Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School Have basically given up on entire year 11

135 replies

ReformedWaywardTeen · 16/09/2022 16:19

Our school have been questionable at best for a while. I've allowed a few concerns to slide, haven't we all, putting it down to unforeseen Covid related kiboshing.

Our school is different in that it starts GCSE studies in year 9 rather than 10, so they traditionally choose options in March of year 8. It was promoted as being helpful as work is more staggered and worst case they could swap a subject if they hated it in year 9.

So, DD was due to choose their options in March 2020, with an options evening for of all dates the first day of lockdown.

When it didn't happen we assumed they would cancel options picking completely. Except they didn't, we did it with just a booklet giving some idea of the curriculum. They were slow to organise online learning so no virtual event took place (not a surprise, these were very strange times).

DD ended up picking 4 subjects, 1 of which they were on the fence with.

Obviously, as we all know, life didn't go back to normal as predicted, and a few of us parents did voice perhaps by December 2020 that maybe they should start from scratch for year 10. The school was hit hard by Covid isolations from Octopus onwards, whole year groups were off due to a lack of teachers. Then we had the January to March lockdown, and within a week of being back they were on school break.

This has had a hugely negative effect on DD, they've gone from a confident kid to being a shell.

Year 10 was a nightmare, not just for DD, for the entire year group. They did tests before the end of term and it was, to quote one teacher, a nightmare. How it's taken school this long to realise how badly behind they all are and the knock on MH effect of lockdown is beyond me. They also hadn't taken up the government offer of tutoring.

Meanwhile, DS didn't pick his GCSE subjects in 2021 (year 8), down to covid, he waited until year 9 and had the benefit of talking to tutors to ensure they are right for him. He has entered year 10 last week full of confidence and is thankfully very happy.

The one constant we had was the school has always had a place for any pupil who wanted it at the school's onsite sixth form.

Until last night.

We had a curriculum evening, not unusual, but this time, they are about to become part of an academy.

Suddenly, the school has been trumpeting their top 25% results for GCSE this year and top 20% A'levels.

They have now said the kids won't get a place automatically, and of you think they won't do well, then start looking elsewhere. Charming.

They have to apply, have an interview, get grades and have an exemplary record of great grades. DD does not have that since Covid.

On the way out a lot of parents were angry. It felt like because they were going on about the top 20% score and they realised the tests done at the end of last academic year were terrible, they are replacing kids they let down by not responding to covid in year 9 effecting GCSE study to be able to show off.

My AIBU is whether I'm right to raise this with the headteacher? I feel like they've let them down so much and the lack of foresight with their year group is ridiculous.

Is this what happens when a school is an academy?

DD was utterly broken last night, saying they may as well give up now, as even the school thinks they suck and will fail. They know what they want to do post A Level and need GCSEs to do it. It's been so hard to try and reassure a kid who is totally adrift thanks to two years of carnage.

What would you do in this situation?

OP posts:
TeenDivided · 16/09/2022 18:46

It sounds like your school was hit harder than most with covid lockdowns and disruption.

Moving forward. Plans B & C.

If she is looking at a Level 3 Extended Diploma BTEC there will be various entry requirements, possibly passes in English language & maths. What if she doesn't meet those requirements? Well, she can do a 1 year Level 2 BTEC in the same subject and then the 2 years at Level 3.

If she doesn't even qualify for a Level 2 course, she can do a Level 1 course followed by a Level 2 the following year.

You need to understand entry requirements so you can agree a plan of campaign (which could be ignoring a subject) and know where to focus.

You must make sure you look at and apply to other places.

MH is more important than anything, having plans will help with MH. Even if she passes nothing at all there will be options. (I have current experience with my DD).

Hawkins001 · 16/09/2022 18:45

Not sure what is best to advise op@ReformedWaywardTeen , other than the bottom line it's up to the individual if they want to increase their chances to succeed.
It's all well and good blaming x,y,z even if true, but then studying and learning still needs to happen to at least give themselves a good chance, it's no good just saying I give up or what's the point, as that thinking will certainly not achieve anything useful.

Goldencarp · 16/09/2022 18:41

Our school do the same, pick options in year 8. My son didn’t have a clue what to pick, being at home and having to make those decisions without any support from school was hard.

FernPotts · 16/09/2022 18:41

She has 2 years to get her grades up.
It is definitely possible, especially in subjects that are coursework heavy.

I think from the OP that this child is already in yr 11, not 10.

Alucadekena · 16/09/2022 18:39

Right, I would go at it that you need to draw a line under how it was all meant to be and start from where you are now. Point out to your DD what time she gets home from school and the potential number of hours on a school night to put some effort in and turn this around. Also weekends, usually full Saturdays and Sundays to work at this too. It doesn't mean all work but she will feel better if she feels she knows the content better. If you can, be available to help her stay motivated and feed her treats.

In this day and age a lot of information is online at your fingertips. Yes Seneca for science as it tests you. But also Free Science Lessons on YouTube or Primrose Kitten. Same with English I recommend Mr Salles who I feel is better than Mr Bruff. For maths Corbett maths has playlists depending on the exam board.

As she gets through year 11 then look at past papers, in fact if you can open up the paper and on another computer/laptop or just tab open up the mark scheme. Go through each question one by one, compare her answer with the mark scheme. Seeing the mark scheme means she can see what they are looking for.

Yes the situation is shit beyond shit, some schools have been massively affected by covid for staffing etc but it is what it is and she needs to look forward. Nail it this year and never have to learn maths again or English lang again. It is only September. If you post up her other subjects and exam boards we can point her toward some other resources to help her. Revision guides are great but can be very boring.

Summerfun54321 · 16/09/2022 18:38

What would you do if your DD were in a good school and unhappy and not doing well academically because that also happens? Focus on your DD and the things you can do rather than worrying about things you can’t change. Part of teaching your DD to be resilient is to show her and help her to face challenges head on, think for herself and find her own solution.

Hopeandlove · 16/09/2022 18:36

Your daughter is on a level 1?? Most schools expect 6 or above on their subjects for a level. They also need at least a 4 on English and maths - a 4 is a weak pass.

if she seriously is only on levels 1 and 2 then a levels are not an option for her. You need to look realistically at what she is capable of and what she can do.
CGP books and workbooks, bitesize home help from you etc

Testina · 16/09/2022 18:33

“We were hoping that should they not do well at GCSE English and maths they could resist at school but that is part of the whole not guaranteed a place thing.”

So is the school no longer offering resits in Y12?

I’m not convinced by angry discussion on line - it’s very easy for parents to whip up a bit of outrage without a full understanding.

The reason I think there isn’t a full understanding is you also haven’t said what the grade criteria are.

I think the school has always had the right to refuse unsuitable candidates, just now they are giving Y11 a full year of notice not to cruise because they think it’s a done deal!

Noteverybodylives · 16/09/2022 18:30

I think this may be my school.

If it is then I think the school has many faults but not giving automatic places to 6th form isn’t one of them.

If I was a hard working student and had to put up with 5 years of idiots in my class constantly messing around, I’d think it was so unfair that they’re then in my class in 6th form.

6th form should be a privilege and it should encourage them to work hard to gain a place.
I think it should be based on behaviour too.

I think the interviews are great too, as it is good experience for when they get a job.

I would hope that if the requirement is a 5 and your DD got a 4 then they would accept her based on behaviour.

She has 2 years to get her grades up.
It is definitely possible, especially in subjects that are coursework heavy.

In year 11 there will be extra revision sessions which she can take advantage of too.

My DD chooses her options in year 9 for year 10 which she has just started but we’re not worrying about her grades or 6th form yet.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 16/09/2022 18:26

Testina · 16/09/2022 18:20

“Science is their kryptonite. They hate the staff (quite a weak department, very old staff, not very approachable). They've never been very keen but now they say they feel physically sick before class and during.“

Again, I’d look at the summer’s Y11 results.
This is coming from your daughter’s mental health issues not a bit of age-ism regarding experienced teachers.

I wouldn’t waste any energy on the school rightly selecting for Y12, because you need all that energy to be focused on her mental health issues.

You are adamant they would accept all to Y12 before. Have you actually checked with them whether this means they will not be offering Level 1/2 BTecs and Maths / English resits? Do you actually know anyone from previous years who got 1-3 and has nevertheless been accepted to A levels or Level 3 BTec? I find that hard to believe.

Yeah science, it's not ageism. They really are very unapproachable. I have tried emailing a few of them (different teachers for different aspects) to ask what we need to do at home, where are knowledge gaps. Did not get a response. When they've failed to appear at Virtual parents evening, I asked for a written report. Got no response. Asked the head of year and she didn't get a response either.

We had bullying in that class last year, because DD cried they were sent out. No support offered and headteacher said the tutor didn't know DD was having bullying issue sin class. This despite the boy involved actively shouting in their face. Headteacher dealt with the boy. But the trust has gone there with science and DD.

OP posts:
canyouextrapol · 16/09/2022 18:24

She needs to be looking at other options. She's not suited to A levels. They are hard. Very hard. Get her looking round colleges for something vocational. However miserable she is now will only be made worse by two years of a level pressure

ReformedWaywardTeen · 16/09/2022 18:22

The thing is, from speaking to parents at the school, and from the angry in some cases reaction last night, I don't think this is singularly a DD issue.

It's been widely discussed online too.

DD was predicted between 6-7 for maths previously (they give GCSE predicted grades on all reports from the start, we don't get written comments at all just numbers, was fine before parents evening went Virtual as its 5 minutes per tutor and some don't turn up (eg I've not seen a science teacher in person or virtually since 2019 for DD or DS)

We were hoping that should they not do well at GCSE English and maths they could resist at school but that is part of the whole not guaranteed a place thing.

Currently, I'm going by a "Well you're not very happy there recently so perhaps a move is a good idea?" I booked a tour of the local college but as I say it's that or very hard to find an alternative here.

At home we are encouraging I can't stress it enough but I wish they'd had done the meeting for parents last night because it's really hit hard and to her mind (and her friends) they think the school thinks they are failures and wants rid of them. I've said to not see it like that, but when your already feel like you will fail everything it's not come at a great time and rather than encouraging them post the exams last term, it's done the opposite and I guess that's why I'm disappointed with school. Bad timing, bad audience!

OP posts:
Testina · 16/09/2022 18:20

“Science is their kryptonite. They hate the staff (quite a weak department, very old staff, not very approachable). They've never been very keen but now they say they feel physically sick before class and during.“

Again, I’d look at the summer’s Y11 results.
This is coming from your daughter’s mental health issues not a bit of age-ism regarding experienced teachers.

I wouldn’t waste any energy on the school rightly selecting for Y12, because you need all that energy to be focused on her mental health issues.

You are adamant they would accept all to Y12 before. Have you actually checked with them whether this means they will not be offering Level 1/2 BTecs and Maths / English resits? Do you actually know anyone from previous years who got 1-3 and has nevertheless been accepted to A levels or Level 3 BTec? I find that hard to believe.

Lindy2 · 16/09/2022 18:17

There's no point doing A levels without strong passes in those subjects and at least 5 GCSE passes. If your DD is unlikely to get those grades then 6th form isn't likely to be the best place for her. Looking at the college options is a good idea and perhaps a more interesting option for your DD.

Offering all pupils a 6th form place is very very unusual. The school hasn't really made a shocking change there, they've just moved to be in line with everyone else.

If she's year 11 now then she would have had a normal year 10. Hopefully a normal year 11 too. That's 2 years without Covid disruption. 2 years of normal GCSE lessons is what most schools do. If she works hard for year 11 then she's got a chance to catch up and make up the lost learning.

My DD picked her GCSE options in year 8 using just a booklet. She could have asked her teachers questions but didn't feel the need to. To be honest, once you've got the core subjects in such as Maths, English, Sciences etc actual choices are fairly limited. Is usually only 2 or 3 things that you actually get to select based upon what subjects they enjoy. I don't really see the problem of making those choices without an open evening.

Her grades from her tests are obviously lower than expected and hoped for. She's got time to turn it around though. I would stop looking back and blaming the choices process and Covid issues in year 8 and 9 (all children suffered the same problems) and crack on with doing the best you can, going forward.

MsTSwift · 16/09/2022 18:13

Really don’t understand this. We’ve all had covid disruption dds cohort last year year 11 just done their GCSEs lots with very strong passes 8s / 9s even the less academic ones have got what they needed for the next stage. State school.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 16/09/2022 18:12

Doingprettywellthanks · 16/09/2022 17:58

Everything is hopeless accordingly to them.

that would be a huge concern to me.

Your school’s approach is completely reasonable (in fact sensible). Why waste everyone’s time having two years of a 16 year old who failed all exams, disinterested, likely disruptive as a result of disinterest, and leaves after two years with no qualifications. I’m not saying that’s your DD. But if not yours, it would be someone.

DD is so demotivated they couldn't get the wherewithal to be disruptive.

They've previously always been a good kid. Quiet, respectful. Not a rock the boater. Not a kid known to all students as chasing headgirl status. Just a kid who was liked by staff, small, very close group of friends. Had some mild bullying but sorted very quickly.

They as I say we're mid groups for subjects. Had no restrictions on subjects picked for GCSE. In fact quite the opposite was seen as capable at a number of subjects.

To my mind, they were just turning 13 in 2020. It's like they've stayed there. Couldn't have the awkward teen year of 13 due to lockdown so had it last school year instead and we still have the hangover now.

Science is their kryptonite. They hate the staff (quite a weak department, very old staff, not very approachable). They've never been very keen but now they say they feel physically sick before class and during.

Maths again was always a difficult subject but they had an amazing teacher last year who was disappointed that they went to pieces in the exam. Said with the right attitude could get a 6. He then left in July but she seems to like the current teacher.

Same with English, great teacher, was so gutted by her result she phoned me to say she was very worried for her. Also left in July. She was given a teacher who has been there for decades so seen it all but has yet to really gel there as not been taught by her before.

I will reiterate though, this school has never not had an automatic place for sixth form for its year 11 cohort. They would obviously advise those who weren't up for carrying on in education post 16 and also helped those who wanted to study something not offered there.

OP posts:
listsandbudgets · 16/09/2022 18:09

I've never heard of a school giving automatic places for 6th form. DD has just started 6th form. She applied for the one at the school she was attending, 2 colleges and also 6th form at a selective grammar. Her own school wanted her to get 7s in the subjects she wanted for A level and 3 6s in any thing else. The colleges wanted at least 6s in the A level subjects plus 3 5s in anything else. The selective grammar 8s in all her A level subjects and 3 6s in anything else

Her friends have gone to a variety of settings for 6th form and all of them had to meet offers and a lot of them had interviews. A couple of them didn't get the grades Sad

Dishwashersaurous · 16/09/2022 18:06

Most schools have a minimum requirement to do a levels. It's not fair on the children otherwise. Someone getting a 2 in a subject is not going to be able to study it for a level. They also have a requirement to pass maths and English because that's a minimum.

She has the whole of year 11 to study and work really really hard. And try and pass her gcses. Then she can work out what to do.

But unless she passes she won't be able to.do a levels anywhere.

Testina · 16/09/2022 18:04

As you daughter wants to do a BTec, I think she needs to find out what that means in terms of entry requirements. They’ve become an academy, they’re changing the rules - that’s fair enough. It doesn’t sound like they’ve announced only a full sweep of 7-9 gets you an A level place. There will always have been entry requirements - even if soft ones - for A levels and Level 3 BTecs. She needs to find out exactly what she has to get to progress to BTec and what the options are - Level 1 + GCSE resits for example. Get facts first.

The school is not writing off an entire Y11 or they’ll be up the creek filling the spaces they have. Perhaps they’re aware that too many children and parents are coasting because they think it’s OK “cos Covid” and can sail into 6th?

How did this summer’s Y11s do? They had the interruption at a more critical time. If they did OK, so can current year at same school.

Honestly it sounds like your focus should be your daughter’s mental health issues, not the school. It’s those that have made a previously strong candidate get a 2 in English. Maths hard to tell as you say she’s always struggled. If you can’t support her and motivate her, why do you think the school can? You can get a higher grade in Maths than a 1 with KS3 work alone, so there’s more going on here than just “giving” up on an entire year.

Did she do badly only because she had a panic attack, or because she didn’t know the material too? You need to understand whether she needs academic support or health support or both - and prioritise accordingly.

Do not waste your time arguing about a school wide Y12 entry policy that doesn’t seem clear anyway. Talk to them about your child.

Squidlydoo · 16/09/2022 18:02

Hi

most schools across the counties who previous took options in year 8 have reverted back to year 9 options - this is down to pressure from Ofsted to follow a three year KS3 and to stop schools spending three years on GCSE. Your child has benefitted from three years of GCSE during this covid period so I don’t see what this is a negative.

in terms of the entry requirements, all sixth forms have some entry requirements! Some higher than others but ultimately a place is never guaranteed if you don’t do well. It would not be in the best interest of a child to accept them into a levels if they were below the academic ability needed to access the course.

many towns have colleges and other FE establishments that cater to all abilities of students so your child should have plenty of options available to them.

plus part of these messages will have been designed to motivate your child (and others) to work hard, show up and perform as well as possible in the exams. I don’t understand why you feel upset by these. I’m reality, most schools are very accommodating to individual students!

CantFindTheBeat · 16/09/2022 18:00

Needing the required grades (equiv of 6 Bs in recent years) to access Sixth Form is quite standard in the schools around here, OP.

Can you explore HE colleges too if you're not sure your DD will get what's needed?

There is a long time to go, though, OP. Your DD certainly has time to pull GCSE grades up if they start really applying themselves now (with your support).

Doingprettywellthanks · 16/09/2022 17:58

Everything is hopeless accordingly to them.

that would be a huge concern to me.

Your school’s approach is completely reasonable (in fact sensible). Why waste everyone’s time having two years of a 16 year old who failed all exams, disinterested, likely disruptive as a result of disinterest, and leaves after two years with no qualifications. I’m not saying that’s your DD. But if not yours, it would be someone.

nicknamehelp · 16/09/2022 17:57

My ds just done Alevels and despite getting 6 and above in all GCSEs and getting 8s in Alevel options he still found it a v big step up. So if achieving 4/5 Alevels might not be best option. Dd doing a btec but still determined will go to uni and do a masters to get into her chosen career x

FernPotts · 16/09/2022 17:57

I see you're already doing that (I type too slowly).

FernPotts · 16/09/2022 17:56

OK, the idea of mocks is partly to get used to exam conditions and avoid the panic (I too have a panicker). Looking at past questions will be useful, but maybe just a few at a time so that it isn't overwhelming. Can she also practise some calming techniques?

Maths and English can be re-sat repeatedly if necessary. That's the fallback to bear in mind.

Meanwhile, lots of reassurance -- 'you can do some of it, you'll get more marks for writing something than nothing, and nobody will actually die if you get the answers wrong'.

Gentle, frequent practice for maths in particular. Is your own maths OK enough that you can help?