Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School Have basically given up on entire year 11

135 replies

ReformedWaywardTeen · 16/09/2022 16:19

Our school have been questionable at best for a while. I've allowed a few concerns to slide, haven't we all, putting it down to unforeseen Covid related kiboshing.

Our school is different in that it starts GCSE studies in year 9 rather than 10, so they traditionally choose options in March of year 8. It was promoted as being helpful as work is more staggered and worst case they could swap a subject if they hated it in year 9.

So, DD was due to choose their options in March 2020, with an options evening for of all dates the first day of lockdown.

When it didn't happen we assumed they would cancel options picking completely. Except they didn't, we did it with just a booklet giving some idea of the curriculum. They were slow to organise online learning so no virtual event took place (not a surprise, these were very strange times).

DD ended up picking 4 subjects, 1 of which they were on the fence with.

Obviously, as we all know, life didn't go back to normal as predicted, and a few of us parents did voice perhaps by December 2020 that maybe they should start from scratch for year 10. The school was hit hard by Covid isolations from Octopus onwards, whole year groups were off due to a lack of teachers. Then we had the January to March lockdown, and within a week of being back they were on school break.

This has had a hugely negative effect on DD, they've gone from a confident kid to being a shell.

Year 10 was a nightmare, not just for DD, for the entire year group. They did tests before the end of term and it was, to quote one teacher, a nightmare. How it's taken school this long to realise how badly behind they all are and the knock on MH effect of lockdown is beyond me. They also hadn't taken up the government offer of tutoring.

Meanwhile, DS didn't pick his GCSE subjects in 2021 (year 8), down to covid, he waited until year 9 and had the benefit of talking to tutors to ensure they are right for him. He has entered year 10 last week full of confidence and is thankfully very happy.

The one constant we had was the school has always had a place for any pupil who wanted it at the school's onsite sixth form.

Until last night.

We had a curriculum evening, not unusual, but this time, they are about to become part of an academy.

Suddenly, the school has been trumpeting their top 25% results for GCSE this year and top 20% A'levels.

They have now said the kids won't get a place automatically, and of you think they won't do well, then start looking elsewhere. Charming.

They have to apply, have an interview, get grades and have an exemplary record of great grades. DD does not have that since Covid.

On the way out a lot of parents were angry. It felt like because they were going on about the top 20% score and they realised the tests done at the end of last academic year were terrible, they are replacing kids they let down by not responding to covid in year 9 effecting GCSE study to be able to show off.

My AIBU is whether I'm right to raise this with the headteacher? I feel like they've let them down so much and the lack of foresight with their year group is ridiculous.

Is this what happens when a school is an academy?

DD was utterly broken last night, saying they may as well give up now, as even the school thinks they suck and will fail. They know what they want to do post A Level and need GCSEs to do it. It's been so hard to try and reassure a kid who is totally adrift thanks to two years of carnage.

What would you do in this situation?

OP posts:
Porcupineintherough · 16/09/2022 23:23

I think you need to let go of your issues around covid - they applied to most schools. Your dd was doing OK going into Y10 and not coming out the end of it and schools were "back to normal " during that period. So what happened? That's what you should be worried about.

Hawkins001 · 16/09/2022 21:41

ReformedWaywardTeen · 16/09/2022 21:02

Ok more questions!

The issue with my concerns on school is because they previously were great. Warm, approachable, if you didn't get a response from a department, you were always encouraged to email head of year and they would gain a response for you. However, it would never reach that point. DD was happy in school. It was great.

But in the last year it's like they've all had a personality transplant. I know things have been tough in education, they were thrown under a metaphorical bus during covid and yes, they've every right to be annoyed by that. But going from a warm and supportive school to being unapproachable, and ignorant it felt of the way the pupils feel is sad really and always going to be harder when it's so unexpected.

DD hasn't been messing around in class. I think they are so low and lacking in confidence it's hit them hard. The school was very slow to adopt any online learning. We weren't using Google classroom at the time, the school had to adopt it during the first lockdown but it took a while to get the hang of and adjust. Not slating them I recognise that Covid was so out the blue.

When year groups had to be put on rota due to staffing issues they had no work to do. I would check. And during the January to March lockdown, again, it was very dependent on the tutor. Some gave live lessons in full from their kitchen table. Some would just post work. But most didn't give feedback. Which possibly accounts for why DD was still getting good predictions.

From what the head of year said, the school was actually taken aback by how bad the results were in July. I think perhaps they took their eyes off the ball or thought they had put enough work online to get them through. They didn't. It's sad, it's not their fault. But the results are what they are and they now have a whole year group to get through to May next year and that's going to be some task.

The school doesn't just offer A'levels. They offer other options as well. For those who wish to do apprenticeships, they help them find one. Or they did. No idea if that's gone out the window too.

I'm not angry. Really I'm not. Disappointed yes. Think they could've handled it better, definitely.

I would just like the warmth and supportive environment back. It's why we didn't pick the alternative school at year 6 because all they went on about was academic high achievers and top sets. It felt like they only cared about the kids they could show off about. When you know your kid is happy in the middle, you want an environment that doesn't disregard them.

Going forward, it seems all students need to engage and study as best as possible, if they want any chance of improvement, yes from the seems of it, it's a pickle, but the situation is what it is, if students don't engage and study then failure is a guarantee.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 16/09/2022 21:02

Ok more questions!

The issue with my concerns on school is because they previously were great. Warm, approachable, if you didn't get a response from a department, you were always encouraged to email head of year and they would gain a response for you. However, it would never reach that point. DD was happy in school. It was great.

But in the last year it's like they've all had a personality transplant. I know things have been tough in education, they were thrown under a metaphorical bus during covid and yes, they've every right to be annoyed by that. But going from a warm and supportive school to being unapproachable, and ignorant it felt of the way the pupils feel is sad really and always going to be harder when it's so unexpected.

DD hasn't been messing around in class. I think they are so low and lacking in confidence it's hit them hard. The school was very slow to adopt any online learning. We weren't using Google classroom at the time, the school had to adopt it during the first lockdown but it took a while to get the hang of and adjust. Not slating them I recognise that Covid was so out the blue.

When year groups had to be put on rota due to staffing issues they had no work to do. I would check. And during the January to March lockdown, again, it was very dependent on the tutor. Some gave live lessons in full from their kitchen table. Some would just post work. But most didn't give feedback. Which possibly accounts for why DD was still getting good predictions.

From what the head of year said, the school was actually taken aback by how bad the results were in July. I think perhaps they took their eyes off the ball or thought they had put enough work online to get them through. They didn't. It's sad, it's not their fault. But the results are what they are and they now have a whole year group to get through to May next year and that's going to be some task.

The school doesn't just offer A'levels. They offer other options as well. For those who wish to do apprenticeships, they help them find one. Or they did. No idea if that's gone out the window too.

I'm not angry. Really I'm not. Disappointed yes. Think they could've handled it better, definitely.

I would just like the warmth and supportive environment back. It's why we didn't pick the alternative school at year 6 because all they went on about was academic high achievers and top sets. It felt like they only cared about the kids they could show off about. When you know your kid is happy in the middle, you want an environment that doesn't disregard them.

OP posts:
Helgadaley · 16/09/2022 20:53

The practical solution is to make sure that your daughter is ready for the exams, by hiring a tutor if possible, doing online revision and buying past papers, so that she can get an idea of the questions that might come up.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 16/09/2022 20:48

TeenDivided · 16/09/2022 19:22

Did she revise for her end of year 10 exams?
Did you help her revise / test her?

Not really, if I'm honest. They were already extremely stressed and negative at that point, and had been since the end of year 9.

Even I didn't think it would be that bad. The school did send out an academic info sheet based on whether the pupils were behind or had gaps in knowledge, on a traffic light system, in September of year 10. DD didn't have any red gaps, and two amber spots the rest were green so I have no idea how they managed to drop so quickly or more whether school just hadn't noticed due to Lockdowns etc.

Also, for any absence of doubt, no I won't be going to the press. It was more a quiet polite email to the head voicing a concern that at a time when the students need positivity, that meeting last night was the polar opposite and has left DD and others scared stiff.

And I would agree on not guaranteeing a place if that hadn't been the case for years before. To suddenly change that and worse do it when the pupils were there, after almost all did terribly in the exams they set up at the end of year 10, it felt rotten. They have all been through a nightmare, we all have in fact and I think some are still processing stuff.

I just think it could've been handled more sensitively and there was very little info on requirements for entry either. It would've been better to have all the info before springing on us all.

OP posts:
Blueblell · 16/09/2022 20:20

Covid has been a big problem for teens. The problem I think is that some schools did really well and some didn’t. I think though we have to move on and not dwell on it. My son suffered during covid emotionally and this year sat his gcse - his grades were down on pre covid predictions but he managed to do well enough in his a-level choices to stay at 6th form. You have to inspire your dd to not let the past few years ruin her future and move forward.

cansu · 16/09/2022 20:01

Achieving a grade 1 or 2 in maths and English suggests that your dd is more than a bit behind. It suggests she is either messing about and not doing any work or that she is much weaker than you have understood. I think that blaming covid is now no longer accepted as a reason for not performing at the right level. Your dd also has the whole of Year 11 to work through. You also need to consider that a place in sixth form is no good if you can't cope with the work. Your best option will be to get all the guides recommended and start working with her yourself every weekend. Go through all her homework with her and start revising now. Get hold of some past papers to look at with her.

Mamansparkles · 16/09/2022 20:01

So your school:

  • put together a booklet for GCSE options whilst unable to hold an options evening, like every other school in the country
  • was hit badly by covid but did its best
  • has had teachers phone you personally to talk through a poor grade
  • has a teacher putting on an extra hour revision session a week in their own time
  • has made a very sensible decision to get in line with almost every school in the country by saying they need to be able to be capable of A levels to stay on for A levels?

It is likely they don't have the staffing for resit classes anymore. And yes, teachers are leaving the profession in droves. It isn't just your school.

I am very cynical about big academy trusts and I'm sure the staff are too but nothing you have said so far indicates anything other than a good school with dedicated teachers being honest with and fair to their pupils in really difficult circumstances. I don't really see what you think they can do about your DDs mental health and lack of work?

Testina · 16/09/2022 19:56

“Let's just say, we embarrassed them more than a tad AND we got to keep our head.”

Do you think going to a part time head is the equivalent of setting a perfectly reasonable entry standard, as practised by every school the posters have so far experience of?

Hawkins001 · 16/09/2022 19:53

Doingprettywellthanks · 16/09/2022 19:50

Are you seriously saying that a 16 year old could fail every single one of their GCSEs, having shown zero aptitude or commitment to study - and this school may have advised them about alternatives but if they’d wanted to study a levels at the school, they would have. Despite not passing any GCSEs?

come on op.

Excatly, especially when someone that wants and will make the grades, would be more suitable.

StaunchMomma · 16/09/2022 19:51

If many parents are angry then it would probably be best to request a meeting with the head with parents together.

Academy Trusts do not like negative press attention so think about speaking to local press and making some collective noise on social media.
Also try your local MP. Some are quite vocal about such things.

My son's school is the only school in the country which has changed Trusts.
The old one tried to make us share our Head with a local school (saving themselves a ton of cash by not replacing the retiring head of the other school, which would have left 2 schools with a part time head in the process) and we kicked up a right old stink. After disappointing meetings with Trust representatives, a month of kicking off on SM, local press involvement & local tv involvement our local MP got involved and brought it up in parliament.
A bunch of us made banners and turned up at an education conference they were attending.

Let's just say, we embarrassed them more than a tad AND we got to keep our head.

Get together and make yourselves heard! The kids have been let down enough.

Doingprettywellthanks · 16/09/2022 19:50

Are you seriously saying that a 16 year old could fail every single one of their GCSEs, having shown zero aptitude or commitment to study - and this school may have advised them about alternatives but if they’d wanted to study a levels at the school, they would have. Despite not passing any GCSEs?

come on op.

FernPotts · 16/09/2022 19:45

They were not getting 1 or 2 grades until July, we have barely had testing due to covid. But the reports we got had nowhere near that low, with 6 and above even in maths and science.
That's why the grades were a shock when tested.

OK, that sounds like exam panic is the problem rather than actual knowledge of the subjects. So practice papers and further mock exams (and a decent amount of revision!) may well be most of what’s needed.

One of mine once got 2% in a mock exam. It’s a much better time to do it than the real thing.

neverbeenskiing · 16/09/2022 19:37

Go to the head, the governors, the local papers, the national papers if they'll listen. Fight for your child.

Why?? Because the school have made a decision that she doesn't like? This will achieve nothing except make OP look unhinged. Schools are allowed to make changes to their policies and procedures! As long as they are not failing to meet any legal requirements obviously, which they're not in this case. Some changes may not be popular with parents, but that doesn't mean they're not necessary.

It is highly unusual and frankly, completely bonkers, for all Y11 students to be automatically entitled to a place in Sixth Form regardless of their ability. It makes no sense to set kids up to fail by allowing them to undertake A levels in subjects they couldn't achieve a decent grade in at GCSE. Why put them through the stress when they clearly won't cope? I would put money on them having a much higher than average number of students drop out midway through sixth form. It is entirely normal practice for existing Y11 students and those wishing to move from other secondary schools to have to meet entry requirements and interview for a place at Sixth Form. Not doing so is failing to adequately prepare them for the world of further education or employment.

TeenDivided · 16/09/2022 19:22

Did she revise for her end of year 10 exams?
Did you help her revise / test her?

TeenDivided · 16/09/2022 19:20

Absolutely ask for how they can support the DD through the GCSEs.

But the OP's post seemed to be primarily about how they shouldn't be putting academic entry requirements in for 6th form. That is quite reasonable and not something to kick a big fuss up about.

ittakes2 · 16/09/2022 19:20

I am sorry if your daughter is getting a 1 and a 2 for maths and English this is a bigger problem than A levels. She needs a min of a 4 to pass these subjects before she can do a lot of things I think.
I would go to the head and say she has anxiety and can she drop an option she does not like much and use this time in the library to study more.
Please google inattentive ADHD - do you think she has this? I am a bit shocked at her current grades if she was predicted a 6 for maths etc (sorry if I missed something.)
Worth her looking into T levels too - or redoing year 11 as another option.

Saz12 · 16/09/2022 19:20

DD can just ... stop. Just shrug it all off and think “fuck it. I’ll do what I can face doing and screw the rest”.

Shes not meeting her potential now due to the pressure and her poor MH. She might as well not meet her potential because she spends too much time doing fun things and improving her MH.

When she is ready, she can go back to studying. If she needs to resit all GCSE’s then start A levels, then would the world really stop turning, would her life be messed up? She’ll be a couple years older than she would’ve been otherwise. That’s it. Unless her plans involve something where being young is important (Olympic athlete or supermodel...) then why does it matter? I’m in my 40’s and couldn’t tell you which of my colleagues are 36 or 38 or 34... 2 years makes no difference at all.

She can spend a year working, or volunteering or a mix or whatever she needs to. So long as she does something meaningful it won’t matter.

No worthwhile future employer is going to look at someone who, as a kid of 15, messed up school but picked herself up and did well thereafter and decide they’re crap.

Sylvaniandream · 16/09/2022 19:17

Fight for support for the student now! Fight for a plan of action, which may include dropping certain subjects, targeted help, extra work in the freed-up time, new, realistic targets and a plan of revision which is clear to stop the overwhelm, mental health support and careers and further education guidance so that there is excitement about going elsewhere and poss not doing A levels. That would be a good start, and a bare minimum for a half decent school.

Testina · 16/09/2022 19:16

“They were not getting 1 or 2 grades until July, we have barely had testing due to covid. But the reports we got had nowhere near that low, with 6 and above even in maths and science.
That's why the grades were a shock when tested.”

What do you think is her real level? There’s a huge difference between a 6 and a 1. Are you saying they over-reported during Covid, or that she is fully capable but her mental health impacted her exam performance? They are two very different issues. Neither of which is best approached at this time by arguing with school over their Y12 entry policy.

TeenDivided · 16/09/2022 19:12

Sylvaniandream · 16/09/2022 19:07

Go to the head, the governors, the local papers, the national papers if they'll listen. Fight for your child. It sounds like the school wont be. They need sorting out. Awful. Parents have a surprising amount of power in things like this. Get other parents on board. Do not be quiet.
This is your child's mental health. Exams can be retaken, other 6th forms will have places, but your child's self-esteem, confidence and happiness could be affected for years. How dare that school!!!!

And fight for what? The school was clearly badly hit by covid.
It wouldn't help anyone to take pupils to Level 3 courses if they aren't ready for it.
They will still need pupils to do as well as they can otherwise their Progress 8 values will be dire.

Testina · 16/09/2022 19:11

“Go to the head, the governors, the local papers, the national papers if they'll listen”

Complete with APILN photo?

A story that a school set a minimum standard for Y12 entry is not newsworthy.

Now if they’ve withdrawn re-sits leaving an entire town with no colleges / not enough places that do - take that all the way.

But an entry interview and passing exams is not a news story.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 16/09/2022 19:10

So yes to confirm, DD is year 11, DS is in year 10. DD picked option in year 8, March 2020, DS picked in year 9, March 2022.

They haven't really said what grades they expect. It all felt as if this change had literally just been decided as there were no slides for the projector for that bit.

I agree some parents do love for the drama on the online groups and after 5 years I can spot the ones by name. But this has been concern from parents you would never hear a bad word from previously. It's why I've been able to reassure DD they aren't the only pupil feeling that all is lost.

We have tried to emphasise the need for after school revision. But they are so anti school work they get visibly upset by it. They literally don't want to discuss it.

They were not getting 1 or 2 grades until July, we have barely had testing due to covid. But the reports we got had nowhere near that low, with 6 and above even in maths and science.
That's why the grades were a shock when tested.

I think they lost a huge number of staff at the end of July which was surprising but I wonder if they were perhaps unhappy with changes made. DS is doing well but said he has noticed a change in atmosphere recently.

It's worth noting DS when he felt behind with a subject sat and used online resources. DD is the opposite. And we can't push too hard right now because it ends in tears and further makes her push back.

OP posts:
Sylvaniandream · 16/09/2022 19:07

Go to the head, the governors, the local papers, the national papers if they'll listen. Fight for your child. It sounds like the school wont be. They need sorting out. Awful. Parents have a surprising amount of power in things like this. Get other parents on board. Do not be quiet.
This is your child's mental health. Exams can be retaken, other 6th forms will have places, but your child's self-esteem, confidence and happiness could be affected for years. How dare that school!!!!

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/09/2022 18:53

My friend’s ds got 4s in all subject apart from one of his options, which he failed. He was capable of much more and his mental health was not great. He left school for college and is studying a BTEC.

Your dd would be better in a setting, where the teachers are concerned about your dd rather than at a school, where they’re only interested in the students with higher grades. Much as your dd could achieve these in an ideal world, they are not attainable for your dd right now. As a result, there could be a too large gap between the level your dd is working at and the level the school is working at. This would not help her and she would be better somewhere, they could cater for your dd’s needs and try to help her reach her potential.