Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ILs won't contribute to our wedding but spent fortune on BIL

258 replies

gobblefiend · 17/09/2022 16:08

Would you be annoyed if ILs paid £35000 + for BIL/SIL wedding but did not want to contribute a penny to yours?

Both my family and ILs are well off. SIL family aren't rich so ILs paid for their entire wedding. Big big wedding, country house, entertainment then paid honeymoon business class flights upgrade for them both. Spent a fortune on them.

MIL made it very clear she did not want to pay for our wedding by saying 'I'm not paying for it' very bluntly after we announced our engagement. We were shocked she was so tactless but she has form for not wanting to help us. This furthered my already deeply held suspicion of favouritism towards BIL/SIL anyway (long story).

Now, firstly let me say that we didn't expect any contribution from ILs, genuinely. We were going to pay for it ourselves, but am I wrong to feel hurt that she said this? To not want to contribute anything for her other son? I feel she is jealous of my family's money (even though she is rich herself) and it stems from this (plus the favouritism) that she'd go as far as not wanting to contribute anything. Our feelings weren't considered and never are, it's all about pleasing her son/DIL.

My family don't splash the cash like her, in fact the opposite, they are very frugal. I couldn't imagine doing it to my kids, I would always treat them fairly but AIBU?

OP posts:
Escapingafter50years · 17/09/2022 20:02

They sound like a horrible family. Your DH-to-be has grown up in this dynamic so there's going to be a lot of ingrained crap there which will show up over time. I think you both would benefit from several months of therapy before proceeding with a wedding.

From your latest post, OP, I think your gut might be telling you to have a big think about whether you want to be involved in this toxic family "until death do us part". @billy1966 has given great advice which I hope you'll take on board.

On another note, I don't think I've ever seen a thread where so many posters have such poor comprehensive skills!

  • The parents paid for the son's wedding, the DIL is who he married, not their daughter
  • It's about the unequal treatment, not how much was spent on a wedding day
Booklover3 · 17/09/2022 19:59

Careful OP my in laws are very much the same and the favouritism has never ended. In fact they’ve caused a bone of contention between my husband and I since day one. He won’t say anything to them about how they make him feel and is always upset with their behaviour. He did try once or twice (he said) but they didn’t listen. Didn’t want me to say anything either. It eats away at him.

Ive stopped taking the shit and am now no contact with them.

My therapist warned me that you marry the family too before I got married… and she wasn’t wrong but I scoffed at the time.

Not saying any of this to put you off because you need to do what’s best for you. Just enter the marriage with your eyes open. It’s doubtful that it will get better. Toxic people don’t stop being toxic.

💐 neither of you deserve to be treated this way.

perfectlypickled · 17/09/2022 19:53

Why are you fighting this ?

”I find her so difficult. She throws her toys out of the pram so often her family laugh it off. I'm not willing to put up with it anymore though. To feel second best”

You are giving her power over you if you are allow her to effect you emotionally by feeling second best. You need to let that go, be cordial, and indifferent, it seems like she knows how to press your buttons to get a response. Don’t do that.

Let her poor behavior be hers, don’t buy into it. Laugh with her family, cuz they are not laughing with her….

She lives across the country so you can go super low contact. Plan the big holidays with people you want to be with, no strain or dread when you think about those plans, right?

Show your fiancé how a supportive family operates, this will empower him and hopefully arm him with the tools needed to support your own family as it grows.

You have a life to live where she doesn’t warrant being a footnote. Take care!

gobblefiend · 17/09/2022 19:51

crosstalk · 17/09/2022 19:41

I would just go ahead with your wedding with the happiness she can't call the shots because she's contributed. If your fiance is happy with everything and doesn't particularly feel his mother's preference towards his brother and wife, then just leave it and don't get angry on his part. Do you and your and his family all live in the same neck of the woods? A red flag is your future MiL berating your father for not contributing to your husband's business. I wouldn't like her on my doorstep. Also, how do you get on with BiL and SiL?

We don't see BIL/SIL often as they moved to the other side of the country. I prefer SIL to BIL. He has cheated on her in the past-she found out about one but not the others. We (me, partner, MIL/FIL) all know he's cheated many times on her in the past so I'm not his biggest fan. IMO she deserved to know when we found out but I would never divulge it now of course. He been a gambler too. SIL is nice but full of herself

OP posts:
noirchatsdeux · 17/09/2022 19:43

Virtually the first words out of my future MIL's mouth when my fiance told her we were engaged were "We don't mind if you elope".

I first thoughts were 'fuck you then' and 'I don't care what you mind' ... I know for certain FIL doesn't like me, but even to this day my fiance insists his mother does...meh. I'm 54, they are both 73 and I'm far too old to care...

crosstalk · 17/09/2022 19:41

I would just go ahead with your wedding with the happiness she can't call the shots because she's contributed. If your fiance is happy with everything and doesn't particularly feel his mother's preference towards his brother and wife, then just leave it and don't get angry on his part. Do you and your and his family all live in the same neck of the woods? A red flag is your future MiL berating your father for not contributing to your husband's business. I wouldn't like her on my doorstep. Also, how do you get on with BiL and SiL?

RoseJam · 17/09/2022 19:26

Your MIL is being unreasonable paying for one son's wedding and not another.

However, is there anything you can really do about it?? Agree with other posters who have said it is up to your DP to raise this with his Mum.

On a positive note - if she refuses to contribute, you get to call the shots and make all the decisions. You owe her nothing and you don't need to to tell her f*all. You can treat her like a normal guest - you are free!!

Also- it sounds as if you have benefited from her handouts in the past. I would be personally grateful for that. Not many have that privilege. Also, by acting the better person and rising above it, you may find she may be willing to help you both out in the future. (But you also have every right to feel annoyed about your wedding).

Loachworks · 17/09/2022 19:24

HRTFT but I had similar ILs. I come from a family with lots of siblings and DF was terminally ill when I married so I had no expectation of anything from my parents, who were actually very generous considering.
They made it perfectly clear what they thought of me. How I wish I'd read 'Toxic in laws' back then but I might not have married my lovely DH if I hadn't been so naive. There are so many outing details of that day but one is they said it was embarrassing that we chose a tiny wedding in a registry office (I'm atheist and it was there or church.) They didn't even get us a card or gift, despite paying thousands for both SIL's weddings. MIL spent a thousand pounds on an outfit and told everyone it cost more than my dress.
I gave my bouquet to an aunt to put on my grandmother's grave. When we came back from honeymoon the flowers were sat on her dining room table. They did and said some unforgivable things.
They have set you free by telling you now. Just make sure your partner is firmly on your side. I'd see this as a positive because you owe them nothing and no invites would be extended to any of their friends and their input would not be welcome.

billy1966 · 17/09/2022 19:06

Good for you for learning to assert yourself.

The thing is how exhausting and soul destroying it is to be married to a man that is conveniently "laid back" AKA someone who avoids conflict and will stand by while his wife is bullied and disrespected.

How exhausting it is to live a life where you have to be constantly alert and ready for the next insult and put down from his ghastly family.

It's no way to live.

You are young and energetic now.
A decade on with a family like that and you will look back at this time and think differently.

So many posters have written how if they had their time over they would have made a different choice, the stress and upset is not worth it, even more so with children involved.

I would strongly recommend you press pause and pay for some good therapy for yourself.

It will be money well spent.

What are your parents like?
How do they feel about these awful people and their precious daughter attaching herself to a weak man and his toxic family?

They can hardly be happy?
Who on earth would want this for any child?

worriedatthistime · 17/09/2022 19:06

@Zebedee55 read the op they have to sons no daughter mentioned

bpirockin · 17/09/2022 18:53

I can understand your resentment totally, but for me it's the way she's gone about it rather than the money itself. Having been involved with a man from a controlling family, it certainly isn't an easy situation to deal with, and is only likely to get worse over time if the pair of you don't set some boundaries now. A friend of mine is happily married to a man from a similar and moneyed family. His parents told him that if he married her they wanted nothing more to do with him and he would be cut out of their Wills. He married her, moved away and had children, moving back to 'home' ground some years later. The family reconnected, the grandparents adore their grandsons, and the defiant son who stood up to them is now considered the only one with any gumption, and has their respect. The other siblings continue to be manipulated for fear of losing their inheritance, while the brother who stopped taking their shite, is now the favourite.

Your partner has been a people pleaser for a long time, he'll need your help to put his brother and his parents where they should be, by not accepting their complete disregard for you, his chosen partner. It'll be uncomfortable for a time undoubtedly, but worth it in the end. They don't have to like you, but if they have such a preference for the other son, then let them get on with it. Let them bail him in out when he needs help. You're on your own and managing perfectly well thank you. Show them that their controlling behaviour only succeeds in pushing you away. One day they'll realise it is their loss.

worriedatthistime · 17/09/2022 18:52

All those who say they wouldn't be bothered etc . Do you treat your own children with such favouritism because thats what it is
Even the daughter thing of parents paying is old fashioned , outdated and sexist really.
But even adult children are your children, so if you help out one you try and help the other when needed.
You wouldn't order a pizza for one kid and tell the other there bread in the cupboard would you
Obviously people can do what they like with their money but then when it comes to how people treat them later in life they need to remember they reap what they sow
My mil treats my dh poorly compared to his siblings, which is fine and her choice and also out choice not to help out now she needs it or do any care as what goes around comes around

wholesomen · 17/09/2022 18:49

Ok, OP, seriously. This is your future life. If you're going to enter into a marriage, you need to be a team in that marriage. Marriage and relationships come with all sorts of tests. This is not a frivolous fling. This is a marriage you're entering which, I'm pretty sure you know, is a legal and binding contract. Are you confident that your marriage partner is on the same page as you? Has he the same goals? The same dreams? Are you his priority? Or is his mother?

wholesomen · 17/09/2022 18:43

This advertisement used to be around donkey's years ago. I loved it then. For some reason it didn't last long on TV (I suspect some MILs complained)

gobblefiend · 17/09/2022 18:41

Mosso · 17/09/2022 18:23

It sounds like you've been together years. I wouldn't want to pay for an expensive wedding then either.

No idea why but I wouldn't see the point.

BIL/SIL have been together longer than us so your logic doesn't work there!

OP posts:
gobblefiend · 17/09/2022 18:33

billy1966 · 17/09/2022 18:23

Why are you marrying into an family?

You are spectacularly naive and you will regret it.

I mean that kindly.

That laid back man who doesn't notice things is actually probably weak and will NEVER stand up to them.

The money is the least of your problems.

You are marrying a man from a toxic background who is cowered by them.

You are young and think love will conquer all, when the truth is it often doesn't when you marry weak men that are frightened of their bully parents, and have been reared to accept shit behaviour.

@Whokno post is a sensible approach if you insist on marrying him.

If you insist on marrying him, ask his immediate family and no one else, no friends, or other randomers.
If they kick off tell them their attendance isn't necessary.
Be prepared to go NC.

You will not want any children you might have around such toxicity.

Women like you often bitterly regret marrying into such a toxic stress.

No happy gatherings.
No warm and loving involvement.
No feeling you have an extended group of people who want the best for you and are genuinely interested in you.

Life is short and to knowingly tie yourself to such awful people is such a waste.

If you were my daughter I would strongly recommend you rethink this.

That you found it acceptable that his mother has been so rude and unpleasant to you for so long, and he doesn't seem to notice, should be a huge red flag to you.

Most women with boundaries and self respect would have run for the hills, and realised who needs this bullshit in their lives.

I mean all of the above very kindly to you.

Do you really want this?
A life with a man whom you are constantly having to discuss how rude, nasty and ghastly his family are?

Having boundaries and self respect is only a recent development of mine unfortunately. I've been a doormat for too long. Thank you for your post it has resonated with me

OP posts:
wholesomen · 17/09/2022 18:29

Zebedee55 · 17/09/2022 18:28

The first wedding was for their daughter. Old traditions are that parents pay/help out with their daughter’s wedding.

You are the female here, and if they’re traditionalists, they would expect your parents to pay/help out for you (their daughter).

WRONG.

Two sons.
OP is marrying the eldest son.
The unsuccessful younger brother is the BIL in question.

Zebedee55 · 17/09/2022 18:28

The first wedding was for their daughter. Old traditions are that parents pay/help out with their daughter’s wedding.

You are the female here, and if they’re traditionalists, they would expect your parents to pay/help out for you (their daughter).

wholesomen · 17/09/2022 18:26

Don't come crying back here when you end up telling her 'YOU'RE THE CARCASS!'

BadNomad · 17/09/2022 18:25

I'm another one who thinks you should really think twice about marrying into this family. It's not so much because of MIL, but rather because you and your DP are not on the same page when it comes to his mother. You need to be a united front. If he's going to be "laid back" and never pull her up on her awfulness to your family (you, DH, any children), and allow her to treat you both badly for the sake of keeping the peace, then you are going to have a lot of problems in the future. You'll be back on here being told "you have a DH problem, not a MIL problem".

wholesomen · 17/09/2022 18:24

billy1966 · 17/09/2022 18:23

Why are you marrying into an family?

You are spectacularly naive and you will regret it.

I mean that kindly.

That laid back man who doesn't notice things is actually probably weak and will NEVER stand up to them.

The money is the least of your problems.

You are marrying a man from a toxic background who is cowered by them.

You are young and think love will conquer all, when the truth is it often doesn't when you marry weak men that are frightened of their bully parents, and have been reared to accept shit behaviour.

@Whokno post is a sensible approach if you insist on marrying him.

If you insist on marrying him, ask his immediate family and no one else, no friends, or other randomers.
If they kick off tell them their attendance isn't necessary.
Be prepared to go NC.

You will not want any children you might have around such toxicity.

Women like you often bitterly regret marrying into such a toxic stress.

No happy gatherings.
No warm and loving involvement.
No feeling you have an extended group of people who want the best for you and are genuinely interested in you.

Life is short and to knowingly tie yourself to such awful people is such a waste.

If you were my daughter I would strongly recommend you rethink this.

That you found it acceptable that his mother has been so rude and unpleasant to you for so long, and he doesn't seem to notice, should be a huge red flag to you.

Most women with boundaries and self respect would have run for the hills, and realised who needs this bullshit in their lives.

I mean all of the above very kindly to you.

Do you really want this?
A life with a man whom you are constantly having to discuss how rude, nasty and ghastly his family are?

This with bells on.

Mosso · 17/09/2022 18:23

It sounds like you've been together years. I wouldn't want to pay for an expensive wedding then either.

No idea why but I wouldn't see the point.

billy1966 · 17/09/2022 18:23

Why are you marrying into an family?

You are spectacularly naive and you will regret it.

I mean that kindly.

That laid back man who doesn't notice things is actually probably weak and will NEVER stand up to them.

The money is the least of your problems.

You are marrying a man from a toxic background who is cowered by them.

You are young and think love will conquer all, when the truth is it often doesn't when you marry weak men that are frightened of their bully parents, and have been reared to accept shit behaviour.

@Whokno post is a sensible approach if you insist on marrying him.

If you insist on marrying him, ask his immediate family and no one else, no friends, or other randomers.
If they kick off tell them their attendance isn't necessary.
Be prepared to go NC.

You will not want any children you might have around such toxicity.

Women like you often bitterly regret marrying into such a toxic stress.

No happy gatherings.
No warm and loving involvement.
No feeling you have an extended group of people who want the best for you and are genuinely interested in you.

Life is short and to knowingly tie yourself to such awful people is such a waste.

If you were my daughter I would strongly recommend you rethink this.

That you found it acceptable that his mother has been so rude and unpleasant to you for so long, and he doesn't seem to notice, should be a huge red flag to you.

Most women with boundaries and self respect would have run for the hills, and realised who needs this bullshit in their lives.

I mean all of the above very kindly to you.

Do you really want this?
A life with a man whom you are constantly having to discuss how rude, nasty and ghastly his family are?

Snog · 17/09/2022 18:23

Often the money comes with a serious amount of strings attached and expectations from the recipients that will stretch way into the future.
It may well be a blessing in disguise that no money is coming your way.

wholesomen · 17/09/2022 18:23

You need to walk into this with your eyes wide open. She will never like you. Why? Because HER BABY loves you. So, now that we've that aside, how enmeshed in your financial affairs is she?

Have you any common ground? Can you stand being around her?