s real life in 2022, not the opening 10 minutes of Casualty in 1986. Most people don’t even own a chip pan.

OP, she’ll be perfectly fine.

CallMeLinda · 18/09/2022 00:49

purpleme12 · 17/09/2022 23:38

Why isn't there childcare options then if it's not safe to leave a high school age child on their own?
Childcare options end at end of primary school.
All these comments about shouldn't be leaving her are making me worried for when I have to leave mine

In the real world, people leave high school age kids alone all the time (barring any disability etc that makes it unsafe, or course).

Bubbleguppette · 18/09/2022 00:30

Also the NSPCC guidelines recommend leaving children under 12 with family, friends or in other childcare rather than leaving them alone.

Bubbleguppette · 18/09/2022 00:23

It's too young imo.
If something goes wrong the child may not know what to do.

Sunnytwobridges · 18/09/2022 00:18

LtMoose · 17/09/2022 20:15

Personally I think 11 is old enough to be left in the day alone

I agree. Plus she’s almost 12. When my dd had school holidays when she was 11/12 and I had to work she would be home alone and she was fine. But she’s always been very independent, and level headed.