Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don’t ‘do’ dying and death well in the UK

83 replies

FrenchFancie · 17/09/2022 18:06

I’m currently sitting vigil with my grandmother who at 96 is slowly dying - she’s had a lovely long life but a miserable old age riddled with cancer that has robbed her of her sight, and now led to a broken hip and shoulder. She is settled with pain relief and slowly slipping away but this isn’t the quick clean death she would have wanted.

i don’t want to open a euthanasia debate (really can’t cope with that right now!) but I’ve noticed that many people are very very awkward around death and some have even gone so far as to tell me she might recover (she really won’t). AIBU to think we as a culture don’t handle death well? How do we I prove that? Do other cultures do better or is this unease with death a uniform human experience?

OP posts:
FrenchFancie · 18/09/2022 08:50

We’ll she’s got through another night, although I don’t know how or why 🤷‍♀️. She is comfortable on a morphine pump but with no other treatment except Hycosine for her secretions.

ive noticed that most of the nursing home staff are ok with the idea of death and dying, but a couple still think she will get well. I have to say that I really don’t want her to - I’m not being callous but her quality of life in the last few months hasn’t been great.

i just find it odd that even care home staff members, who must see a fair share of death, can be so awkward around death and saying goodbye. I used to be a solicitor so Nan has a will, powers of attorney and an advance medical directive in place from years ago - we know her wants and wishes and, now she can no longer communicate, we are following them. I just wish everyone had that level of openness.

OP posts:
Talkingtocamels · 18/09/2022 08:40

We do it dreadfully. All of it. From the Will planning…..almost everyone should have a will……to the final days. It’s all dreadful. I work in front line healthcare and I see the worst of this. When faced with a critically unwell loved one(or even some who is old and trying hard to die)….even if this is expected or the patient is 108, the vast majority of the population want me (a hospital dr ) to ‘do everything’ ……presumably so that the antibiotics will cure the UTI and enable them to go back to their nursing home and continue their slow and pitiful decline, in a state of blissful dementia driven ignorance, until 5 sets of antibiotics and multiple hospital stays later they are finally allowed to die. I’ve had many conversations with families with end stage dementia relatives who want CPR and a stay on ITU for their loved one. I totally despair. And if the patient is under 70 but with a life limiting condition you can guarantee that nobody has had an end of life conversation with them.
im 45. I have both POA completed and a will and my family know I want to be buried and where. I’m also an organ donor. I haven’t written my funeral….but I should probably put that on my to do list. Death is part of life. The whole euthanasia conversation bemuses me. We are so far from allowing dying people to die to even start considering letting living people die.

Ponoka7 · 18/09/2022 08:27

I think that Covid showed us that we had completely lost sight of the age that death becomes natural. We had relative after relative criticising the NHS because their family member, usually way past 80 had not had enough intervention.
I used the term passing to a neighbour when I had to run home while my mum was dying. Other relatives were with her. She had a DNR in place, supported by us all. I'd worked in end of life care. Other relatives worked across social care. But I wasn't ready to say out loud that my Mum was dying. When I phoned her sister, I just said that she had gone. It's what I needed to do.

TightDiamondShoes · 18/09/2022 08:15

My mum died a few years ago. She had stage 5 kidney disease, stage 4 oesophageal cancer, type 1 diabetes, etc etc. my dad and sister are still furious at the NHS and think they should’ve done “more” to keep her alive. 🤷‍♀️

Snugglemonkey · 18/09/2022 08:12

BadNomad · 18/09/2022 06:55

It is really strange. The Irish and Scottish definitely have a healthier relationship with death in my experience. Even during the process, the language is different. People wish you quick, painless, peaceful passing for your relative, not a "Good luck! I hope a miracle happens!"

I am Irish in Scotland and I find the Scottish way more reluctant to deal with death. Wills are a difficult topic, funerals are awkward and everyone is so self contained. I really don't like it, as it just feels alien to me.

I am much more comfortable with the open discussion, having the deceased at home, doing a wake etc. I think it really helped me with the grieving process when my mum died.

If my partner died, I would try my best to do things Irish style. Even if his family didn't engage, my family and friends would come over and do it. I would never do the Scottish thing of just leaving him in a funeral home. It feels so cold and unloving. It would be far too distressing.

itsjustnotok · 18/09/2022 08:01

Im sending you hugs OP.

You are right that we don’t deal with death well. My granny was diagnosed with a tumour in late June m. She heard the word cancer and I honestly think she decided that was that. My dad was clueless, he stuck his head in the sand and kept saying she looked better after she was rushed to hospital. I got a call to say they were letting her come home and nurses would visit to make her comfortable. Still my dad couldn’t accept it and it was a hard conversation. I asked if they mentioned palliative care and he said yes but wasn’t sure what it was. I had to explain that Granny was coming home to die and he should spend as much time as possible with her. He just didn’t cope. When my children asked if Granny was going to die I was honest and said yes it was sad but the doctors couldn’t make her better. It’s devastating but also a reality you cannot ignore. I don’t want to ignore that she died and not speak about it. It’s only been a few months and my dad thinks my grandad should be ‘better’ but this was his best friend and they never had a day apart. I don’t think he will ever be ‘better’. I call my grandad and I know he misses her because he chats on the phone with me when he used to pass it straight to Granny. Death needs to be acknowledged and worked through at an individual pace because it’s so personal and sometimes traumatic. We don’t do it well.

Pashazade · 18/09/2022 07:50

I think it is the lack of ritual that has made a lot of dealing with death harder for many as people don't know what to do. Having some kind of frame work makes it easier. I've never shied away from it lost a parent young, but no one spoke to me about them properly. Most odd. I think things have improved in that there is far more support out there for children now but generally I agree people flounder and don't know what to say. I think the heavy ritual around the queen's death has made it easier for people to express themselves as it is acceptable (expected??) to express grief about her.
I always think the limbo time between death and funeral is hardest because you loose all sense of time and have no structure to keep you moving forward but then after the funeral life carries on and everyone not immediately affected drifts back to their normal lives and you're left marooned.

mostlydrinkstea · 18/09/2022 07:01

The English customs around death have all but gone and nothing has replaced them. People used to die at home, funerals happened quite quickly and the funeral service for most people was a standard CofE Book of Common Prayer with no eulogy. The whole community would turn out for it and if people couldn't attend they would shut their curtains as a sign of respect. Those who were bereaved would wear black for more than one day. It sounds restrictive and our culture is different now but the customs back then acknowledged that death was real, gave the community a rite to manage the transition and did not expect the deeply bereaved to be over it in a fortnight.

It seems that death is now the last taboo. We don't talk about it, plan for it and we expect people to be silent about their grief. Perhaps the late queen's death will open up a conversation about how to do death, dying and bereavement well.

BadNomad · 18/09/2022 06:55

It is really strange. The Irish and Scottish definitely have a healthier relationship with death in my experience. Even during the process, the language is different. People wish you quick, painless, peaceful passing for your relative, not a "Good luck! I hope a miracle happens!"

DaisyWaldron · 18/09/2022 06:51

I agree. I'm Irish, and it's one if the really big cultural differences I've noticed since moving here. Death in England seems to be treated as a very private, personal matter, like some sort of intimate body function which can't be mentioned in public and which you never dream of intruding upon. So dying and grief and mourning are things where you get support from your immediate family and may e a very close friend, but no wider community support.

Carpy88999 · 18/09/2022 06:42

Babdoc · 17/09/2022 19:02

I wonder if it’s just atheists who have this problem?
To them, death is utterly without consolation, they believe it’s total oblivion, so they either avoid mentioning it or make inappropriate remarks about the possibility of recovery, which are so crass to the family of a terminally ill patient.

Christians see death as a beginning, not an end. A glorious transition from the bonds of this mortal state, to eternal life in the loving presence of God, reunited with our loved ones. We are perhaps more accepting of its inevitability and comforted by our faith. I found that my minister and Christian friends and family were able to say and do all the right things when my DH died unexpectedly.

You couldn't be further from the truth if you tried. I don't fear death because its not an experience, its not like being trapped in a dark room that you can't escape for eternity. I do believe in an afterlife but only in the sense we all live in on people's memories. When my father died the worst people were his devout Christian parents. They couldn't accept it and were pretty much useless and we are now NC with them.

I see you pop up on a lot of threads and I'm 100% certain you see all atheists as nihilistic and deeply miserable.

PicaNewName · 18/09/2022 06:40

Yepp.
My English husband doesn't have a will, won't discuss one. This could leave me i a shit situation as she had a grown up child from a previous relationship.
He won't ask his mother about what she'd want or what arrangements are there for his disabled brother in case she passes.
It's all because of being superstitious... drives me up the wall.

Bigoldmachine · 18/09/2022 06:22

In my opinion it is because we (as a general society) try and shield children from the realities of death and grieving. I feel like I deal with deal “well”, but it is because my parents both died when I was young, and I HAD to accept death as a part of life, and had seen it first hand. I’m also very in touch with my feelings so allowed the hard feelings to exist and get through when I was grieving. That definitely helped.

I am an atheist and I think in general atheists have done so much thinking about their beliefs and how they fit in with the world that they do accept death as a part of life. Devout Christians I know are hugely comforted by the prospect of going to meet Jesus and be in Heaven. I find it’s those who hold more “general”, or looser (for wont of a better word) Christian beliefs who struggle. Perhaps their parents were bigger believers and they’ve grown up with death being talked of as “going to heaven” or “the angels came to take them” and despite not quite wholeheartedly believing the whole idea they don’t have anything to replace it with, and may not have had direct experience of death (especially as people are living much longer). I’m in my 30s and a lot of people my age still have both sets of grandparents alive. If we are not exposed to death how can we expect to be able to deal with it? We do need to be much more straightforward and honest about death.

Beseen22 · 18/09/2022 05:14

I'm a nurse in acute care with single rooms so I'm with a lot of people who are dying. I think death on acute hospital care is on the whole done terribly. When someone dies on hospice it's generally a death from cancer and more of an expected timeline. Family can plan a little better and its a more homely environment.

In acute care we often treat but if they deteriorate they would not be for extreme measures such as ventilation or CPR as they would be incredibly unlikely to have any beneficial outcome. The fact that we are treating with antibiotics etc leaves family with a hope that they will get better even though things are deteriorating and because we are still in active treatment I'm still doing hourly observations and daily bloods and multiple antibiotics and fluids and I sometimes feel a sense from the patient that they want me to just leave them to rest with their family. I find it the hardest part of my job.

The British awkwardness around death means that people rarely have these conversations with their family until a time when someone is critical unwell and emotions are high. I remember my poor grandfather had very advanced COPD, completely bed bound, on home oxygen, nursing home resident, multiple pressure sores and weighed about 6 stone. They dragged him up by ambulance every few months when he got a chest infection in the middle of the night where he was treated with antibiotics/constant painful bloods/vital signs taken hourly then back to the care home. The last time he went up he was terrified and said he didn't want to go and just wanted to die. I asked my dad to make sure there was a plan in place and medications to keep him comfortable at his care home to let him die with some dignity.

Longdistance · 18/09/2022 05:01

My dm passed away two weeks ago. I didn’t like that she was on ward and we were curtained off. A quiet room would’ve been better. My manager rang me when I was with my dm. He was all ‘I’m sure she’ll be fine’. I knew he was a complete dickhead, but this cements it for me as to why I don’t like him.
Dm was a DNR, so when the nurses and doctors were hinted that she was very unwell, I knew what they were angling at.

For you op 💐

Andromachehadabadday · 18/09/2022 04:17

@MyFragility thank you.

Just wanted to pick up on the point about atheists and Christians. I don’t find that at all. I don’t consider myself Christian or atheist.

The people I know who found it hardest were all people who are Christian. The 2 Atheists that I know, have been fully accepting of how much I miss her. They understood how devastating it is to spend your life building a relationship with someone, to have such a bond with someone that no one could break, then to physically lose that person in an instant.

I don’t believe in Christian heaven. But I do believe there’s an afterlife and I will see my loved ones again. But it’s not enough. It’s not the same. Seeing mum again, when I die and have to leave my kids and knowing they will go through what I am now, isn’t a great comfort.

Mums family are Catholic and comfortable with talking about how it’s not the same and are great.

I think it’s more cultural than based on religion.

@FrenchFancie I hope your Grandmother has a comfortable night.

Xdecd · 18/09/2022 02:15

I agree OP. I got all kinds of unhelpful comments when my partner died. I have tried to be tolerant because I think it is society's problem, not individual.

Because her dad died I have had to talk to our young daughter about death. I have been taken aback by some of the responses I've had. For example nursery told me that when she mentions her dad they quickly change the subject because they don't want her or the other children upset. Other parents started crossing the street to avoid me. I thought, no wonder we don't deal with death we'll, look at the messages our children are getting.

LikeAStar1994 · 18/09/2022 01:22

There was a girl two or three years younger than me who was fighting cancer. Unfortunately she disclosed that her cancer had become terminal.

From what I could see through her words and photos she was extremely ill, tired, exhausted and had pretty much given up.

People were commenting under her post saying how she will get through this and how she needs to stay positive. WTF?

She literally stated her cancer was terminal and nothing else could be done for her. I found those comments really insensitive and in poor taste.

Yeah, I fully acknowledge I'm being a bitch as these people would have been hurting. But it really seemed as though they were trying to give her false hope. She had simply had enough, I could see it for myself and I didn't even know her.

I'm so sorry for you, OP. Sending Much Love 💕

Tabitha888 · 17/09/2022 21:07

I agree with you. It's so frustrating that people dismiss things that are happening.

seething1234 · 17/09/2022 19:21

I don't know if other cultures do it better. I'm irish and I sat through my mother's last days which were incredibly painful for her. She was put on morphine and we were then sent into palliative care unit. Her siblings called in and chatted, there were tears and laughter and stories exchanged while my mother was sleeping (we knew she wouldn't wake up and it was a matter of time.

One particular relative went above and beyond helping us - she was a nurse in the hospital off duty and she was brilliant and it was almost like the "wake" had begun and I think that is quite common with the older generation on someones deathbed they gather to support the family in the final hours- sometimes its a bit much with the prayers and stuff but it can be comforting.

Hbh17 · 17/09/2022 19:11

We don't generally cope well with death, it's true. It has almost become taboo for some people, and thus something to be feared.
And the awful euphemisms that are used don't help - particularly "passed away" and (even worse) "passed". I'm actually reassured that some of the language about the death of HM The Queen has been much more honest and straightforward.

DeadButDelicious · 17/09/2022 19:10

Babdoc · 17/09/2022 19:02

I wonder if it’s just atheists who have this problem?
To them, death is utterly without consolation, they believe it’s total oblivion, so they either avoid mentioning it or make inappropriate remarks about the possibility of recovery, which are so crass to the family of a terminally ill patient.

Christians see death as a beginning, not an end. A glorious transition from the bonds of this mortal state, to eternal life in the loving presence of God, reunited with our loved ones. We are perhaps more accepting of its inevitability and comforted by our faith. I found that my minister and Christian friends and family were able to say and do all the right things when my DH died unexpectedly.

Nope. I'm an atheist and I'm not afraid of oblivion or anything like that. Death is the end of a life hopefully well lived. I don't need the promise of anything else.

Most of the people I know who simply couldn't handle our daughters passing or death in general were those who would describe themselves as Christian.

I don't think it has much to do with religion though as it goes. I think society has distanced itself from death and dying in order to convince itself that it won't happen.

Random789 · 17/09/2022 19:09

My experience has been very different from that of several people on this thread. I lost my son, and I found that with just one or two exceptions people were good, kind, appropriate. No one avoided me; no one was uncomfortable with tragedy.
Perhaps it is because I am a reserved person in any case. I didn't have a host of goood-time friends who couldn't make the switch from trivial socialising to profound empathy.

Babdoc · 17/09/2022 19:02

I wonder if it’s just atheists who have this problem?
To them, death is utterly without consolation, they believe it’s total oblivion, so they either avoid mentioning it or make inappropriate remarks about the possibility of recovery, which are so crass to the family of a terminally ill patient.

Christians see death as a beginning, not an end. A glorious transition from the bonds of this mortal state, to eternal life in the loving presence of God, reunited with our loved ones. We are perhaps more accepting of its inevitability and comforted by our faith. I found that my minister and Christian friends and family were able to say and do all the right things when my DH died unexpectedly.

bootseason · 17/09/2022 19:00

Sorry for your situation @FrenchFancie YANBU. I hope it all goes as well as these things go. I'd go further and say as a culture we don't do empathy well. An awful lot of people either have poor social skills or just don't care to say the right thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread