Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Prince Harry should now do whatever it takes to cancel his book contract?

808 replies

FromageRouge · 16/09/2022 22:13

And withdraw his book?

A rapprochement looks possible if he meets the RF halfway.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 17/09/2022 03:48

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 03:24

said they didn't want titles for their children

When did they ever say that? They didn't. Find one single article quoting them as saying that, you can't.

Stop believing everything you read in the tabloids. A tabloid claiming they don't want titles is not the same as them actually saying it themselves.

Omid Scobie tweeted it. I'm not searching for it at 4am.

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 03:24

said they didn't want titles for their children

When did they ever say that? They didn't. Find one single article quoting them as saying that, you can't.

Stop believing everything you read in the tabloids. A tabloid claiming they don't want titles is not the same as them actually saying it themselves.

HoppingPavlova · 17/09/2022 03:24

YABU. I doubt a rapprochement is possible because I don't think Meghan will ever be accepted into that family, and that's what the problem has always been.

Bulldust. The problem was two-fold. Firstly, she thought she could swan in, become a princess, do whatever she wanted her way and if necessary get the rules bent for her as she thought she was special as she believed she was famous in her own right.

Secondly, Harry was too thick to explain to her from the beginning that about strict Royal protocols, how to behave and that, while he might think she was special, there would be no bending of the rules for her and if she didn’t accept that it wouldn’t work between them.

Then when it went pear shaped, she tantrumed, and he thought he could run to granny and have considerations made for her. Granny laughed. They got a shock, got the shits and flounced thinking everyone else would cave. No one caved and do they made up a lot of shit and went public with it to justify their flounce.

They will never leave public life as she is an attention seeker. Stay tuned for more lies every time they start to fade into the background. She will do whatever it takes to stay ‘in the limelight’. I see not one book but a new book every few years as they desperately try and stay front and centre. When they can no longer stay front and centre and command attention, she will leave him.

DysonSphere · 17/09/2022 03:14

But here's some of the incendiary petty nonsense:. So apparently M&H have been 'uninvited' to the State Reception. Presumably because they are not 'working' royals. Daily Mail of course.

Either the RF want to bring them back in the fold or they don't.

This sort of stuff brings resentment.

onlylarkin · 17/09/2022 03:13

TomPinch · 17/09/2022 02:54

It's pretty underwhelming though. From the article:

"(50%) said they have seen coverage of Markle that they thought was “racist in tone or presentation”."

(emphasis mine)

On those parameters I would have expected way higher.

But the main point is that it's very different to saying that the press has, overall, presented Megan in a racist way.

Newsflash. Things that are seen as racist are, in fact, racist.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 17/09/2022 02:57

FarmerRefuted · 16/09/2022 23:42

Harry has wanted to leave the RF for years and has expressed disatisfaction for years, long before he ever met Meghan, then when he did reach a stage of wanting to get married, have children, etc it motivated him to get the fuck out.

Good for him, more people should opt out of toxic situations that are damaging their health and the world would probably be a happier place for it.

He's not opted out though. They want to do what they want, said they didn't want titles for their children then grumble to Oprah Winfrey about the lack of titles. They want it both ways, one foot in the past, the royal family, one in the future, Cali celebrity.

With one foot in the past and one in the future you piss on the present.

DysonSphere · 17/09/2022 02:56

Meili04 · 16/09/2022 23:43

Nope give them an inch they take a mile. They want to merch the RF without doing any of the boring stuff. Absolutely no HRH titles for the children they don't live in the UK nor even a commonwealth country. There's no royalty in the US. They are petty and spiteful they will still find something to complain about let him release the book. There's not much more after that he could sell. MM was in the RF for 2 years . They have been frozen out and won't be privvy to new information they are no where near as popular as Diana.

Once he sells the book the interest in them will massively die down they are one trick ponies with very little talent.

Maybe you're right.

TomPinch · 17/09/2022 02:54

It's pretty underwhelming though. From the article:

"(50%) said they have seen coverage of Markle that they thought was “racist in tone or presentation”."

(emphasis mine)

On those parameters I would have expected way higher.

But the main point is that it's very different to saying that the press has, overall, presented Megan in a racist way.

onlylarkin · 17/09/2022 02:41

TomPinch · 17/09/2022 02:18

"according to half journalists completing PG survey"

I'm not sure what that proves exactly.

That even many journalists in the UK think she received racist and unfair coverage, while at the same time seeing posts on forums such as MN and social media from the citizens of the UK do not see that the coverage was racist.

I am not saying that the citizens of the UK are racist. I am saying that the media coverage of her has been racist and anyone saying it has not been is blind.

TomPinch · 17/09/2022 02:32

The second article is the usual scurrilous shit that every woman who marries into the RF has to put up with.

The first article is more interesting. It says two things. The first is that Megan's genetics will improve the RF's appearance. Provocative, but hardly a criticism. The second is that she leave Harry when she gets a better offer. Well, she has left the RF so the article is accidentally prescient.

Misogyny, not racism, is the issue with those articles.

I'm not interested in the smalldoings of the RF. I think they should be left in peace. Most families would have problems under all that constant scrutiny.

So I don't know what annoys me more: those who dig the dirt on celebrities, ie the press; those who consume the dirt, ie, those who buy the mags, or those who throw others under the bus to monetize it, ie, H & M.

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 02:28

The thing with streamlining the monarchy and not giving HRH titles to anyone except the monarch/heir's children is that it is an excellent idea in theory but tricky to implement due to the family dynamics, and there are concerns about ramifications on future generations.

It's a shame the Queen didn't start slimming things a generation ago. It would have been so much simpler if Charles' children were the only ones given HRHs and all three younger children treated the same. It's harder when there are only two because the divide is more stark. If Harry had siblings whose children were also not HRHs it would reduce the impression this is about punishing or not punishing him for leaving. The treatment of the Queen's grandchildren was also a bit of a mishmash due to sexism (Anne's children not automatically getting HRH just because Anne is female) and Andrew's pushiness with his girls.

The other issue is the future. Issuing new LP saying the grandchildren of a monarch are no longer entitled to HRH means that Charlotte and Louis' children likely won't be HRHs. Who knows what William thinks about that precedent being set and whether he would want his future grandchildren to be HRH or not. But the royals do have to think in the long term and to think about precedent. The RF are all about tradition and the longterm. They aren't going to make permanent changes just because one relatively unimportant person left.

lemmein · 17/09/2022 02:18

People with toxic or dangerous families are not generally encouraged to build their lives around that family or use their membership in the family as the centerpiece of their income.

How have they done that?

TomPinch · 17/09/2022 02:18

"according to half journalists completing PG survey"

I'm not sure what that proves exactly.

lemmein · 17/09/2022 02:16

The constantly talking over Harry, making it all about her rather than all about them. Its just not the royal way!

Seriously when I read comments like this I imagine older women in the 1950s with their hair-nets on gossiping in hushed tones on the doorstep about the 'loose' woman who lives up the road.

I swear we haven't progressed at all.

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 02:11

MangyInseam · 17/09/2022 02:07

Way to miss the point....

There was a point to bizarre ramblings about Harry becoming fat, Meghan turning into a plastic surgery addict, and a baby growing up to become a cokehead? Really?

Because it looked like unhinged ranting.

MangyInseam · 17/09/2022 02:10

lemmein · 17/09/2022 02:06

I've never known a person go low contact with a loving family, ever - doesn't happen, there's always reasons.

People always advise posters on here to go no/low contact with toxic family members - why should harry just put up with it because they're royal? Why should Meghan 'keep her head down'(ffs 🙄) and put up with blatant racism and lies from the press? Fuck that - 2022 and we're still telling women to be fucking kind in the face of abhorrent abuse directed at her.

People are pissed because he didn't marry a silent clothes horse and instead chose a black, vocal, American actress. Just own it.

It'll be those very people that'll be first in line to buy the book though; just so they can fume 😂

It's not really a matter of going low contact though.

People with toxic or dangerous families are not generally encouraged to build their lives around that family or use their membership in the family as the centerpiece of their income.

It wouldn't be healthy for regular people to do that either.

MangyInseam · 17/09/2022 02:07

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 01:52

Speculating that a baby will grow up to become a drug addict.

Keep it classy, Meghan haters.

Way to miss the point....

lemmein · 17/09/2022 02:06

I've never known a person go low contact with a loving family, ever - doesn't happen, there's always reasons.

People always advise posters on here to go no/low contact with toxic family members - why should harry just put up with it because they're royal? Why should Meghan 'keep her head down'(ffs 🙄) and put up with blatant racism and lies from the press? Fuck that - 2022 and we're still telling women to be fucking kind in the face of abhorrent abuse directed at her.

People are pissed because he didn't marry a silent clothes horse and instead chose a black, vocal, American actress. Just own it.

It'll be those very people that'll be first in line to buy the book though; just so they can fume 😂

Bacibaci · 17/09/2022 02:06

Regarding Archie and Lilibet possibly not being given the address of HRH, Charles has said long before Meghan came on the scene that he wanted to slim down the Royal Family probably as he knows that will give it a better chance of surviving. Only the Norwegian King, Queen and their first born child and children have titles and the address of Crown Prince or Princess and carry out Royal duties as members of the Royal House. The Kings second child is still called a Princess but not Crown Princess and her children have no titles. She is classed as member of the Royal family but not the Royal House.

The King of Sweden in 2019 removed royal titles - Prince and Princess and HRH - from his 5 grandchildren by his second and third child. The grandchildren are still allowed to continue to retain their titles of Duke and Duchess. The grandchildren are no longer expected to do royal duties once they reach adulthood. The King’s 2 affected children recorded no problem with this and publicly said they were glad as they think it is good that their children now have a greater opportunity to shape their own lives as individuals in the future. Zero drama.

Charles now though will probably find it difficult to remove the Prince or Princess titles from Archie and Lilibet if that had been his original intention for any children Harry would have as the Swedish King has done , as some would probably say it was being spiteful and part of the rift rather than it being part of his aim to slim down the Royal Family. It’s completely reasonable if it is confirmed he won’t give A and L the address of HRH as they won’t be doing royal duties as adults and it fits in with his wish to slim down the Royal family.

StormzyinaTCup · 17/09/2022 02:03

There are a lot of posters I think who can't wait for this book to come out because they are hoping it's going to bring about the downfall of the monarchy but they dress it up as faux concern for Prince Harry, when in reality they couldn't give two hoots about a Prince that comes from the very family they so dislike. He is their useful idiot.

CatServant2020 · 17/09/2022 01:58

I'm surprised that so many people on this thread know the Royal family so intimately that they know exactly what's gone on in the past and not only that they are fortune tellers as well that can tell us what's going to happen in the future.

It's none of our business and is down to the Royal family to sort if that is what they all want.

ShandaLear · 17/09/2022 01:54

He’s a grown almost 40 year old man with family. He has a voice. He is his own agent and he has a right to talk about whatever is important to to him. Stop trying to cancel his lived experience.

TheWheeledAvenger · 17/09/2022 01:52

Speculating that a baby will grow up to become a drug addict.

Keep it classy, Meghan haters.

MangyInseam · 17/09/2022 01:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

antelopevalley · 17/09/2022 01:40

This thread is full of people making things up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread