Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we don’t ‘do’ dying and death well in the UK

83 replies

FrenchFancie · 17/09/2022 18:06

I’m currently sitting vigil with my grandmother who at 96 is slowly dying - she’s had a lovely long life but a miserable old age riddled with cancer that has robbed her of her sight, and now led to a broken hip and shoulder. She is settled with pain relief and slowly slipping away but this isn’t the quick clean death she would have wanted.

i don’t want to open a euthanasia debate (really can’t cope with that right now!) but I’ve noticed that many people are very very awkward around death and some have even gone so far as to tell me she might recover (she really won’t). AIBU to think we as a culture don’t handle death well? How do we I prove that? Do other cultures do better or is this unease with death a uniform human experience?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AbsentinSpring · 21/09/2022 16:58

People keep saying the Irish way is better than the English. I would have found people viewing my mum's emaciated body distressing. And I didn't want hordes of people around either.

Our neighbours were kind and respectful but I was heartbroken and wouldn't have taken comfort in a wake.

Let's just respect people's different ways of dealing with death and grieving.

AbsentinSpring · 21/09/2022 16:45

@bagboo 🌹I felt the same when my lovely mum was dying. I just wanted her suffering to end.

mathanxiety · 21/09/2022 15:18

@Babdoc
The communities I'm describing would be largely RC in both Ireland and the US. I've also seen several funerals in the local Unitarian community. In all cases there's a pull together approach by the community, and lots of support for the bereaved.

mathanxiety · 21/09/2022 15:14

I do think there's an awkwardness to British culture in this area. YYY to the poster who mentioned the euphemisms - passed away and passed - died, dead, dying are perfectly fine words yet people won't say them.

My mum (Irish) had me choose readings and hymns for her funeral and go over them with her. She's fit and healthy at 88 and a half, but she's prepared. Her will has been made for years. She has a funeral fund in the bank and recently reupped the family grave lease. I've told my DCs what they're to do with me when I die and where I'm to be buried, and I've gone over the grave business with them. My will is made.

Dad's family (his mother came from an Anglo background) were all a bit more skittish about wills. Mum packed dad off, protesting, to do his with his solicitor family member as soon as he turned 65. Dad felt a bit superstitious about it.

I wonder if the horrible delay between death and funeral observances that seems to be the norm in the UK plays a role in reducing the community spirit? In Ireland and the US (and presumably in British communities where prompt burial of the dead is done for religious reasons) a funeral and burial will take place soon after the death. This necessitates a lot of communication and notification or people might miss the opportunity to go to the wake and funeral.

In the community I live in in the US wakes are big, and people drop flowers and all sorts of essential food and home made dinners and desserts to the home for weeks afterwards.

At the wake there are baskets to drop a condolence card into, and the envelopes usually have cash inside too. Funerals can cost quite a bit, and often there's a home to be cleared and disposed of as well, and a delay until funds are released after probate.

Overall there's a practical and helpful approach, no shying away from reality.

DoraSpenlow · 21/09/2022 15:07

The trouble is everyone reacts differently to the death of a loved one. When FIL died we had a continuous stream of family and friends knocking on the door. Now some people would like that but MIL got to the 'oh God, who is it now. Can't they just give me some peace" stage.

And personally I can't think of anything worse than family surrounding my bed watching me die. Just leave me be.

cheaperyp · 21/09/2022 14:34

Yea. The English come up with ridiculous things to say, such as

'She's got this!' Or 'Praying for a miracle' or 'it's not over till it's over' Hmm

About my poorly babies in NICU. Who died, and I told them they were dying but still it isn't believed until you announce it

And then people avoid you in the street. Or don't mention them ever again.

My family are from Spain. Very open talk about death, and children are exposed to it. It is a fact of life. Nobody can be shielded from it, as it can happen to anyone and for so many reasons. Children need to be prepared for that

Despite how open and frank we are as a family about death, we seem to cry the hardest and show emotion more openly too

Odd. My dad is English so I've nothing against English people, I am English! I was born here. But you got what I meant

CloseYourMouthLynn · 21/09/2022 14:23

I agree. My brother died recently of cancer and I was so traumatised by seeing him die and all that went with it because I had never been properly exposed to grief (didn't attend grandparents funerals etc). After having bereavement counselling,I am so glad I was there in his last moments and hope that my own death can be surrounded by those I love. We also took my 4 year old daughter to the funeral and she talks about him and his death in a healthy open way.
I talk about him and his death freely and I'm sure it might make some people uncomfortable.

CruCru · 21/09/2022 14:13

Thanks SparkyBlue.

RaininSummer · 18/09/2022 19:13

Not sure why the atheists on here are being described as bitter. Very odd.

SparkyBlue · 18/09/2022 16:39

@CruCru I'm very sorry for your loss
@gatehouseoffleet yes traditionally most people were buried and for a long time there was only one and then two crematoriums in the country but that's changed and lots of cremations and also lots of non religious funerals among all age groups but most of the rituals still remain such as people going to sympathise and the body being laid out. I have heard of one direct cremation a few weeks ago which was unusual however in general the move away from the traditional funeral hasn't changed how we treat death.

Honeyroar · 18/09/2022 16:38

A very poignant, but interesting thread. I’m currently sitting with my father while he’s dying from heart failure and sepsis. I’m struggling, but trying to cope with it. On the day the Drs decided that he ought to go onto end of life care it made it easier that my father sat up and had the best day he’d had in ages (health wise) and told me he’d had enough, the meds weren’t working, he was sick of being poked and prodded. Everyone has to die sometime.. He was more accepting of it than I was. He is definitely not religious, he’s a scientist.

My mother has been pretty ill for the last few years too. Her best friend (and her daughters, who are my age) are adamant that she must be fixed, she’s too young (81). I wonder if I’m a bit more accepting of it because we’ve hD lots of pets die over the years, so I’ve had to cope with death.

I absolutely hate the phrase “they passed”. I’ll be using died.

lomoko · 18/09/2022 16:37

I have read this a lot and I'm sorry it's people's experience. It's not been my experience of bereavement in England. When my mother was dying many people visited her almost every day -- colleagues, friends, relatives, neighbours, the local priest (even though she was an atheist and he knew that full well). It was a hard death, cancer, and it took a while.

After she died, I received so many kind letters from people, filled with memories about how she touched their lives. I appreciated knowing she was valued and missed, and it made me understand properly why it's important to always write to people about their own bereavements, and go to the funeral if you can. It really matters. People still contact me from time to time to share their memories and I am so grateful.

She died at home and after we said goodbye to her body, they took her to the funeral home by the crem. We had an ordinary crem funeral, no god stuff, and a simple wake in the community centre. Or what we know as a wake, which is basically a do after the funeral, with no body present.

My mother left no instructions but it was not difficult to arrange. The CoOp did it all, basically. I organised it in about a day, and I was barely 25 at the time. We chose some music and read some words and shared some memories and cried together. It wasn't very different from the many funerals I have attended in church, just a bit more Lennon and bit less Jesus.

After she died our family and friends organised an unofficial rota of support for my father, inviting him for dinner etc and checking in on him, for a year or so. Of course we were sad and nobody expected anything else. It was terribly sad. I have always talked freely about my mother and I've had many conversations with all kinds of people about their own family bereavements.

I am of Irish Catholic extraction but way back, like 150 years back, same as half the bloody country, I think! I think we could say it was an English bereavement.

gatehouseoffleet · 18/09/2022 16:19

I've heard a lot that funerals happen very quickly in Ireland, but that is because most people ae buried, isn't it?

I think since Harald Shipman, you need to get through quite a lot of red tape to release a body for cremation and most bodies in the UK are cremated so that creates delays. And then we just don't have enough crematoria; or celebrants to carry out funeral services whether religious or non-religious, so that creates more delays.

My father's funeral was about 2.5 weeks after his death (6 years ago) but my MIL's this year was 5 weeks later! Relatives who've been buried have had funerals more quickly, but still at least 2 weeks later (the church where my uncle and aunt's funerals were held only does requiem masses one day a week, so that also delay things).

CruCru · 18/09/2022 16:17

FrenchFancie I hope your grandmother has an easy death.

CruCru · 18/09/2022 16:15

I sort of agree OP. My Dad died last Sunday and I’m finding it quite hard (or perhaps I’m just irritable). It’s the combination of using a soft, sympathetic voice while expecting me to get on with things as usual.

I’d find the process Jewish friends go through a bit easier - really quick funeral and a set amount of time to mourn. My Dad’s post-mortem is on Tuesday (a week and a half after he died) and we can’t get the death certificate until that’s been done - and we can’t start with the funeral director until the death certificate is available. God knows when the funeral will be.

SparkyBlue · 18/09/2022 16:14

@evilharpy I'm in Ireland and I've never ever known a funeral mass to take place during normal mass. Maybe it's a country thing but certainly not what happens everywhere.
I agree with everyone who is saying the differences in how death is dealt with is cultural rather than religious. I was at a funeral only last week with my three year old now I didn't go into the church with her but stayed outside in the church grounds with lots of others while she played about and when mass was over I went over and sympathised with the daughters of the deceased when they came out of the church . Both of whom I'd known growing up and their absolutely lovely mum was a neighbour of my mum so it's just something that's done here. I met lots of my old childhood neighbours as people show up to pay their respect. It's a great show of support for the bereaved family.
@FrenchFancie thinking of you at this difficult time

OhForGoodnessSake1 · 18/09/2022 16:02

I agree: since my parents' generation starting dying (having got to a variety of ripe old ages), as a family we have been struck by the importance of talking about death and funerals in advance: the worst services have been where the individual had not expressed particular desires, leaving the grieving to work out what would be good. The best have been planned by the individual, or at least been based on preferences or thoughts they have had. And the value of the wake, gathering to share memories, has really shown itself.

DownNative · 18/09/2022 15:44

BadNomad · 18/09/2022 15:30

Yes, maybe your relatives are more Irish in their ways when it comes to this. I have worked as a nurse in N. Ireland and Scotland, and it was prodominantly the English relatives that struggled to see death was the positive or right outcome in these situations. There was a different vibe around it. A fear or denial. That's not to say some Irish/Scottish didn't find it hard, but in general they were more likely to set up camp around the bed and have a good natter about life and whatnot.

I would say it likely had more to do with the fact they were farmers until relatively recently. So, death wasn't exactly alien to them.

But I would expect this to be the case anywhere in the UK and ROI where people live in countryside.

And I'd expect those living in urban areas to struggle more as you don't often see all kinds of death I those areas (human and animal).

DownNative · 18/09/2022 15:38

Snugglemonkey · 18/09/2022 08:12

I am Irish in Scotland and I find the Scottish way more reluctant to deal with death. Wills are a difficult topic, funerals are awkward and everyone is so self contained. I really don't like it, as it just feels alien to me.

I am much more comfortable with the open discussion, having the deceased at home, doing a wake etc. I think it really helped me with the grieving process when my mum died.

If my partner died, I would try my best to do things Irish style. Even if his family didn't engage, my family and friends would come over and do it. I would never do the Scottish thing of just leaving him in a funeral home. It feels so cold and unloving. It would be far too distressing.

I don't think there's any major difference there either. Some Scottish families are like this and some are not.

My English grandfather's coffin was brought home for the last time too. Again, some families will do this and some will not.

One relative wouldn't put soil in on top whereas another did.

BadNomad · 18/09/2022 15:30

DownNative · 18/09/2022 15:02

I'm from Northern Ireland, but none of my English relatives match your description at all. Certainly none would say "Good luck!" or something silly like that.

On the whole, the way we deal with it in both places is very similar. I think it is in many, many places in the UK.

Where it differs tends to be on an individual family basis rather than cultural.

Yes, maybe your relatives are more Irish in their ways when it comes to this. I have worked as a nurse in N. Ireland and Scotland, and it was prodominantly the English relatives that struggled to see death was the positive or right outcome in these situations. There was a different vibe around it. A fear or denial. That's not to say some Irish/Scottish didn't find it hard, but in general they were more likely to set up camp around the bed and have a good natter about life and whatnot.

DownNative · 18/09/2022 15:29

Angrymum22 · 18/09/2022 10:51

My first memory of death was my great aunt. I was 5/6 yrs old and we were staying with my other g-aunt ( both aunts lived together). No one, back then, left their family member in a chapel of rest, this was 1960s England and not catholic. I wanted to see the coffin, I’d never seen one, so after a little discussion my DF took me into the room. It was an open casket and I clearly remember the lid resting against the wall with a brass name plaque on it. I don’t remember being sad or scared. I was actually more interested in the coffin that the dead body within. The room was as it always was, the curtains drawn but not dark.
A huge contrast to my DM in a chapel of rest with strange amber lighting (quite spooky/disturbing) . I would have been much happier seeing her in our sitting room at home.
I agree that we have sanitised death to the point where we are no longer able to grieve in a natural way.
I think the Queens death has opened up a conversation for many people. Why don’t we offer our own family the same ability to say goodbye. The queens family were allowed time with her body to adjust to accept that life had gone. It was not whisked away only to be seen again as it is taken away for good.
Many hospices have a cold room ( a normal bedroom kept at a low temp) used when a patient dies for family to come and spend time with their loved one. Why shouldn’t every family be afforded the time to say goodbye properly.
It used to be the norm, now it is seen as odd. Perhaps funeral directories should offer it as an option to everyone.
A vigil is not a religious act it is an act of love. Looking after your loved one after death is no less important that looking after them when alive.

When my English grandfather passed in 2012, everyone was given the choice of seeing him in a cold room. My English sister and I (N.I.) went together. No-one else wanted to including my other N.I. sister.

The option is still there for people.

I don't think there's major differences between the UK and ROI in dealing with death. IME, any differences tend to be on an individual family basis as you can find many in both who conform to the typical stereotype and many who don't.

Oblomov22 · 18/09/2022 15:24

I talked to my mum about her wishes, re death, funeral, we made a list of her wishes, who to give her rings to! I'm also executor for her will. I don't know why people can't have such conversations.

Motherofalittledragon · 18/09/2022 15:19

My mum died recently with pneumonia and although she passed away in less than 24 hours she suffered in those hours and there was nothing really that could be done to ease that for her. Death in this country is not dealt with well at all.

BadNomad · 18/09/2022 15:19

Snugglemonkey · 18/09/2022 08:12

I am Irish in Scotland and I find the Scottish way more reluctant to deal with death. Wills are a difficult topic, funerals are awkward and everyone is so self contained. I really don't like it, as it just feels alien to me.

I am much more comfortable with the open discussion, having the deceased at home, doing a wake etc. I think it really helped me with the grieving process when my mum died.

If my partner died, I would try my best to do things Irish style. Even if his family didn't engage, my family and friends would come over and do it. I would never do the Scottish thing of just leaving him in a funeral home. It feels so cold and unloving. It would be far too distressing.

I haven't found that with my Scottish relatives at all. I can't think of any who weren't brought home and put in the front room or bedroom for the wake. My family have been crossing back and forward between Ireland and Scotland for centuries, they're more similar than different in most ways. But even the Scots I'm not related to are this way too. So maybe it depends on the area.

DownNative · 18/09/2022 15:02

BadNomad · 18/09/2022 06:55

It is really strange. The Irish and Scottish definitely have a healthier relationship with death in my experience. Even during the process, the language is different. People wish you quick, painless, peaceful passing for your relative, not a "Good luck! I hope a miracle happens!"

I'm from Northern Ireland, but none of my English relatives match your description at all. Certainly none would say "Good luck!" or something silly like that.

On the whole, the way we deal with it in both places is very similar. I think it is in many, many places in the UK.

Where it differs tends to be on an individual family basis rather than cultural.

Swipe left for the next trending thread