Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don’t ‘do’ dying and death well in the UK

83 replies

FrenchFancie · 17/09/2022 18:06

I’m currently sitting vigil with my grandmother who at 96 is slowly dying - she’s had a lovely long life but a miserable old age riddled with cancer that has robbed her of her sight, and now led to a broken hip and shoulder. She is settled with pain relief and slowly slipping away but this isn’t the quick clean death she would have wanted.

i don’t want to open a euthanasia debate (really can’t cope with that right now!) but I’ve noticed that many people are very very awkward around death and some have even gone so far as to tell me she might recover (she really won’t). AIBU to think we as a culture don’t handle death well? How do we I prove that? Do other cultures do better or is this unease with death a uniform human experience?

OP posts:
Carpy88999 · 18/09/2022 14:34

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 18/09/2022 10:37

@Babdoc

I’m sorry that your post seems to have attracted so many bitter atheists, eager to deny the reality of your experience . Whatever their denial of God has given them, it doesn’t seem to be compassion or courtesy. I suppose if you have resolutely turned to your back on the spiritual, those who have embraced and been embraced by it must be very unsettling.

I also have known people who have found great comfort and support in their faith in times of trouble and bereavement.

No one here was bitter towards her or her faith. She made a dumb statement and has been called out for it.

Singleandproud · 18/09/2022 12:28

Personally I feel very removed from death, I don't have a faith and the only people I have a personal experience with that have died are three people in a road accident I was first on scene for and my paternal grandparents who died well into their 90s and I wasn't overly close to. I was much more upset for the three people I didn't know perhaps because I was there at the end or it was a sudden way to go than my grandparents who had lived long lives.

Completing our family tree though death was such a normal part of life either through wars, illness or infant mortality up to 70 years ago that I would imagine through sheer experience and practise (if that's the right word) we dealt with it better particularly as our neighbours would be dealing with similar things as well. I have no idea what to say to people when they are grieving or have a family member with a terminal illness.

AnotherPidgey · 18/09/2022 12:14

We lost an elderly relative this year after a long, difficult year of illness and slowly slipping away. Her quality of life was minimal and fortunately she and her next of kin all agreed that it was now the point of declining medical intervention that only served to delay the inevitable, and care focused on basic needs and comfort. She died semi-abruptly about 2 months later.

Due to distance my DCs hadn't had an opportunity to see her for a long time, and we have been pragmatic that she was very old and her body was gradually ceasing to work. With simple honesty they seem to have accepted her death well. It was their first experience of a funeral and was a full traditional Irish funeral including open casket.

Having suddenly lost a parent in childhood, I've always been open that death is a conclusion to life. It's quality of life that means more to me than duration of existence. There can be things worse than death, and I've had relatives where death was a relief and release from their suffering. It's not a viewpoint that society always embraces though.

NanaNelly · 18/09/2022 11:00

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen sorry, just to add that I do have a faith but it’s my faith and it doesn’t make me better than anyone else and I don’t believe that it’s only people from my faith who could comfort me in a time of sadness. I’d take comfort from anyone with the spirit it was intended regardless of which path they follow.

Talkingtocamels · 18/09/2022 11:00

I'm Irish but lived in England for many years and never really got my head around the differences in approach to death/funerals etc. My husband is English and has experienced a couple of Irish deaths including my own dad, and thinks the Irish way is a lot healthier. He was mildly freaked out by the open coffin but liked the sort of business-as-usual normality of it all

im Irish too. I was 12 when my dad died suddenly aged 45 and we lived in England. Coffin was open in my parents bedroom. DB was 10. It was a really healing and helpful experience for us all to go and sit with him and talk to him and say goodbye. I still remember it like yesterday. He was dressed really smartly and we all thought he would have liked that. We chose some of his favorite things to place with him in his coffin. We had a proper wake. Almost all the English people who came expressed horror that we had an open coffin in the house and that we kids were going in and out to see our dead dad. Almost all of them also went in to see him and afterwards said what a positive experience it had been.

NanaNelly · 18/09/2022 10:57

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 18/09/2022 10:37

@Babdoc

I’m sorry that your post seems to have attracted so many bitter atheists, eager to deny the reality of your experience . Whatever their denial of God has given them, it doesn’t seem to be compassion or courtesy. I suppose if you have resolutely turned to your back on the spiritual, those who have embraced and been embraced by it must be very unsettling.

I also have known people who have found great comfort and support in their faith in times of trouble and bereavement.

I think the point you (along with Babdoc) have missed is that a person can be an atheist and still be open, accepting and supportive of others having their own beliefs and their own way of doing things without considering yourself better than anyone else. The fact Babdoc has said only her fellow Christians get it right for her says more about her and who she mixes with than it does about anyone else .

Angrymum22 · 18/09/2022 10:51

My first memory of death was my great aunt. I was 5/6 yrs old and we were staying with my other g-aunt ( both aunts lived together). No one, back then, left their family member in a chapel of rest, this was 1960s England and not catholic. I wanted to see the coffin, I’d never seen one, so after a little discussion my DF took me into the room. It was an open casket and I clearly remember the lid resting against the wall with a brass name plaque on it. I don’t remember being sad or scared. I was actually more interested in the coffin that the dead body within. The room was as it always was, the curtains drawn but not dark.
A huge contrast to my DM in a chapel of rest with strange amber lighting (quite spooky/disturbing) . I would have been much happier seeing her in our sitting room at home.
I agree that we have sanitised death to the point where we are no longer able to grieve in a natural way.
I think the Queens death has opened up a conversation for many people. Why don’t we offer our own family the same ability to say goodbye. The queens family were allowed time with her body to adjust to accept that life had gone. It was not whisked away only to be seen again as it is taken away for good.
Many hospices have a cold room ( a normal bedroom kept at a low temp) used when a patient dies for family to come and spend time with their loved one. Why shouldn’t every family be afforded the time to say goodbye properly.
It used to be the norm, now it is seen as odd. Perhaps funeral directories should offer it as an option to everyone.
A vigil is not a religious act it is an act of love. Looking after your loved one after death is no less important that looking after them when alive.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 18/09/2022 10:37

@Babdoc

I’m sorry that your post seems to have attracted so many bitter atheists, eager to deny the reality of your experience . Whatever their denial of God has given them, it doesn’t seem to be compassion or courtesy. I suppose if you have resolutely turned to your back on the spiritual, those who have embraced and been embraced by it must be very unsettling.

I also have known people who have found great comfort and support in their faith in times of trouble and bereavement.

strategyhelp · 18/09/2022 10:14

I agree! Most HR policies also don't reflect the need for some time to grieve or bereavement counselling!

Most of them seem to be a day off for the funeral & straight back to it!

In lots of cases this just isn't possible!

whythou111 · 18/09/2022 10:14

“They say you find out who your real friends are when you are bereaved. I sadly found this to be true when my ds died. People who I thought were close suddenly refused to talk to me/cross the road from me.”
@MyFragility I am so very sorry you went through this, it must have been heartbreaking at an already profoundly painful time of losing your DS. To go through such pain, and for people not to be there for you, because they wanted to avoid a relatively small discomfort must have been shocking. Unfortunately, the story that gets told in our culture again and again is that people will rally around when there is a death in the family, and it will likely be the people closest to the deceased who will want to withdraw from social contact. This is often not the case of course, and becomes a convenient belief for people who struggle with the awkwardness of it. You should have had more support 💐

whythou111 · 18/09/2022 10:02

FrenchFancie · 17/09/2022 18:06

I’m currently sitting vigil with my grandmother who at 96 is slowly dying - she’s had a lovely long life but a miserable old age riddled with cancer that has robbed her of her sight, and now led to a broken hip and shoulder. She is settled with pain relief and slowly slipping away but this isn’t the quick clean death she would have wanted.

i don’t want to open a euthanasia debate (really can’t cope with that right now!) but I’ve noticed that many people are very very awkward around death and some have even gone so far as to tell me she might recover (she really won’t). AIBU to think we as a culture don’t handle death well? How do we I prove that? Do other cultures do better or is this unease with death a uniform human experience?

@FrenchFancie I’m so sorry for you and your family, such a time of grief, even when someone you love dearly has had a long and happy life. A difficult death is such a hard thing, she will be a peace soon, and she will die surrounded by a loving family.

I think what you say is so true and important to talk about. People seem to just not know what to say or do, this seems to lead them to hesitate and ultimately avoid engaging.

I think the way other cultures deal with it varies greatly. If there is a time in life when a religious framework becomes a true comfort for people, then I think death would certainly be it. In Tibetan Buddhism they have a very structured, but very humane approach to dying. Life and death are seen as one in many ways, and a large part of meditative practice in Buddhist traditions involves contemplating death and dying. Death is ever present, because the reality of death is true for everything that lives and so it a good route to seeing reality for what it is. In the Tibetan tradition a lot of emphasis is put on the individual dying, their journey to death, and often the final moments will be completely alone to allow the person to let go in peace. The structure is I think mostly focused on them, The Tibetan book of living and dying goes into detail of this tradition, I haven’t read it in years but I remember being very moved by it.

In the Jewish tradition there seems to be a lot of formal customs too these seem to have more focus on the mourners with a mix of encouraging the outpouring of grief, as well as quiet mourning which can last for a year. It ranges from sitting shiva for 7 days to a prolonged period where mourners will avoid gatherings, music, celebrations in honour of the dead. I think this is mainly in the orthodox tradition now.

It feels like this sort of script would be useful to have in the UK, but I suppose maybe it fell away in part because people found it too restrictive. It does make it difficult for people to connect when they need it most though, it seems a lot of people tell themselves “oh I don’t want to upset them by bringing it up” but this can be so isolating too for many people.

alpenguin · 18/09/2022 09:55

I’m very open about death and dying. I have a condition that will most likely be the reason I die (not for a long time yet I hope) and since my teens I’ve spoke about my own death. It’s not something I’m uncomfortable with. I have no religion or belief system, it will be the end of my life and life without me will go on.

My family refuse to talk about death, they say it’s too morbid, they ask me not to talk of my own death despite it being a way for me to accept my own mortality and impending demise.

when my grandfather was dying I was the only person he could talk about planning for dying with because no one else would face the fact he was dying. It was such a relief to him to have someone listen and not shit him down. My relatives employed some very strange systems of behaviour, going against my grandfathers wishes to appease their own grief and each claimed it was what he would have wanted. I was the only person who listened to what he actually wanted and none of that was what happened.

As sad as I find death and grief on a personal level I also find great comfort in having had these people shape my life and feel like it’s my duty to honour them by living, talking of them often and celebrating what they taught me in life. This idea we have to close all the curtains and hide ourselves away as an honour is bonkers. The biggest honour and greatest respect is to live your life now, enjoy it while you have it and take the lessons the deceased have taught you and share them with the world.

NanaNelly · 18/09/2022 09:41

Funerals are similarly open to everyone

it’s the same whee I live but people are buried within hours. In fact it’s a persons responsibility to join a funeral procession if these one and it doesn’t matter a bit if you don’t know the person who has died, or their family. Also if you pass a house and there is obviously a funeral gathering going on you are free to go in and offer condolences.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 18/09/2022 09:39

We have distanced ourselves from death, so we can’t be surprised that he comes as an unwelcome stranger.
My great grandmother was the village midwife, nurse, and she also laid out the dead, nearly always at home. My grandmother visited the bereaved, that was an established ritual. My mother would not visit my father when he was dying, although the hospital had made great arrangements for us.

For myself, I try to follow my earlier female ancestors. I will talk about the dead with the bereaved, I don’t pretend they never existed,,or skip over evidences of grief.

I find the terminology of ‘ passing’ bizarre. Where are the dead passing to? Have we retreated to a Greek idea of the river Styx , with the souls trapped on the other side?

I wish you strength and peace OP. My thoughts are with you today.

bagboo · 18/09/2022 09:39

I feel very conflicted about this at the moment.

My mum is dying. She is definitely dying and it is likely to be soon. In any case, she is hugely suffering right now, and in a very bad way.

Obviously I'm very sad about this. But my dad is very much in denial about it, still hopes that she might get better, and wants her to stay alive as long as possible, even though she cannot move, see or speak.

He thinks she still had a quality of life. I do not. I completely understand that he doesn't want to lose his wife and for his whole life to change. But at this point I want her to die quickly, for her suffering to end as soon as possible. He hates me saying this, and would be content to sit by her bed holding her hand for another 5 years. He doesn't acknowledge that she's drying, only that she's poorly.

I hate it. I want her to die soon. I can't bear thins pointless suffering. I don't see how she can be content or happy if she can't move, see or speak. Surely that is everyone's worst nightmare.

I don't want her to have to endure more of this. I would end her life now if I could.

NanaNelly · 18/09/2022 09:38

Babdoc · 17/09/2022 19:02

I wonder if it’s just atheists who have this problem?
To them, death is utterly without consolation, they believe it’s total oblivion, so they either avoid mentioning it or make inappropriate remarks about the possibility of recovery, which are so crass to the family of a terminally ill patient.

Christians see death as a beginning, not an end. A glorious transition from the bonds of this mortal state, to eternal life in the loving presence of God, reunited with our loved ones. We are perhaps more accepting of its inevitability and comforted by our faith. I found that my minister and Christian friends and family were able to say and do all the right things when my DH died unexpectedly.

No. I’m not afraid of oblivion. And I don’t make crass remarks to those who have had a bereavement or are waiting for someone’s life to end either. In fact I find your comments extremely narrow minded and discriminatory as you are very clearly saying your way is the only way and everyone else gets it wrong.

People don’t need to have a faith to have any gumption about them and to know how to behave and what to say in very sad circumstances. I think you need to chose different people to be around. Open up your horizons a bit.

evilharpy · 18/09/2022 09:27

I'm Irish but lived in England for many years and never really got my head around the differences in approach to death/funerals etc. My husband is English and has experienced a couple of Irish deaths including my own dad, and thinks the Irish way is a lot healthier. He was mildly freaked out by the open coffin but liked the sort of business-as-usual normality of it all.

Funerals happen very quickly, usually 2-3 days after death. I can't speak for the whole of Ireland but around here, in the Catholic community (and I mean culturally Catholic rather than necessarily actually religious), in the days leading up to the funeral the body will be either at their home or a close family member's home which will be an open house that half the town turns up to to pay their respects, or increasingly commonly in a funeral home that will have time slots for visiting but is otherwise very similar and people will just come along to see the family, say a prayer if they're that way inclined, and stay and chat for a bit. The sandwiches and biscuits seem to have tailed off a bit post-Covid though Grin It's almost always an open coffin and nobody bats an eyelid. People speak normally, not in lowered tones, and you'd go along even if you had never met the deceased but knew one of their children for example. Funerals are similarly open to everyone as they just take place during a daily mass, with the front few rows reserved for the family. If you weren't part of the family you would just go along but sit further back.

In England, any time I've been to a funeral it's by invitation only. And yes I agree there's less acceptance that death is going to happen and a kind of stiff upper lip mentality/air of silence about it all.

BlooDeBloop · 18/09/2022 09:23

Apologies, the Aberfan disaster

BlooDeBloop · 18/09/2022 09:22

Interesting thread. The critical care unit couldn't stop putting needles into my mum hours from her inevitable death. They just couldn't let her die peacefully. I still feel angry about this (7 years ago now).

Pulling out a broader lens, I blame the Victorians and their stuff upper lip (have you read about the silence around the Abergavenny disaster?) and the untold damage wreaked across generations of unexpressed grief. And western socities' refusal to accept any/all signs of aging. There is a real undercurrent belief in living forever. Where does that come from?

RaininSummer · 18/09/2022 09:22

OP I hope all is going peacefully and my condolences to all with recent losses.

I agree that atheists are much more pragmatic and accepting of death than Christians. To me death will mean total oblivion. Thinking about leaving my loved ones makes me sad and I hope it won't be for another 20 years but it could be any day. I will want them to remember happy times and I will live on in their memories until I guess my grandchildren also leave this earth. I hope my ashes rejoin nature and travel with the wind.

I know Christians who seem to be very sad and almost resentful that people they love have died and they are still here waiting to 'join them'. That doesn't seem healthy.

Chevyimpala67 · 18/09/2022 09:04

Carpy88999 · 18/09/2022 06:42

You couldn't be further from the truth if you tried. I don't fear death because its not an experience, its not like being trapped in a dark room that you can't escape for eternity. I do believe in an afterlife but only in the sense we all live in on people's memories. When my father died the worst people were his devout Christian parents. They couldn't accept it and were pretty much useless and we are now NC with them.

I see you pop up on a lot of threads and I'm 100% certain you see all atheists as nihilistic and deeply miserable.

In my experience its the opposite.

The so called devout I know are terrified of illness and death and atheists far more accepting.

debbs77 · 18/09/2022 09:00

I follow Katie Costello on Facebook. She is a Soul Midwife and has had a career in palliative care. She talks openly out death and I find watching her quite comforting.

whythou111 · 18/09/2022 08:57

mostlydrinkstea · 18/09/2022 07:01

The English customs around death have all but gone and nothing has replaced them. People used to die at home, funerals happened quite quickly and the funeral service for most people was a standard CofE Book of Common Prayer with no eulogy. The whole community would turn out for it and if people couldn't attend they would shut their curtains as a sign of respect. Those who were bereaved would wear black for more than one day. It sounds restrictive and our culture is different now but the customs back then acknowledged that death was real, gave the community a rite to manage the transition and did not expect the deeply bereaved to be over it in a fortnight.

It seems that death is now the last taboo. We don't talk about it, plan for it and we expect people to be silent about their grief. Perhaps the late queen's death will open up a conversation about how to do death, dying and bereavement well.

This is so interesting, thanks for sharing. I’m from a different culture and what you say makes a lot of sense. It seems like there’s no agreed script for death in the UK, it can make it tricky to navigate for outsiders as well.

EllietheElephanti · 18/09/2022 08:55

I agree.

I lost my daughter and quite a few people could not mention her or our loss and I know they'd be uncomfortable if I did.

stripeyzeb · 18/09/2022 08:52

My mum died suddenly after a minor op. Her heart just stopped and they couldn't revive her. The shock of the phone call from the hospital was overwhelming but I also remember in the immediate minutes afterwards thinking, 'I know exactly what I have to do.'

My mum was an orphan and had been exceptionally traumatised (as you would be!!) by the early death of her parents. She often said she wanted more for her own family than the horrific trauma she'd been through, so from me being in my 20s, even though she was fit and well, mum and I had good, healthy occasional chats about death and grieving.

I always knew her wishes. She didn't want anyone looking at her body, she wanted us to honour her by living our best lives, she wanted a thanksgiving service rather than a 'funeral' and as she was a Christian, she wanted us to know that she would be ok with Jesus.

She was early 70s when she died and as she was pretty healthy, we never thought we'd lose her as soon as we did but I am so thankful for the many healthy conversations we had about it. It's been nearly 2 years and we've gone through every conceivable emotion but it's good to accept that death comes to us all and it's important that we talk about it long in advance of it being a near reality.

I'm sorry you are in these final stages with your grandmother and I wish her a peaceful and comfortable conclusion to a much-loved life.