Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the UK suffering from mass hysteria?

458 replies

User135644 · 16/09/2022 19:19

The Queen's passing is sad and seismic and the funeral will be a special occasion.

However, people genuinely seem to have gone mad.

OP posts:
TopSec · 18/09/2022 14:16

Just because people do something that others would not does not make them mad or hysterical. We have just got back from holiday and obviously was out of the country when this happened. I will happily admit that I cried a lot when the news broke and the local people were all very respectful to the British folk staying in the hotel. This is an historical moment in the lives of most folk and I don't think anything has been over the top - many people take a great comfort from watching / reading the news on this.

2bazookas · 18/09/2022 13:57

Well said Ginexplorer.

2bazookas · 18/09/2022 13:55

ThisUserNameIsAvailableOk · 16/09/2022 19:23

No, just going through the motions that Brits usually do when a monarch dies

We don't "usually" do this.

The last time a reigning British Monarch died was 1952, when ordinary Brits didn't have TV or the internet . After announcing his death , the BBC stopped broadcasting for 5 hours as silent respect. So the news spread very slowly, the only images seen by the vast majority of the adult population were newspaper photos in coming days, and later Pathe news in cinemas. Children like me, never saw or heard anything. I had no interest at all until the following year when the Queens Coronation happened.
We got a TV to watch it on (the first TV in our street) and every school child got a coronation mug.

jennakong · 18/09/2022 13:40

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2022 17:50

People are leaving marmalade sandwiches as if from an imaginary, talking bear.

People are standing in a queue for approximately twenty hours to shuffle past a coffin.

People have pretended there’s no cost of living crisis going on or a planet earth on its knees and are leaving plastic wrapped, flown-in cut flowers to rot in parks.

The flowers are being left unwrapped, in London's parks anyway. Yes - I do find the flower thing a bit frustrating - charities would love the money that people are spending on flowers that will just be composted. As for the other stuff, who does it harm? The sandwiches are just a bit of affectionate nonsense. The queue is traditional British eccentricity. Hysteria is a completely different phenomenon!

Brefugee · 18/09/2022 13:00

that sounds lovely @ginexplorer - i really don't get the digging-on people who did go. Queuing up to pay your respects to a public figure is a traditional thing to do, it harms nobody and it has actually shown the country in a good light, i think. All ribbing about the British and queuing aside, i think it's been one of the more positive things to come out over the last few years.

LEnferCestLesAutres · 18/09/2022 12:49

And with all the current doom and gloom it’s great to see so many appreciate rather than bring down Great Britain.

This, imo, is a huge part of it (and certainly reflects the tone of most media coverage). Don't buy it myself but there we are.

MarshaBradyo · 18/09/2022 12:04

Good on you Gin

A lot of the things you mention are good for people’s moods, probably why everyone comes out saying good things about it

You’re right though it’s far from weeping and wailing - which is typically associated with hysteria

More community and sharing

ginexplorer · 18/09/2022 11:29

For those that think you spend 24 hours in a queue in the cold to walk past a coffin you are wrong ! We went at night (Sat) leaving 6 pm and were there at 230 am. So 7.5 hours. Ok not short but consider this . We took in all the fabulously lit up iconic buildings, bridges and landmarks that makes London the fantastic place it is and helps me to have a different adventure from the usual monotony of day to day full time career , ferrying teenagers and all that goes with that treadmill. We experienced a new part of London we had never seen before and would love to back ( Southwark) wharf. Loads of fab restaurants. Got to chat with friend for ages! Plus the exercise. It was civilised, peaceful, people were lovely and friendly and so many supporters in the form of marshals , police, ambulance helpers handing out warm blankets when temps dropped a bit, and water, loos everywhere. We watched the changed of guard in Westminster Hall and it was certainly an emotional ( as in a few private tears) and a quick hug but certainly not hysterical moment. The Queen for me was a woman who provided a constancy throughout the years. She is part of my own national identity. Whilst some of her family were involved in scandal , she wasn’t. She was the longest serving female leader who actually just kept her head down and got on with the job. The fact 100’s of 1000’s of people choose to come to London from all over the world is testimony to her life of service to our country. And with all the current doom and gloom it’s great to see so many appreciate rather than bring down Great Britain. Yes there are ‘traditions’ and ceremony that is followed but no one is being forced to participate. Most people if lucky will get a day off work ! If you ( like my own husband) have different views which in a democracy you are absolutely entitled to then great! Fine! But please don’t attach your lack of interest/ dislike to people who do want to pay respects as ‘hysteria’. I can well imagine the media has whipped up some choice stories in some quarters and I agree the constant media over analysis is tiring to listen to. I’m sure the media pick the weirdest and most sensational people out of the queue as they want to sell news stories . Don’t listen to the hello mags and daily mails and perhaps talk to ordinary people and just listen. Be curious. Then you might find another perspective to add to your own.

Blueink · 18/09/2022 11:10

Well most people seem to agree with you, but It’s not like Diana at all, which was mass hysteria, dominating all conversation IRL and people’s mood. That isn’t happening now in my experience (thankfully because it was horrendous and very self indulgent beyond her family and friends).
This level of media attention and in state viewing is to be expected during this official mourning period. It’s easy to switch off the TV.
Other people queuing is of no consequence to me.
I don’t agree with leaving flowers etc as consider it wasteful and all has to be cleared up. Better to light a candle and reflect.

sunglassesonthetable · 18/09/2022 11:00

I am shocked at the queues to see a coffin (yes coffin, you dont know shes in there

Thinking about you at a funeral "are they REALLY in there, show me the proof?" 😁

I suppose any coffin, any where, might have been weighted , It's just a chance you have to take @NoMoneyHun

Jesus wept.

MarshaBradyo · 18/09/2022 10:43

RedAppleGirl · 18/09/2022 10:24

The hysteria has been embedded for a while-think Covid and the Col crisis.
Now that's hysteria.

Agree - Out of all of it I’ll take a good natured queue than the whipping up over those

Brefugee · 18/09/2022 10:42

have not RTFT, sorry.
I just read elsewhere that perhaps a lot of it is the grieving for the people who have died since March 2020 where up to now people have tended not to be able to grieve properly. And it has all rolled into this.

SJW0 · 18/09/2022 10:40

Gilead · 18/09/2022 10:36

Yep, absolutely.

Where though? Show me the hysteria because I cannot see it.

Gilead · 18/09/2022 10:36

Yep, absolutely.

NoMoneyHun · 18/09/2022 10:35

I was very sympathetic when she died. (Mostly for the rest of the royal family). Although I am not a royalist I do belong to organisations that pledge to serve the royal family and do their "duty".
I am shocked at the queues to see a coffin (yes coffin, you dont know shes in there), the remarks online and the parades in the streets. I am shocked I can't find any DECENT news articles about what's actually going on in the funking world other than the monarch of the UK has died. I really don't care if Prince Harry wears his uniform or not. (That seems to be all people are harping on about....)
News flash: they aren't your family. King Charles won't be paying inheritance tax on his massive inheritance, while we face one of the hardest winters ever thanks to the cost of living crisis and our government is still doing fuck all about it while Liz truss pats herself on the back (but atleast she's not Boris eh?)

So I don't get why everyone is in favour of shutting everything for a woman who was clearly all about duty and service. I don't get all the crying and "oh my goodness I can't believe she's gone" - we will be lucky to reach 96!

Nolongera · 18/09/2022 10:28

A bit bonkers? Yes, but we are fairly bonkers as a nation, it's why we have a royal family.

Compared to Diana's death this is cool, calm reflection.

2 weeks down the line this will seem like a distant memory.

RedAppleGirl · 18/09/2022 10:24

The hysteria has been embedded for a while-think Covid and the Col crisis.
Now that's hysteria.

sunglassesonthetable · 18/09/2022 10:20

I've got the Live Stream on from Westminster Hall.

Shrieking, wailing, people prostrating themselves.

Oh hang on.

Off to empty the dishwasher.

sunglassesonthetable · 18/09/2022 10:18

She might not be in that coffin

indeed 🙄

Sazzasez · 18/09/2022 10:17

I think there’s perhaps an unexpressed need for grieving, which is more personal than people’s feelings about the actual Queen, but which this event is acting as an enabler for. I’m thinking of the woman who brought her Mim’s ashes, for instance, to the queue.

it’s certainly being whipped up for various more or less grubby reasons, but people feel what they feel.

cyclamenqueen · 18/09/2022 10:16

@MooseBreath possibly because as I said to a huge number of people in this country she is not a stranger , she is someone who has been part of their lives for all of their lives ( I agree this seems odd and I think the time has come for change) but the British have a strange and complex relationship with their Royal family and more specifically The Queen. She was the most well known face in the country , people might have no idea about politics or church leaders or other national figures but everyone knew who the Queen was.

Hoggarth · 18/09/2022 10:15

She might not be in that coffin

MrsLargeEmbodied · 18/09/2022 10:14

i dont think it is hysterical
no hysteria that i can see
no weeping and wailing - no elton john
it is a huge event
a state funeral for a monarch who reigned for 70 years
94% of the global population have never known another monarch.
plenty of us are unlikely to have a queen again.

SJW0 · 18/09/2022 10:12

I go out and about my business and I see no hysteria of any kind. I hear more people talking about holidays, school lessons and garden birds than I do about the Queen's death and funeral.

I can go into a range of shops and buy cornflakes, scollops and shower gel at any time from 6am to midnight.

I was at an establishment dinner two nights ago and not one mention about the Queen.

On Monday the shops will be shut for a few hours to enable staff to watch the funeral if they wish.

As is common with most things, the hysteria is on social media (behind anonymity and not real life) and the tabloid press.

MooseBreath · 18/09/2022 10:07

Waiting 12+ hours outside (and encouraging children to do so) to pay respects to an elderly woman you've never met and who had never even heard of you is hysterical, regardless of how "composed" and "patient" the crowd is.

Closing shops, schools, doctor's surgeries, crematoriums, holiday destinations, entertainment venues, and cancelling planned treatments and operations over the death of one person is hysterical.

24-hour Breaking News coverage of the death of a 96-year-old (including the shipping of her coffin, the status of her grandchildren holding hands with their spouses, and ogling the bereaved family) is hysterical.

Admittedly, I am not a royalist, nor am I British, though I have lived in the UK for 8 years. That said, I genuinely do not understand how people are grieving and crying over a lovely, but privileged woman who they never so much as crossed paths with. I see that as hysterical.