Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Prince Harry should now do whatever it takes to cancel his book contract?

808 replies

FromageRouge · 16/09/2022 22:13

And withdraw his book?

A rapprochement looks possible if he meets the RF halfway.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
StormzyinaTCup · 17/09/2022 01:31

bloodyplanes · 17/09/2022 01:14

@TheWheeledAvenger Oh and you are definitely reading the mood in the country very badly if you think that Charles isn't well liked. He's played a blinder and captured the mood of the country over the last few days!

@bloodyplanes I have always been a bit unsure about Charles and if you had asked me two weeks ago who I would prefer as King I would have said William. However, having seen King Charles out and about this week and listened to his speeches, all under extremely difficult circumstances, I have been pleasantly surprised and would have to concur that indeed a blinder has been played.

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 01:30

Anyone who think Charles will strip his own child of his rightful title just because he moved to California and wrote a book is delusional. Using language like "slap Meghan down" is deeply unpleasant. The King does not make major changes that will affect future generations of royals in order to "slap a woman down."

It's like Harry personally betrayed them, and now they're writing revenge fantasy fanfiction. They're convinced Charles is going to enact some triumphant revenge while Harry snivels away with his tail between his legs and is never heard from again, when in reality Charles appears desperate to do everything he can to make the family appear solid and unified. Why else do they keep dragging Meghan out to do these funeral-related events when she looks like she'd rather be having a root canal? Because they need the family to look unified. Charles cannot be a world diplomat if he can't even keep on decent terms with his own child.

Anyway it's not as simple as Charles deciding whether to grant Archie and Lili HRHs or not. If Charles doesn't want them having HRHs then he will have to issue new Letters Patent, and he has to think about the potential ramifications on the younger Cambridge children.

bloodyplanes · 17/09/2022 01:26

Elisi · 17/09/2022 01:23

I never ever thought I'd hear myself saying this, but I'm starting to feel a bit sorry for The Meghan. Take one unhappy member of our Royal Family, the most famous family on the planet, add an actress who wants nothing more than to be rich, famous and influential, and aforementioned unhappy Prince has got his get-out excuse, he can just blame it on the wife. Their evacuation to America happened SO quickly, one could wonder if it was all pre-meditated. They used the excuse that they wanted privacy from media intrusion, yet The Meghan is milking her Duchess title for all it's worth, appearing on everything that'll have her. Harry on the other hand, is living the life of Riley, using the Prince thing without lifting a finger re Royal duties. He's got what he wants (the life of a Royal without doing anything to earn it) and she's got the fame and fortune she wanted (again, without lifting a finger except to bite the hand that's feeding her). Cut them loose and see how well they do then.

Spot on

bloodyplanes · 17/09/2022 01:23

@TheWheeledAvenger because you stated in a pp that Charles needs to present an image of a united family to the world. Antagonising H&M by refusing to give their children HRH is hardly likely to achieve that is it! Im sure they will run straight back to the US and sell their upset to the highest bidder!

starrynight21 · 17/09/2022 01:23

StartupRepair · 16/09/2022 22:33

He knew the Queen's age when he signed up to write it. She was either going to be alive and hurt by the content or have just died. He wasn't bothered obviously by either of those scenarios.
.Harry does not seem like someone who thinks ahead much.

This. I suspect that he doesn't think ahead about anything.

Elisi · 17/09/2022 01:23

I never ever thought I'd hear myself saying this, but I'm starting to feel a bit sorry for The Meghan. Take one unhappy member of our Royal Family, the most famous family on the planet, add an actress who wants nothing more than to be rich, famous and influential, and aforementioned unhappy Prince has got his get-out excuse, he can just blame it on the wife. Their evacuation to America happened SO quickly, one could wonder if it was all pre-meditated. They used the excuse that they wanted privacy from media intrusion, yet The Meghan is milking her Duchess title for all it's worth, appearing on everything that'll have her. Harry on the other hand, is living the life of Riley, using the Prince thing without lifting a finger re Royal duties. He's got what he wants (the life of a Royal without doing anything to earn it) and she's got the fame and fortune she wanted (again, without lifting a finger except to bite the hand that's feeding her). Cut them loose and see how well they do then.

thefoggiest · 17/09/2022 01:23

I can't explain why this is but I feel like when the queen was alive Harry and Meghan were more important. Now that she has gone they have dropped down and will presumably now be faded out more.
Does anyone know what I mean? Its weird because if anything you'd think it would be the opposite but that's just the feeling I'm getting, that with the queens death their rank has lessened

TruffleShuffles · 17/09/2022 01:19

I can’t see the death of the Queen making a difference to whether the book is released or not. They had no issue with the effects it would have had on a 96 year old woman in ill health who had lost her husband last year when alive so why would they be bothered when she’s dead?

onlylarkin · 17/09/2022 01:18

Can someone show me proof that Charles has denied the Sussex children their HRH titles?

Proof not in a tabloid?

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 01:18

bloodyplanes · 17/09/2022 01:11

@TheWheeledAvenger I think that king Charles has showed that he is perfectly capable of toeing the hard line by refusing to give Archie and Lillibet HRH titles! Knowing full well how much this will infuriate H&M and give them even more whinging material!

Eh?

Your comment was about Charles "not hesitating" to "slap Meghan down" (lovely misogynistic language) by removing her and Harry's titles. Why have you changed the subject?

Stripping his own son's title is very different from not giving Archie and Lili titles to begin with!

Oh and you are definitely reading the mood in the country very badly if you think that Charles isn't well liked. He's played a blinder and captured the mood of the country over the last few days!

Well yeah you would say that.

bloodyplanes · 17/09/2022 01:18

Fwiw I actually don't think Meghan could win this week no matter what she did. She has been visible as a member of the royal family and supporting her husband and has been roundly slagged off for having the nerve to show her face at a time like this. But if she had jumped on a plane back to the USA then she would have been slagged off for that as well. But I suppose you reap what you sow, she has courted controversy and now she has it regardless of if she wants it or not!

Bacibaci · 17/09/2022 01:18

FarmerRefuted · 16/09/2022 23:17

Exactly this.

And when Catherine is praised in the press and written about positively for the very same actions and behaviours that Meghan is criticised for, you have to wonder what the defining difference is between them.

Examples here,:

Here Are 20 Headlines Comparing Meghan Markle To Kate Middleton That May Show Why She And Prince Harry Left Royal Life buzzfeed.com/ellievhall/meghan-markle-kate-middleton-double-standards-royal

The tabloids were awful about Kate for years. Their stock in trade seems to be cruel to all new female partners of the Royal Family for a good while.

The two Daily Mail articles about Meghan , the almost straight outta Compton one and exotic DNA ones -that were in the video posted in this thread were racist. However, no excuse for those 2 articles, but even the tabloids mainly gave positive coverage until a few months after the wedding. The public were v supportive. They then - especially the Daily Mail - got vicious and were criticising Meghan almost daily. I remember thinking she may have done something to annoy them. We have since read that the Royal Family have an agreement with the press on matters, how articles are shared amongst the press etc, and I wouldn’t be surprised - I have zero evidence of course - Meghan and Harry didn’t want to follow this agreement and this angered the toxic Daily Mail who became relentless in their criticism. Even if she did annoy them their relentless criticism was grim.

Cameleongirl · 17/09/2022 01:16

I really hope the book is a rather boring introspection fest, @TheWheeledAvenger, it would be much better than pages of vitriol. I don't think being vitriolic will make Harry any happier - getting on with his life in the US will.

viques · 17/09/2022 01:15

Whammyyammy · 16/09/2022 22:31

Agreed, and selling his family secrets to the highest bidder

He will be bringing it up to date with funeral gossip and titbits……

bloodyplanes · 17/09/2022 01:14

@TheWheeledAvenger Oh and you are definitely reading the mood in the country very badly if you think that Charles isn't well liked. He's played a blinder and captured the mood of the country over the last few days!

MissFancyDay · 17/09/2022 01:13

I may be simple but I just don't get them, and I just don't know what they want.

They wanted out of the RF, all fine by my book. Lovely mansion and lots of celebrity friends. So why are they constantly complaining and angry, the faces on them both when they are over here.

I get that they dislike the RF and that they both hate the u.k ( it's on record) so why come and demand to be visible all the time. Why not just be like Zara, and other grandchildren. Pay their respects and go back home.

CatServant2020 · 17/09/2022 01:11

Do I think that Harry should try to get out of the book contract ? yes if he wants a rapprochement with his family.

Do I think the media and those buying into their narrative that Megan is pure evil have behaved disgusting this week ? yes the vitriol Megan has faced is disgusting.

Do I think that Harry and Megan behaved appropriately in the past, no

However over the past week in my opinion they haven't done anything that can be seen as wrong yet we've had smirk-gate which in my opinion a photo has been taken of a facial expression which has been labelled as a smirk to suit the media narrative.

The Royal family have been seen smiling whilst out and about, is smiling not worse than smirking, even if it was true. I'm not criticising the smiling, with grief in the early days you go between hysterical laughing to sadness. I'm just highlighting the double standards.

We then had holding hand-gate, it was disgraceful that Harry & Megan did it but when it was pointed out that Zara and either Beatrice or Eugenie and spouse did the same. people could not explain why it was ok for them but not for Harry and Megan. I don't think that this was due to race but that it didn't suit the narrative that people wanted to paint that about Megan.

I think it's all very complicated. Harry had a privileged childhood but it wasn't a normal childhood. Someone will say but so did William but people react to the same situation in different ways and the death of their mother was a traumatic experience.

What I find most ironic is that the media played a part in Harry's mother's death and now his wife is being hounded by a media driven narrative and no I wasn't a Diana fan so that isn't my reason for saying this.

I know there will be comments that oh they courted publicity but that does not excuse the behaviour of the media or those making vitriolic against Megan now.

My final thought is that none of this affects any of us directly and really what goes on in the royal family is their business and not ours.

bloodyplanes · 17/09/2022 01:11

@TheWheeledAvenger I think that king Charles has showed that he is perfectly capable of toeing the hard line by refusing to give Archie and Lillibet HRH titles! Knowing full well how much this will infuriate H&M and give them even more whinging material!

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 01:05

bloodyplanes · 17/09/2022 00:45

@TheWheeledAvenger exactly that! The "institution of the crown" is bigger than any of them! Its not really a voluntary choice to not use it because if she does they not hesitate to slap her down by LP and remove her titles! How would she get the money and attention she so craves then?

That's highly, highly unlikely for several reasons.

First, stripping the child of a monarch of their title for weak reason creates a dangerous precedent that Charles and William are desperate to avoid.

Second, stripping Harry and Meghan of their titles to punish them for committing the crime of wanting to work and live their own lives, and whining a bit, while permitting Andrew to keep his (who's also no longer a working royal), is disastrous optics. Removing Harry's title and not Andrew makes Charles look hypocritical.

Third, making a very public display of punishment would cause a scandal that would backfire on Charles at the very time he needs to create the appearance of stability and unity. There's already a lot of criticism for how Harry has been treated in comparison with Andrew. Publicly punishing his own child but not Andrew makes Charles look petty and vindictive. Charles is not well-liked, he's having to replace a beloved Queen, the last thing he wants right now is that kind of scandal.

Fourth, punishing Harry would lead to wider conversations about how the BRF operates behind the scenes and lead to greater focus on Harry's comments about the unspoken agreements. Edward VIII didn't get his HRH stripped and he abdicated and he was a Nazi sympathiser. There's no way letting Nazi sympathisers and (alleged) rapists keep their HRHs but stripping Harry of his isn't going to massively rebound against the RF.

Fifth, Harry is the King's son and he always will be. Removing a title doesn't change that and comes across as desperate.

Finally, Charles has to work hard to create the image of a King. A Monarch has to be head of their own household and head of the country. A Monarch has to be a diplomat. Why do you think Harry and Meghan were invited for the Jubilee, why they got shoved out to do high profile walks with William and Kate? Why Charles mentioned Harry and Meghan in his speech? Because it's part of the game. It's all PR! The BRF desperately need to make the family look unified right now, and to make Charles look like a peacemaker. How bad does it make King Charles look if he can't even keep peace with his own child? If he severely punishes his own child and removes his child's birthright, it'll do more to damage his own reputation than it will Harry's.

No. People online love their little revenge fantasies. In the real world, there's little chance of that.

And again the weird idea that Americans know or care about the intricacies of British titles. Having her HRH removed formally wouldn't make the slightest jot of difference.

Tierne · 17/09/2022 01:00

No I hope the book goes ahead so their vitriol is fully exposed.

With her majesty gone, the public will no longer feel duty bound to show begrudging good will.

Harry will become fully rejected by the UK public which will presumably work in H and M's favour as they will no longer be called upon to perform cameos and will finally be able to live the life of tranquility they aspire to have.

bloodyplanes · 17/09/2022 00:59

nonono1 · 17/09/2022 00:56

I really liked Meghan - and was very excited about what she and Harry could have achieved together within the royal family - until they moved to the US and started bad-mouthing the RF at every given opportunity. I just wish they'd put their incredible platform to better use than slagging off the RF!

Tbh i had no opinion on her either way! I had never heard of her. However I must admit that when I watched the engagement interview I did think that she could be trouble. The constantly talking over Harry, making it all about her rather than all about them. Its just not the royal way!

nonono1 · 17/09/2022 00:56

I really liked Meghan - and was very excited about what she and Harry could have achieved together within the royal family - until they moved to the US and started bad-mouthing the RF at every given opportunity. I just wish they'd put their incredible platform to better use than slagging off the RF!

IAmAReader · 17/09/2022 00:53

FarmerRefuted · 17/09/2022 00:44

When was it that they liked her? Was it when they were posting articles about her being straight out of Compton? Or when they were ridiculing her for talking about the importance of mental health and saying she should show some stiff upper lip? Or when they were clutching their pearls over her putting scented candles in the church for their wedding? Or when they were saying she could have poisoned her little bridesmaids with her choice of flower arrangement? Or when they implied her love of avocados was wrecking the environment and fueling low pay for the workers picking them?

@FarmerRefuted

Right I don't get when people go back to this mythical time when Meghan was accepted and loved by the public.

I mean was it not even at her wedding she was reported to have made Kate cry and the media and public dragged her for that, when it now seems the truth was she was the one made to cry by Kate. And if the latter isn't true why I find it interesting they didn't put out a press statement correcting that after the OW interview.

They never liked MM, there is a whole host of reels and photo collages people have put together to show how the DM, the most read news paper in the UK, has constantly put out negative stories about Meghan and then reported something similar about Kate but put a positive spin on it.

This was from day one, it did not begin at they left or after the OW interview. Prince Harry even put out a statement criticising the subtle and not so subtle racism in many of the articles. I can't remember when but I think it was before the wedding.

I had to get rid of a friend who sent me a photoshopped picture of MM in her wedding dress with a penis, one the day of the wedding. There is a racist history of comparing women of black heritage to men so I saw it for what it was and phased out the friendship later that year (and btw she showed other signs of racism too, it wasn't just that one incident)

A key indicator of racism is punishing someone of colour more harshly for the same perceived infraction or wrong than a white person who does the same thing. It's like the black footballers who were loved until they made an error in the euro finals and then suddenly they were [insert racial slur] .

No doubt some people liked MM at the start and now do not, but I still believe if she were fully white, she would not have had as many people turn on her or at least attack her like this even if they grew to disagree with her actions.

bloodyplanes · 17/09/2022 00:52

@FarmerRefuted you are confusing the British public with the British press! As I previously stated the press have been vile to every single woman that has married into the royal family for years and Meghan was no exception. The public however were pleased for Meghan and Harry even when they no longer wanted to be working royals and moved abroad. The tide started to really turn against them after the OW interview and its just got progressively worse since then! I do think it's unfortunate that her latest interview slagging off the royals was published only a week before the death of HMQ, which has led to the public loathing her even more.

RosalindsAFuckingNightmare · 17/09/2022 00:49

I do wonder if "being back in the fold" this last week and seeing the amount of support The Queen and new King have will change their focus? Being part of the pomp and circumstance with a bit of distance may change both of their views, especially Harry now that he has lost the grandmother he professed to be close to and is grieving. Who knows what has happened behind the scenes this week, maybe conversations, dinners together. I hope it will have taken some heat out of their view of how they have been treated. I don't think there is any appetite right now for a book slagging off the Royal Family.

Swipe left for the next trending thread