Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ILs won't contribute to our wedding but spent fortune on BIL

258 replies

gobblefiend · 17/09/2022 16:08

Would you be annoyed if ILs paid £35000 + for BIL/SIL wedding but did not want to contribute a penny to yours?

Both my family and ILs are well off. SIL family aren't rich so ILs paid for their entire wedding. Big big wedding, country house, entertainment then paid honeymoon business class flights upgrade for them both. Spent a fortune on them.

MIL made it very clear she did not want to pay for our wedding by saying 'I'm not paying for it' very bluntly after we announced our engagement. We were shocked she was so tactless but she has form for not wanting to help us. This furthered my already deeply held suspicion of favouritism towards BIL/SIL anyway (long story).

Now, firstly let me say that we didn't expect any contribution from ILs, genuinely. We were going to pay for it ourselves, but am I wrong to feel hurt that she said this? To not want to contribute anything for her other son? I feel she is jealous of my family's money (even though she is rich herself) and it stems from this (plus the favouritism) that she'd go as far as not wanting to contribute anything. Our feelings weren't considered and never are, it's all about pleasing her son/DIL.

My family don't splash the cash like her, in fact the opposite, they are very frugal. I couldn't imagine doing it to my kids, I would always treat them fairly but AIBU?

OP posts:
Kate0902900908 · 18/09/2022 20:44

Have a destination wedding.
don’t invite them. If they ask why no invitation just explain it’s a destination wedding for friends and family who have contributed and made it possible.
She is poison. Don’t hang around to watch BIL inherit it all run now and keep them at arms length.

cooldarkroom · 18/09/2022 19:49

Can you have a wedding, with reduced numbers, just your best friends & loving family ?
Mine was fabulous, (& without being biased !!) the best wedding I have every been to. We did the paperwork at the town hall, then everyone walked to a lovely restaurant, we had privatized, had champagne & fab food, which we could afford as reduced numbers. etc, then most of us back home to party & dance into the night.
Informal, full of laughter, with only the people we really wanted there

LaDamaDeElche · 18/09/2022 19:46

Like other posters have said, I would be rethinking the marriage. What you know describe as 'laid-back' in your DP may not look that way in x years time after years of this shit and him not really doing anything to address it. Add children into the mix and either she treats them as lesser or tries to take a controlling roll, cutting you out of the picture as much as she can, with your DP still not really having the balls to rock the boat too much. Imagine however many years more of that. It also sounds like you have got tied up with her in business, which is absolutely mad to be honest.

superplumb · 18/09/2022 19:34

I'd elope with a few choice people..then I'd tell them it was a small do because you wanted to keep costs down hence why they weren't invited but then I'm petty

Mix56 · 18/09/2022 19:33

This isn't about money, it's a power play, showing you & their son their disapproval. his place & value in the family.
He takes it because he was subjected to their toxicity since childhood, being the the less loved 2nd child, & he hasn't got the character & courage to change it.
Please read & re read billy's posts.
The only potential solution with your Husband 1000% completely on board is to go Low to No contact, avoid them, move a good distance from them, don't go at Xmas etc, don't expect any love, help, support or care, & if there is any it will be a double sided sword that will return & cut the legs from under you.

& for all that is holy, keep you future children far far away from them

Mariposista · 18/09/2022 19:07

Everyone ought to pay for their own! If you can’t afford it you can’t have it

Monstermunch67 · 18/09/2022 19:05

My in-laws were the same, fawning over DH's siblings and paying for wedding gifts etc. Never contributed to our wedding, no housewarming gift, not even a gift or card when our daughter was born. Admittedly it was hurtful, but I brushed it off saying at least we didn't have to thank them for anything.

Luredbyapomegranate · 18/09/2022 18:57

Just pay for yourselves - most people don’t get endless handouts.

Also, it’s just a wedding and it doesn’t need to cost much. Save sticking your hand out till you need help with something important like school fees or an op, you’ll have more credit that way.

Also I am not sure it’s favouritism so much as the wedding costs probably galloped away from them and ended up more than double what they expected.

Your MIL’s comment has the air of shell shock

Dragonsmother · 18/09/2022 18:15

OP, sadly this woman sounds awful.
if she gave you a penny for the wedding she would own the whole show.
I too HAD a toxic MIL and SIL. For the first year my DH didn’t have my back and stood back whilst I was demoralised, emotionally abused and at my lowest. We nearly got divorced.
The minute he woke up and saw everything for what it was everything was better. We have been NC with In-laws for 7 years. This is the best thing we have done.
cut her out of your life. She is vile

IamMaz · 18/09/2022 18:12

I experienced this. My DH’s parents paid for my BIL’s wedding - as parents of SIL had no money. My parents funded my wedding to DH - in full. I never expected in-laws to contribute but was miffed all the same.

What really annoyed me was that my DH made his speech thanking BOTH sets of parents!!!!!! WTF????? It was only MY PARENTS!!!!

I nearly stood up to put the record straight!!!! But this was 32 years ago and then it was not expected for brides to speak up! It still bloody rankles!!!!!

Rosie22xx · 18/09/2022 17:58

You are right to be hurt. Do not allow her to have any input then as she doesn't want to pay. Don't let her chose the guest list for your husbands side of the family, let your husband chose and who he even wants there, not all this extended family that don't even care about you both anyway. Majority of people that are invited only come for the food and judge everything. So only invite who actually cares about you both etc. She don't wanna contribute, so she has zero say on anything. It's not her wedding, simple. She can't have it two ways, so any complaining she does into valid, she has zero grounds. She does not sound supportive whatsoever.

Heygal · 18/09/2022 17:57

gobblefiend · 17/09/2022 16:08

Would you be annoyed if ILs paid £35000 + for BIL/SIL wedding but did not want to contribute a penny to yours?

Both my family and ILs are well off. SIL family aren't rich so ILs paid for their entire wedding. Big big wedding, country house, entertainment then paid honeymoon business class flights upgrade for them both. Spent a fortune on them.

MIL made it very clear she did not want to pay for our wedding by saying 'I'm not paying for it' very bluntly after we announced our engagement. We were shocked she was so tactless but she has form for not wanting to help us. This furthered my already deeply held suspicion of favouritism towards BIL/SIL anyway (long story).

Now, firstly let me say that we didn't expect any contribution from ILs, genuinely. We were going to pay for it ourselves, but am I wrong to feel hurt that she said this? To not want to contribute anything for her other son? I feel she is jealous of my family's money (even though she is rich herself) and it stems from this (plus the favouritism) that she'd go as far as not wanting to contribute anything. Our feelings weren't considered and never are, it's all about pleasing her son/DIL.

My family don't splash the cash like her, in fact the opposite, they are very frugal. I couldn't imagine doing it to my kids, I would always treat them fairly but AIBU?

My mum called my FIL when engaged and explained she wants to make a contribution of £x and would he be offended. He said absolutely not and matched her. Thought very diplomatic of her and also very kind of them both. Perhaps your parents could reach out and check if they wanted to contribute (be it financially or by a particular assistance). Of course, you may not want to considering your MIL sounds like a 🙃🙃🙃

StrongTea22 · 18/09/2022 17:51

We didn’t get anything by towards our wedding or married life from my in-laws.

my sil got a deposit for her first house and wedding contributed towards and gets all the childcare she ever needs.

Unfair, wasn’t expected at all but still felt to be unfair. I have both sexes of children myself and will help both.

adultchildofalcoholicparents · 18/09/2022 09:52

Before your eyes, your love will die.

Your respect and admiration will disappear as you realise you haven't married a healthy man, but a scared child.

You will realise you are the ONLY adult in your marriage and your children only have one parent.

100% this. It will destroy all of your resources: emotional, cognitive, physical, and financial.

You will think love and support can conquer all. They don't. There is a gaping maw of need and deep unhappiness that creates a vortex of misery and hopelessness.

Biker47 · 18/09/2022 09:49

Not inviting them would be the nuclear option, which is something I would have insisted on if it was me, but I'm a psycho with no social skills who doesn't take people's shit, so it would be like water off a ducks back for me, but it sounds like that's a nonstarter with your future husband.

I like the idea of them having no involvement and publicly subtly erasing them from any involvement, I'd ask your partner to not have his dad or brother in the wedding party as ushers etc. same for SIL as bridesmaid etc. I'd sit the in-laws and their golden son and daughter-in-law on a table at the back not at a head table, then wheel out the gifts for your parents/siblings/friends who were involved, and don't even mention them in any speeches, but I also think your partner isn't going to agree to any of that either, so you're going to end up sitting next to you MIL on the head table listening to her criticise everything from the DJ to the quality of the food you picked.

billy1966 · 18/09/2022 09:12

You are getting wise advice on here.

Especially when people remind you that we do bring our rearing into our marriages with us.

If he has been reared in a toxic environment of favourites, golden children, narcissistic parents, it will have left his mark.

He's laid back means he avoids conflict because he is still a scared child.

He is unable or unwilling to stand up to his parents when they behave badly.

He won't stand up for you.
He won't 🙈🙉🙊.

This will be who he is.

If you have children he will allow them to be used and manipulated and will follow his parents directions ahead of yours.

Before your eyes, your love will die.

Your respect and admiration will disappear as you realise you haven't married a healthy man, but a scared child.

You will realise you are the ONLY adult in your marriage and your children only have one parent.

I am so sorry to be negative but young women like you have their lives and dreams destroyed by marrying men that are so enmeshed with a toxic dynamic that they are unable to stand up for themselves not to mind another person.

You deserve better than this.

Honestly the money and the wedding is so unimportant.

It is the marriage that you should be focusing on and how you will feel if this poisonous dynamic is a part of your life.

That your MIl would come to your parents home demanding money is extraordinary.

Surely any decent family would be appalled and aghast at such crass behaviour.

She has no boundaries and she will spend your marriage trampling on any you have.

Press pause, get into therapy and look very hard at this man.

Whatever love you feel you have for him won't long be going out the window as you witness nothing but drama and ugliness surrounding your every interaction with these people.

Dramatic perhaps, but save yourself!!

Cognacsoft · 18/09/2022 08:35

passport123 · 18/09/2022 07:19

Laid back = he won't support you against her

Don't marry this man

Agreed.

Also how do your inlaws know about your family finances?
You need to be more discreet.

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 18/09/2022 08:34

My MIL is the same. Probably paid a fortune towards SIL's wedding (never asked though) Had DH's sister and brother living with them, mooching off them and generally taking the piss for years. My DH had no choice but to leave home and fend for himself because his loser brother (an adult at the time) kept stealing his stuff. And when my DH was made redundant the first words that came out of his mum's mouth was 'you needn't think you're moving back in with us' (we never asked to anyway thanks bitch and frankly I'd rather sleep in a cardboard box and stick pins in my eyes than live with you but good to know where you stand....) We have a dd now and they run around ragged after his sister's kids but offer basically zero help to us. And this is all just the tip of the iceberg tbh ITO some of some of the horrific stuff they've done. This is all fine. They're grown adults. They're entitled to do what they wish with their time and money just as we are. What goes around comes around. They needn't think I'm lifting a finger or paying a penny towards any nursing care they need when the time comes ...

RampantIvy · 18/09/2022 08:21

Laid back = he won't support you against her

IME laid back = lazy

passport123 · 18/09/2022 07:19

gobblefiend · 17/09/2022 17:11

My partner is supportive of me but he's incredibly laid back about things. He has stood up for me but just doesn't get as emotional about things as I do.

Laid back = he won't support you against her

Don't marry this man

Murdoch1949 · 17/09/2022 22:50

Blimey MIL is a manipulative piece of work! If you truly love your husband to be, marry him, pay for it yourself, give MIL the minimum hospitality your fiancé can deal with. Do not involve her in any wedding plans, tell her nothing except date/time. She will criticise everything from colour scheme to menu if you give her a window in.
If she kicks off on the day, have her removed, do not let her toxicity spoil your day (have some burly male friends primed to help if necessary). After the wedding, distance yourself from her, and BIL. It's up to your future husband what he wants to do. When (if) you have children, think carefully of the extent of her contact with them. She sounds as if she could try to manipulate any grandchildren, so time alone with them is a red flag. Good luck.

Indoctro · 17/09/2022 21:09

billy1966 · 17/09/2022 18:23

Why are you marrying into an family?

You are spectacularly naive and you will regret it.

I mean that kindly.

That laid back man who doesn't notice things is actually probably weak and will NEVER stand up to them.

The money is the least of your problems.

You are marrying a man from a toxic background who is cowered by them.

You are young and think love will conquer all, when the truth is it often doesn't when you marry weak men that are frightened of their bully parents, and have been reared to accept shit behaviour.

@Whokno post is a sensible approach if you insist on marrying him.

If you insist on marrying him, ask his immediate family and no one else, no friends, or other randomers.
If they kick off tell them their attendance isn't necessary.
Be prepared to go NC.

You will not want any children you might have around such toxicity.

Women like you often bitterly regret marrying into such a toxic stress.

No happy gatherings.
No warm and loving involvement.
No feeling you have an extended group of people who want the best for you and are genuinely interested in you.

Life is short and to knowingly tie yourself to such awful people is such a waste.

If you were my daughter I would strongly recommend you rethink this.

That you found it acceptable that his mother has been so rude and unpleasant to you for so long, and he doesn't seem to notice, should be a huge red flag to you.

Most women with boundaries and self respect would have run for the hills, and realised who needs this bullshit in their lives.

I mean all of the above very kindly to you.

Do you really want this?
A life with a man whom you are constantly having to discuss how rude, nasty and ghastly his family are?

If I had known how toxic my In-laws are I would of reconsidered marrying my husband

They have caused no end of stress, also favour his sister over him. Similar thing done with weddings

Never bother with our kids or my husband .

Husband is used to it so says nothing

I'm totally NC with them now as couldn't take there toxic behaviour anymore

I find it sad though as some of my friends have fantastic in laws and I feel upset with what awful people I got stuck with

I honestly would think long and hard , if your husband will cut them out your lives for hood I would marry him but if not then I would run a mile.

Watzzap · 17/09/2022 20:56

My ils paid for their DD’s wedding and everything had to be the best. They actually asked dh if we could help them out financially! DH and I had been married for 6 years and had 3 DCs, so definitely did not have any spare money. They were most upset that he wasn’t willing to help out his DS, to the extent he actually thought about taking a loan out, which I completely put the kybosh on, I told him I would leave him if he put his DS before his own children!

When we had got married, they gave us a miserly £200 and dh’s share of the guest list was mostly made up of their friends! I wasn’t happy that he didn’t get to ask his friends, but he didn’t want to rock the boat!

Be very careful OP, that you know your future DH will be strong enough to support you and stand up to his parents.

Porcupineintherough · 17/09/2022 20:54

You know OP its really hard for people you don't see to treat you badly.

mammiaa · 17/09/2022 20:37

For me, as someone who's BIL is clearly favourite, this is how I would do it.

I would plan it your way. Not allow her any input into the guest list. Let your husband decide his family guest list and stick to it.

Do a round table, not a "top table" that way you don't have to parade the miserable cow as if you're all happy families and she had a prize spot as darling mother of the groom. Sit yourself next to your parents. Fill the rest with MOH and best man, invite them both out for dinner and drinks with your parents the month before so they all get along well and you have a nice table atmosphere.

Photos, do your family ones, then some group ones and try avoid ones with them. Let your husband take ones with his parents , they don't deserve your wedding pictures on their mantelpiece!

Keep your cool. It's your wedding!