Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Head girl at my daughter's school is Head Mistress's daughter.

114 replies

StrawberryPims · 17/09/2022 13:32

Just to be clear my daughter was not in the running and is in a lower year group. It is a primary school, year 6. The new Head Girl is more of an all rounder than an academic. No idea how they make these decisions, but, regardless feel that there is a massive conflict on interest. AIBU?

OP posts:
Andromachehadabadday · 18/09/2022 07:58

So you aren’t fussed, have no interest in finding out how the decision is made but are convenes about it?

I don’t see why the daughter should be automatically exempt from being head girl because of their parents job.

I would wait until I found out more before forming any opinion.

Blondeshavemorefun · 18/09/2022 07:55

onlythreenow · 17/09/2022 21:31

This is a prime example of why you shouldn't be able to teach at the same school your children attend let alone be a headmistress at one.

I grew up in a small town with two primary schools (one Catholic) and one high school - should all the teacher parents of students have travelled out of town to work? Towns are further apart here than they are in much of the UK by the way. It never seemed to be an issue having teachers/children at the same school. The heads also had children at those schools.

It seems to me that it's only an issue because parents who are too involved in their children's school lives feel their precious little darlings might be disadvantaged.

Yes the teachers should travel

I know 3 teachers and all refuse to work in their local town schools as 1) their kids go there 2) they don’t want to bump into their pupils or parents locally

so they travel 20/30mins

speakout · 18/09/2022 06:48

onlythreenow · 17/09/2022 21:31

This is a prime example of why you shouldn't be able to teach at the same school your children attend let alone be a headmistress at one.

I grew up in a small town with two primary schools (one Catholic) and one high school - should all the teacher parents of students have travelled out of town to work? Towns are further apart here than they are in much of the UK by the way. It never seemed to be an issue having teachers/children at the same school. The heads also had children at those schools.

It seems to me that it's only an issue because parents who are too involved in their children's school lives feel their precious little darlings might be disadvantaged.

I agree- it isn't so easy.
If you live in a rural community school choice can be effectively non existant. LA will usually only pay for transport at the catchment school, rural public transport is dire in many areas, meaning having to drive long distances to get to school and parents get to work

onlythreenow · 17/09/2022 21:31

This is a prime example of why you shouldn't be able to teach at the same school your children attend let alone be a headmistress at one.

I grew up in a small town with two primary schools (one Catholic) and one high school - should all the teacher parents of students have travelled out of town to work? Towns are further apart here than they are in much of the UK by the way. It never seemed to be an issue having teachers/children at the same school. The heads also had children at those schools.

It seems to me that it's only an issue because parents who are too involved in their children's school lives feel their precious little darlings might be disadvantaged.

onlythreenow · 17/09/2022 21:24

So, you really don't know how the decision is made, but you are questioning the decision!! Her being an all rounder sounds perfect. Why do you actually care anyway - she's Head Girl at a primary school, she hasn't landed some high flying executive job!!!

teaisready · 17/09/2022 21:06

Totally agree @lovelyboneslove there is a boy in DD’s school who is absolute horror however as both his mum and dad are teachers at the school nothing ever gets done about it. It really is a conflict of interests and is very unprofessional

lovelyboneslove · 17/09/2022 20:34

This is a prime example of why you shouldn't be able to teach at the same school your children attend let alone be a headmistress at one.
Total conflict of interest.

WGACA · 17/09/2022 17:47

Testina · 17/09/2022 14:25

Do you think MN will have a different set of opinions? I’d have thought any group would have a mix of:

  • it’s fine if she’s best candidate
  • should be excluded even if objectively best
  • meh

Do you really need more opinions, or do you just disagree so want to get more people saying it here to fan your fire?

Do people still say “headmistress?”

Headmaster/Headmistress is widely used in independent schools. The Head’s children nearly always go to their school as otherwise it’s like saying this school is ok for other people to pay for their children to attend but not mine!

In one independent school I worked in the Head ultimately lost her job because of how favourably she treated her own children. Many children in their classes left because of how favourably her (rather badly behaved) children were treated and the situation was becoming untenable.

If I’d have been the Headmistress in this situation I’d have made it clear that the process had nothing to do with her this year due to potential conflict of interest with her daughter in the running. That said, the daughter would still have an advantage potentially if her mum could help her with her campaign but sometimes it’s all done with the class teacher in the interests of fairness.

People don’t like nepotism it’s like ‘Chair of Governors son gets Head Boy shocker’ I don’t even need to ask who got it because well of course he was always going to get it!

speakout · 17/09/2022 17:45

I don't believe the "student choosing" is a real thing.
My DD was head girl recently in her last year at a very large comprehensive.
Students had a vote, and the feeling was that a couple of the very popular girls would be chosen.
My DD wasn't terribly popular with other students, but staff knew her to have a strong but quiet personality, very kind, calm in a crisis, kept her achievements ( qualified and worked as a dance teacher part time while still at school) to herself.
Some of the popular students ran voting campaigns, my DD didn't even try but decided to go for interview anyway- that was the head, and two of her teachers who knew her well.
My DD became head girl- it didn't feel much like the student vote held any sway at all, just a way of making students feel empowered- when in fact the positions were chosen by staff.

Yesthatsit · 17/09/2022 17:38

I thought this was common at prep schools. The one mine went to had a lot of staff parents and their kids won absolutely everything going. Which did irritate as they also got a massive discount and weren’t known for going above and beyond. More the TA/admin staff though rather than the teachers. It was the only (and still is) the only prep in a large area so bit of a captive market.

This had the result of parents being generally disgruntled so had no time for the pta malarkey or events or being overly generous with their time and money. They tried running a few events for parents and never sold any tickets. It was painful to watch. It also generated a feeling of general unease so there was no sense of fun or togetherness, everyone had a air of pissed offness which did go through parents and kids.

Then if any kid who wasn’t a member of staffs child won anything it was always because the parent had complained about something and everyone knew it. So rather than say to the mum ‘oh well done I heard Dot won the so and so award’ it was ‘oh my gosh I saw what Dot won, what happened?! What did the school do?!’

Shame really. I was told it’s the same everywhere so good learning for the kids that life’s unfair, but nothing to get knickers in a twist over. Teaching was good though.

itsgettingweird · 17/09/2022 17:34

Lesserspotteddogfish · 17/09/2022 16:44

The teachers choosing rather than the students might not be a bad idea. I remember my class went rogue and voted in someone fun as head of class over the other responsible candidates, just to annoy the teacher.

I think this is one of the reasons the students choosing is fabulous.

Teachers choose who who they. If it's to represent the students why not take a risk at what the students want.

After all - that's who they represent. And it gives you an insight into how to meet the mindset of your current students.

That's why I didn't like our recent PM selections. It was who the members wanted. We don't know what the public want but yet they are the ones being represented.

True democracy allows the public to make their decisions - and they have to live by them. So if the class clown proves not to be useful for actual student representation - lesson learnt Grin

asblindasabat · 17/09/2022 17:33

Depends how it’s chosen.

if it was decided by other students in a vote then I can’t see much wrong with it

Norma27 · 17/09/2022 17:31

I was at secondary school with the head’s daughter. She was in my class. We didn’t have head boy/girl but to be honest if we did and it was her she deserved it as much as anyone else. She was a popular all rounder.

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2022 17:28

Zone2NorthLondon · 17/09/2022 17:20

Have no desire to join PTA and I’m at work FT.
PTA don’t work and obsess over the minutiae of who gets what

It’s a factual observation not a gesture of Pick me, pick me

I’m on the PTA and work full time. And aren’t you on here complaining about who gets what?

Zone2NorthLondon · 17/09/2022 17:20

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2022 16:13

Join the PTA then.

Have no desire to join PTA and I’m at work FT.
PTA don’t work and obsess over the minutiae of who gets what

It’s a factual observation not a gesture of Pick me, pick me

cinnabongene · 17/09/2022 17:18

I’m a school governor and my daughter is Head Girl at the same school. She was voted by pupils and teachers. I didn’t even know she was in the running. I’d hate to think other parents are bitching about it (but they probably are)

IAmAReader · 17/09/2022 17:15

@Zone2NorthLondon I agree, as an educator who worked in roles which involved visiting various schools I seen a lot of this.

Not everyone can join the PTA and the fact if this is happening, it's definitely wrong so more people piling onto the PTA to secure preferential treatment for their child wouldn't solve it.

Important to note, the PTA parents are often the ones in a position to choose to work part-time or not work at all.

A PP suggested it might be because those kids are seen to have more supportive parents but I don't altogether buy this. I think when this kind of unfair bias occurs it's more linked to rewarding the more involved parents who help the school out. And they are also the type of parents to create a fuss if their child is given a silent part.

There are very capable children whose parents aren't in the PTA who need very little input from parents who would learn lines or be the captain of the school sports team etc fine.

And if they are really doing it for that reason that would discriminate against a range of children including ones from troubled backgrounds which isn't fair and replicates the kind of inequality we are seeing in society.

If teachers genuinely feel there's issue where the child won't get as much as support as they will need, they can always try and work around it and put in that additional support including setting the child 'homework' to learn lines.

I used to work with children in care, and some of them didn't have the most engaged foster parents, and their biological parents had limited contact.. I'd have been horrified if a teacher passed them over for a role or position they were capable of because they didn't have the 'right' parents.

WilsonMilson · 17/09/2022 17:09

It does scream nepotism, and it it’s surely ridiculous and meaningless to have a head girl at a primary school.
I don’t think my annoyance about this would extend further than some eye rolling though.

speakout · 17/09/2022 17:08

It is a hard one. In the last few years at secondary school ( a very large comprehensive) I was close friends with the head's daughter ( he also taught us English)
He was relentless in pulling up his daughter for every little demeanour- in an effort to be seen not to show favouritism he would pick her out in line for having the wrong shoes or a sloppy school tie ( even though others had the same).
He would come down harder on her in class for talking or getting an answer wrong. I felt so sorry for her, her father was a tyrant, and there was no escape- at home ( he was a bully there also) or at school. No hope of my friend becoming head girl.

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 17/09/2022 17:04

If her mother appointed her then yeah that's not on. I think the world is getting quite sick of the blatant nepotism going on.

Blondeshavemorefun · 17/09/2022 17:03

Bet she can’t wait to leave and go to secondary

if pupils and teachers voted no probs

if head chose then yes an issue

IAmAReader · 17/09/2022 17:02

Summerslam · 17/09/2022 16:05

I work in a place where the big boss's daughter is on the payroll. She gets seconded for training opportunities and helped to further her career because of who her mother is, and not because she is brilliant at the job. Other people working at the same grade aren't offered the same opportunities and it isn't fair.

But life isn't fair.

Learning this a primary school is a good.

Nepotism is rife in a lot of industries.

This is sad but very true.

Riverlee · 17/09/2022 16:57

Thatiswild · 17/09/2022 13:38

She shouldn’t excluded from having an opportunity because of it nor should she be favoured so it completely depends on how she was chosen. An all rounder sounds perfect for the role!

This

ReformedWaywardTeen · 17/09/2022 16:50

If this was secondary it would bother me. It's not entirely fair at this point either but kicking up a stink will do you no favours if your child is in a lower year group.

Trust me, many eyebrows will be raised. Let someone else raise it

And I say that as someone at 15 was indeed voted head girl by staff, but the daughter of a wealthier parent with a fat chequebook waved a big donation and she was made head girl over me. It sucked at the time but it did the girl involved no favours at all. She grew up thinking daddy would pay her way to doing well and getting ahead. It really didn't. And when Daddy was later found out to have committed fraud, her downfall was massive.

dianthus101 · 17/09/2022 16:47

This kind of thing happened all the time when DD was at primary school. The favouritism was unbelievable and very obvious to the children. One child in particular (a teacher's daughter) received just about every award going and it made her quite unpopular so really didn't do her any favours.