Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say Balmoral could/should be National Trus

109 replies

Happyhapoydog · 16/09/2022 16:47

for
Scotland or similar. Is Charlie going to want it? Don’t they all have their own estates?
I said this to a colleague who got really ANGRY as it’s ‘disrespectful’ after claiming only the Royals would have the money to upkeep the place. I said - turn it over to NTS or similar and give it back to the public.
she’s now not talking to me!

OP posts:
LuluBlakey1 · 17/09/2022 15:04

The private wealth of the Royal family is not public money. Much of it comes from investments made many years ago by grand and great grand parents. HM The Queen has inherited money that came to her mother from The Queen Mother's grand-parents and great-grandparents- who were not Royal, as have the Queen's children.
Money has been invested in trust funds every time a child has been born- as it is in many wealthy families. They are managed for decades to ensure they perform when the child comes of age.
That may have included investments in land, natural assets like minerals, precious metals, companies, property. It's no different to other rich families. I'm not sure why you think it appropriate that it should be taken from them.
Many ordinary families do similar things on a smaller scale. My grandma put money away for me every month until I was 21 into a savings account and then the account was mine. It wasn't much, a few thousand pounds but I was very surprised and grateful. My parents did the same.
DH's parents are doing the same for our DC and so are we. They won't get a fortune each but they'll get an amount that will help them.
That's what lots of families do. Surely you are not suggesting that should be taken by the government?

derxa · 17/09/2022 15:03

Happyhapoydog · 17/09/2022 14:57

‘but if he had to give up much of his private wealth to become monarch, how would he pay inheritance tax?’

he hasn’t given up anything. He’s inherited more.

I know this will have steam coming out of your ears but when I inherited my Scottish farm from my father I did not pay inheritance tax because agricultural land is exempt.

Luredbyapomegranate · 17/09/2022 15:02

I don’t think the NT wants more houses to run - it’s very hard to get them to take one on these days.

Balmoral is privately owned.

I think it’s quite likely KC will open more of the crown owned places - Buckingham Palace and Windsor - to the public, but Balmoral is the family holiday home, so I doubt it.

Happyhapoydog · 17/09/2022 14:57

‘but if he had to give up much of his private wealth to become monarch, how would he pay inheritance tax?’

he hasn’t given up anything. He’s inherited more.

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2022 14:57

Discovereads · 17/09/2022 14:53

Most sources count the entirety of the U.K., and everywhere she was head of state (ie Canada, Australia). It’s stupid because the monarch doesn’t actually own all that land.

No, it’s private land isn’t it? Here’s a run down:

people.com/royals/all-of-king-charless-sprawling-estates-across-the-uk/

And the Dutchy estate covers a lot of land, not sure if that counts as private or not.

PizzaFunghi · 17/09/2022 14:54

but if he had to give up much of his private wealth to become monarch, how would he pay inheritance tax? Are you saying he should be allowed to keep all this private wealth on becoming monarch

Happyhapoydog · 17/09/2022 14:54

Ok for the millionth time I KNOW it’s privately owned. I also know they own a LOT of other Estes, land and houses.
make him pay inheritance tax. like the rest of us have to.
lots of estates and houses that were once privately owned are now in public hands for many people to enjoy, rather than a few.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 17/09/2022 14:53

wonderstuff · 16/09/2022 18:06

Apparently our new King is the biggest landowner in the world - I'm guessing that is crown estates plus privately owned property. DH read it somewhere today, not seen the source info myself. But in any case I think it's highly unlikely that our new monach is going to start signing over privately owned estates to the National Trust. Doesn't seem to be his style.

Most sources count the entirety of the U.K., and everywhere she was head of state (ie Canada, Australia). It’s stupid because the monarch doesn’t actually own all that land.

LuluBlakey1 · 17/09/2022 14:50

It's a private house. It does not belong to the monarchy but to the individual. Windsor and Buckingham Palace are houses of the monarchy. Balmoral and Sandringham are privately owned, bought privately by previous monarchs- Queen Victoria and George V and left to their eldest child by them. HM The Queen can leave Balmoral and Sandringham to whoever she chose to leave them to- although most likely Charles.

Pumperthepumper · 17/09/2022 14:48

derxa · 17/09/2022 14:45

Go up to Balmoral and tell the local people all of this. I take it you're not Scottish.

I’m Scottish and I agree with the OP. The wealth of that family is insane, he definitely should be paying inheritance tax. On another thread someone pointed out the Imperial state crown is worth around 5 billion. And all while their loyal subjects are in a cost of living crisis.

derxa · 17/09/2022 14:45

Happyhapoydog · 17/09/2022 14:33

‘Oh dear OP!! You really have got your facts wrong here, haven't you!?’

Have I? I am aware that it’s not public property. I just thinking should be. It’s not like the Royals ‘earned’ their wealth is it? Saved up those pennies and bought themselves a nice estate with it…

Go up to Balmoral and tell the local people all of this. I take it you're not Scottish.

Happyhapoydog · 17/09/2022 14:33

‘Oh dear OP!! You really have got your facts wrong here, haven't you!?’

Have I? I am aware that it’s not public property. I just thinking should be. It’s not like the Royals ‘earned’ their wealth is it? Saved up those pennies and bought themselves a nice estate with it…

OP posts:
Happyhapoydog · 17/09/2022 14:21

‘Its privately bought and owned not a Public property’

fine, in that case let’s have Charlie pay inheritance tax. Then see if he wants to keep it.
would be a nice gesture though, wouldn’t it. Given all the land the Royals have amassed over the years…

OP posts:
TightDiamondShoes · 16/09/2022 20:31

Balmoral is so “open to the public” that during the covid years, delightful “wild campers” were shitting throughout the grounds and leaving their bog roll and faeces.

oh yes, the Guardian. bastion of truth that one.

BloodyHellKen · 16/09/2022 19:47

OP, Balmoral is the one royal residence actually owned by the Royal family rather than held in trust etc which begs the question why on earth do you think they should give it away to the NT?

I think it was bought by Prince Albert for Queen Victoria btw.

derxa · 16/09/2022 19:39

Of all the goady anti monarchy threads, this is the one that has got my goat the most. English superiority complex at its worst.

tenbob · 16/09/2022 19:34

Hasn’t the National Trust stopped taking on new properties?
They don’t want to add to the portfolio

Not sure if NTS have said the same though

RaraRachael · 16/09/2022 19:31

Balmoral is a beautiful peaceful place that has been treasured by the Royal Family for years and somewhere that they can completely escape from everyday life and unwind. It is open to the public in a limited capacity but it's lovely to wander among the beautiful gardens.

Why should it be given to the National Trust?

PizzaFunghi · 16/09/2022 19:29

Doesn't he have to give up loads of his wealth on being monarch anyway, though? that probably goes some way to not paying inheritance tax on the private properties

Pedallleur · 16/09/2022 19:28

SusiePevensie · 16/09/2022 19:14

It's not like the other owners of National Trust places happily handed them to the trust. They had to, because they couldn't afford to run them or couldn't pay the inheritance tax. Or both.

If it is privately owned, then it shouldn't be exempt from inheritance tax.

As an aside, demonising inheritance tax is the biggest con played by the rich. It is a wonderful tax. Take it away and you end up with the rich getting richer and the poor getting screwed.

Generates business for their estate planners. Get it right and you save £££ e.g. Duke of Westminster.

Pedallleur · 16/09/2022 19:26

MushroomQueen · 16/09/2022 19:24

I was reading about this. Only the King/Queen doesn't have to pay. All other royals do.

Almost as though back in the day they had a meeting with the Govt and said wouldn't it be good if....

MushroomQueen · 16/09/2022 19:24

ProfessorLayton1 · 16/09/2022 18:14

@wonderstuff - how convenient.

I was reading about this. Only the King/Queen doesn't have to pay. All other royals do.

Pumperthepumper · 16/09/2022 19:18

TightDiamondShoes · 16/09/2022 19:01

Lol @ KC3 being the world’s biggest landowner.

Good grief - is that really believed?

Largest in the UK isn’t he?

SusiePevensie · 16/09/2022 19:14

It's not like the other owners of National Trust places happily handed them to the trust. They had to, because they couldn't afford to run them or couldn't pay the inheritance tax. Or both.

If it is privately owned, then it shouldn't be exempt from inheritance tax.

As an aside, demonising inheritance tax is the biggest con played by the rich. It is a wonderful tax. Take it away and you end up with the rich getting richer and the poor getting screwed.

SirChenjins · 16/09/2022 19:12

Zosime · 16/09/2022 18:52

I would like to see it sectioned off into royal apartments and the turned into a residential centre for the Princes Trust - the RF could have their bit for 3 months of the year, the remaining sprawl of rooms and estate could be run as a business training centre with outward bound, arts facilities, workshops etc for the remaining 9 months.

Prince Charles (as he was at the time) has already done this with the Castle of Mey, which he inherited from the QM, and which I believe was almost a ruin before she bought it as a project after she was widowed; and with Dumfries House and its contents, which were on their way to the saleroom when he managed to put together a last minute rescue package.

I don’t think it’s run by the Prince’s Trust - it’s run by a foundation with more limited activities and as a visitor attraction.