Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Prince Harry should now do whatever it takes to cancel his book contract?

808 replies

FromageRouge · 16/09/2022 22:13

And withdraw his book?

A rapprochement looks possible if he meets the RF halfway.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Diverseopinions · 17/09/2022 22:15

It didn't come across that they were having to leave the country because of their treatment by the press - not at the time.

Don't forget they had their own pet journalist - that guy who copped for the: 'Thanks for asking how I am; not a lot of people ask", comment in South Africa. He was a sort of friend, like Richard Kay was to Diana: a pet poodle to get good pics of them in the press. And now there is Omid. And the power of Sunshine Sachs, which all their privileged millions of pounds has been able to buy.

When they left Britain, H and M pre-empted a more carefully thought-out version of how the removal was going to function, by bouncing the Palace into a fait accompli, in the form of a published statement, saying that they were going to carve out a progressive new role within the Royal Family. It wasn't escape it was growth, thriving, and all that gumpf. They had also patented aspects of the 'Sussex' brand in readiness, and thought they could be the trendy royals, who do things in their own way, but still represent the crown. They found out they couldn't. But why did it take them so long to find out?

They wanted to control the narrative and be a sucker shoot sprouting off from the main rose bush of the Royal Family. That doesn't happen. All of us can try it in our own jobs....if we are in any doubt that life doesn't work in this way. Why don't we? We can go in on Tuesday and tell our bosses that they are fuddy duddies and that we are carving out our own progressive job role. We can email the client list with the news - without first informing our managers - and we can see what will happen. It won't be good. If we can see this, in advance, why can't Harry?

H and M were told to desist from publicly using HRH titles. Those titles go with working as an official royal. Boris Johnson can't continue to use 10 Downing Street and Chequers, now Liz Truss has the top job. A lot of privileges, in the UK, attach to the role and come with a big work load. In the case of royalty, when you.marry in, you are asked if you want to be a working royal. If you say 'no', you don't have to do it: you can be private and avoid public scrutiny.

It's all proscribed. The Royal Family isn't a mystery. Cressida Bonas and Chelsey Davies didn't want the attention and constrictions and they now have lovely beaux, without the same hassle as being with Harry. Please don't talk about Meghan, commentators, for a senior leadership role, if she can't even research the well-documented protocols of, perhaps the most unique and peculiar ( in the non-judgemental sense) famous family on the planet .....which also happens to be the one which she intends to marry into.

I don't read all the press, but I'm aware of opportunities and privileges being given to Meghan and Harry, like the African tour and the personal train trip with the Queen, on which quite frankly, I didn't notice her to be smiling along with the Queen, but more laughing into her hand to herself.

I mentioned Carrie Johnson above. Dominic Cummings has said that she is the 'Mad Queen' who wants to rule ( a story as old as time) and, on the back of that comment, practically the whole of the press decried her heavy influence and dug out quotes by other politicians along that theme of her interfering too much. Lots of people get unhelpful press. Having a high profile engenders it. You don't have to go for a high profile, you can choose to marry in and be a non-working royal.

Meghan was hugely fortunate to have had the means of controlling the media narrative of who she is and what she believes in. She had a lot of freedom to do Vogue editions and clothes for work projects and her own favourite stuff. This gave her a direct voice through the media to say in her own words, who she thought she was. If we are saying that it didn't counter other press ramblings, then maybe it's because people didn't take to what she was saying, because her ideas are not very powerful. There was that magazine cover with little pics of all the most influential women. She controlled what that article said, and it represented a big opportunity for her to make her mark.

I'm gob smacked at their naivety as a couple. I just think, well if I know that when you meet the cast of Lion King, that it's too support the theatre industry, ...then why doesn't Harry? If I know you don't shake hands with the producer and then say: " My wife does voice over work, you know? She's good!". Flipping hell! Doesn't Harry know that too! That evening should have been about putting the spotlight on the theatres which have had a shocking time through Covid; not feathering your own nest, with a cheeky comment, when you're supposed to be representing the British public. You could see by everyone else's faces, Beyonce, etc., that they also knew that he was out of order.

I can't take H and M's grievances seriously, because they don't seem to know their arse from their elbow. Harry even got taken in by a fictitious, pranking Greta Thurburg and gave her, a supposed kid, as far as he thought, his personal pitch and spiel as to who he is... a thoroughly down to earth guy. The way H and M view things is so off kilter, that I don't think anyone can believe what they imply about having being unfairly treated. Their judgement is warped.

Dinoteeth · 17/09/2022 22:02

IrisVersicolor · 17/09/2022 18:46

Because they’re family and H’s grandmother just died?

Is Andy a working royal? No he’s just a nonce.

The State reception isn't going to be your normal tea after a funeral.

It's representatives of other counties meeting the UK Royals who will have been briefed on each other and potentially know other issues with those other people.

Would H&M be willing to read the briefs and act in the professional hat rather than the family hat?

FromageRouge · 17/09/2022 20:11

I feel a bit like, every time anyone mentions H or M publicly, half the responses are “tell me everything you know/think about the Sussexes” bad exam answers.

OP posts:
Fullupdowntown1a1 · 17/09/2022 19:27

BlueRidge · 17/09/2022 19:19

"to be fair is this not more or less what Harry said happened?"

Well, as our dear late Queen said, "Recollections may vary."

@BlueRidge true! but I just meant that @Murdoch1949 was mainly just summarising their side of the story that they are on record with, rather than making up fiction. The other side of the story, is less clear at the moment.

IrisVersicolor · 17/09/2022 19:24

@Murdoch1949

The RF had the opportunity to defend and support the Sussexes when they were under siege from the vile UK press. They told the Sussexes to suck it up, even though they made the same error with Princess Diana. The Sussexes left the UK, had their HRH and charity patronages removed, Harry lost his military posts, which was unnecessary and cruel. The Sussexes were willing to split their lives between UK and USA, but that was rejected. The RF is antiquated, poorly advised by men in suits, and brought this on themselves. They continue to do it, with the Sussexes being first invited then de-invited to the Commonwealth heads dinner tomorrow - WHY? Rudeness personified.

I don’t agree with the rest of your post about jealousy, but this part is spot on.

Very very poor advice from upper class middle-aged white men who know a lot about palace protocol and fa about how the rest of the world works.

IrisVersicolor · 17/09/2022 19:19

A580Hojas · 17/09/2022 18:53

"The world sees the first British royal to marry a mixed race woman being chased out of the country and frozen out at a funeral"

Is that better Iris? What is your point about race in that sentence?

God knows I'm a pedant but when you are reduced to pedantry to crush someone's comment it doesn't make you (one) want to engage.

It’s not pedantry to use quote marks correctly.

The point is that whatever the actual motivations: the world, the majority of whom are not white, see a non-white woman having to leave the monarchy she married into and leave the country, her husband having to cut ties with his own family for marrying her, and draw their own conclusions.

I don’t think race is the only issue - misogyny and xenophobia play their parts, and cultural differences of woke vs non-woke, and also snobbery, but even Diana didn’t cop with MM did, and she had a huge number of supporters and family and friends in this country to turn to, whereas MM did not.

It’s disingenuous to claim that MM left because she didn’t fancy royal life, when she was subject to abuse that no-one on this forum would ever want to be subject to and likely couldn’t deal with. It’s perfectly reasonable to suppose that if she’d been left alone she’d still be here.

BlueRidge · 17/09/2022 19:19

"to be fair is this not more or less what Harry said happened?"

Well, as our dear late Queen said, "Recollections may vary."

Fullupdowntown1a1 · 17/09/2022 19:16

BlueRidge · 17/09/2022 19:10

@Murdoch1949 That piece of fiction you just posted was almost amusing.

@BlueRidge to be fair is this not more or less what Harry said happened? Bar the point about Kate and William being jealous which I doubt he’d ever say outloud even if he privately thought as much.

BlueRidge · 17/09/2022 19:10

@Murdoch1949 That piece of fiction you just posted was almost amusing.

Murdoch1949 · 17/09/2022 19:06

The RF had the opportunity to defend and support the Sussexes when they were under siege from the vile UK press. They told the Sussexes to suck it up, even though they made the same error with Princess Diana. The Sussexes left the UK, had their HRH and charity patronages removed, Harry lost his military posts, which was unnecessary and cruel. The Sussexes were willing to split their lives between UK and USA, but that was rejected. The RF is antiquated, poorly advised by men in suits, and brought this on themselves. They continue to do it, with the Sussexes being first invited then de-invited to the Commonwealth heads dinner tomorrow - WHY? Rudeness personified. The Sussexes will continue to be successful, and Kate will continue to be jealous of Meghan. Remember, Meghan worked, actually had a job, can deliver thoughtful speeches with great poise. If Kate was more welcoming to Meghan, things would have been different, ignoring the birth of Archie for days was weird, rude and unnecessary to someone who had relocated her life to the UK. Kate didn't take her children to meet their cousin either. Kate & William encouraged the rift, because of jealousy, they know the other couple have the charisma they lack. Now they are trying to copy them, too little too late.

Fullupdowntown1a1 · 17/09/2022 19:05

lemmein · 17/09/2022 19:02

Interestingly none of the royal men seem to get pegged as having diagnosable disordered personalities, despite being known for emotional outbursts and losing their temper. They have each been accused of worse as well.

That's a really good point!

(pegged was an unfortunate word to use though, unless deliberate Grin)

😂Oh god, I didn’t even notice that!

Fullupdowntown1a1 · 17/09/2022 19:03

A580Hojas · 17/09/2022 19:00

No, by ppd I very obviously mean post partum depression. Another post scraping the barrel of pedantry.

Oh I’m sorry, I genuinely didn’t know that’s what you meant. PPD to me means paranoid personality disorder.

lemmein · 17/09/2022 19:02

Interestingly none of the royal men seem to get pegged as having diagnosable disordered personalities, despite being known for emotional outbursts and losing their temper. They have each been accused of worse as well.

That's a really good point!

(pegged was an unfortunate word to use though, unless deliberate Grin)

Maireas · 17/09/2022 19:01

A580Hojas · 17/09/2022 19:00

No, by ppd I very obviously mean post partum depression. Another post scraping the barrel of pedantry.

I know what you meant, and I agree with you. She most definitely was unwell.

A580Hojas · 17/09/2022 19:00

No, by ppd I very obviously mean post partum depression. Another post scraping the barrel of pedantry.

Maireas · 17/09/2022 19:00

Although I can see the other points of view, it's really not fair to say that Meghan has been frozen out of the funeral, or that they as a couple aren't allowed to take part.
The only thing they're not part of is the dignitaries reception, but the only grandchild attending that is William. Oh, and Andrew isn't going either.

ThickCutSteakChips · 17/09/2022 19:00

Wow, you must know a hell of a lot of people! Grin

Maireas · 17/09/2022 18:56

MoChridhe · 17/09/2022 18:26

No way 4 billion people are going to watch the funeral. More like 40 million. No one I know will be watching.

With all due respect, that's not exactly evidence.

Fullupdowntown1a1 · 17/09/2022 18:55

A580Hojas · 17/09/2022 18:11

I think it's likely that M suffered ppd which is not uncommon but an absolutely awful thing to go through. It's a terrible shame she felt unsupported but equally would she have wanted publicity around it?

I do not think she was "chased out of the country due to racism". I honestly don't. I think she decided royal life was not for her and quite wisely spoke to her husband about taking a different path, and luckily he agreed, and off they went with a lot of public support and understanding. Including from the family.

It's just all gone a bit bad since then. How anyone can think that some people currently having feelings against them has nothing to do with their very public life since then is nothing to do with THE TWO OF THEM AS A COUPLE AND NOT JUST MEGHAN, I really cannot fathom.

I was all for them until Oprah. Now I wish them no ill will but want them to stop with the publicity-seeking. Am I racist? Don't insult me.

@A580Hojas PPD, as in paranoid personality disorder? what are you basing this diagnosis on?
Also, I think it is considered very uncommon, it is usually considered relatively rare, between 4% and 0.4% of the US population. All personality disorders are very rare really, people may have tendencies towards one disposition or another, but to meet the threshold of personality disordered the symptoms typically need to be persistent over time and be moderate-severe.

What’s interesting is that Diana was also “diagnosed” with a personality disorder. Borderline personality disorder, again much discussed but still quite rare. I’m sure she would have been accused of paranoia too if that letter where she said that she thought Charles was planning a car accident to kill her had come to light during her life time. Diana did definitely suffer with bulimia, as did Sarah Ferguson, and Kate Middleton has also been said to be bulimic.

Interestingly none of the royal men seem to get pegged as having diagnosable disordered personalities, despite being known for emotional outbursts and losing their temper. They have each been accused of worse as well.

I wonder if maybe there’s something about being a royal wife which leads to symptoms that mimic personality disorders?

ajandjjmum · 17/09/2022 18:55

Roussette · 17/09/2022 16:08

I just don't know what to think. It was unfortunate footage and the most my DH would be doing is touching a shoulder or the small of a back with our adult DDs. But I do think they are a touchy feely family if what they say is anything to go by. I am, my DH not so much

I am far more concerned at him ingratiating himself back into the family and Charles letting him do royal duties

After the funeral I do not want to see his face ever again to be honest

It is definitely uncomfortable footage to watch, but his daughters are clearly very fond of him, so I think it was probably a mixture of keeping his balance and camera angles.

A580Hojas · 17/09/2022 18:53

"The world sees the first British royal to marry a mixed race woman being chased out of the country and frozen out at a funeral"

Is that better Iris? What is your point about race in that sentence?

God knows I'm a pedant but when you are reduced to pedantry to crush someone's comment it doesn't make you (one) want to engage.

lemmein · 17/09/2022 18:48

Is Andy a working royal? No he’s just a nonce

That really made me laugh Grin

IrisVersicolor · 17/09/2022 18:46

BlueRidge · 17/09/2022 18:23

@IrisVersicolor "Not invited to the state reception. It’s all so snippy."

Why would they be invited to a state reception? They are not working royals.

Because they’re family and H’s grandmother just died?

Is Andy a working royal? No he’s just a nonce.

antelopevalley · 17/09/2022 18:44

BlueRidge · 17/09/2022 18:23

@IrisVersicolor "Not invited to the state reception. It’s all so snippy."

Why would they be invited to a state reception? They are not working royals.

They do not behave like a normal family. It is all about protocol than behaving like a parent who loves their children.

Rapidtango · 17/09/2022 18:42

I think there might be a few more than 40 million Grin